Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for help deciding between ELCS and vaginal birth

107 replies

elm26 · 03/02/2023 21:10

Hello everyone

I am 24 weeks pregnant with my first baby and I'm 29 years old.

I've had multiple miscarriages (double digits) and this is the first time I've made it past the first trimester.

Due to my history of unknown cause of miscarriages, endometriosis and my history of anxiety and depression, my consultant has asked me to think about my birth and whether I'd like a planned, controlled ELCS or to allow myself to go naturally.

My placenta is currently low and nearly covering my cervix so of course this could take the decision out of my hands and I have scans at 30 and 34 weeks to see if this has moved up.

I love the idea of natural birth BUT I'm terrified of the thought of needing an emergency c-sec or an emergency in general. I'm naturally nervous of the pain, the length of time it can take etc. I'm equally as nervous for a c-sec as it's surgery and there are risks and the physical recovery is longer, pain etc.

However, if a planned c-sec I imagine it would be calm and controlled (unless something unexpected happened I guess), I'd know the date, I'd be able to prepare myself.

Please help! I'm giving myself anxiety thinking about the anxiety of either! 🤦🏻‍♀️ I really have struggled with this pregnancy, convinced I will lose her at any given moment because of our losses and it's really taken it's toll on me.

OP posts:
superplumb · 04/02/2023 09:49

superplumb · 04/02/2023 09:49

Go c section. You'll get over not having a natural birth. My 1st was an emergency c section. Had the option with my 2nd. I chose planned section and I'm glad I did. Surgeon told me afterwards after a e hour op there was no way I would've managed a natural ans it would resulted in an emergency again. I cannot describe the iff between an emergency and elected. Elected was so relaxed ( for me not the surgeon).

After a 2 hour op that should say

superplumb · 04/02/2023 09:49

Go c section. You'll get over not having a natural birth. My 1st was an emergency c section. Had the option with my 2nd. I chose planned section and I'm glad I did. Surgeon told me afterwards after a e hour op there was no way I would've managed a natural ans it would resulted in an emergency again. I cannot describe the iff between an emergency and elected. Elected was so relaxed ( for me not the surgeon).

NameChangeFor2023 · 04/02/2023 09:45

Having had two episiotomies, recovering from birthing isn't always easier. Inability to sit most times of the day. Two weeks PP and still in pain with stitches.

GneissGuysFinishLast · 04/02/2023 09:42

ShinyHappyTits · 04/02/2023 09:12

I was you, I had crippling, dreadful anxiety I’d Labour and something would go wrong (previous bad experiences on the NHS too) I blurted all this out to my consultant in tears at 36 weeks and she said ‘my dead, of COURSE you may have a section. Don’t worry)
It was lovely. Planned, calm and controlled. A few things: get the private room if you can, most wards have them although you need to pay. It’s worth it.
And try to keep fit as you can, it helps hugely with recovery and getting your body back.
Best of luck OP 💐

Paying for a private room isn’t a thing everywhere. I think it’s gross that it would be in the NHS, actually - offering a better service to those who are more well off. Where I am, single rooms are for mums who are covid positive, or those who’s baby ends up in NICU/SCBU.

Pollywoddles · 04/02/2023 09:17

I had loads of miscarriages too and my thoughts on it were that I wanted my baby out as quickly and safely as possible. My consultant agreed that a ELCS was best for baby and that’s what I did. I didn’t have any particular desire to have a vaginal birth anyway.

The section was fantastic, we had such a beautiful day, lots of lovely memories and my recovery was fast and easy. Just keep on top of your pain meds.

ShinyHappyTits · 04/02/2023 09:12

I was you, I had crippling, dreadful anxiety I’d Labour and something would go wrong (previous bad experiences on the NHS too) I blurted all this out to my consultant in tears at 36 weeks and she said ‘my dead, of COURSE you may have a section. Don’t worry)
It was lovely. Planned, calm and controlled. A few things: get the private room if you can, most wards have them although you need to pay. It’s worth it.
And try to keep fit as you can, it helps hugely with recovery and getting your body back.
Best of luck OP 💐

QueefQueen80s · 04/02/2023 09:00

CS everytime. The damage I hear people suffer from vaginal birth is awful.

Fifthtimelucky · 04/02/2023 08:55

I don't have any personal experience of a caesarean section but it's something I was glad to avoid.

One of my nephews was born by caesarean section (on medical advice, because the baby was breech) and according to my sister the recovery from that was far worse than after her previous natural births.

I also have a friend who has had recurring back problems which she thinks are due to her caesareans.

There are risks either way, of course, and I think you can only weigh those up nearer the time based on medical advice.

Good luck either way.

nolongersurprised · 04/02/2023 08:53

elm26 · 04/02/2023 07:52

Also forgot to mention that I carry strep B so baby would need antibiotics after birth if I went with vaginal delivery and we'd have to stay in for 48 hours so the hospital stay wouldn't be a lot different in length to a c-sec, this is what I've been told anyway.

That would be a usual protocol for known grp B strep carriage. It might be different in the UK but the Australasian protocol is for antibiotics in ideally 2 doses, 4 hours apart. Maternal antibiotics in Labour is the most effective way of reducing carriage to the baby.

Your baby would need antibiotics if there were concerns they were sick (very low threshold) but this would occur even if the group b strep status of the mother wasn’t know.

SomeareDeluded · 04/02/2023 08:48

3 vaginal births, all difficult, the last can only be described as barbaric.

Baby 4 was a C. section with GA due to placenta praevia - total relief. Recovery was much quicker tbh except not allowed to drive for several weeks but we managed.

Elcs would be my first choice every time.

SouperNoodle · 04/02/2023 08:38

I was expecting to say give VB a try but then read your post and honestly, I'd do CS.
More for the placement of the placenta than anything else but given everything, it sounds like the best option for you and your baby.

MrsPicklesonSmythe · 04/02/2023 08:36

I've had 3 natural births, one on time, one late induction, one early induction with a drip.

In your circumstances I'd go cs. Recovery is worse but you have time to prepare. You've been through enough love.

nolongersurprised · 04/02/2023 08:35

I have had 3 vaginal births and one LSCS. The section was the 3rd, I could’ve had another but opted for another vaginal birth.

Nothing wrong with my LSCS but, for me, the recovery after a vaginal birth was so much faster

mumoffourminimes · 04/02/2023 08:34

OP have you thought about talking all this through with a doula?

One that knows the culture of the local hospital and also your preferences/what's important to you etc and knows how to navigate the system to get what you want.

They can also support you in the post natal period x

Doowop1919 · 04/02/2023 08:31

I've had two calm vaginal births that went well but in your situation, I'd think about the elective section. Especially if anxiety is high at the moment.

Destiny123 · 04/02/2023 08:28

(Anaesthetist). Nearly all emergency sections are also lovely chilled happy times so I wouldn't let that put you off. Only a v tiny proportion are rushes and even then everything is explained and you're v safe. The vast majority involve music on the speakers of your choice or cheesy csection play list if no preference, delayed cord clamping, dad cuts cord, then skin on skin till finished and an anaesthetist taking you a ton of cute photos of the 3 of you

Not going to sway either way (I'd prob go normal and see what happened) but emergency interventions are still happy birth experiences (I rarely see normal deliveries now in my job but I love it and think its v pleasant if a little unexpected for the parents). Elective sections can relatively commonly become emergencies too if labour before your date. Most important thing is to not have a rigid birth plan as they're the ones that often don't happen as wanted and the parents are disappointed

Just remember the birth plan should just involve a healthy happy mum and baby and the teams support u to achieve that

ittakes2 · 04/02/2023 08:28

I had an emergency c section for twins due to low lying placenta bleeding - it was very calm. But it’s not with it it’s downsides - no labour meant my body did not trigger the hormones to make breast milk. Not so good for tummy muscles which are torn. It is better for the baby to go down the birth canal as they are exposed to friendly bacteria they need for their gut and it also triggers infant reflexes to go dormant. But I must admit I don’t have leaky bladder like some other mums

dakel · 04/02/2023 08:26

Failed induction with my first that ended up in an emergency c-section. Was a very scary experience baby needed resuscitating didn't want to go through that again! Dc2 and 3 were planned c-section much more calmer and relaxing and recovery with planned was much easier

orion678 · 04/02/2023 08:25

It's so hard. I've had 2 vaginal births, and the first I found quite traumatic. I planned a water birth in the midwife center. She was back to back and labour started with my waters breaking, so from the start it was very painful and my contractions were erratic. I reacted badly to gas and air, throwing up a lot, and ended up on an epidural. It was long and slow (but the epidural was fantastic!) and I had the world's most disengaged midwife when it came to delivery. I ended up exhausted and needing forceps, which are brutal and my recovery from that was hard. I ended up needing counselling after because I found the birth so difficult to deal with, emotionally.

Second, I was better prepared and supported, planned an early epidural, and was a lot calmer. I had some issues with the epidural and blood pressure dropping, and felt sick a lot during labour. He ended up coming out fist first, which meant he got a little stuck and I needed ventouse. But it was a much, much easier recovery. And because I was better able to articulate what I needed during labour in my birth plan, I was much better supported, so even though things went a bit wrong, it was a super positive experience overall.

Point being, vaginal birth has a lot of uncertainty. You don't know how it will go and there are lots of things that can go awry. There's more certainty with the elcs, but that brings the certainty of surgery and the longer recovery time that naturally brings. For me, the most important things were feeling in control (as far as you can when giving birth!) and feeling supported - that was the difference between a really difficult first experience and a super positive second experience (though on paper my second labour was more difficult!)

Vallmo47 · 04/02/2023 08:22

In your situation I would lean towards a c section OP, I think it will help your anxiety to have a set plan and just knowing that will give you a much calmer pregnancy as well. It is obviously possible to change your mind closer to the time if you’ve had a change of heart, but in your situation I would try to make a decision now so you can let the worry go. I’m not sure hearing everyone’s experiences of both will necessarily help you, though you did ask for it. People are much more likely to share if they have a strong reason for not wanting you to do something in my opinion. It’s like with anything else, if you’ve gone out for a meal and had a horrible experience, you’re much more likely to share in order to warn others. It’s very possible you could have “good” experiences with either and I hope you will. Either way the final outcome will be 100% worth it. Good luck and I wish you and your little girl the best.

Dippyeggz · 04/02/2023 08:21

What is the right decision for someone else isn't necessarily the right one for you.

No need to make a decision now. Wait, read up on both options, get some second opinions.

FuckOffPeroids · 04/02/2023 08:20

Having read your posts I’d go of a CS.

I had 2 vaginal births, and would do so again for me, but in your situation I’d want as much control as possible.

knowing the date, it being sooner, as I think they do sections before 40weeks.
Get baby to term and get it out in the most controllable way possible.
i hope whichever way you choose it all goes really smoothly

DashboardConfessional · 04/02/2023 08:19

I had a relatively pleasant vaginal birth with just gas and air and in your shoes I'd have the C-section. Even thought it was straightfoward, there was a lot of monitoring due to infection risk and I got very fixated on the readouts, beeping noises and movements.

Squamata · 04/02/2023 08:14

I think the issue is that you're carrying all the weight of your horrible experiences with you op, you're approaching birth thinking 'oh no, what awful thing is going to wrong that I need to worry about.'

You need to start to trust your body to bring this baby into the world, whatever mode of birth you go for there will be people on hand to help. It's so easy to fixate on birth but it's really only a matter of hours.

Do some yoga, swimming, walking etc and visualize your baby in your arms. Focus on that, not the details of the birth.

Personally I preferred vbac to emcs, but you need to decide based on your own circumstances, not a straw poll on here. If it was that cut and dried then everyone would give birth the same way.

LanaCara · 04/02/2023 08:11

I've had an emergency CS and a planned one. Whatever you decide, both mine were absolutely fine. The emergency one felt nothing like an emergency, it was just as calm and controlled as the planned one as they are such professionals in looking after you. Good luck whichever you decide x