Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for help deciding between ELCS and vaginal birth

107 replies

elm26 · 03/02/2023 21:10

Hello everyone

I am 24 weeks pregnant with my first baby and I'm 29 years old.

I've had multiple miscarriages (double digits) and this is the first time I've made it past the first trimester.

Due to my history of unknown cause of miscarriages, endometriosis and my history of anxiety and depression, my consultant has asked me to think about my birth and whether I'd like a planned, controlled ELCS or to allow myself to go naturally.

My placenta is currently low and nearly covering my cervix so of course this could take the decision out of my hands and I have scans at 30 and 34 weeks to see if this has moved up.

I love the idea of natural birth BUT I'm terrified of the thought of needing an emergency c-sec or an emergency in general. I'm naturally nervous of the pain, the length of time it can take etc. I'm equally as nervous for a c-sec as it's surgery and there are risks and the physical recovery is longer, pain etc.

However, if a planned c-sec I imagine it would be calm and controlled (unless something unexpected happened I guess), I'd know the date, I'd be able to prepare myself.

Please help! I'm giving myself anxiety thinking about the anxiety of either! 🤦🏻‍♀️ I really have struggled with this pregnancy, convinced I will lose her at any given moment because of our losses and it's really taken it's toll on me.

OP posts:
Clouds3898 · 04/02/2023 08:10

elm26 · 04/02/2023 07:46

Thank you all for sharing your experiences with me.

When I said a natural labour I meant I'll take pain relief and any intervention they would need to do to get her out safe, didn't word that very well in my post.

There is a lot to think about.

To PP who mentioned home birth, whilst I think this must be lovely and serene and comfortable in your own home if you are that kind of person who can relax and trust in your body, it's my worst nightmare.

Are you me?! People always well meaningly suggested home birth to me to help me feel less anxious. The thought of it makes my blood run cold. The more doctors in the room the better as far as I'm concerned!

CheshireDing · 04/02/2023 08:08

Everyone is different and everyone’s experience is different so there’s no cookie cutter answer unfortunately. I have 3 vaginally without drugs and 2 were home births (one without a midwife as she didn’t arrive in time). I was able to pop to the shop for cake a couple of hours later, whereas with a c section you would need at least a few days

Whatever you decide I would highly recommend hypnobirthing, don’t just buy a CD to do it yourself actually find someone who teaches it and go to their sessions. You can use it in either birth scenario as it teaches calming techniques. It’s amazing

Rowgtfc72 · 04/02/2023 08:03

As an older mum with gestational diabetes I was offered induction at 37 weeks or a c- sec at 38.
The recovery from a c-sec terrified me more than a vaginal birth. Dd was going to be big I was told and was back to back and if she'd ever been at risk I'd have gone for a section.
I was only going to do it once and to me a vaginal birth seemed like the easier option.
As it was I did 13 hrs in labour, the drugs had worn off before it was time to push and 8lb 6oz dd was hauled out with forceps 3 weeks early.
Still believe I made the right choice.

elm26 · 04/02/2023 08:01

Thank you, there's so much to think about.

10 years ago, I'd of told you all I want 3 or 4 children. I come from a big family and always wanted the same but after all of our problems with getting this far with this little miracle I won't ever be having another one.

The mental toll the past 9 years have had on me has been incredibly difficult and I even voluntarily spent 4 weeks in a psychiatric hospital a couple of years ago to get help for severe depression, anxiety and PTSD. This baby was a surprise and I thank my lucky stars every single day she's still okay in there at 24 weeks.

I do have a very good support system, I'm very lucky and have a lovely DH who has worked weekends and evenings to be able to save enough money to cover 8 weeks wages if it was needed due to high risk of post partum depression/difficult birth etc.

OP posts:
DownInTheDumpster · 04/02/2023 08:00

I had two vaginal births and they were honestly one of the best most empowering moments of my life. Yes there’s pain and it’s hard but it was also a fantastic experience. I’m glad I was lucky enough to experience that and I’d have missed it with an ELCS!

EdithStourton · 04/02/2023 07:56

In your shows I'd consider a couple of things. Firstly, did I want more children (every section increases the odds of certain complications). Secondly, where is the placenta going to end up? The decision might be taken out of your hands.

Whatever you decide, I hope it goes well for you.

MooseBreath · 04/02/2023 07:56

I have never had an ELCS as both my births were vaginal. That said, both of mine needed intervention from a doctor and there was a lot of pain and an episiotomy in both cases. With my first, there was a lot of blood loss.

If I had to do it again, I would opt for an ELCS, especially if you have a good support system at home for after the birth.

Clouds3898 · 04/02/2023 07:56

Given your anxiety and previous losses etc I would go ELCS. I've had 2 due to anxiety and it really helped me to feel it was a controlled environment. The chances of a completely uncomplicated non-tearing vaginal birth are reasonably small and that was enough for me.

Congratulations and good luck. Sounds like you've really been through it to get to this point x x

PaddyDingDong · 04/02/2023 07:55

elm26 · 04/02/2023 07:52

Also forgot to mention that I carry strep B so baby would need antibiotics after birth if I went with vaginal delivery and we'd have to stay in for 48 hours so the hospital stay wouldn't be a lot different in length to a c-sec, this is what I've been told anyway.

Same situation as myself, and I went for ELCS for my 2nd due to this as well as other factors. I dont have a number stomach and my lovely female surgeon spent a long time on my elected section to ensure I had no problems post birth and I don't.

wishuponastar1988 · 04/02/2023 07:54

I would opt for a vaginal birth. I am a FTM and my waters broke day before due date and baby was born 12 hours later. If I had to go down the induction route for whatever reason then I think I would've seriously considered ELCS just because of the statistics for inductions that lead to EMCS in first time parents specifically. However what I would choose should not dictate what you should - trust your gut and do what it right for you x

PaddyDingDong · 04/02/2023 07:53

raffegiraffe · 03/02/2023 22:51

Another vote for elcs. I strongly pushed for this for myself after a different first birth ending in a crash section. My elcs was very calm and recovery from both c sections was fine, much better than I'd been expecting

This, you won't regret it at all.

elm26 · 04/02/2023 07:52

Also forgot to mention that I carry strep B so baby would need antibiotics after birth if I went with vaginal delivery and we'd have to stay in for 48 hours so the hospital stay wouldn't be a lot different in length to a c-sec, this is what I've been told anyway.

OP posts:
PurBal · 04/02/2023 07:52

Sorry for your losses and congratulations on your pregnancy. Given your journey to get here and a low lying placenta that may or may not move I would plan for a ELCS. I haven’t had one, but it can be planned for much better than a vaginal birth. Good luck!

SunshineAndFizz · 04/02/2023 07:48

You've been through enough, I'd go with ELCS. Take the worry and uncertainty away.

I've had two CS, yes there's recovery afterwards but if you know ahead you can plan for it.

elm26 · 04/02/2023 07:46

Thank you all for sharing your experiences with me.

When I said a natural labour I meant I'll take pain relief and any intervention they would need to do to get her out safe, didn't word that very well in my post.

There is a lot to think about.

To PP who mentioned home birth, whilst I think this must be lovely and serene and comfortable in your own home if you are that kind of person who can relax and trust in your body, it's my worst nightmare.

OP posts:
JodiePants · 04/02/2023 01:13

I had an ELCS only a few weeks ago and I am satisfied with my decision. To help with my decision, instead of thinking about which way of having the baby was better, I looked at the potential negatives of both and which negative I would absolutely hate the most. So for me, in an ideal world I would have liked a vaginal birth but having a episiotomy or the baby delivered by forceps was my worst birthing nightmare, so I chose the ELCS.

PeppermintTeaThenBed · 04/02/2023 00:43

This is a very tricky decision and I really feel for you. I've had both a natural and an ELCS. My first natural birth was very long (4 days) and resulted in a forcep delivery and a bad tear which required theatre treatment. No way of sugarcoating this but there was also damage to my bumhole - whilst being sewn up the surgeon recommended I do not have a natural birth again. However recovery was good. For my second I was offered a elcs due to the damage caused and also there were concerns of may suffer from incontinence from both ends 😢. Yes you are right in that it was a much calmer experience going in for an elcs and a quick delivery, but my goodness I found the aftermath excruciating. I was in debilitating pain for over a week and bled terribly. My DC2 is now 6 months and I now feel I'm turning a corner. After the awful pain wore off I was left with deep aches, very strange numbness / pins and needles sensation on the scar site and could not bare the area to be touched up until about a month ago. I also have the c section overhang. It's definitely no walk in the park. But it's one of those crystal ball moments that I will never know what the outcome would have been if I had gone for natural. BUT I have lots of friends and posters on here that have had excellent c section experiences.

You will be monitored very closely and like you say the decision may be taken out of your hands. Easy to say but try not to worry, you don't have to make this decision for a good few weeks and the more you speak to others / read about positive birth stories, the choice will slowly come to you. Good luck 😊

blueshoes · 04/02/2023 00:31

My post was in answer to Gneiss who said a elcs is final.

blueshoes · 04/02/2023 00:30

The answer to that is if you have a vaginal birth, you have no control over the outcome. If you don't want an emergency cs or forceps or ventouse, you could not say nah, I'll stick with no intervention natural thank you very much. By that time, it is an emergency and all choice goes out of the window.

With ELCS, the theatre is properly stocked with staff and the outcome is calm.

GneissGuysFinishLast · 04/02/2023 00:25

PinkPlantCase · 04/02/2023 00:22

There have been so many of these threads recently. They always go the same way, the OP has too much anxiety about vaginal birth, other posters re-enforce it with stores of horrific vaginal births and easy Elecs.

The OP goes with the Elecs.

Sorry OP I wish you the very best for your pregnancy it really has been a difficult road for you.

Personally I had a very hands off home birth, it was beautiful. A really empowering experience, I was
in awe of what my body could do and very much enjoyed being in the comfort of my own home. I wouldn’t of had it any other way.

Everyone should be entitled to try for the type of birth they prefer whether this is an Elecs, a home birth or anything in between. You don’t need anyone’s permission.

The thing that makes me less keen to say go for an elective is that it’s so final. If you choose vaginal, you can always change your mind as labour progresses, but if you choose elective section you can’t exactly say stitch me up and let me push mid section.

QueenCamilla · 04/02/2023 00:24

I had a prolonged, difficult labour followed by an emergency section. The worst of both worlds, though the CS was a relief and the end of suffering.

I'm mentally scarred and will never choose to conceive again.
In a different scenario, I would fight tooth and nail for an elective section.

PinkPlantCase · 04/02/2023 00:22

There have been so many of these threads recently. They always go the same way, the OP has too much anxiety about vaginal birth, other posters re-enforce it with stores of horrific vaginal births and easy Elecs.

The OP goes with the Elecs.

Sorry OP I wish you the very best for your pregnancy it really has been a difficult road for you.

Personally I had a very hands off home birth, it was beautiful. A really empowering experience, I was
in awe of what my body could do and very much enjoyed being in the comfort of my own home. I wouldn’t of had it any other way.

Everyone should be entitled to try for the type of birth they prefer whether this is an Elecs, a home birth or anything in between. You don’t need anyone’s permission.

Proudofitbabe · 04/02/2023 00:20

I've done both. Before having kids I'd have always chosen the vaginal birth. Now I'd pick the C-section every time, which was a doddle by comparison. Recovery absolutely fine too.

BlueDiamondGlow · 04/02/2023 00:14

I would go for a vaginal birth.

But I'm not you.

blueshoes · 04/02/2023 00:09

No brainer, no drama, ELCS.