Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for help deciding between ELCS and vaginal birth

107 replies

elm26 · 03/02/2023 21:10

Hello everyone

I am 24 weeks pregnant with my first baby and I'm 29 years old.

I've had multiple miscarriages (double digits) and this is the first time I've made it past the first trimester.

Due to my history of unknown cause of miscarriages, endometriosis and my history of anxiety and depression, my consultant has asked me to think about my birth and whether I'd like a planned, controlled ELCS or to allow myself to go naturally.

My placenta is currently low and nearly covering my cervix so of course this could take the decision out of my hands and I have scans at 30 and 34 weeks to see if this has moved up.

I love the idea of natural birth BUT I'm terrified of the thought of needing an emergency c-sec or an emergency in general. I'm naturally nervous of the pain, the length of time it can take etc. I'm equally as nervous for a c-sec as it's surgery and there are risks and the physical recovery is longer, pain etc.

However, if a planned c-sec I imagine it would be calm and controlled (unless something unexpected happened I guess), I'd know the date, I'd be able to prepare myself.

Please help! I'm giving myself anxiety thinking about the anxiety of either! 🤦🏻‍♀️ I really have struggled with this pregnancy, convinced I will lose her at any given moment because of our losses and it's really taken it's toll on me.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Annfredandcharles · 27/02/2023 22:35

Hey OP so happy for you that this is going well!
on your case especially because of the placenta it seems an ELCS would be the best option!!
I had a semi elective and it was amazing. Sooo calm and I knew I’d have my baby out safely. Recovery was fine you just have to relax for a bit. Tbh those few days cuddling your newborn and watching films is lovely anyway. Hope this helps and all the best! X

Oysterbabe · 07/02/2023 08:45

Birth is so unpredictable. I lean towards recommending vaginal because both of mine popped out in a few hours with no drama. It was actually an amazing experience, so exciting, and I feel a bit sad I'm done with babies and won't do it again.

It could be the same for you or very, very different. At least with ELCS you have a bit more certainty about a lot of things, which you may need if you suffer with anxiety.

babyjellyfish · 07/02/2023 08:15

Like you I had recurrent losses trying to conceive my first baby, although over a relatively short period of time (15 months) and not in double figures (I had 5). I don't think I was as traumatised as you, but I was pretty anxious. I managed to calm down during the second half of my pregnancy and start to actually enjoy it. And somewhere along the way I started to believe that I would have a wonderfully straightforward drug free vaginal birth and breathe my baby out like some kind of earth mother.

What actually happened was that I got to almost 40 weeks, had an episode of reduced movement, panicked and went in for monitoring, and my doctor recommended immediate induction. The induction ultimately failed and I ended up with an emergency C-section. My physical recovery was easy but psychologically I found it difficult to move on from.

A year after my C-section, I got pregnant again and this time I had no miscarriages but straightforward healthy pregnancy. I considered having an elective C-section, but decided to try for a VBAC, and had a straightforward vaginal delivery with an epidural and no complications other than a small tear which has healed well. (I'm just coming up to 4 weeks postpartum.)

Although I loved my VBAC and felt much better afterwards than I did after my C-section, you need to make the right choice for you. If you don't feel you particularly want to experience vaginal birth and your sole aim is to get your baby out safe and well whilst minimising your own anxiety, an elective C-section may be the best way to do it, especially if you don't think you will have any more children. You could have it at 39 weeks, meaning potentially up to three weeks less waiting around at the end. If you do feel you want to experience vaginal birth, you could ask for extra monitoring at the end and just see how things go. An epidural once you're in active labour may help you to feel more calm and in control of things, and the anaesthetic will already be in place should you need to go for an emergency C-section.

CoalCraft · 07/02/2023 06:10

I had two very straightforward and easy vaginal deliveries. In fact they were so easy that on both occasions no one realised how close to delivery I was and I only just made it to a delivery room in time. Both babies also both came before an elcs would have been scheduled, so even if that has been the plan I'd have ended up having them vaginally just because of how quickly it all happened. Just a possibility to keep in mind.

Recovery in both cases was a breeze.

My advice to you would be to plan for vaginal.

Girlswithgoodbodieslikeboyswithferarris · 07/02/2023 04:34

Moomoo2o22 · 06/02/2023 14:08

GneissGuysFinishLast it's strange you mention shoulder pain I had awful shoulder pain too I thought I'd just got cold in my shoulder! No one else I know who had c sections had this. I'd still do it again though 😊.

It’s trapped gas irritating the diaphragm! I couldn’t use my right arm- it was bad!

Moomoo2o22 · 06/02/2023 14:08

GneissGuysFinishLast it's strange you mention shoulder pain I had awful shoulder pain too I thought I'd just got cold in my shoulder! No one else I know who had c sections had this. I'd still do it again though 😊.

Mummyme87 · 04/02/2023 16:43

I had an emergency section at 9cm first time, really sick baby in NNu for 2weeks and I was poorly, required blood etc. I went for a vbac second time, was induced and it was hard. I had a 3rd degree tear and bled a lot. However, would go for another vbac next time 100% as for me, the risks of CS are more significant.

it is a very personal decision, and no one here will be able to make or should be influencing your decision making

scotscorner · 04/02/2023 16:35

Interested to hear so many people voting for ELCS!

I had a smooth vaginal birth and it was (very hard! but) a really good experience, and I recovered very quickly - walking the dog within days and swimming within a month. Small second degree tear which caused me no bother.

Theres no right answer, only the answer that’s right for you and which gives the confidence and peace of mind. I would also recommend The Positive Birth book by Milli Hill - I think it leans towards ‘natural labour’ but the overarching messages are about CHOICE in how your baby is delivered and can put you in a more positive mindset whatever you choose.

congratulations on your pregnancy OP and hope you have a good experience for birth whatever you choose!💐

BeautyGoesToBenidorm · 04/02/2023 11:21

I've had one vaginal birth, one EMCS, and one ELCS.

Even though I was in a lot of pain afterwards, I'd choose the ELCS every time. My local hospital don't have a fantastic reputation, but the experience was amazing from start to finish.

I opted for it due to shattering my coccyx a few years ago, and I didn't want to risk refracture by having a VBAC. When the lovely anaesthetist asked why I'd chosen an ELCS, I told him about my coccyx and the poor bugger went ghost white 😅😅 He said "Oh darling, say no more! All the pain relief for you!"

The operating theatre was so calm, despite loads of staff milling about. The radio was on, lots of laughing and joking. DP got to watch DS being lifted out, he helped the midwife clean him up and he cut the cord. Absolutely lovely.

Rainbowclimbinghigh · 04/02/2023 10:55

As another PP says, birth is such a lottery so you will never know which option is best for you. But I think there's definitely less uncertainty with an ELCS, so imagine you will be feeling less anxious with that option which will make things a lot smoother anyway.

Personally speaking, I've had one category 1 crash section after being left for three awful awful days of back-to-back labour where I couldn't sleep, eat or pass urine (when I was finally admitted, they drained 750mls of urine 🤢). (And this was after a very straightforward pregnancy, I was normal weight, walking two miles a day right up to the end etc.)

And one ELCS which was so much calmer and smoother.

Recovery wise, first one took about a week before I could walk to the end of the road, second I was walking around a huge zoo within the same time period. No long-term repercussions; people I know had much worse issues and injuries from third degree tears, forceps, episiotomies etc.

Also I have to say of all the women I know, for first time births, more had problematic births than not, which I think is very common and not very widely publicised.

APurpleSquirrel · 04/02/2023 10:28

I've had both - a vaginal birth with DD & a CS with DS.
The vaginal birth was traumatic - no epidural as no anaesthetists available; back-to-back Labour; 3rd degree caused by DD turning on exiting; massive postpartum bleeding & retained placenta which required surgery & GA to remove. DD was born around 9am, I wasn't really conscious & with it till 5pm. I missed almost all of my DDs first day. Consequently my breast milk was delayed by the loss of blood too making establishing breastfeeding harder.
DSs birth - had initially opted for natural birth but was told I needed to be induced at 39 weeks as they were unsure of his size. The induction (pessary) was agonising but worked & went into labour a few hours later. However a few hours further on & nothing had change, no further dilation. Midwives could no longer feel babies head & after a scan we discovered he'd gone back up the birth canal & was lying oblique & it was now to dangerous to progress with natural labour. So CS it was. I was terrified but it was actually incredibly calm & controlled. DS was out within minutes & on my chest whilst they finished up. No PPH, no tears, no retained placenta.
For me, the recovery after the CS was easier & better than the vaginal birth - but I know I had a very traumatic one compared to others. If I was to do it again (I won't be!) i would choose a ELCS.

Rosiefifi · 04/02/2023 10:18

Ask what your consultant recommends. I started having contractions on the Monday evening, I rang up the hospital numerous times and they said I wasn't in enough pain to come in. Late on a Wednesday night my DH rang up and they still said not to come in as I didn't sound in enough pain. I told them I was coming in anyway. I got in the car walked to labour ward , midwife finally got round to examining me and she was shocked . I was 10cm and my DD was born 30 mins later. I had no pain relief nothing. On the positive side I recovered really quickly midwives also lied on my notes and said active labour of 5 hours 😳.

Runnerduck34 · 04/02/2023 10:17

I've had 4 vaginally births.
So can't compare with a c section.
Timing of a natural birth is clearly unpredictable, labour is painful but you get get a breather between contractions and pain relief is available. Hospitals are busy places and with DC1 I did feel I was left to my own devices until I was 8cm dilated by which point I was swiftly moved to labour ward where I wasn't left alone.
Second hospital birth was a lot more attentive.
My advice is to try your best not to arrive at changeover of shifts!!
Third and fourth births were home births which were brilliant, undivided attention of 2 midwifes , calm environment. Im a bit of an anxious person too so homebirth might sound counterintuitive but in a home birth you are in control of your environment ( I hate hospitals) and midwives are totally focussed on you.
I did tear very badly for first birth and not so badly for 2nd and third .
First VB left me unable to use tampons and I talking to friends I was surprised about how common this actually is.
Other than tearing recovery time from a VB was very quick.
I was up and about pretty much straight away but would strongly recommend resting as much as possible to allow yourself to recover.
A part of me wanted to experience a natural birth, our bodies are amazing at what they can do! But perhaps c sections are more civilised! Do whatever you feel most comfortable with and take advice from consultant and midwife.
As long as there are no health concerns there's no right or wrong decision.

Pinkbananas01 · 04/02/2023 10:15

I had an emergency CS after failed induction/back to back Labour & foetal distress with 1st, DS in SCBU for 7 days & me a mess afterwards. Next 2 were ELCS, totally relaxed births in comparison, not an exhausted wreck of a mum which meant skin to skin & EBF was a breeze right from start.
In terms of recovery 1st time 10days in hospital for both, I was up fairly quickly cos baby in SCBU is a big motivator to get up! At home took a while to get out walking with pram , maybe 2 weeks i think for short walks. ELCS- home after 3 days & getting out for longish walks with pram within 1st week.

MacDoodleofredbrookcounty · 04/02/2023 10:12

ELCS vote from me. I delivered vaginally for my first and found it to be quite traumatic - though no real damage done, but the shock of the actual delivery stayed with me for a long time.

I chose an elective c-section second time around and it was a wonderful birth experience. Healing was no issue either, neither was breastfeeding.

tulippa · 04/02/2023 10:08

I've had one of each and would go for the section in a heartbeat. Vaginal birth does not always equal no complications. I recovered quicker from my section and it was a much calmer and more positive experience for me.

lookslikeabombhitit · 04/02/2023 10:04

Problem with questions like this is you're relying on others experiences and inevitably personal experience influences judgement.

I've had two semi elective/ "emergency" sections. First was due to IUGR breech baby and second was failed induction and 'running out of time'. Neither were cat 1 (i.e. under general/ crash scenario) but both were awful for different reasons - the spinal didn't work in first and they didn't believe me until I started trying to roll away and I had complications after second that led to a further surgery. Both of those things could have happened in a planned or emergency section scenario. I still can't bear anything touching my section scar- it's a weird mixture of hyper sensitive and totally numb (almost like the ick feeling you get if you shove a finger into your belly button- unless that's just me? 😂). It also tethered so I have a permanent overhang that I hate. My third was a home birth and was amazing- I wish I'd had the same experience for my first and second!

Wild horses couldn't make me opt for a section unless it was a true medical emergency but that's based on my personal experience- which is what makes it entirely irrelevant to your situation iyswim? Have a read of the rcog guidelines, nice guidelines, Sara wickham's books, aims website and the positive birth book by Milli Hill (covers all birth options). Look at the brain decision making tool and make your decision that way. Good luck! X

Maray1967 · 04/02/2023 10:03

ELCS in your situation. I’ve had both ways - there are pros and cons to both, but I don’t regret going for CS when advised. Birth was straightforward and recovery fine. Yes, it takes longer but I’ve probably been bothered more over the years by the second degree tear after DS1 than DS2 CS.
At the current time I would definitely go for CS - you’ll have a team of staff in the room, not one mw on a short staffed ward. When I had DS1 mw didn’t leave at all in second stage and second mw came in after one hour so I had two of them when he was born. That was over 20 years ago though - I’m not sure all units could guarantee that staffing now.

The only thing that would have put me off a CS was if I’d had a toddler to lift. As DS1 was 7 that wasn’t an issue - nor would it have been for my first.
Whatever you decide, I wish you all the very best.

Gillyyy · 04/02/2023 10:01

Hi, I’ve had the same thoughts recently as I also have endometriosis and wanted to understand if a c section would be better, and especially if I was going to need one, I would rather have elective than emergency.

I decided not to pick one or the other straight away, see how the pregnancy progresses, any complications nearer the time and just keeping an open mind.

I went to hypnobirthing classes which have helped massively with the anxiety surrounding giving birth. I did KG hypnobirthing with a hypnobirthing teacher. Even if you decide it’s not for you, Katherine Graves’ Instagram is so helpful with videos talking through topics like induction etc. I found that now I know all the options for induction, pain relief, anything that can happen I feel calmer knowing what we would do in those situations and more prepared. You also go through relaxations/visualisation which is really helpful.

Luckily I haven’t had any complications, so I’m planning a hospital water birth, to reduce the risk of tearing. Obviously anything can change between now and then, I’m 35 weeks, but I feel confident that whatever happens we can make the best decisions for us.

DaveyJonesLocker · 04/02/2023 09:57

You've got a long time to change your mind.
Personally I'd hope for a vaginal but if the placenta isn't optimum I'd have a C section.

I wouldn't go through induction again so if I didn't go into labour naturally I'd have a c section.

And, as I did with my induction, if things weren't progressing well, rather than risk needing an instrumental birth. C section.

My c section was shitty to recover from.

KatieB55 · 04/02/2023 09:57

Recovery from planned c-section is usually good - just have someone on hand for the first few weeks to drive and help you. Emergency with GA will take longer. If you have anxiety then prepared c-section may well be best for you. Hope all goes well.

BakewellGin1 · 04/02/2023 09:56

In your situation I would go section I think as it is more planned and controlled. I can't speak from experience as I have never had one but I had two vaginal births which both went off plan.

Siameasy · 04/02/2023 09:52

Planned CS all day long in your position.

superplumb · 04/02/2023 09:51

As for private rooms, I was told they don't offer this anymore after birthing due to a mum falling asleep on her baby. They like to keep you where they can see you all. Didn't make sense as my curtain was closed for most of it. This is going back to 2015 so it may be diff now

HannahsLife · 04/02/2023 09:50

My ELCS was lovely. And the recovery was great too - kept on top of paracetamol and ibuprofen for a few days but barely needed it, so don't let people scare you about the recover either! I'd do it again in a heartbeat.