Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it too expensive?

257 replies

miniandmestudios · 04/02/2023 19:40

Not sure if it is entirely the right thread but I’ve started making hats by hand to try make some money - I’m a stay at home mum of 2, can’t afford childcare to go to work but can’t afford to not work. So I’m a bit stuck (DP works) and there is no one else I have to watch the kids.

My friend told me she would never pay £15 for a hat but it costs me £5 in materials and 3 hours roughly to make so it’s £3.33 ish an hour. I really don’t want less than that as working for £2 an hour is stupidly low.

I’ve attatched images of the hats so if I could get everyone’s opinions I’ll lower the price or keep as they are!

YANBU - the prices are okay
YABU - the prices are too expensive

Post edited by MNHQ

Is it too expensive?
Is it too expensive?
OP posts:
threatmatrix · 05/02/2023 17:36

Try Etsy, people that buy on their appreciation the difference between quality and Primark.

Kentishbornknitter · 05/02/2023 15:23

I think they are hand cranked on a machine, not hand knitted, especially if they are only taking three hours to knit?

PurplePansy05 · 05/02/2023 13:04

I think this is poor advice. Op can never compete with Primark etc. She will never be able to produce enough items quickly enough.

I think you've misunderstood the advice. I am not suggesting lowering her standard to Primark, but catering for the right audience - many parents will not be purchasing upper range quality hats for their toddlers and young children, mid range will suffice and make it more interesting in line with market preferences. That indeed is good advice as ultimately she needs to sell them. Myself and many toddler mums I know often buy mid-range decent quality items for our kids, shop sales and either have family gifts/hand me downs or buy second hand very good quality items as they're cheaper and they last. I resist paying significant sums for something they may lose/destroy/grow out of very quickly.

That's just common sense.

And FWIW, whilst I'm not a Primark shopper I absolutely do not dismiss those who shop there, particularly now when times are tougher. Indeed, some of the items there are far better quality than boohooland and the likes - I walked through my local Primark recently and frankly had it not been for its lack of ethics, I probably would have bought few bits for DS. I also would have if my choice was for him to be naked or dressed if I had money issues. The reality is many of us parents are struggling now and won't be paying premium fot not so special hats, merino or not.

Goldpaw · 05/02/2023 12:00

I would say slightly cheaper materials and catering to the market taste would help

I think this is poor advice. Op can never compete with Primark etc. She will never be able to produce enough items quickly enough.

I would never buy handmade that's been made with cheap materials.

Elevating out of the mass consumer market with a change in focus so that she can charge more is really the only way if she wants to make any money. If OP likes the pared back style, then promoting a fresh Nordic look might be the way forward. But I'd go with ice blues, greys, even a red, for that rather than generic pastel colours that don't make any kind of statement about who the maker is, what kind of style they have, and what lifestyle they're wanting to promote.

zingally · 05/02/2023 11:58

I wouldn't pay £15 for a kids hat either, sorry.

They are very nice, but a bit... meh/generic? I'd maybe be tempted in if they were a bit more "fun".

PurplePansy05 · 05/02/2023 10:46

OP, FWIW I bought my DS a hand knitted hat which was lovely quality and very attractive looking (multicoloured, rainbow stripes pattern and a pom pom) from a stall at our local Christmas market for £8. Really fancy ones were selling for £12, adult sizes for £16. I would say slightly cheaper materials and catering to the market taste would help, these are nice looking but personally I think for many people not attractive enough to justify the price.

watsthecraic · 05/02/2023 10:45

Part of the issue is that they look like they're loom knit. And that means they're fast to do, even if all you have is one of the hand crank machines from eBay or similar.

And that is the same as the hats for sale in primark or similar - and the primark ones will be loads cheaper.

Blinkingheckythump · 05/02/2023 10:38

miniandmestudios · 04/02/2023 20:06

It’s an alpaca merino wool blend so 100% wool!
I’ve done them more minimalistic as that’s my style and will expand to do more decorative ones as time goes on, they’re the easiest to knit with my kids around me as they take little to no concentration!

I'm a crafter myself and I appreciate the work that goes into handmade for the cost. But being honest, these are boring and whilst it may be your style and easy to do, people won't pay for it and that's the bottom line. If you want to sell handmade items they need to stand out, these are too generic.

You mention you need to do the night wake ups, are you breastfeeding? If not then why do you need to do them? And would you not be better off working a day at the weekend?

Oysterbabe · 05/02/2023 10:37

I just don't think you can make any money on this kind of thing. I make crochet toys but give them away. An old school friend insisted on paying me £30 for a small one I made her as a favour, she said she knows they take a lot of work and are undervalued. Most people don't feel that way.
I crocheted a giant tarantula. It cost me about £20 in materials and took around 40 hours to make, a full working week in time. I'd need to sell if for around £400 to make it worthwhile! I donated it to the school as a raffle prize.

NormasJeans · 05/02/2023 10:25

Hi OP- Haven’t read all the replies, so apologies if this has been suggested previously; have you looked at ‘Make it at Market’ on iPlayer? If not, it is worth a look to see how experts help take home crafters to the next level. Good luck :)

Theopossumwasmeantforme · 05/02/2023 10:18

I can't get on with hats but I spend a fair bit on nice wrist warmer fingerless gloves. Raynauds 😑

Some are just like a tube with a thumb hole so (to me with no experience) seem fairly straight forward?

Yerroblemom1923 · 05/02/2023 10:09

I think those that appreciate hand made products will go for them but many won't consider the time and skill that goes into producing a quality product vs a £2 Primark hat, sadly. I think it depends where and to who you market them.
I doubt there's a lot of money in it for you, OP.
What about doing some evening/weekend shifts in your local pub/restaurant once your dh comes in from work? As your children are only young, he's only got to feed, bath them and put them to bed then he's got the rest of the evening to chill.

BarbaraofSeville · 05/02/2023 10:08

It's not just a matter of caring about home made, it's what's economically sensible.

Very few people have the available budget to pay £15 for items that do the same job and look very similar to those that cost a quarter of that from a supermarket.

They might be able to do it as a one off, but they're not going to be able to do it for enough items to make a difference to someone like the OP, especially as it's been demonstrated that £15 is still too little to allow her to earn even NMW from her endeavours.

If the OP keeps knitting hats, it's a hobby that might cover its costs if she's lucky, not something that's going to earn a wage unfortunately.

JessicaFletcherscrewnecksweater · 05/02/2023 10:02

Will they stretch and recover? I think you might need to use a cheaper yarn. They also look like they might stretch out and then be rendered slightly useless.

Sadly, people don’t care about homemade items when they can get lots of very cheap things from the high street.

BarbaraofSeville · 05/02/2023 09:53

Etsy is also a giant mega Corp that makes a lot of money by taking a cut of the labours of a lot of individuals.

See also Uber, Deliveroo, Amazon etc

LadyPoison · 05/02/2023 09:28

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 04/02/2023 20:43

Why not Etsy? Etsy is made up of small businesses.

Etsy is a nightmare. It’s full of “hand made” items mass produced in China and the OP is very unlikely to have anyone find her products let alone buy them

LadyPoison · 05/02/2023 09:22

For hand knitted they are nor expensive but you need to find your market. That’s not the sort of people who are happy with a £5 machine knitted Primark one.

BarbaraofSeville · 05/02/2023 08:34

Floralnomad · 04/02/2023 21:03

its irrelevant what you charge because you need to sell them in bulk to make any money and that’s unlikely to happen . You would be better off getting a job in a pub on the evenings when your husband is off .

This. What people think the hats are worth isn't an issue because it's very very unlikely that you'll reliably make money any time soon.

You need to work in the evenings or weekends when DP is home to look after DC. Restaurant, bar, care, supermarket for a few hours all likely to pay more than earned by knitting unfortunately.

Does he make decent money for the long hours he works? Have you reviewed your spending to see if if its a lack of income or a spending and budgeting issue as to why you need more money?

Teeshirt · 05/02/2023 07:54

Uniqlo beanie hats (cashmere) are £24.90 at the moment- on sale from £34.90. And that’s a high street shop. So £15 is a bargain. That’s half the original shop price. Cashmere is a bit more expensive than merino/alpaca, though. You need to market them better. Plain colours I think are better than patterned. Definitely do not add pom-poms.

HallieHufflepuff · 05/02/2023 07:43

I wouldn't pay so much for a hat, I appreciate it takes time but too expensive for me when they're so cheap in shops.

I would never buy wool either.

CeeceeBloomingdale · 05/02/2023 07:38

Coming back to this. I think you need to do adult sizes too, kids lose things so not everyone is happy to spend a lot on someone who will outgrow or lose it quickly. Having said that I always did but decent quality and natural fibres for my children. Have you though about wrist warmers, scarves, necklets, snoods etc?

Crumpledstilstkin · 05/02/2023 01:36

Have you spoken to your local zero waste shop? Ours stocks things like locally made bits and bobs and their clientele are the sort who buy those things.

I'm also in the market for a reasonably priced hat/scarf combo with the scarf monogrammed but have found all the natural material ones are so expensive it's untrue. Might be an opportunity!

bridgetreilly · 05/02/2023 00:54

Get something like these to make them look more professional.

bridgetreilly · 05/02/2023 00:51

Just hope you will be declaring your earnings OP. Good luck.

If you are self-employed and make less than £1000 profit in a year, you don’t have to declare.

Wetblanket78 · 04/02/2023 23:41

Plus you are making them for babies I lost count of the amount of hats my kids lost. They just refused to keep them on until they were about 6 (both autism and ADHD) With the cost of living most families wouldn't pay it for a small item of clothing when you can pay for a full outfit for less.