Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be annoyed with my fearful DD

115 replies

MiMouse · 04/02/2023 18:40

OK, not sure what I want with this thread, but I need to get this off my chest. I know I am being unreasonable, but my kid is driving me up the wall. She will be 4 this month, and she is afraid of the most random things. Everything is scary. I can never play any of the music I like because it is "scary" (believe me - I have the most basic taste in music), stories are scary (we're still reading Dear Zoo and Where's Spot - even something like The Tiger Who Came to Tea is too scary, let alone any Julia Donaldson), the playground is scary... She just seems to have so much anxiety. Anyway, today I bought her a dvd box of the one tv show she loves -she asked for it and I thought it'd make her happy- but she's terrified of the menu screen (again, I have no idea why) and refuses to watch it, getting herself into a panic if I even come near the tv now. I gave her a row for making me spend money on something that she now doesn't want anymore, and sent her to her room. I know it is counterproductive, but I am just out of patience. I have tried to be understanding for so long, but I was never like this as a kid and I have no idea where it is coming from (no traumas or big events in her life, am happily married to her dad, no tensions in the family, neither her dad nor I are stressed or have anxiety).

OP posts:
Happyhappyday · 04/02/2023 21:41

My DC is a little like this, she’s very sensitive to emotional drama, Finding Nemo was a DISASTER. She gets upset with DH and I “argue” ie, I say I’d like Thai for dinner and he says he fancies Indian, the emotion is too much for her. We tend to not change behavior but briefly explain that we’re discussing not arguing. She decided she was afraid of dogs after previously loving and having no negative interaction. Initially we talked about it a lot and got nowhere, so started just ignoring when she shrieked and hid and started a joke with her that they must be baby wolves if they were so scary (she enjoys), while also having small positive interactions with a couple of very gentle old dogs she knows well. She is fine now, but took about 8 weeks for the full cycle. Might be that the attention to the fears are reinforcing them, it’s certainly the case with my DC.

Toomuchinfor · 04/02/2023 21:39

I think your daughter may be autistic.

Don't punish her. You'll look back and kick yourself. Life really is scary to her. Have her back.

TheSnowyOwl · 04/02/2023 21:36

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 04/02/2023 21:14

My niece is like this, I can understand why you got frustrated op I would as well.

I personally wouldn't enable the anxiety by allowing her to avoid everything she's scared of. The only way she's going to learn to manage anxiety is by exposure and understanding she can manage these feelings.

I'd also be looking for ways to build her confidence.

It depends why she is like it. If she is ND then she won’t just get used to it.

Burgoo · 04/02/2023 21:33

@MiMouse "I gave her a row for making me spend money on something that she now doesn't want anymore, and sent her to her room."

OUCH! I had that when I was a child. I still feel terrible guilt for making my parent get me something (I am now nearly 40!)

I want to know how she knows she is "scared". Try getting her to tell you what exactly is scary about it. She may not know. Don't punish emotions, please!

Validate that it must be awful if she is scared and still push through and don't shy away from things she is scared of. She will learn to avoid things and that is so damaging longer-term.

Good luck!

Purplepepsi · 04/02/2023 21:33

Would recommend reading 'the highly sensitive child' and 'why smart kids worry and what parents can do to help'.

noscoobydoodle · 04/02/2023 21:31

My DD was like this from about 18months. Scared of all sorts of random everyday things like walking on grass and crossing the road. Some things have been fine one day (book, TV programme, certain route to school) and then suddenly she is scared- and it's full on terrified. She is 9 now and manages her worries much better as she is more often able to rationalize with herself or discuss feelings in more depth with us. I would describe her now as very risk averse and with a heightened sense of danger - so she wouldn't walk on the canal towpath for example, but could watch a TV programme where someone does that without getting scared. She likes school-, lots of rules, predictable timetable etc. And has lots of friends at school and her sports club. Never assessed/diagnosed with anything. I sometimes feel like I need the patience of a Saint but I would say for us it's got easier over time and we have never dismissed her feelings of being scared but have tried to support her to address the fears where possible.

Joshitai · 04/02/2023 21:27

I understand losing your patience, but YABU to row with a 4yr old and send them to their room after guilting them about spending money on something they didn’t like but couldn’t possibly know if they would like it ahead of time!! Really! You should have apologised to her for accidentally buying something that scared her. You need to be her safe and trusted person if she is going to get confidence.

4yr olds often are either fearful or fearless. I have had both. They both come with challenges. The fearful one would be afraid they’d gets sucked down the plug hole so refused to take a shower or be in the bath when you pull the plug. The fearless one went to the seaside and decided to run straight into the waves and fought me when I picked them up, saying the waves will knock you over! It’s why some 4yr olds are in harnesses on leads and others are holding their parents hands like glue.

You have a fearful 4yr old and the tactic I found that worked best was to keep to the comfort zone and only add one small new thing a day. Like at the playground, the swing is much too scary…so day 1, we just hold onto the swing and push it a bit while empty. Next visit, mum acts all silly with the swing. Next visit, child brings a doll to put in the swing. Then child sits in swing. Then gently swing while holding doll.

Trust me, the fearful ones don’t stay that way forever, just like the fearless ones don’t either. They gravitate to an equilibrium of sorts around age 7 or so.

bagelbagelbagel · 04/02/2023 21:16

She's scared, OP. Believe her. She finds the unknown very scary. She finds sudden noise scary. Turn the tv down a bit, reassure her.

Girliefriendlikespuppies · 04/02/2023 21:14

My niece is like this, I can understand why you got frustrated op I would as well.

I personally wouldn't enable the anxiety by allowing her to avoid everything she's scared of. The only way she's going to learn to manage anxiety is by exposure and understanding she can manage these feelings.

I'd also be looking for ways to build her confidence.

JudgeRudy · 04/02/2023 21:08

BaroldandNedmund · 04/02/2023 20:10

My mum still tells me off for screaming when I have a fright. I’m 50 and she’s 83🙂. I’m autistic and scared of my own shadow.

I shriek when the microwave pings even though I'm actually watching it.

Tandora · 04/02/2023 21:04

Woooaaa. YANBU for feeling frustrated- it sounds infuriating, but YAB vvvv u to have sent her to her room. She has done absolutely nothing wrong and you are shaming her and punishing her for having her own emotions. That’s emotional abuse. You need to do some damage control. Start but acknowledging how wrong you were and apologise. A pp was spot on when they said you need to parent the child you haveZ Perhaps look into some parenting resources for parenting a hyper sensitive child.

FatGirlSwim · 04/02/2023 21:01

Why? Autism isn’t a bad thing.

JudgeRudy · 04/02/2023 21:01

Is she actually scared of things or do they just 'jar'. I have sensory issues and have eg walked into a room and audibly recoiled at horrible wallpaper or shrieked at a sudden movement or smell. Also have a bit of blu tac with me to cover 'offensive' lights on work PCs. I once had to put a poncho over my head and run through the duty free at the airport as the competing perfumes smells were 'assauting' my senses. It is an unpleasant sensation and I can certainly relate to a 'scary' menu. It's a similar emotional feeling to getting a bucket of water thrown in your face.
Maybe she just doesn't have the vocabulary to explain. Have you noticed any other unusual behaviors?

Optionally · 04/02/2023 21:00

My dd like this largely grew out of it, but in her teens remains highly sensitive to noise and busyness. Still hates airport waiting areas, for example. I found explaining what was going to happen in advance, maybe even having a practice run with her attached to me like a limpet, making it clear I was calm and everything was ok all helped.

No diagnosis here - I think she’s learned how to handle things she’s not comfortable with by using the approaches I used with her (research beforehand, practice run etc).

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 04/02/2023 20:55

Mariposista · 04/02/2023 20:52

School will sort her out. But will be a rude awakening

It may well make her worse.

TheSnowyOwl · 04/02/2023 20:55

Mariposista · 04/02/2023 20:52

School will sort her out. But will be a rude awakening

It might not. It might be traumatic and psychologically cause all kinds of harm. School might also say she can’t manage mainstream in a way others can and adapt for her. A good school will pick up on any sensory concerns or autistic traits and work with her to ensure it’s not a rude awakening.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 04/02/2023 20:54

And losing temper/shouting just made everything worse.

Sparkleshine21 · 04/02/2023 20:53

@Mariposista 🤦🏼‍♀️ she’s not doing anything wrong ffs!

Mariposista · 04/02/2023 20:52

School will sort her out. But will be a rude awakening

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 04/02/2023 20:52

My dd was like this. Scared of lots, wouldn’t sleep on her own.

Later diagnosed as ASD.

AllOutofEverything · 04/02/2023 20:51

Too much reassurance can enforce that she is right to be scared of something.

I too wonder if this is being reinforced as it gets her attention.

I would be more matter of fact. She can read or watch what kids TV programmes she wants. But I would not entertain her being frightened of ordinary music. I would play it lowish and if she does not like it, she can go to her room. Avoiding ordinary things that makes her anxious will make her worse.

whataboutsecondbreakfast · 04/02/2023 20:50

MiMouse · 04/02/2023 20:19

A lot of you are have brought up autism. While I cannot rule it out completely because DD is still so young and I know ASD can present itself in different ways, she shows no other symptoms. She's also not particularly quiet or shy.

Part of why this is so frustrating is that her fears seem to be so unpredictable. She can love a song or a picture or a game for weeks, wanting to see / hear it every day, and then suddenly be terrified. She cannot express why or what scares her exactly: it is just scary and she doesn't like it. I do think she has a very vivid imagination - her pretend play scenarios are often epic.

All the things you describe in your post fit perfectly with ASD. Of course, your DD could just be highly sensitive, but please don't rule out autism just because she doesn't come across as quiet or shy.

I was diagnosed autistic in my twenties but came across as a very confident child. I performed in school plays and at the local theatre, happily read in glass and regularly had playdates and loved parties. I also had an incredibly vivid imagination and could play alone for hours on my own.

As an adult I struggle with sleep as my imagination gets away with me - often to the point of anxiety attacks although these are better controlled than they were. I also hyper-focus on things for several days/weeks and then dismiss it completely and won't look at it again for months (if ever). Often things I used to love overwhelm me, and sometimes it flips the other way - things I was terrified of suddenly appeal hugely.

The fear of (what seems like) really basic things could be sensory overload that she can't explain verbally. As a child, I hated having my hair touched/played with, wearing socks, the texture of bananas and the smell of chicken. I couldn't explain why - but in my head it was just an overload of the senses to the point I couldn't cope. Interestingly as an adult, I still hate wearing socks and having my hair played with, but I love banana sandwiches Grin

Sparkleshine21 · 04/02/2023 20:49

@Quail15 read @bunhead1979 s comment about how she was treated as an autistic child and how that made her feel, and then please adjust your behaviour with your dd before you do her damage.

bunhead1979 · 04/02/2023 20:47

Zooeyzo · 04/02/2023 20:36

@bunhead1979 do you have male autistic family members? My 7 year old DD is fearful of everything and her younger brother is autistic. I think she probably is as well and just make adjustments for her. But like a lot of girls is under the radar...highly intelligent, social to an extent, extremely empathetic and very sensitive. She really is the best person I know I want to wrap her in cotton wool.

No one was diagnosed at the time but my dad and brother are very probably autistic.

MiMouse · 04/02/2023 20:47

I have been wondering if "scary" really means "scary". She seems to use it for negative emotions or sensations in general.

And yes, she's been through a pandemic, but compared to most families I think we had it easy. Both her dad and I are key workers, no front line stuff but not able to work from home, and she just went to nursery.

No autism in the family. I read the list @bagelbagelbagel , and it really doesn't resonate aside from perhaps a few things. Then again, she's only 4 - not even 4.

OP posts: