Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is AIBU me or DH in regards to DD punching girl in her year.

287 replies

Pointlessworrying · 03/02/2023 20:20

Our 14 year old DD is a wonderful, intelligent and happy girl, she is in Y9 at an independent all girls school and has a lovely bunch of friends.

She does however have quite a short fuse and like most teenage girls can be at times be quite grumpy, she also takes no prisoners and is quite good at putting up heathy barriers when it comes to her peers.

I would say she has a good sense of worth which we obviously encourage and the following is an isolated incident.

I caught the tale end of her telling her DS at the dinner table that a girl in her year had slapped her, the 1st time she had turned round she thought it must have been an accident, the 2nd she had asked her to stop the 3 time she actually caught her head and DD had turned round and punched her in the Jaw.

The girl was initially quite shocked and then had ran off an told a teacher supported by her friends. DD was asked by the teacher to have a chat she had explained the situation, teacher was really kind about it and just spoke to to DD about managing feelings and to come and talk to her in future.

However what has came out in this is this DH has fully supported DD in her actions, told her she was absolutely in the right and to do the same thing again.

Talking it over tonight he said that DD has the right the defend herself and couldn’t be punished for doing so, he also said that if she hadn’t retaliated in the way she did in found of a group of mean girls she would have opened herself up to bullying…

I however feel that DD has enough about her to do this without using her hands and worry that if this became more than a one off incident the repercussion it would have for her.

Mostly it’s highlighted that DH and I are obviously on quite different pages to how our DC should act in this kind of situation and wondered what people thought.

OP posts:
Rainbowshit · 03/02/2023 21:12

I'm with your DH. Good for your DD.

The bully will think twice before doing that again.

EarringsandLipstick · 03/02/2023 21:11

Teeshirt · 03/02/2023 20:39

I’m shocked by the replies so far. I wouldn’t have punished her, and she was clearly provoked, but punching the girl was not the right thing to do. She should have walked away and reported it.

Exactly this.

Some of these responses are mental.

I too would not have 'punished' but I would be absolutely clear it was unacceptable behaviour.

Regardless of the other girl's behaviour, you cannot respond by punching.

She is 14. In the real world, you do have to find other ways of dealing with unwanted or wrong behaviour, other than retaliating physically.

In the school my DC go to, both girls would be punished.

MrWhippersnapper · 03/02/2023 21:10

I work in a girl’s school, we don’t get much punching, mainly ragging each others hair out and scratching. Hopefully the girl will leave her alone now

VintageThoughts · 03/02/2023 21:08

Team Dad here.

Other girl behaved like an arsehole and your DD defended herself.

Motelschmotel · 03/02/2023 21:07

I think you’re both right

I would say she wasn’t in the wrong to do what she did. But that violence has to be the last resort. I’d talk to DD about exactly what happened, blow by blow (pun intended) and delve into the point at which she could have done something for it not to descend into a punch being thrown.

Separately, I’m alarmed at this indecorous behaviour from such young ladies <gasped in my old headmistress’s sternest voice!>

Maverickess · 03/02/2023 21:07

I think your DD should be aware of the potential for that situation to have gone wrong and for her to be in trouble if it had, because unfortunately imo, PP's are right and a punch in response to slaps could be seen as retaliation rather than self defence, pushing the hand away or raising an arm if unable to get away, and that going wrong would be more likely to be seen as self defence, but, and it's not necessarily fair when the one who creates the whole situation becomes the victim, but it's the way it works, and clearly this girl knows that because she ran off to tell the teacher when your DD retaliated, so she needs to be mindful of future incidents and how she handles them.

That said, part of me thinks that if a few more bullies got walloped back and were then told that it's a potential risk when you bully someone that they'll retaliate and you'll lose, rather than told they're the victim, there'd be less bullying all round.

minipie · 03/02/2023 21:07

The problem with retaliation is there is a chance that your DD’s retaliatory punch will be seen by or reported to teachers, but the original slaps aren’t seen or reported.

At which point your DD may say oh she slapped me three times first but if everyone else says no she never, your DD is in big big trouble.

The other issue is if the girl carries on with her slapping (despite all the assurances here that the punch will stop her doing it ever again Hmm) your DD can’t really complain to teachers as the girl will just say well she punched me and your DD loses any sympathy.

Soubriquet · 03/02/2023 21:07

Teeshirt · 03/02/2023 21:00

Absolutely shocking.

And frankly I don’t give a fuck.

Im not having my son picked on and the teachers doing nothing. By him saying those two words, his bully stopped.

MichaelKeaton · 03/02/2023 21:06

Genegenieee · 03/02/2023 20:28

This. A punch that resulted in this might be manslaughter, but could be murder if prosecution established intention to commit GBH.

A punch following a slap wd be unlikely to constitute self defence. It's disproportionate.

I think this might be a tad OTT.

FlissyPaps · 03/02/2023 21:06

She doesn’t know her own strength and I can guarantee the hook she gave the girl back would have been 10 times harder than what she did to her.

Good. Well done to your DD!

Hopefully the bully who started it will think twice about doing something like that again.

Kitcaterpillar · 03/02/2023 21:05

I'm confused by the 'doesn't know her own strength' statement... Why doesn't she know her own strength? Is she freakishly strong? Or you haven't mentioned she's a black belt or...what?

WuTangGran · 03/02/2023 21:04

Soubriquet · 03/02/2023 20:59

I’ve told my children to hit back. Even swear back if they have too.

There’s a kid a year above my ds who keeps picking on him.

Ds is only 7 but he turned round and told the boy to fuck off.

Boy has left him alone since. I fully support him

Quite right too.

Ghostbusters104 · 03/02/2023 21:04

Yes to DD all the way, tried to resolve with words , not happening, slapped the twat, good on her.

MrWhippersnapper · 03/02/2023 21:04

she won’t do it again

pictoosh · 03/02/2023 21:03

If you don't put someone who feels at liberty to hit you straight the first time, they keep coming back.
That girl will not be hitting your dd again.

Rowthe · 03/02/2023 21:02

Pointlessworrying · 03/02/2023 20:25

I wouldn’t say I thought she was in the wrong necessarily wrong I just know that these things aren’t always black and white when it come to repercussions and punishment and would worry what that might mean for my daughter.

She doesn’t know her own strength and I can guarantee the hook she gave the girl back would have been 10 times harder than what she did to her.

Dont thi k you need to worry.

I doubt that girl will do the same again.

And news like this spreads quick.

Doubt many others will try and attack your daughter either.

She protected herself. Which is great!

Rainyday4321 · 03/02/2023 21:00

I have told my DD that there is a 3 strike rule- and then she is allowed to use physical force.
first time - tell them to stop and or tell a teacher
second time- as above.
third time- hit them back and don’t pull your punches.

I stand by it. The people who are supposed to deal with it get 2 chances to get it right. After that- you are totally allowed to deal with it yourself.

Why would you teach them that that is never an option?

Teeshirt · 03/02/2023 21:00

Soubriquet · 03/02/2023 20:59

I’ve told my children to hit back. Even swear back if they have too.

There’s a kid a year above my ds who keeps picking on him.

Ds is only 7 but he turned round and told the boy to fuck off.

Boy has left him alone since. I fully support him

Absolutely shocking.

Soubriquet · 03/02/2023 20:59

I’ve told my children to hit back. Even swear back if they have too.

There’s a kid a year above my ds who keeps picking on him.

Ds is only 7 but he turned round and told the boy to fuck off.

Boy has left him alone since. I fully support him

Highdaysandholidays1 · 03/02/2023 20:59

you can also do things to stop aggression which aren't run and tell the teacher or put up with it. If someone did that, I'd put my hand up to stop them slapping and shout 'don't f*ing do that again' at them, then stand up, walk away in a physically strong manner. In most cases, getting into a fistfight isn't the best way, because there's always a chance that you escalate and then they escalate back.

PriOn1 · 03/02/2023 20:59

PAFMO · 03/02/2023 20:49

Was beginning to think MN had been taken over by streetfighters tonight.
Well said.
OP- if this story is true, then presumably you've been in touch with the school, both about the incident leading to the punch, and the aftermath. Our school would have, rightly or wrongly, suspended your DD for 3 days. As pp says, a punch can kill.

Well said to the idiot who suggested that a girl who didn’t start a fight, but merely lost her temper a bit and retaliated against someone bullying her would go to prison?

Get a grip, both of you. The chances of OP’s daughter are so negligible it’s laughable anyone would even think it. Both girls will grow up and probably never hit anyone again.

Teeshirt · 03/02/2023 20:59

PinkiOcelot · 03/02/2023 20:47

Nah. So she could then have been called a wuss and a coward?!

I told my dds if anyone ever hit them, to hit back. Harder. They didn’t turn out to be inmates of the future!

How would that make her a wuss and a coward? It’s a bit pathetic to hit someone - the mark of someone not in control of themselves. It’s much stronger to control your emotions and react appropriately. And even if she was a “coward”, better than than aggression.

ChristinaXYZ · 03/02/2023 20:58

Toooldtoworry · 03/02/2023 20:26

Am also with your DH and DD. Bullies need to be shown that their actions have consequences. Your daughter taught the bully the consequence of slapping someone x 3 is getting punched back.

That's fine so long as the bullies parents don't call the police. You cannot just punch people. It was not reasonable force - hand up to defend herself - fine. Even pushing her away as the bully came near her if your DD reasonably expected another slap. But not a punch. For your DD's sake she needs to know she might well not get away with that either legally or actually - as someone else has said one punch can kill and she would have to live with the knowledge of that and the consequences.

MissyB1 · 03/02/2023 20:57

Hang on a minute? Your dd was involved in a serious incident at school in which she punched a fellow pupil, but the school didn’t contact you? You only heard about it because dd was bragging to her brother about it?
Someone is exaggerating here, either you or dd.

MrsMiddleMother · 03/02/2023 20:57

I'm with DH and DD on this one. Growing up we was always taught never hit first but hit back