Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for help- husband witnessed a death

184 replies

bingbangbongding · 03/02/2023 23:25

Hi all,

Need help.

Husband was leaving work today and found a colleague dead in his car. He was about 50, was still warm. He asked passers by for help but no one would help him. Everyone had left work.

He called 999 and they got him to drag this man out of the car and perform CPR even though he said he was dead. It didn't work.

The ambulance and police arrived and the ambulance worked on him for a while. Police dismissed him immediately (didn't even want his details which I thought was weird).

He's absolutely shaken and has decided to get quite drunk (understandable).

Has anyone been through this?

How can I support him? I'm terrified he's going to get PTSD or something.

OP posts:
Scrobbler · 04/02/2023 14:13

Hi OP,

something very similar to this happened to me recently. I came across someone who had collapsed and needed up giving CPR. It was extremely traumatic. They didn’t survive despite the best efforts of the emergency services. There is some support info on the British Heart Foundation website, but the most useful thing for me was contacting my GP who arranged for someone in the practice to give me a debrief - a chance to talk through what had happened with someone who could understand it and explain it.

overtaxedunderling · 04/02/2023 13:59

SoShallINever · 04/02/2023 08:05

It actually really annoys me that the ambulance service do this to passers by. Getting involved in CPR is a choice that will affect the volunteer and have potentially long term mental health effects.

I've done CPR twice (outside of work) and several times inside work (HCP).
In both community events the patient was dead and I told the operator that.
With my father, although I knew he was dead I (stupidly) followed the advice of the 999 operator and continued with CPR for 20 fucking minutes.
I kept saying "I'm sorry I have to stop now" and she was like a high school cheerleader yelling "no you can't do that, you have to keep going" and "do this for your Dad".
I was traumatised for years.
What I wanted to do and should have done was to sit with my Dad, hold his hand and tell him that I loved him.
There are at least 2 victims in CPR events. I really hope your husband is OK.

From personal experience, I share you concerns, particularly with Mental Health First Aiders in the workplace.

Beachsidesunset · 04/02/2023 12:51

PSA - no-one legally has to perform CPR, even if 'instructed' to by the 999 call handler. It's absolutely your choice. CPR only has a 4% success rate, and the older the patient, the more the likelihood of survival falls. Being with and talking to someone as they are dying is incredibly important, and if that's what you want to do, then do that.

StrawbRhi · 04/02/2023 12:43

10 years ago I found a man in a car boot field with his non English speaking wife sobbing next to him. He wasn't breathing and had a trach. I performed cpr whilst my husband called 999 and in between breaths I screamed at the people gathering round to get an event organiser or blankets or even just hold his wifes hand but they all just stood there filming it on thier phones. I kept his heart going, and comforted his devestated wife. It was exhausting.
Event organisers eventually arrived and took over and I was sent away.

I drank neat whiskey out of the boot of my car and cried. Later, I called the only hospital nearby and found out he had died en route.

I can still taste it, my arms remember the ache of pumping pumping pumping. I remember his wife hugging me and holding my face trying to thank me in Italian. I remember his name and I think of it often. Sometimes I whisper it, and my husband nods and whispers it back. I wasn't prepared to find that trach tube, and will always wonder if I fucked it up.

I started out this reply to say your husband will be OK in time. But now I'm wondering if I've never really addressed the trauma of it myself.

itsgettingweird · 04/02/2023 12:40

I found a man dead and did CPR on him for 40 minutes whilst I waited for an a,balance that turned up and pronounced him dead.

I then with him for 3 hours waiting for the police to turn up - announce it wasn't suspicious and then the coroner to come.

It played on my mind for years - not in a PTSD way or level but definitely stayed with me.

I'd say give him time and space and allow him to talk about it whenever he needs to. These things will have an effect on you as expected.

The difference for me was I didn't know the man. I did have to inform his partner though when she can looking for him Sad

JFDIYOLO · 04/02/2023 12:28

There is a lie repeatedly told on TV dramas that a person stops breathing, no heartbeat, star character does cpr for a minute, casualty suddenly takes huge breath, eyes open, 'where am I?' and all's well.

My first aid course taught me that this doesn't happen, we can't expect it to happen, or feel we failed when it didn't happen.

Cpr is there to ventilate the person especially the brain until expert help arrives.

If the person is gone, they can't be brought back.

Trying gave the poor man the best possible chance, I hope your husband can accept he did the right thing, the best thing, in a situation where the experts are by no means assured of success.

If we don't work in healthcare we just don't get the sense of proportion that those who do have about these things. It's extraordinary and shocking and of course he'll need time to process.

Both of you taking a first aid course together is a brilliant practical idea - you may meet people who had a similar experience, which could be helpful.

JFDIYOLO · 04/02/2023 12:16

Poor love, I'm so sorry. I'd agree that his line manager, staff welfare, HR, EAP, unions are all sources of help. He may be able to source some therapy. Keep an eye on the drinking as a form of self medicating, as this won't help him - or your family life.

ShakespearesBlister · 04/02/2023 12:14

He didn't actually witness a death though. He found a body. I witnessed an actual death. I held their hand while they took a final gasp. That's traumatic. You will be surprised how people move on from this. I don't even think of the actual moment any more and haven't for years. You do file it away. The problem with society is we shy away from one of the most natural parts of life which is that people die. Sometimes we will be there when it happens.

FarethemFareMeFareYou · 04/02/2023 12:06

A few years back I witnessed a body floating upside down in the river. I called the police. They contacted me afterwards to take a statement and then asked me if I was OK or needed to speak to anyone (a member of their support team).

I wonder if your local force has anything similar?

ApiratesaysYarrr · 04/02/2023 12:02

Support for people who've given CPR

Hi OP, check out this link from the British Heart Foundation, which might be useful.

As someone who has done plenty of CPR, most CPR is unsuccessful, but in all honesty, it might help to understand that there was zero chance of the patient surviving without CPR. Your husband doing CPR might have made a difference to the person surviving, and 100% did not do any damage or make things worse - the person's heart had stopped already - it doesn't get worse than that.

I'm sure the man's family will be grateful that someone did what they could to help him.

TimandGinger · 04/02/2023 11:53

bingbangbongding · 04/02/2023 11:13

That's the same as mine. He's so steady normally so I think he will be ok.

I just panicked last night because I'd never seen him that panicked and wild eyed.

Sympathies to him.

I've worked in healthcare so I am used to seeing illness and death. If you're not it can be pretty scary especially under the circumstances you describe.
My husband isn't in healthcare, but he has been a beach lifeguard and so was trained in CPR and did come across some nasty situations from time to time.
I like talking things over after to process, he doesn't.

TheaBrandt · 04/02/2023 11:28

My parents had this similar situation last week the emergency services were very aggressive in treating the poor elderly lady and they ended up being questioned separately by the police! They are pretty tough though but even they were shaken by it but self medicated that evening with red wine. Didnt occur to me that they would have PTSD though!

twoandcooplease · 04/02/2023 11:27

It will have been the adrenaline op. It is good to know he is a bit better today

Thelnebriati · 04/02/2023 11:19

I think there's a difference between being in a job where you expect to deal with that kind of thing during a shift, and coming across it in everyday life, when you've had no training.
Your DH sounds level headed and sensible, and even if he does get PTSD from the incident, he can manage it. PTSD isn't the end of the world and its treatable, and I say that as someone who had it.
Taking steps to process what happened, and to be aware of what to do if it happens again will help most people prevent PTSD.

bingbangbongding · 04/02/2023 11:13

That's the same as mine. He's so steady normally so I think he will be ok.

I just panicked last night because I'd never seen him that panicked and wild eyed.

OP posts:
TimandGinger · 04/02/2023 11:11

bingbangbongding · 03/02/2023 23:32

He said that the passers by were female and he felt that they thought he was suspicious so I don't think he feels too bad about that as he was likely acting erratically trying to flag down help.

Employee assistance is definitely one to go through. I'm glad to hear some of you/people you know didn't get PTSD, although I'm sure this will live with him a long time.

My husband had to give CPR to a neighbour in the summer, who didn't survive. It was pretty unpleasant but he has been ok.
Everyone is different but he's views things in a fairly practical way and doesn't tend to dwell (unlike me).

bingbangbongding · 04/02/2023 11:01

He's up, is ok.

He's had a call from the police who tracked him via his 999 call. They are going to come over for a statement I assume.

He's remembering little details like the chiropractor thing and laughing and said he's now considering how on earth he moved him as he was a 'massive bloke' in his eyes.

He's also remembering that Lionel Ritchie came on in the car as he was administering CPR and saying how he doesn't think he'll ever be able to listen to that song again.

He's ok though. We're off for a bike ride and a walk through the woods today.

Thanks everyone.

OP posts:
Whatislove82 · 04/02/2023 10:51

I rang my most recent cpr trainer after the event to ask this question and she said people who have stopped breathing can look dead but some can be revived.

what on earth are you on about?

Whatislove82 · 04/02/2023 10:50

ittakes2 · 04/02/2023 10:46

I gave cpr to someone who ‘looked’ dead. And despite having been on about 10 cpr causes in my life it’s never been discussed - it’s never been discussed if someone looks dead does that mean cpr is futile? I rang my most recent cpr trainer after the event to ask this question and she said people who have stopped breathing can look dead but some can be revived. It’s not for the families it’s for the person - although I must admit I continued until help arrived because I was thinking if I was this man’s family I would want to know someone tried

If someone “looks dead”?

surely on your 10 cpr training courses you learned that you do a bit more then do a visual glance at the person before administering cpr?

Justmeandme19 · 04/02/2023 10:46

Not quite the point of the post. But my own father was involved in a horrible incident publically which him passing away in. The think thats always been a massive comfort is that a member of the public tried to help him. Please remind your husband that the family may well find out they a member of public tried to help him. Believe me that's tramendious.

ittakes2 · 04/02/2023 10:46

TrinnySmith · 04/02/2023 06:59

I wonder if the CPR is so that the family can be told every effort was made to save him and that it was not a lingering death or that it was anyone's fault.

I gave cpr to someone who ‘looked’ dead. And despite having been on about 10 cpr causes in my life it’s never been discussed - it’s never been discussed if someone looks dead does that mean cpr is futile? I rang my most recent cpr trainer after the event to ask this question and she said people who have stopped breathing can look dead but some can be revived. It’s not for the families it’s for the person - although I must admit I continued until help arrived because I was thinking if I was this man’s family I would want to know someone tried

plumduck · 04/02/2023 10:45

bingbangbongding · 04/02/2023 01:30

Thank you for your expert advice. We will follow it.

He's still awake. We are watching comedy and he's asked if the dog can come in the lounge if he falls asleep (the dog is usually in bed by now), he says he feels comforted by it.

He's laughing at the fact that someone ran up (after the paramedics arrived) and shouted 'I can help! I am a chiropractor!' And the paramedics just looked at him like Hmm and asked him to keep traffic moving down the road as people were stuck behind the ambulance.

Glad the chiropractor tried to help

plumduck · 04/02/2023 10:40

LittleRedYarny · 03/02/2023 23:28

Does his company have an Employee Assistance Programme? They often have self referral for counselling and bereavement type support.

Yes try this

Nonimai · 04/02/2023 10:37

My daughter went through something similar. She found an elderly friend who she lived with had died days earlier ( daughter had been away, came back, found body). She called the police and the operator insisted she perform cpr. Friend was clearly days/ week dead and decomposing. She refused and was shouted at but was forced into touching the body which was extremely traumatic. When the police arrived she was shut in a room in the house for three hours and then questioned in a harsh way. She was treated really badly by the services and that traumatised her as much as finding the body. She was only 18, did they have to be so unkind? She is over the horror of it, but it has left her vulnerable and frightened.

Luredbyapomegranate · 04/02/2023 10:28

So sorry to hear this OP.

I also think PTSD is vanishingly unlikely. It’s important he gets to talk it through and it sounds like you are really on top of this so that’s great. It’s a real shock but he’ll return to normal pretty quickly I think, and the memory will gradually retreat back.

I would also encourage him to think that the fact he was there will be a comfort to the man’s family - if they ask if someone tried CPR, the records will show that they did.

Swipe left for the next trending thread