Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for help deciding between ELCS and vaginal birth

107 replies

elm26 · 03/02/2023 21:10

Hello everyone

I am 24 weeks pregnant with my first baby and I'm 29 years old.

I've had multiple miscarriages (double digits) and this is the first time I've made it past the first trimester.

Due to my history of unknown cause of miscarriages, endometriosis and my history of anxiety and depression, my consultant has asked me to think about my birth and whether I'd like a planned, controlled ELCS or to allow myself to go naturally.

My placenta is currently low and nearly covering my cervix so of course this could take the decision out of my hands and I have scans at 30 and 34 weeks to see if this has moved up.

I love the idea of natural birth BUT I'm terrified of the thought of needing an emergency c-sec or an emergency in general. I'm naturally nervous of the pain, the length of time it can take etc. I'm equally as nervous for a c-sec as it's surgery and there are risks and the physical recovery is longer, pain etc.

However, if a planned c-sec I imagine it would be calm and controlled (unless something unexpected happened I guess), I'd know the date, I'd be able to prepare myself.

Please help! I'm giving myself anxiety thinking about the anxiety of either! 🤦🏻‍♀️ I really have struggled with this pregnancy, convinced I will lose her at any given moment because of our losses and it's really taken it's toll on me.

OP posts:
GneissGuysFinishLast · 04/02/2023 00:07

I’d personally NOT go for an elective for a first birth.

I have a similar history to you - many miscarriages/ectopic pregnancies. Horrible anxiety.

I was told I could have a c section if I wanted, but also got offered counselling with a specialist midwife, a free hypnobirthing course, etc.

Ultimately I decided to try for a vaginal birth. I did end up with an emergency c section, after a long labour, but it didn’t feel scary at the time. I didn’t have much time to get into my head about the surgery, and by that point I was just so relieved that the pain had stopped to be honest. The c section itself was fine. Recovery was good - honestly, my boobs were sorer than my stomach. By day 4 we were out walking with the pram, going out for lunch ETC.

When I got pregnant again (after more miscarriages and another ectopic) I decided to have a planned section.

The section itself was HORRENDOUS. I had to be given anxiety meds every few minutes for the whole thing, I dissociated and was drifting in and out of awareness. My anxiety in the lead up to the c section was far worse than in the lead up to my (attempted) vaginal birth. I also ended up with horrendous shoulder pain, far worse than the section pain itself.

That being said, I did have a great recovery second time as well - even better than my first. He was born on the Thursday and I hosted a (smallish!) party on the Sunday night after being at the supermarket and at soft play en route home the day before.

Twinklenoseblows · 03/02/2023 23:35

I was in your position and went with a planned c section. I discussed it at great length with my consultant and consultant midwife and we all agreed that I was so stressed about something going wrong that this was likely to inhibit a successful labour and increase the chances of needing intervention. I also felt that due to my state of mind if something went wrong with the labour I would never forgive myself.

I was also told that interestingly the data re c section safety looks at c sections as a whole and therefore factors in emergency c sections. But in reality a planned c section has less risk of adverse outcomes than a natural delivery.

No regrets at all. The recovery was pretty simple for me luckily and I was able to establish breastfeeding.

One question I find helpful to ask medical professionals is "what would you do in my position?/advise a loved one in my position?".

Readyforspringtime · 03/02/2023 23:26

For my complicated pregnancy and health issues I had a home waterbirth. It was safer and calmer with less emotional or physical difficulty. Being in the water throughout labour meant I didn't tear or anything and was back to normal very quickly. I was in my own well prepared space with privacy, a midwife for me and one for baby. Getting straight in to my own bed after was the best thing.

PermanentlyinUAT · 03/02/2023 23:23

From my perspective, ELCS is the best thing ever. It was truly wonderful. Never had a vaginal delivery so nothing to compare it to. That said, I’m not one of those women who is pre conditioned to think that giving birth without pain relief is something to be proud of.

CatherinedeBourgh · 03/02/2023 23:23

My home water births were the loveliest, calmest experiences of my life. I would choose them over any c section ever.

But you have to be prepared to take the risk that it won't be like that. An elective takes away the risk, but also takes away the possibility of the absolute best outcome.

Only you can decide which of those matters more to you.

Abasnada · 03/02/2023 23:20

ELCS all the way! So much nicer, and pain free than a natural birth!

I wouldn’t risk having an natural birth with the issues you’re having. There are too many variables. ELCS is much more controlled.

Mapletreelane · 03/02/2023 23:12

DC1 vaginal delivery with forceps.

DC2 Section as baby was transverse.

Without a shadow of a doubt C Section.

I don't feel I missed out on any bonding with DC2, in fact I bonded with them better as first delivery was so traumatic i think I was in shock for a few weeks. No issues breastfeeding. Fully recovered quickly from the Section, was much easier and quicker than I expected. Have never physically fully recovered from the vaginal delivery. I really wish I'd had a C Section with DC1

Wish you all the best OP.

raffegiraffe · 03/02/2023 22:51

Another vote for elcs. I strongly pushed for this for myself after a different first birth ending in a crash section. My elcs was very calm and recovery from both c sections was fine, much better than I'd been expecting

forevercurious · 03/02/2023 22:33

I’ve had both a VB and a ELCS. With the natural birth I tore badly and ended up being in theatre with a 3rd degree tear. The pain was horrific - no pain relief other than gas and air for the labour & I genuinely felt traumatised afterwards.

Because of this I had an ELCS with my second. It actually was classed as an EMCS as I went into labour 2 days before my CS date so the CS happened there and then instead. I wont lie, entering the theatre I was terrified. The thought of the op was a scary one but it was better than I expected!

Recovery was hard, but that was because I also had a 2 year old. If it was my first baby it would have been no problem to rest and recover! I also had a long and painful recovery from the VB due to the tear but would prefer the CS recovery any day!

In your shoes I’d take the ELCS. Good luck & hope it all goes well! I’m

lifehappens12 · 03/02/2023 22:14

I think I would go for the emcs. We lost two babies before my last and that was hard enough. Due to some risk factors I had an early induction. Early on in the induction they said they had concerns and offered a c-section.

I was so relieved that it was close to being over (waiting and worrying for my son) and we would safely been born soon.

I think having some control back would help.

JKRfan · 03/02/2023 22:12

Your consultant has given you the option for a reason. I would go for elective C Section. Most people have 1 or 2 miscarriages before succeeding not double-digit losses. From experience I can confirm that it will be much more relaxed as an elective procedure. Best wishes 💐

Squamata · 03/02/2023 22:01

Have you thought of hypno birthing to help with anxiety, whatever you choose?

The problem is, good vaginal birth is easier than CS, but CS is better than a hard vaginal birth. You don't know what you're going to get, it's a gamble. But risk rates of anything going seriously wrong are super, super low.

nildesparandum · 03/02/2023 21:59

ELCS definatly.
53 years ago there was no choice at all.It was assumed everyone would have a vaginal birth, except as in my case twice when things went wrong then EMCS
I am 4ft 10ins, myDS1 and I both nearly died during his birth by EMCS when my very long labour ended with him going into transverse lie and the GA given during the CS nearly saw the end of us both. Two years later when pregnant with his brother I was assured everything will go well this time.It certainly did not, he got stuck my narrow pelvis during labour, and my uterus was on the point of rupturing by the time the EMCS was done.
I had the tubal tie done as I would never have this done to me or any future babies again.
You have a choice these days.50 or more years ago you did not.

Alittlenonsensenowandthen · 03/02/2023 21:56

Only had c sections so no comparison but mine was elective and a very calm and positive experience. Some friends who had natural births took longer to recover than I did.

Negatives - an overhang over my scar. Not nice. Feel like I hadn't given birth.
Positives - controlled, relaxed, was more awake to deal with baby as I'd not had a long labour

ShadowPuppets · 03/02/2023 21:50

I had a vaginal birth with a birth injury that did clear up eventually (after physio) and a ELCS where I have a numb stomach and overhang 8 months later.

ELCS was the right decision for me because my VB first time around was traumatic and emotionally I just couldn’t do it again. But it’s the ELCS which has left me with lasting issues. I don’t regret my ELCS as it was the right call from a MH perspective but I’ve made my peace wit the fact my body isn’t going to be the same as it was / snap back like my first.

Its such a tough call because my preferred option would have been to have a straightforward VB which no one can guarantee for you.

Do you want more children if possible?

spidereggs · 03/02/2023 21:43

I was you and the consultant said section without question.

Orangesare · 03/02/2023 21:43

I’ve had both an emcs and a VBAC and if I had another I’d had another VBAC. My VBAC was unplanned as I’d booked an elcs.
Yes it’s very painful whilst you’re in labour but the recovery is so much quicker. Yes you can have injuries from a VB but a cs can also leave you with longer term issues. I had a very good recovery from my cs.
I would go with the advice from your consultant and I suspect in your case you would be very carefully monitored during labour and they would move to a cs quite quickly.
I wouldn’t worry about worrying about the birth, although you probably will. I stressed about a natural labour all through my first pregnancy and then agonised over the VBAC/ elcs decision for a fair chunk of my second but then had a massive panic at the end and went into labour early and stuck with the VBAC. Totally my choice as the hospital checked and triple checked I didn’t want the cs!

Moomoo2o22 · 03/02/2023 21:39

I've had 3 natural births and bled badly for 2 of them so I went for a c section for my 4th pregnancy. It was so much better, it was calm and quick I wish I'd had c sections from the beginning I've recovered quickly and didn't have much pain. The best part of it for me was the fact you have team of people in the room compared to an overworked midwife popping in and out of the room. Everyone's experience is different though. The main reason I wanted a c section the last time was I felt it was unsafe to be looked after by one person pulled in too many directions I felt much better knowing I was surrounded by a team of people if things didn't go to plan.

HungryandIknowit · 03/02/2023 21:38

ELCS was a good experience but recovery was terrible. Had an infection which lasted months. Couldn't face that again. VB was fine. Not easy but nowhere near as bad as I'd been led to believe, but I wasn't induced. A lot of it comes down to luck and positioning of the baby. Read the NICE guidelines on CS. If you do opt for VB look at spinning babies and hypnobirthing for some tips. If I did it again I would opt for ELCS scheduled for 41 - 42 weeks. If baby came spontaneously before then, great.

Pandagirl10 · 03/02/2023 21:38

My daughter had an ELCS - she was very very anxious throughout her pregnancy and spoke frankly to the midwives and consultant and they all agreed together not to go vaginal. Correct decision for her and she had a perfect little boy 8 months ago. She said she would make the same decision again

monitor1 · 03/02/2023 21:38

As the veteran of first delivery forceps (healthy primip with uncomplicated pregnancy) and a second delivery CS maternal request I'd say CS every day

JKDcot · 03/02/2023 21:37

I would definitely go for the elective c section. I had one for my son and was really happy with my choice. It’s planned, calm and you feel in control and supported by the wonderful team caring for you. There is minimal unknowns and the recovery and procedure was fine. A great experience (sending best wishes from another anxious soul)

Genevieva · 03/02/2023 21:37

You don't have to decide anything yet and, even if you do make a decision now, you can change your mind.

The lower part of the uterus grows so there is a high chance the baby's placenta will be positioned nicely by the time you are full term.

Aside from infertility and miscarriage induced mental health problems, it sounds like you might be quite an anxious person anyway. I wonder if you could ask your GP for some CBT sessions so that, whichever delivery method you end up having, you feel less anxious about it.

Chickenly · 03/02/2023 21:35

I was in a similar position with DS and I absolutely agonised over it. I spoke to my midwife (who, to be honest, I think recognised I needed the decision to made for me) and she said that, if I’m torn, to go for the vaginal birth because the statistics are on my side and if you’re stuck, go with the stats. I followed that advice, I ended up being induced at 39 weeks and, honestly, it was my favourite part of the pregnancy. I have no regrets at all.

I can’t give any advice on what would’ve happened if I’d had an ELCS, maybe I’d have preferred it. But, for me, the vaginal option was great.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 03/02/2023 21:34

OP in your situation I’d go for the ELCS. You’ve been through enough, it seems like in your circumstances it’s the safer option.

Swipe left for the next trending thread