Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parent refusing to have their child assessed

132 replies

StrongCoffeeAvalanche · 04/02/2023 11:01

Hi, I don't want to give too many details for obvious reasons.

I am a teacher. A student I teach has many signs of SEN. We realistically cannot cater for their needs as things are. We need to put extra support in place. However due to their strong beliefs the parent is refusing to allow any assessments or help to be offered. They say their child is lazy and just isn't working hard enough. The parent does no believe in neurological differences.

I have spoken to SENCO. For reasons I cannot disclose I also want to look into this myself.

Is this parent breaking any policies? I am wondering if it falls under being a form of child neglect? Is there anything we can do or does parent opinion mean we can't do anything?

The child is desperate for assessment. It is crushing them and their mental health.

Thanks.

OP posts:
Itisbetter · 04/02/2023 18:20

@Justmeandthedog1 surely exactly the same arguments could be made about this teachers input?

Itisbetter · 04/02/2023 18:18

@RampantIvy How does a student get extra consideration without some kind of evidence @Itisbetter? Can they get this without diagnosis? It will be needed to claim DSA at university?

  1. they will need evidence of support used consistently over time in school.
  2. yes
  3. I don’t have experience of claiming DSA at university
Justmeandthedog1 · 04/02/2023 17:59

A 16 year old can consent to their own medical treatment and make their own medical appointments. If a parent is preventing this because of their” beliefs’ surely that is a form of coercive control? Surely the school safeguarding team should involve SS so the teen has an independent advocate?

RampantIvy · 04/02/2023 17:37

RosesAndHellebores · 04/02/2023 15:03

For all those suggesting that a 16/17 year old can and should refer themselves independently of their parents, do you have any idea how vulnerable and disempowered a young person suffering from anxiety/depression with possibly neuro-diverse conditions accompanying it actually is? Notwithstanding the need to have unwavering support and an advocate to get them on the road to recovery.

I totally agree.

none of that requires diagnosis.

How does a student get extra consideration without some kind of evidence @Itisbetter? Can they get this without diagnosis? It will be needed to claim DSA at university?

InspectorPaws · 04/02/2023 15:30

It’s odd to me that any teacher would be asking this. It’s a desperately regular occurrence so I’m a bit surprised you haven’t come across it and appear so flummoxed by it.

Skiphopbump · 04/02/2023 15:29

The SENCO can still put support into place without a diagnosis.

I remember one of my DDs was assessed by the SENCO for writing speed and fluency, I wasn’t aware until DD told me about it. There must be internal assessments that can be done and based on those support can be put in place. My DS has also had many interventions which I haven’t had to consent to. The child can be helped without his parents support.

Willyoujustbequiet · 04/02/2023 15:27

Itisbetter · 04/02/2023 13:42

Extra time in exams, use of a laptop in exams, extra consideration just isn't going to happen if a parent just tells the teacher that their child has ASD or other issues. When they go to university they need written evidence so that the student can claime DSA. none of that requires diagnosis.

This.

I find this odd. Schools can go down the EHCP route and secure additional funding without a formal diagnosis.

PennywisePoundFoolish · 04/02/2023 15:24

For those saying it's neglect, the wait for an ASD assessment in my area is about 3 years. It's really not akin to a possible broken limb.

I say this as a parent of DC who do have formal diagnosis 2 DC NHS, 1 private.

Quisquam · 04/02/2023 15:23

Extra time in exams, use of a laptop in exams, extra consideration just isn't going to happen if a parent just tells the teacher that their child has ASD or other issues. When they go to university they need written evidence so that the student can claime DSA. none of that requires diagnosis.

DD had a specific learning difficulty with no name. The university told her, she couldn’t have any reasonable adjustments, as it had no name. While my education solicitor wrote them a letter, we still didn’t fancy taking action against them. Luckily she was diagnosed with something else, and then they gave her all the help she needed.

TeamadIshbel · 04/02/2023 15:17

ClearMoth · 04/02/2023 14:07

Another perspective which I've seen argued very persuasively by the brilliant neurologist I mentioned earlier is that a diagnosis of any condition, but especially those that involve the mind and personality and behaviour, is to some extent a self-fulfilling prophecy.

It is not as simple as care instructions on garment. Having a specific diagnosis has an impact on that person's future in many, complex ways. People aren't items of clothing and being formally diagnosed with a neurological/psychological/behavioural condition is not a neutral act.

Yes, that's a good point to consider. I find it concerning how frightened this child is around the parent finding out they have sought help, major red flag.

But also if a child had a hearing impairment that seriously impacted the quality of their life experiences would they be denied a hearing aid, if a child had was blind would it be acceptable to have no sensory accommodations made in a mainstream setting or if they were immobile with no learning difficulties would they be given access to a lift, a wheelchair to be accommodated in a mainstream school?

Many of these issues are covered under the Equality Act and its basic level for a teacher to identify the child's needs and plan to meet those needs, a diagnosis in itself doesn't affect that. However for some ND conditions a diagnosis provides relief and is a way for the child or person to understand themselves and access help. Although dyslexia isn't ND many people aged 60 plus are only realising now they have dyslexia but never got support leading to a lifetime of confusion and shame.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 04/02/2023 15:07

@ppure your child is getting a good education and care that you're arranging for him, but the OP's pupil clearly isn't, and these assessments are needed so he or she can get them. The school can put help in place up to a point but how are the school supposed to evaluate what interventions the child needs if the parents wont agree to call in professional help?

Your child doesn't have a specific diagnosis but does have a paediatritian and his needs and disabilities have been recognised. Without a referral the OP's pupil child wont have that, and when he gets to 18 without a recognised disability he wont be entitled to any support at all, not at work or in education, unless he looks for them himself.

And boys who don't have "obvious" autism can easily end up in trouble and in the criminal justice system. So it's a different situation.

RosesAndHellebores · 04/02/2023 15:03

For all those suggesting that a 16/17 year old can and should refer themselves independently of their parents, do you have any idea how vulnerable and disempowered a young person suffering from anxiety/depression with possibly neuro-diverse conditions accompanying it actually is? Notwithstanding the need to have unwavering support and an advocate to get them on the road to recovery.

Spinninggyro · 04/02/2023 14:41

I would suggest you talk to whoever is the safeguarding lead in your school.

larkstar · 04/02/2023 14:37

divine=simple!

Confrontayshunme · 04/02/2023 14:36

We had a child who had fits in our class, and the parents were to be called first, NOT an ambulance, as they believed the child was doing it for attention. It was so distressing, and we filled out safeguarding concerns multiple times, but were told that as the fits had "no adverse impact" on the child's overall health or intelligence, it was not formally considered neglect. It was just distressing and embarrassing for them to wet themselves and shake in the class every month or so.

I think in some cases of SEN, it would help the teacher, TA and school to get the extra funding from a diagnosis, but some parents are just never going to understand neurodiversity. I am currently 1:1 for the most severe case of ASC I have ever witnessed in a mainstream school, and I have stopped telling parents when he is having meltdowns as they just scream at him for being naughty and not listening to me then punish him by removing his sensory toys at home. It is awful, but they are embarrassed and just want to discipline him into being normal.

larkstar · 04/02/2023 14:36

@Tickledtrout teachers, like many other professions also have a duty of care under common law, statutory law (Children's act 2004) and under the contract of employment - it's not as divine as saying that a teachers job is to teach.

SovietKitsch · 04/02/2023 14:32

I’ve not read the thread, so sorry if I’m repeating what’s already been said - but being year 12 16/17 years old is good news - for example once 16 young people bring their own ECHP appeals etc - they themselves can ask the LA to assess, the parent doesn’t need to be involved

DuchessOfDisco · 04/02/2023 14:28

this happens all to often.
I remember a student starting in yr7, who we all referred to senco for asd assessment as they hit so many markers. Turns out it was the parents who refused to acknowledge there were any issues and had demanded the primary school to remove any comments about possible asd when they moved up schools. It was heartbreaking. We got around it by always placing him on the same table with the students who did have ehcp’s and therefore TA help, and an informal agreement between TAs to support him when we could, but it’s awful that when it came to exams and then moving on to college he wouldn’t get the support he needed.
it honestly should be a form on neglect - if a kid had a broken leg and parents refused to let them seek medical help then it is. Mental health and neurological conditions should be treated exactly the same

ChildminderMum · 04/02/2023 14:09

This young person doesn't need a diagnosis for an ECHP or to have interventions at school?

How long are waiting lists where you are? Seems likely they will have left school before they are seen by anyone anyway.

ClearMoth · 04/02/2023 14:07

Phineyj · 04/02/2023 13:44

I saw a good analogy for the diagnosis/label thing the other day. "It's like washing labels. Wouldn't you want to know if your jumper is wool, delicate, needs extra care, will shrink at a high temperature?" And from a practical point of view, in an English state school, no diagnosis often means no help because resources are so stretched. That "label" matters.

Anyway, OP, I've been in your position. The child was removed to a boarding school in the parents' home country at the end of year 12.

One practical thing the SENCO can do is apply for rest breaks for exams. No diagnosis or testing needed for that.

Another perspective which I've seen argued very persuasively by the brilliant neurologist I mentioned earlier is that a diagnosis of any condition, but especially those that involve the mind and personality and behaviour, is to some extent a self-fulfilling prophecy.

It is not as simple as care instructions on garment. Having a specific diagnosis has an impact on that person's future in many, complex ways. People aren't items of clothing and being formally diagnosed with a neurological/psychological/behavioural condition is not a neutral act.

Inkpotlover · 04/02/2023 13:57

SunnySnowdrop · 04/02/2023 13:45

No it doesn't, the child is 16. If they want to apply for an ehcna they don't need parents permission, the young person can authorise and sign the relevant documents and make the relevant decisions.

Might be worth seeing if you can get them an advocate actually OP. Your local sendiass/IASS or parent career forum may be able to advise on where to find one in your area,

I missed where OP had mentioned their age. I still find it a little odd she seems to know nothing about how to proceed, isn't it standard training for teachers these days?

SunnySnowdrop · 04/02/2023 13:45

Inkpotlover · 04/02/2023 13:40

Are you an ECT, OP? I thought all teachers would aware parental permission for diagnosis/support application has to be sought in cases like this, so I'm surprised you don't know that and have posted on MN saying as much.

No it doesn't, the child is 16. If they want to apply for an ehcna they don't need parents permission, the young person can authorise and sign the relevant documents and make the relevant decisions.

Might be worth seeing if you can get them an advocate actually OP. Your local sendiass/IASS or parent career forum may be able to advise on where to find one in your area,

Phineyj · 04/02/2023 13:44

I saw a good analogy for the diagnosis/label thing the other day. "It's like washing labels. Wouldn't you want to know if your jumper is wool, delicate, needs extra care, will shrink at a high temperature?" And from a practical point of view, in an English state school, no diagnosis often means no help because resources are so stretched. That "label" matters.

Anyway, OP, I've been in your position. The child was removed to a boarding school in the parents' home country at the end of year 12.

One practical thing the SENCO can do is apply for rest breaks for exams. No diagnosis or testing needed for that.

SunnySnowdrop · 04/02/2023 13:43

Patineur · 04/02/2023 12:10

At age 16 and in year 12, the child is technically a young person under the Children and Families Act 2014 (which governs SEN provision) which means that the right to make decisions has passed over to the child. They can make their own request for assessment, and they can consent to an assessment request made by the school. The norm would be to involve parents closely in the process, but given all the circumstances I believe that if they were to ask that their parents are kept right out of it the LA would have to accept that request. However, I assume they would have to make an arrangement for post to come to them through the school or a PO Box address.

All of that needs to be done in conjunction with safeguarding action given their fears of their parents. I'd suggest chasing up with the safeguarding leads what they have done about that referral.

This!

Itisbetter · 04/02/2023 13:42

Extra time in exams, use of a laptop in exams, extra consideration just isn't going to happen if a parent just tells the teacher that their child has ASD or other issues. When they go to university they need written evidence so that the student can claime DSA. none of that requires diagnosis.

Swipe left for the next trending thread