Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for help- husband witnessed a death

184 replies

bingbangbongding · 03/02/2023 23:25

Hi all,

Need help.

Husband was leaving work today and found a colleague dead in his car. He was about 50, was still warm. He asked passers by for help but no one would help him. Everyone had left work.

He called 999 and they got him to drag this man out of the car and perform CPR even though he said he was dead. It didn't work.

The ambulance and police arrived and the ambulance worked on him for a while. Police dismissed him immediately (didn't even want his details which I thought was weird).

He's absolutely shaken and has decided to get quite drunk (understandable).

Has anyone been through this?

How can I support him? I'm terrified he's going to get PTSD or something.

OP posts:
Littlewhitecat · 04/02/2023 08:39

My dad died of a heart attack whilst out for a walk. The man who found him had to do the same thing your husband did when it was obvious dad was dead. My mum reached out to this man via the police and was able to let him know how grateful we were he tried to help and that there was absolutely nothing he could have done. Having been on the other side of this as a relative of the dead person please reassure your husband that this man's family would be so grateful that he even tried to help.

Conkersinautumn · 04/02/2023 08:37

You're not obliged to do CPR. It must be stressful in a situation unfamiliar to you eith someone telling you, but there are many reasons to not carry out CPR. Most people looking at someone who has died will probably feel it is inappropriate/ invasive.

Hellsmovie · 04/02/2023 08:37

I hope it eats away at the people who didnt help.

Hope you OH gets the helps he wants/needs

plask · 04/02/2023 08:27

Please don't immediately think he needs counselling or will get ptsd.

He's had an awful shock and will need time to process it. Being upset at this stage is totally normal and shouldn't be pathologised. Let him deal with it how he wants.

saleorbouy · 04/02/2023 08:17

As a teenager I witnessed an accident in which a man who I'd previously been talking to for a while sufelffered severe head injuries and died in a motor racing incident that happened right in front of where I was spectating.
I still remember it as plain as day, the sights the sounds and smells.
I remember coming home to my parents beimg very upset and talking to them about it.
I know everyone processes things like this differently but fore talking about the situation, the tragic outcome etc was a good way to help me get to a place where those events were more emotionally manageable.
Maybe attending the funeral, talking to the man's family will help bring some closure?
Keep him talking and/or seek grief counselling, bottling up emotions or trying to find the solution at the bottom of a bottle will not help in the long term.
Can/does, his employer offer support?
I hope he can process this tragic event and come to a more peaceful place knowing he did everything he could to help.

user1471538283 · 04/02/2023 08:15

I'm so sorry. I think if he gets counseling and talks to you or a friend about it he is in with a chance of disbursing this trauma without PTSD. He needs time and to be kind to himself.

UnaOfStormhold · 04/02/2023 08:08

I've done a trauma risk management course and key takeaways from that included that 90% of people who experience potentially traumatic events are not affected by PTSD - they may be a bit shaken for a while but are fine after 6 months. As PP have said counselling is not generally recommended early on as this can make PTSD more likely. Things that help include talking to friends and colleagues, trying to avoid regularly drinking to forget (straight after is quite common, but if it carries on this can block processing trauma) and looking at other sources of stress in his daily life. Focussing on the fact that he acted and did all he could to help the person should also help as a feeling of being powerlerss and out of control is a key risk factor for developing PTSD. It's very normal to have physical and mental side effects (dreams, shakiness, irritability, difficulty concentrating) immediately afterwards but these should start to subside over the next few weeks - if they don't or if he's starting to struggle more, get professional help.

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 04/02/2023 08:05

Get him to play Tetris, it helps stop PTSD from developing.

SoShallINever · 04/02/2023 08:05

It actually really annoys me that the ambulance service do this to passers by. Getting involved in CPR is a choice that will affect the volunteer and have potentially long term mental health effects.

I've done CPR twice (outside of work) and several times inside work (HCP).
In both community events the patient was dead and I told the operator that.
With my father, although I knew he was dead I (stupidly) followed the advice of the 999 operator and continued with CPR for 20 fucking minutes.
I kept saying "I'm sorry I have to stop now" and she was like a high school cheerleader yelling "no you can't do that, you have to keep going" and "do this for your Dad".
I was traumatised for years.
What I wanted to do and should have done was to sit with my Dad, hold his hand and tell him that I loved him.
There are at least 2 victims in CPR events. I really hope your husband is OK.

Confrontayshunme · 04/02/2023 08:02

There is some new research suggesting that complex moving games like Tetris within the first 24 hours after a trauma can actually prevent the trauma from "sticking" within your neurons and causing PTSD. But ultimately, letting him feel sad and upset with a calm listening ear will help him more than anything.

Bikeybikeface · 04/02/2023 07:58

My friend went through this when she happened on a traumatic car accident. The 999 operator kept insisting she try cpr but she refused as they were so obviously dead. She did get ptsd and it took her so long to get the help she needed, the systems aren’t in place to help witnesses of a death. Emergency workers all have systems in place to help them deal with situations like that ( and so they absolutely should). If I was you and your OH, I would be looking for help right now, don’t let it it spiral.

Neverplayleapfrogwithmrpipes · 04/02/2023 07:56

Let him talk it out, it will definitely help. Please keep reassuring him that he did all he could as well. He is definitely in shock.

I am first aid trained and helped a lady once in a tourist resort who had "passed out" when she came around she was really not making sense. Her adult daughter was really concerned so I sat with them while they waited for the ambulance. Events quickly unfolded and she ended up collapsing sideways from being seated. I put her in the recovery position as she was still breathing.
When the ambulance arrived they said she was having a heart attack and I had done the right thing.

It was only afterwards that I rabbited on about it for months! Questioning myself, had I acted as quickly as I could. Etc

He will be going through the same. It's only natural.

thewinterwitch · 04/02/2023 07:43

He's not massively talky normally and he has rabbited on at me all night so I know he is in shock.

That is a really good sign, and also a really healthy thing to do to prevent PTSD. I would encourage or allow him to talk it out, no matter how repetitively for as long as he needs, over the next few days. And if he is troubled by images and feelings or horror or anxiety, seek professional help sooner rather than later. But only a certain percentage of people exposed to a traumatic event develop PTSD.

Parisj · 04/02/2023 07:39

Don't worry about PTSD unless you are a few months down the line and he's getting intrusive dreams thoughts or images - they are normal at the beginning. Alcohol understandable but best not used to block it out. The brain will be processing a shocking experience and the fact he was rabitting to you is really good. Let him talk, not avoid going back to the place if he feels ready, process his feelings as they evolve. Take care x

TheFretfulPorpentine · 04/02/2023 07:38

It is unlikely that one distressing experience will cause PTSD, but if it does, self-medication with alcohol is contra-indicated.

WeAreTheHeroes · 04/02/2023 07:33

Your husband did a really good thing - however useless he may have thought it was/it proved to be. Bear in mind the other man's family might want to get in contact to thank him. It's very common for someone who has given CPR or used a defibrillator to be shaken by the experience. It's not something most of us will ever do. He does need time to rationalise things and should not blame himself for delays to treating the man. In the same way others wouldn't help your husband, there may well have been people who saw the guy but did nothing. That's not something your husband could have changed.

Pleasecreateausername13 · 04/02/2023 07:33

When I was 16 I was coming home on the train one night. This man got on and sat in front of me a few seats up, we were facing each other. He was probably 55-65 and during the journey fell asleep. The conductor came along to get his ticket and couldn’t wake him.
The guy had literally sat down and died….right in front of me.

The train stopped at the next stop for an ambulance etc but he was quite clearly dead, I had to get my parents to pick me up and I was scared and upset about it for a long time, first few weeks I made my mum sleep inbeside me. But eventually it started to fade and I was okay, I don’t forget it ever but I was fine after a month or two.

NancyJoan · 04/02/2023 07:18

About five years ago, I came out of a meeting into a car park and found a man on the floor next to his car. Lips blue, but still breathing. I ran back inside to get them to call for help/a first aider, then waited while the ambulance came. They worked on him for a long time, then put him in the ambulance. At one point, they had me holding the bag of fluid in place of a drip stand. He was obviously dead before they moved him, though they didn’t say that.

I talked about it constantly for a few days, then it began to fade. when I think about it now, it’s just a thing that happened, shocking at the time and very sad for him family, but no lasting damage to me.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 04/02/2023 07:11

TrinnySmith · 04/02/2023 06:59

I wonder if the CPR is so that the family can be told every effort was made to save him and that it was not a lingering death or that it was anyone's fault.

Well it's because there's still a chance of CPR working. It may only be 10% but that's still a chance. The highest chance someone has of surviving a cardiac arrest is immediate CPR and the use of a defib.
OP well done to your DH for attempting to save him, that was a wonderful thing to do. He shouldn't feel guilty about anything. He may just need some time to process it, I wouldn't jump to PTSD.

TrinnySmith · 04/02/2023 06:59

I wonder if the CPR is so that the family can be told every effort was made to save him and that it was not a lingering death or that it was anyone's fault.

UniversalAunt · 04/02/2023 06:59

Straight away, if his employer has an Employee Assistance Programme, he should make contact.

As this was an employee death in service on premises (assuming that this was a workplace car park), there should be a an HR in-house team working to bring together support for everyone involved, e.g. family of the deceased, any employees there at the time, & immediate colleagues. But as this happened on a Friday afternoon, they may be slow to muster this team.

However you can, make contact with the HR team to let them know that your DH was involved as the company has a duty of care.

WorriedMillie · 04/02/2023 06:58

We went through similar last year with a family member- they had a cardiac arrest and my DP tried to resuscitate them
It was incredibly traumatic at the time and for a while, I kept getting flashbacks, as did DP
Talking things through definitely helped. I dealt with the coroner and even talking to the person there and to the GP, who issued the death cert (hence I had to go through the whole event in detail to them)

look after yourself too, it’s hard to support someone through trauma like this 🌸

FatSealSmugSoup · 04/02/2023 06:57

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Bluelightbaby · 04/02/2023 06:55

In addition if we go to something traumatic (say fatal rtc or paediatric death) were referred for counselling. We’re then given two weeks and if we’re still effected we can go forward with it, but most the time the two weeks is enough to process and move on

Bluelightbaby · 04/02/2023 06:51

I work for the ambulance service and death (in a variety of situations) is sadly a regular occurrence of the job. But on joining nothing prepares you for it, the first time going to a cardiac arrest was traumatic for me, but sadly you do get used to it :(:(
I’d advise your husband to reach out for counselling if he feels he needs it and he can contact the ambulance service who would be happy to give him a debrief and talk him through

sadly there’s only a very very small portion of cardiac arrests we do actually get back, but the fact he gave it a go is an amazing thing and he should be proud of his efforts