Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it too expensive?

257 replies

miniandmestudios · 04/02/2023 19:40

Not sure if it is entirely the right thread but I’ve started making hats by hand to try make some money - I’m a stay at home mum of 2, can’t afford childcare to go to work but can’t afford to not work. So I’m a bit stuck (DP works) and there is no one else I have to watch the kids.

My friend told me she would never pay £15 for a hat but it costs me £5 in materials and 3 hours roughly to make so it’s £3.33 ish an hour. I really don’t want less than that as working for £2 an hour is stupidly low.

I’ve attatched images of the hats so if I could get everyone’s opinions I’ll lower the price or keep as they are!

YANBU - the prices are okay
YABU - the prices are too expensive

Post edited by MNHQ

Is it too expensive?
Is it too expensive?
OP posts:
tirednewmumm · 05/02/2023 19:58

@LuckySantangelo35 don't think so scroll down to the reviews and pics!

Wasn't really a comment to say op won't be able to sell hers that price more just a suggestion to check out the competition and see what similar designs/ material sell for

ScotsBluebell · 05/02/2023 19:51

You aren't asking too much for a hand made item. If you sell on Etsy, they will take their cut, and expect you to include postage as well, so you'd probably need to set the price a bit higher. Nevertheless selling online and at local craft fairs is probably the way forward. Boutiques would expect an even lower trade price from you, so that they can make their (routine) 100% markup. (Never do sale or return. They don't value what they haven't paid for.) I have a friend who makes and sells fabulous hand knitting at high prices mostly at fairs - hats, bootees, gorgeous shawls, tea-cosies, baby things. You need to find good yarn (not acrylic - that's the Primark market!) and you can often find it online - Facebook, eBay - and even in charity shops where you can find spare balls of really good yarn. Some online companies offer mystery boxes of good stuff - ends of ranges etc. Quality yarn is one of your selling points. Get Kraft labels (good but cheap) and hand write your name, the yarn etc. Pack in tissue paper - again you can buy in bulk, cheaply on eBay or Amazon. Treat yourself as a micro business. You need to build up some stock if you're going to do fairs. Similarly, the more you list on Etsy, the more people will find you. Currently, I think I'd be going for brighter colours, if I were you. Hand knitting is popular at the moment and although many of us are struggling (me too! ) there is a lot of cash out there still. You might not make a living, but it would be a good supplement for very little outlay. Good luck!

NeedSomeSpace · 05/02/2023 19:50

Handmade crafts are a tough market and so is being self-employed. I'm not so sure that anyone can be decently profitable and set up a new business either with just a few hours in the evenings or during the daytime around children, particularly in the current economic climate.

BelleMarionette · 05/02/2023 19:44

Have you thought about doing cloth nappy covers? There is a definite market for these.

I'm sure there is a market for these hats, but it's quite niche, as most can't afford/won't pay that much for a baby hat. As others said you need to target that market, maybe on Etsy, or at craft fairs.

AmIDoingThisRight · 05/02/2023 19:38

I love the colours and style. And I adore alpaca wool - it's the only kind that doesn't bobble after 5 minutes. Premium-quality handmade stuff demands premium prices.

I wouldn't flinch at charging a fair price, but absolutely make sure you emphasise the quality of wool and labour. With some arty, rural backdrops they will photograph even better.

Well done OP - hats off to you.

Deathbyfluffy · 05/02/2023 19:33

SarahAshley2 · 04/02/2023 19:46

No I wouldn’t pay that. They’re so cheap in primark!

If you want support the exploitation of people in sweatshops in other countries by buying a cheap hat to save a couple of quid, you’re part of the problem.

Personally I’d rather pay a little more and support someone in the UK crafting quality goods.

Justletmesleeplease · 05/02/2023 19:32

I would pay that for a handmade hat. I wouldn’t buy the hats in the photos though - the style/colours are too plain for what i like.

Rosenary · 05/02/2023 19:31

Shocked to see people think this is too much for a handmade hat. All that work!!

Maybe use really good yarn/wool/alpaca or cashmere blends, slightly thicker yarns, and correspondingly bigger needles and charge a lot more. And find a new market that understands what it is they’re getting.

LuckySantangelo35 · 05/02/2023 19:31

Surely those are for kids??

Ifeelsuchafool · 05/02/2023 19:30

I'll buy one if they're adult size! Send me a link OP ☺️

Lovetoplan · 05/02/2023 19:29

As you are clearly quite creative, how about making home furnishings? Curtains, cushions covers, bed covers are all more profitable. You could also offer a service via a local shop - a furnishing fabric shop or an interior design shop.

Chestnutlover · 05/02/2023 19:26

They’re really pretty, I would pay for one happily. Don’t lose heart, lots of people would prefer to buy from a small business

PinkiOcelot · 05/02/2023 19:12

I wouldn’t pay £15 for a woolly hat. You can buy cheaper in the shops.

Fluffmum · 05/02/2023 19:09

Charge 8 for one they look fab. I love hand made items

wentworthinmate · 05/02/2023 19:06

Sorry but too much £ for me!

Bleachmycloths · 05/02/2023 18:51

Personalise them with a label ‘ handmade by mini and me’. Or offer them personalised with customer’s name? Handcrafted? What are they made of? Pure new wool? 100% cotton? Think about how you can make them unique/special.

Flowersintheattic57 · 05/02/2023 18:49

You are competing with China. Your hats need to be different , very different, to the generic. You could buy the hats ready made and just attach fabulous Pom poms and make a better profit.

BaroldandNedmund · 05/02/2023 18:46

I do like the hats though….you’ve obviously got a good eye for colour and minimalism is always more tasteful.

BaroldandNedmund · 05/02/2023 18:44

Crafts aren’t a good money-maker. After thinking about it for a while I decided that hand-made cards are probably the most time-efficient. The materials don’t cost much and people always need cards. (Don’t use the tacky pre-made bits and bobs though!)

I didn’t actually do this in the end but you could probably make 4 or 5 cards in an hour and charge £3 each.

Fascinate · 05/02/2023 18:41

Sorry, but I cant see the quality here; I'm not surprised they won't sell. Also you say minimalist, but there's a difference between stylish minimalist and just plain.

It seems that you need to practice your skills, both in the art of knitting and in the art of design. It takes years to achieve, and you WILL look back in time and realise that what you produce in 5 years time is head and shoulders above what you are making now.

Don't give up, but you should accept that what you are trying to achieve will take longer than you thought.

Smilingthroughtears · 05/02/2023 18:34

Hi,
You are really talented! I had a hat that is handmade, every hat is totally different bought for me for my birthday recently. It was £20. However they come with the cutest label of a moose, a huge bobble and a different pattern with various different colours on every one. The colours are very bright too.
Previously I have hats from places like salt rock, fat face etc and I think I have paid around £15ish in sales. We have some plain knit H&M ones in the house too which were much cheaper as my girls and I will just grab them if we can’t find another. We spend a lot of time outdoors.

The difference with my more expensive ones is the quality feel, the yarn, the patterns on them. The bright colours(I love bright blues and greens for my hats). With these it is hard to tell the quality and feel. But they aren’t particularly unique in the pattern which is where you may struggle. However if you could explain what they are made with, they are hand made plus add something like free stitching of an initial on then you could probably charge £15. Is there any change of making children’s or baby ones so you use less yarn and people seem to spend a bit more on their children? Maybe charge £8-£10 for them.
Well done for taking action and doing something like this.
Good luck!

TheAllButterBiscuit · 05/02/2023 18:26

Another thought has occurred to me/ have you ever considered not starting from scratch, and instead cutting babies’ pixie bonnets and mittens out of cashmere/merino jumpers that you pick up from charity shops? Your knitting skills would be required for finishing the items off, but it should work out as considerably cheaper than buying the yarn by the ball. I don’t know about where you live, but here in Kent I might pay £2-6 for a decent charity shop jumper. And from one jumper, you could cut 2/3 pairs of mittens plus 2/3 bonnets.

I also have a friend who makes french knickers from old silk wedding dresses… you can buy a dress with a stain on it for very little, and you get acres of silk, often with embroidery and beading on it too.

Just a thought!

TheAllButterBiscuit · 05/02/2023 18:02

I didn’t vote as I don’t think the answer is straightforward: if you could take some gorgeous photos of these hats, marketing them just right, then I think they could sell for £15. If they were photographed as in the pic you shared, then I think you’d struggle to achieve £15.

For context, I sell vintage homewares online… and when I say ‘vintage homewares’ I mean car boot sale stuff, photographed as beautifully as I can. I make at least £1k each month as a stay at home mum selling online, and often more. The best investment I ever made was a second-hand Canon camera, to make sure my photos were just right.

Look at how similar hats have been photographed by retailers you aspire to be like, as well as browsing Pinterest etc. Then copy them! Good luck xx

(Assuming you are hoping to sell online btw)

Saju1 · 05/02/2023 18:00

Do you make berets? I would pay £15 for one of these

anon666 · 05/02/2023 17:47

I'm being honest because I think that is what you want, and I don't want to waste your time.

The reality of making stuff by hand is that automation of simple knits like hats has reduced the value of the skill to virtually zero. As people have said, Primark hats go for next to nothing.

The only way to even sell handmade things is if they are incredibly unique with some kind of artistry AND that this particular quirk is to someone's taste. The likelihood of finding your customers with not only the same taste, but enough money to spend on ephemera is fairly low. Not non-existent though.

To make a success of it, you'd have to find a niche where your skills can be put to use making something that can't be machine made, and also aren't being made elsewhere in the world where people are making piecework at $1 per day.

These niches do exist, for example there are things like personalised cards that people sell on etsy/ebay.

Even in crafts, there are some people selling hats that are beautifully hand knitted in natural yarns, with exquisite colourwork or textures. Or designer made, or in cashmere. However, it would have to be incredibly special to attract interest.

Clothing in this country seems very oversupplied. Not only are there companies like Primark, but also countless charity shops selling second hand stuff, plus ebay sellers selling on stuff.

There are also still an army of pensioners who love knitting and devalue the craft by making things in horrible acrylic yarns, with no particular style.

Its a very tricky market.