Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to give DD smallest room

82 replies

CanStopWillStop · 04/02/2023 18:43

Looking for advice from MNers who've been in a similar position...

We're moving into a new house soon DH, DD and me. It has two doubles and one single room. DH thinks DD should have a double room for space, toys etc, but I am also WFH and know what type of storage we need (a lot!), so I'm thinking second bedroom would be better as storage cupboards, sofa bed and desk, and DD (who is 1yo) can have the smallest room.

AIBU? Will this make more work for us when we perhaps move DD into the bigger room if we have DC2?

OP posts:
Floralnomad · 05/02/2023 01:45

I’d put her in the bigger room now and make your office in the smaller room . If you do have a second they can then share the big room and you don’t need to be moving them or the office .

Chiasmi · 05/02/2023 01:40

I would give her the 2nd room and put the storage in with her. Less hassle than doing 2 different rooms for her in the long run.

When mine were little they shared the 2nd bedroom, their clothes all lived in a massive chest of of drawers, and the built in wardrobe was full of general household shite. You don't need a lot of floorspace for an office but in 2 or 3 years you'll be glad of a bit more floorspace in her room.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 05/02/2023 01:14

She probably wont care at this age, but as she gets older she will resent you. Happened to me and it always seemed to be a message about how important I was. The bigger room was supposed to be a guest room, but no one ever stayed.

CanStopWillStop · 05/02/2023 00:51

Keepyourmummysboys · 04/02/2023 22:12

I never understand this and treated my daughter as equal to us as far as possible . I recall viewing our current house, which had en suite for one of the non master rooms and when I said it would suit our daughter, rhe agent saying but why would you give that to your child, she can have the smallest room.

eh. No. She can have the second biggest. She’s not lesser. I don’t understand why you’d give your child the smallest room. And save the two biggest for you and storage. Don’t you see your kid as part of the family. Or is she just an inconvenience ?

Thanks everyone for all the suggestions, super helpful and considered…

(except this one I’ve quoted, you can feck right off with this – nope, not tonight hun, I’m not in the mood thank you very much. God bless 🙏)

OP posts:
BringItOn2023 · 05/02/2023 00:40

I did the small room thing. Then had to buy a different bed, storage etc when I swapped. Was a waste of time/money.

MargaretThursday · 05/02/2023 00:24

Put her in the double.
If you have a second you have the choice of putting them in together and keeping the little room as an office, or putting #2 in the smaller room.

At 1yo she may not have many toys but when she's 4/5yo she will and you'll want her to play there sometimes. Changing rooms round us a hassle.

AllOutofEverything · 04/02/2023 23:57

I would put her in the biggest room but have storage for other things in there. It will not be long until she needs the size and it would be a faff to move her.

blippyissilly · 04/02/2023 23:42

Seems pointless putting her in the small room when you know you'll need to move her

JarByTheDoor · 04/02/2023 23:33

@WestBridgewater I've got no strong opinion on all the stuff you said about views of gardens and turfing people out of rooms, or even on kids' bedrooms at all TBH. My comment was in response to your sneery joke, because I was wondering why you thought it was useful to point out that someone who thinks a situation is unfair on certain children was likely to have been in that position as a child themselves. For your joke to work, you'd have to assume that being allocated the worst room purely because they were younger has had some kind of lasting effect on the person, influencing how they judge similar situations now, which seems to be the opposite of the point you want to make. I mean, saying "hahaha bet you're still resentful at a minor childhood unfairness" only highlights that minor childhood unfairnesses can loom large for children and be remembered for many decades.

joan12 · 04/02/2023 23:30

I think if you put your one year old in the big room, she will feel it is hers, and if you move a sibling on, in time, it will feel like an encroachment.

I say, put her in the small cozy room fr now with big toys downstairs, and then, if and when a sibling comes along and is ready, make a big fuss of decorating the larger room as a space for them both, with the toys etc in there . At that poi t you take the small room as an office.

FrangipaniBlue · 04/02/2023 23:20

I never said I couldn’t imagine anyone not having a spare room, did I? If you read what I said, I said I didn’t believe anyone didn’t know anyone with a spare room. That’s obviously ridiculous. It’s like saying you’ve never met anyone with a dog.

@Cheeping You actually said guest room. A spare room and guest room are not the same thing.

I know several people who have "spare" rooms in their houses (including myself) but none are kitted out or could be used as "guest rooms".

WestBridgewater · 04/02/2023 22:40

JarByTheDoor · 04/02/2023 20:08

So why is it funny again, the idea that a person who challenges the idea that the eldest gets the biggest/best as standard is likely to be someone who experienced how that feels as a younger sibling? Sorry, I must be a bit thick cause I'm not getting all the 😜-worthiness.

FGS My crime appears to be having an apparently offensive light hearted opinion of putting the eldest child in the bigger room and making a joke at the expense of someone that took umbrage with the original comment.
I can’t imagine turfing a child out of their room because their sibling wants a view of the garden. Does the older child not have a say about being ousted? As stated previously I am the product of the box room, even after my brother had left home and I don’t feel like my parents treated me unfairly. I honestly can’t believe my comment has bothered you that much, it’s an opinion not law.

Luredbyapomegranate · 04/02/2023 22:21

Keepyourmummysboys · 04/02/2023 22:12

I never understand this and treated my daughter as equal to us as far as possible . I recall viewing our current house, which had en suite for one of the non master rooms and when I said it would suit our daughter, rhe agent saying but why would you give that to your child, she can have the smallest room.

eh. No. She can have the second biggest. She’s not lesser. I don’t understand why you’d give your child the smallest room. And save the two biggest for you and storage. Don’t you see your kid as part of the family. Or is she just an inconvenience ?

Are you on the sauce again? Yesterday it was telling some OP her husband had a low salary because he was on £45k, now it’s asking this OP if she sees her baby as an inconvenience because of how she’s planning her house.

The OP’s child is 1. Many babies have smallish rooms because babies are - wait for it - small. They don’t need desks or play stations or filing space and they don’t like hanging out in their rooms except when they’re sleeping, and so a small room can work well for them and the household.

Luredbyapomegranate · 04/02/2023 22:15

LolaSmiles · 04/02/2023 18:53

She's 1 so isn't going to be playing in her room as she'll be playing where you are.

I'd make the second double a guest room come storage come office room like you plan.

If you have another child in future then they can both share the second bedroom and the single room can become your home office.

Yep this.

Just make sure any built in furniture you put in the second double will still work for 2 kids w bunk beds

Keepyourmummysboys · 04/02/2023 22:12

I never understand this and treated my daughter as equal to us as far as possible . I recall viewing our current house, which had en suite for one of the non master rooms and when I said it would suit our daughter, rhe agent saying but why would you give that to your child, she can have the smallest room.

eh. No. She can have the second biggest. She’s not lesser. I don’t understand why you’d give your child the smallest room. And save the two biggest for you and storage. Don’t you see your kid as part of the family. Or is she just an inconvenience ?

CheshireDing · 04/02/2023 22:11

It wouldn’t even cross my mind that the DC would get the small room whilst the double becomes an office. Seems unfair, as an adult you don’t need that much space for a home office and you can be clever with storage.

really young children have large toys and like a pp said want to set things up, today DS has lots of Lego currently being built on his floor and DD has a Barbie house in her room

Cheeping · 04/02/2023 22:02

Cheeping · 04/02/2023 22:00

I never said I couldn’t imagine anyone not having a spare room, did I? If you read what I said, I said I didn’t believe anyone didn’t know anyone with a spare room. That’s obviously ridiculous. It’s like saying you’ve never met anyone with a dog.

I’ve just googled it and 50% of households in the UK have a spare room. Given that half of people have a spare room, I stand by my assertion that it’s absolute bollocks to claim that anyone doesn’t know a single person at all who has a spare room.

Cheeping · 04/02/2023 22:00

WhoNeedsSleepNotISaidMyBody · 04/02/2023 21:50

@Cheeping

how can you not imagine people don't have a spare room or know people that do. Many people don't have enough space for their immediate family. How can you be so unaware of that?

(

I never said I couldn’t imagine anyone not having a spare room, did I? If you read what I said, I said I didn’t believe anyone didn’t know anyone with a spare room. That’s obviously ridiculous. It’s like saying you’ve never met anyone with a dog.

WhoNeedsSleepNotISaidMyBody · 04/02/2023 21:59

ShillyShallySherbet · 04/02/2023 21:54

Unless you have a separate play room she’ll need the bigger room in a few years for all her toys!

& so what?

anything can happen 'within a few years'

@CanStopWillStop I'm team you

Right now she doesn't need a bigger room. She's far too young to play independently, so use the big room as you've said and 'in future'/years to come, you can change things when you want to. It's a weekend & a bit of paint.

ShillyShallySherbet · 04/02/2023 21:54

Unless you have a separate play room she’ll need the bigger room in a few years for all her toys!

WhoNeedsSleepNotISaidMyBody · 04/02/2023 21:50

Cheeping · 04/02/2023 19:34

You don’t know anyone with a guest room?! Really??

  • I have one
  • My parents have two
  • My sister has one
  • Both my brothers have at least one
  • My best friend from school has one
  • DH’s best friend has one
  • Our NDN has one
  • In fact, both sides do.
  • Our NDN at our previous house did
  • So did the other side
  • So did we in our old house
They’re insanely common, how could you possibly not know anyone who has one?

@Cheeping

how can you not imagine people don't have a spare room or know people that do. Many people don't have enough space for their immediate family. How can you be so unaware of that?

(

WiddlinDiddlin · 04/02/2023 21:15

Whilst she won't be playing in her room now, she will later - how long will you want other rooms of the house cluttered up with bulky toys?

I would give her the second double room, make the smallest room your permanent office.

Then if you do have another, she can share the room once the baby is old enough to be out of your room.

The alternative is that if she has the small room and you kit out the bigger room as an office/spare room - when she DOES need the bigger room, needs her own desk, space for her stuff etc, you'd have to switch rooms and probably replace a lot of furniture as it won't fit the other way around.

I think I would put her certain future needs above those of a none existant baby, and guests, personally.

silvermantella · 04/02/2023 21:05

InspectorPaws · 04/02/2023 19:28

Yes, it’s a ridiculous and incredibly unfair behaviour that (for some unknown reason) parents think is entirely justified.

'ridiculous' and 'incredibly unfair' is a bit OTT - for most families it makes sense because oldest child will usually need a room or a room with privacy/more room/space to do homework/have friends over earlier so it would be irrational for a bigger room to sit empty waiting for a younger child to be born/old enough to sleep alone in it while a child already born/old enough is in a smaller room. Also traditionally older child would move out first, whether for uni/to get married etc. so younger siblings would have 'a turn' at the bigger room whereas that would be unlikely to happen the other way round.

Obviously sticking to it religiously if it would actually be better for the individual children to swap/keeping the bigger room empty even when DC1 is off at uni is unfair, but if there's no extenuating circumstances then it makes sense as a baseline.

I personally would give DD the bigger room because at some point she's going to want/need it, so why create faff for the future in swapping things around. Get good storage in her room and store additional stuff in it if needed.

LorW · 04/02/2023 20:11

I’d give her the biggest room, toys as they get older are huge, toy kitchens, barbie houses etc etc. Then if a sibling comes they can share and you can continue using the small room as a office.

HiddenGiraffes · 04/02/2023 20:10

InspectorPaws · 04/02/2023 20:08

I’d say a three year old tends to need more space than a one year old - and, so long as each child’s needs it met, it doesn’t really matter. It’s just frustrating speaking to people and they say things like “oh DD(8) is such a light sleeper and the streetlight keeps her up all night even with the blackout curtains” and then someone would suggest “why not swap rooms with DS(9) who isn’t affected by the light?” and they’d say “oh, but the room at the back of the house is much bigger”.

Like, so damn what?! Why do people think the baseline is that the older child always gets the bigger bedroom and then completely overrides any logical or practical arrangements. I’m very much a logistician so it just irks me - it seems so wildly irrational and yet so widely practiced.

Yeah, if there's a specific reason like that I totally agree with you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread