Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for help- husband witnessed a death

184 replies

bingbangbongding · 03/02/2023 23:25

Hi all,

Need help.

Husband was leaving work today and found a colleague dead in his car. He was about 50, was still warm. He asked passers by for help but no one would help him. Everyone had left work.

He called 999 and they got him to drag this man out of the car and perform CPR even though he said he was dead. It didn't work.

The ambulance and police arrived and the ambulance worked on him for a while. Police dismissed him immediately (didn't even want his details which I thought was weird).

He's absolutely shaken and has decided to get quite drunk (understandable).

Has anyone been through this?

How can I support him? I'm terrified he's going to get PTSD or something.

OP posts:
BishyBarnyBee · 04/02/2023 06:42

This is a really sad and moving thread. I hadn't realised so many people experience this - the idea of having to CPR a very dead stranger is a bit horrific, and I think who've done it should be very proud of themselves.

It's making me think - I've had CPR training a few times in the distant past. I sort of feel like I should know how to do it, but it's a bit rusty. In the event, I'd feel I'd have to have a go, but I'd be very unsure if I was doing it right.

Would just reading up on it from time to time be enough, or do we need to do regular top up training?

And I always wonder how you'd know CPR was the right thing - do you assume anyone not breathing needs it, not matter what the issue might be?

Teateaandmoretea · 04/02/2023 06:40

The CPR had no chance of resuscitating him, so DH doesn't need to feel guilty that he couldn't bring him back.

Wow no passer-by who bravely steps in has any reason to feel guilty. Only about 10% are successful.

My mum died very suddenly and I will always be incredibly grateful to the amazingly brave lady who was there and tried her best in impossible circumstances. Performing cpr on a stranger when you aren’t a healthcare professional is an incredible thing to do whether it’s successful or not and you should be really proud of DH.

I dunno, there’s comfort for me in the fact that when it happened someone was there who cared that much. She found it difficult after and it was a bit weird almost having her dragged into our tragedy from nowhere. I think she did get over it though but it is such a big shock.

Toddlerteaplease · 04/02/2023 06:26

@Sparklynewname our resuscitation team do a debrief if we need it after any emergency. I had one when I had to do CPR at work on a baby. (Got her back) and it was very helpful.

Minimalme · 04/02/2023 06:14

I have ptsd from childhood abuse and I also agree that being scared for my own life caused it (and the repetition over many years).

You dh did so well and can be proud of himself for being brave. Genuinely - most people wouldn't be able to do what he did.

Let him talk as much as he wants but at the moment he is in Adrenalin and once that's gone, he may just need a cry and a sleep.

SeatonCarew · 04/02/2023 06:08

My DC had to perform CPR on a driver who collapsed at the wheel and sadly he didn't make it. Poignantly, she was only able to do this because she herself is a survivor due to CPR. She has no lasting trauma from doing so, although naturally it shook her for a little while, especially as it was part of a much larger incident.

You need to stay calm and reassuring for your DH, OP. Keep reminding him he did absolutely the right thing, and it will be of enormous comfort to the poor man's family in the future to know everything possible was tried, and that somebody cared.

BurntOutGirl · 04/02/2023 05:54

bingbangbongding · 03/02/2023 23:47

Thank you all for the suggestions. I didn't know about being able to contact British Heart Foundation or the recussitation officers at hospital.

He's not massively talky normally and he has rabbited on at me all night so I know he is in shock.

I won't push him or anything but if he's open to suggestions in a few days I'll let him know about it.

Thank you again.

I don't think the resuscitation officers at the hospital will help you.

It's not a hospital patient and he doesn't work there.

If l had a phonecall by a member of public requesting this, I'd advise them to seek help via his employer or charities who offer CPR training.

ittakes2 · 04/02/2023 05:50

The same happened to me in a sainsburys carpark. And also when I asked for help I was told not to bother as this chap was elderly and assumed dead. But the cpr training in inadequate in the UK and I was raised in Australia where we have a lot of cpr training due to the water. Plus I had extra training when I had kids. The guy was still warm and no sign of blueness on his lips etc. It is true that it’s difficult to survive severe heart attacks unless action is taken quickly and I had only seen this man inside the shop 10mins prior. I tried my best for his family’s sake and when the ambulance came they tried too.
From sainsburys perspective it was a bit of a shit show as I was literally 20 steps away from the front door and I assumed they had a defibrillator which I had been trained to use. But when the manager finally came when they called him off his smoke break he said no defibrillator and also no first aider to help me. When a stranger took over cpr from me I remember googling defibrillators and realising they are harder to track down than you think.
the first few weeks were hard as I kept thinking what I could have done differently. To cope I developed an action plan in my mind of what to do if it happened again - which may seem unlikely but this is not the first person I have had to resuscitate in sainsburys ironically. 20 years ago I had to resuscitate a staff member - I wasn’t the first on the scene I was the only person nearby who knew cpr as the training for it in the uk is not extensive. Again on that occasion no staff member came to help me either.
Also to help me process I sent my family on cpr / Debriflatobor training.
I avoided that sainsburys for a year. But I am ok now. Time heals.

the Uk needs to up its game in terms of training so people know what they need to do in these circumstances.

Tiani4 · 04/02/2023 05:47

If it helps at all OP, talking over the times and worrying that it took too long to call 999 or start CPR is an understandable and normal reaction . Also moving a persons body and doing CPR are very physical acts so that physical memory (& all the senses recall) naturally stay a while , his talking about it is his brain processing it and trying to make sense and how to store it

This man's family - down the line- will be so grateful that their loved one wasn't found dead the next day in the car unnoticed. That your wonderful observant DH noticed, tried to wake him through car windows and then called 999 and did CPR on him whilst waiting for paramedics - to try all attempts to save their loved one's life.
He did a very good thing. Not just for this man but also for his family to know that.

LadyGardenersQuestionTime · 04/02/2023 05:07

If he does facebook there’s a gp group called Chain of Survival for those who have had similar experiences. They have useful links and resources too. Horrible shock for him.

Basecampzero · 04/02/2023 05:07

*Your not you're.

Basecampzero · 04/02/2023 05:06

QueenCamilla · 04/02/2023 01:34

Stressful and unpleasant events are quite apart from traumatic ones that cause PTSD.

I suppose some people are mentally fragile. Though I can't help but feel that the over-reaction here is minimising traumatic events & PTSD.

Similar to:

  • My cat died. I'm sad. Am I depressed?
  • No.
  • What am I?
  • You're just sad.
(and probably trans if you ask on TikTok 😂)

What a load of rubbish. Don't post about mental health issues if you don't know what you're talking about.

If you're cat was the only emotional connection you had and something that helped you not to feel lonely or isolated, of course you might become depressed.

People who get PTSD are not necessarily mentally fragile. That is stigmatising nonsense. PTSD is often caused by a traumatic event combined with a sense of powerlessness to change/escape from the situation and a lack of the right kind of support afterwards.

The OP's husband seems to be doing all the right things by talking about it at his own pace, reframing the situation (he was already dead and there was nothing he could do about it etc), getting reassurance from stroking his pet and watching things that make him laugh on TV.

If your DH does develop intrusive thoughts OP, then he may need some psychological support. Someone who specialises in Rewind or EMDR would be ideal. What it does is help people to put the memories which could have become fractured and confused, back into the part of the brain that stores every day memories. So looking back you remember the event as something much more like you remember a more usual event, less powerfully and without the same emotional charge.

As PPs have said, he may not need this though as he's handling it in his own way and you're providing excellent support for him by listening and going along with anything he instinctively needs.

lowclouds · 04/02/2023 04:37

henrilechat · 03/02/2023 23:44

I'm so sorry your husband had to go through that, it sounds awful for him.

This might sound a bit crazy but there's actually research that playing Tetris can help to prevent ptsd symptoms. I think it's something to do with helping the brain to process the memories and file them away properly - trauma tends to lead to ptsd when our brains haven't managed to do that, that's why we get flashbacks and stuff.
I hope he's ok op. It's worth saying that trauma doesn't automatically lead to ptsd. It might help if he understands this isn't inevitable. But equally, if that does happen, it's not his fault and there's help available.

Yes to Tetris or really anything he could do that is repetitive and uses a bit of brain power but not too much.

Video games can actually be quite good if he's into that kind of thing (obviously not too exciting/ shootery ones, but calmer ones, puzzle games etc).

He should try to talk about it as much as he can, to you, to friends/ family, to a counsellor. Every time he speaks about it will help him process it a bit more.

And obviously the other usual advice like getting outside if just for a little walk, or more intense exercise if that's his bag.

Occupying his body and his mind with something, whatever that is.

I'm sorry to hear that so many passers by did not help. That must have added to the trauma :(

WiddlinDiddlin · 04/02/2023 04:02

Diazepam is a good call if you can get any prescribed unfortunately I suspect by the time you can, the benefit of it will be mostly lost (it has an amnesiac effect that can lessen the effect of recent traumatic events).

Otherwise, keep talking to him, keep letting him talk, keep reiterating, CPR is nowhere NEAR as successful in real life as TV etc has people believe, even when done on reasonably healthy people, or indeed in hospitals (though they're generally not healthy people).

The best success rate is actually on athletes, when given immediately, because they're so fit and the people giving it generally well trained, but even THEN... by no means a high success rate (I suspect they are what gives us the success rate for 'outside a medical setting' in the first place, if you take them out its practically zero!)

It does sound like and I am certain a paramedic or dr would confirm, that he never had a chance of saving this person, from the moment he clapped eyes on the guy, the tiny delay in making the call will have made zero difference to the outcome.

I am sorry he has experienced this, but he can take some comfort from knowing he cared enough to do what he could, and many many people would not have.

MyFlagMeansIceCream · 04/02/2023 03:51

I've never had to do CPR, but I have attended crime scenes where there have been dead bodies, and not always in a nice state. I've had trauma debriefing for one of them, and she made me talk through my whole day focussing on how I felt at each stage. It took a couple of weeks for the flashbacks to stop on that one, but being able to talk to someone about the finer details of what was happening and how I was feeling about it really helped.

I hope he feels better soon.

Dustyblue · 04/02/2023 03:30

Reading these experiences makes my heart ache.

OP, your DH did everything he could've possibly done. And in all likelihood, that poor man was dead by the time he arrived. I hope if it were me in that car, someone would've attempted something, however futile.

He was actually very brave. Remind him of that when he's calmer.

kateandme · 04/02/2023 03:19

let him talk. let him talk. often in traumatic events we also shut down parts of the brain for fight or flight survival mode. so over the next few days things might come to him.or he might question himself. his story might even change slightly. be weary and calm with him over this but dont laugh or accuse him of lying or conflating. the brains simply cxathing up now.
remind him also "if you could have saved him would you" and there we go. so all the questioning,what ifs, times hes now thinking of that simple question will answer it all.

icefishing · 04/02/2023 02:55

There are good studies that show that playing Tetris if you are having intrusive memories is really helpful.
It helps disrupt the way that traumatic memories are stored.
So if he is struggling with repetitive memories get him to play Tetris.
It is too late for me to track down the studies.

GreenBiscuitr · 04/02/2023 02:48

GP might be able to give him diazepam for 24/48hrs whilst he goes through shock. This is what I had.

Vegansausagevole · 04/02/2023 02:44

I’ve done CPR on an elderly man who dropped down in front of me in a queue, I know the success rate of CPR isn’t great and it didn’t work for this man unfortunately, but I’m pretty practical and knew I’d given the man the best chance that I could and it never affected me afterwards. My sibling had to perform CPR on our dad at home, they brought him back but he died 3 days later in hospital, my sibling is a researcher in trauma and was able to work through their feelings and were left with no ongoing problems. So PTSD is not inevitable.

peachgreen · 04/02/2023 02:40

I performed CPR on my (very dead) husband. I felt his ribs break below my hands. I don’t have PTSD. It was fucking awful. But PTSD is not an inevitability.

MeetPi · 04/02/2023 02:36

Let him talk, and allow him some space to rest too when he needs to give his brain a break.

I've been through an experience similar to this where I had to rescue a drowned woman and attempt to revive her. It was unsuccessful. This was several years ago, but I still have difficulty seeing people that look like her and going near the place where it happened. I occasionally wonder if I could have done anything different and she might have lived; but I know that isn't likely. I remember the police visiting me too afterwards. I never had any therapy but perhaps I should have done - if your DH shows any sign of difficulty I'd recommend it.

Dustyblue · 04/02/2023 02:09

That's a horrible experience, your poor DH.

Just wanted to echo other posters who put this far better than I can- no, PTSD isn't inevitable after something like this.

I've had a couple of random experiences, like being held up us a shopkeeper and worse, seeing a driver have a seizure & slam into the pedestrians next to me). What your DH is quite different; most traumatic situations have their own nuances I reckon.

Let him process it for a few days and see how he feels. Totally agree that if this happened in his work carpark, he needs to report it. And make use of any support they might offer if he feels like it.

Hugs to you both.

Willyoujustbequiet · 04/02/2023 02:09

Coffeeandchocs · 03/02/2023 23:50

Just to add OP, please don’t assume he is traumatised. I’m not saying you would, but some of the most unhelpful comments I’ve had after dealing with deaths at work have been “that must be so traumatising”, “I couldn’t deal with doing that”, “I’d not stop crying if that were me” or words to that effect.

I know people mean well, they’re trying to be sympathetic. But often, as humans, even though these scenarios are upsetting, we can deal with these things quite well. It can make us feel less of a human if we have been able to cope with the experience and have people asking “aren’t you traumatised?!”.

Just be careful with the wording you use. Don’t question too much. Be there to listen. It may be upsetting to listen to, but try not to project those feelings onto your husband if he is after today feeling OK about it.

This.

Having witnessed many deaths over the years I would be careful to not blow this out of proportion. Yes of course its not nice and you should support him but don't jump to PTSD. Its a trauma for the poor man's family not your DH. Its perfectly normal for him to be upset in the circumstances but just give him some time.

overtaxedunderling · 04/02/2023 01:42

@bingbangbongding Give your husband some space to process this.

I've been in his position twice, the first time, I felt a lot of guilt because if it works on the TV, why not for me. Later, depending on when people had done CPR training, they had differing views and advice - that initially made me angry and frustrated. The reality is that with certain events, even surrounded by specialist doctors, the majority of people will not make it.

The second time, I was close to a major London teaching hospital when someone collapsed. The person quickly received excellent care from passing doctors and nurses, but still nothing could be done. I called my wife and took a long walk to gather my thoughts before going home.

Both memories are still with me, I don't feel guilt, I do find it bizarre that police didn't want a statement about how a young, slim woman died on a busy street - but perhaps it happens more often than we realise.

Let him talk if he wants to, don't bring it up unless he mentions it and don't expect too much of him for the next week or so. Hugs to you both.

DanFmDorking · 04/02/2023 01:37

He's laughing at the fact that someone ran up (after the paramedics arrived) and shouted 'I can help! I am a chiropractor!' And the paramedics just looked at him like Hmm and asked him to keep traffic moving down the road as people were stuck behind the ambulance.
@bingbangbongding - that's hilarious - I know a couple of paramedics - I will take a delight in telling them this. 😀