Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH wants to pull out of house purchase because it's "too stressful"

335 replies

LightBuzzyear27 · 03/02/2023 16:11

We are 8 months into a house sale and purchase, and are literally days away from exchange and due to complete a week today. For a few weeks DH has been grumbling about how stressful it is, how he doesn't think it would be worth it, and doesn't actually care if we move anymore, but he's never actually said "let's pull out". I reassured him it will all be fine and not to stress about anything. Things have still progressed and we got a call today to say we couldn't exchange today as planned but will hopefully be Monday or Tuesday next week now, still with a view to complete on Friday. DH has now come out and said he doesn't actually want to move, it's too stressful with the uncertainty of if it is actually going to go ahead, the packing and actual moving will be stressful, and we won't be able to do anything we want to do to it straight away as we're sinking all out money into it, so that will be stressful too.

Now, unfortunately, when DH gets even the tiniest bit stressed, he shuts down/withdraws/loses interest and there's no coming back from it. And now I don't know what to do, as it seems either way one of us will be unhappy.

We have 3 kids, and are moving about half an hour away. It will be closer to my parents though that is not the reason for the move. We are in a 3 bed semi, on a busy road, with noisy inconsiderate neighbours, no driveway for our 2 cars, and a small garden. The new house in detached on a quiet cul-de-sac, with a large driveway, large garden. It's still a 3 bed, but it has the scope to extend, which our current house also doesn't have.

He's worried about money, I know that, but our outgoings will stay the same. I am looking to change jobs to a better paid one, but will need to put 2 kids in nursery to do so, so my wage probably won't change from what it is now. He earns well, but it's quiet at the moment, and his current work place is an hour away from the new house, and it will add 2 hours onto his already long night shifts. He's applied for over 30 jobs closer to the new house and not heard anything back so he's getting stressed about that too.

He's also refusing to pack so I've had to make a start on my own, with 2 under 2. I can do bits in the evening but I still won't get it all done by myself.

Does anyone have any advice? AIBU to still want to move? How do I convince DH it's going to be short term stress for long term happiness? His brain doesn't seem to work like mine and he's not very rational/logical, especially when he's in one of his funks.

OP posts:
Tiani4 · 05/02/2023 16:38

Movers
Not lovers GrinBlushShock

Tiani4 · 05/02/2023 16:37

Sometimes is adults and parents have to slog through the difficult stuff the physical stuff
Once it's done you won't have to move again (hopefully ever..!)

I'd push it all over the line or I were you OP and tell your DH to just crack on and not wino out at this last bit. Please ask your lovers for a quote to Pack for you, they are genius and so quick at that

Tiani4 · 05/02/2023 16:34

Your DH is being unreasonable

He's also being lazy

It is a long slog selling a house and packing up nearer the time. Ofc you still move

Can you pay the house movers to pack for you? It'll cost about £600 extra but far less than it's cost of you broke the chain

It's ridiculous that he's withdrawn - he needs to adult up

We all go through this pain when we move house, some less painful some chains are more painful... you've done the worst part, it's the physical last push the last spring to the end now. It's be crazy to give up now. Don't let him

Newparentnov2022 · 05/02/2023 14:31

Consider paying for someone to do the packing. It will take a lot longer than you think.

Pr1mr0se · 05/02/2023 14:05

Your new house (excluding the commute for your DH's current job) sounds what you need. I'd be supportive of the house move and hope DH is ok once we're there. Is there any chance you could pay a removal company to pack to take the stress off you with that?

InsiderDad · 05/02/2023 13:15

Pack everything up apart from his stuff, complete on the house and you and the kids move to a better place.

There are people out there that would absolutely love to buy their FIRST property, let alone upsize to somewhere that sounds ideal (hint: me and my family)...

If he's going to act like a child, treat him like a child, buy him a pack of adult nappies and tell him to keep sulking - but he'll be doing it in rented accommodation......

Daddiesnet · 05/02/2023 12:25

I'd make a list of the pro's and con's together.
Assuming the pro's outweigh the con's, ask him then to justify not moving.
Never force someone to choose, cos 9 times out 10 they'll choose the opposite to what you want.

JunglePug · 05/02/2023 11:22

You are most certainly not being unreasonable OP - but he is. If DH had wanted to stop this move he should have talked this over with you months ago, not days before you are due to exchange! By the way, your new house sounds perfect for you in (almost) every way - particularly as you say that your outgoings will remain the same. Stand your ground OP. It's not fair on you, your kids and, the other vendors involved in this chain to back out now. Good luck to you.

QueenieOD · 05/02/2023 11:20

This sounds difficult. I hear in this message a worry about money. This is a serious concern in todays economy. I can also see in order to generate the income you need to buy this house, a man and wife will not see much of one another. The commute you’re asking of him is huge. Let’s not pretend it isn’t. I don’t know what kind of job he has but I know most people want to get back to their families at the end of the day or night. Commute time eats into life time. Commute time is dead time. Most of us are willing to commute an hour and that’s long enough tbh. You have the opportunity to extend your home? You won’t be able to afford for years and your kids will be grown so you won’t need it. Sometimes a new start in a new house feels like the end of woes but sometimes it’s the beginning of new woes. Your DH is trying to tell you something about your life (and his) but you’re not listening. You think this is best for everyone but he’s telling you that it isn’t. He’s not being difficult. Maybe he’s trying to protect your relationship? What’s this fresh start really all about? What’s his resistance all about? You need to get to the bottom of that. It doesn’t sound like his money fears are irrational. Be real about what your family needs right now. Is it space or is it time? Are you running towards space because you fear time with your family? With your husband? Why you giving your time away like this? The time that’s going to be taken from your life to pay for all of this cant be returned to you. And we don’t have the time we think we have in life. In my experience it’s what we waste the most of and for things we don’t need. When we give it away it destroys our relationships, our spirit and our health. All these things you think you’re giving your family in this house move, maybe you’re actually taking something more valuable away from them but it can’t be seen right now. I would listen to your husband and not because the man knows better because I don’t believe this house move has anything to do with parking or noisy neighbours. You have three kids. How quiet is your home? I hope it’s noisy as hell because that’s a beautiful sound. You’re very lucky. I think maybe don’t underestimate the concerns of your husband or what the universe is telling you because it’s not an accident this exchange is taking as long as it’s taking. You’re at crossroads. This decision will impact your family for years to come. Make sure this decision is the right one. You’ll be living with it for a long time. I hope it all goes well for you and your family. It’s possible he has cold feet. It’s also possible he can feel the time drain debt creates and the consequences of it for your family if things should go pear shaped. Be real about all of this. You get one life. Your kids get one childhood. I never heard an adult reflecting on their childhood and say “my childhood is great we have loads of parking” but I hear a lot of adults reflecting on their choosing citing money worries and how they never saw their parents who were always stressed about money. Just saying. Good luck x

almondfinger · 05/02/2023 10:04

I’ve just read your posts OP. Glad to see things are coming along and you have better movers. It makes all the difference with the big pieces of furniture.

I’m not sure if anyone mentioned but what I would be saying is ‘just picture ourselves this summer, lovely garden, better neighbours, no noise, a beer in hand. It’s going to be great’. Plant that picture in his head over and over as something positive to look forward to.

We self built our house and it was at times v v stressful. I used to stand in the new empty kitchen where the sink was going to be imagining my view. Now I stand in the finished job 5 years on and still appreciate how that thought got me through some days and am v thankful.

good luck, your new house sounds fab and the new job might be easier to find when you are actually settled in.

Eowyn78 · 05/02/2023 09:49

He needs to build some resilience. Life is stressful, but he is a husband and a father and needs to grow up and take responsibility. The decision was made and you have to stick to it and make it work.

Is there anyone in the extended family who can help offer additional support during this stressful time? I do think it is important for people to have a 'village/community' in their lives to help each other out.

I fear parents in a nuclear family are expected to do too much alone these days, and it does bring about additional stress.

In regards to packing, how old are the children? Perhaps they can be involved. As Mary Poppins says, "in every job there is to be done there is an element of fun. Find the fun and snap the job's a game." Try and make it a fun adventure for the whole family.

CrazyLadie · 05/02/2023 09:47

musingsinmidlife · 03/02/2023 17:21

I don't know how long his shifts are but adding 2 to 4 hours to a shift for a commute to come home after nights to 3 kids with two under two is brutal. Sleep deprivation and that long of a drive after a night shift is also a recipe for disaster.

This move doesn't seem like it was well thought out. He is definitely the loser in it and I get why he is getting cold feet. Personally I would take the irritation of noisy neighbours and bad parking over a 2-4 hour daily commute. You could easily still end up with noisy or difficult neighbours on a cul de sac. That commute is so much wasted time that could be spend sleeping, with family etc.

Really depends on what they are doing, my old neighbours made my life hell. 5 years of bullying and when they found out I have bipolar they upped the anti. I bought my own home last October, previous to that in 2022 alone they made 2 complaints to the cops, 2 to the dog warden, 1 to the anti social and and numerous ones to my landlord. Not one was upheld, as I had proof, he just expected everyone to take his work for it even though I have proven heaps o times he was a liar. The final straw for me was I saw them in the garden damaging theor own fence, I knew they were up to something so I videoed them, next morning I had the police at my door cause they had reported me for damaging their fence. Copper had a good laugh when he say my video and checked previous history as I had been keeping a log woth the police of their behaviours

LightBuzzyear27 · 05/02/2023 09:38

Isobel201 · 05/02/2023 09:00

I'm in a position where I'm selling my first home and have already moved back into my dad's house as he moved up north to live with a new partner. I have just accepted an offer on it, so I'm hoping it doesn't take another 8 months to complete considering its taken a year just to get to this stage. I do get the stress the DH is in to some extent, although I had the advantage of being able to move out and sort things out pre-sale. I hope you do complete next week, I need the money to pay off some debts so I'm hoping with it being a first time buyer it won't take as long as that.

Just to put your mind at ease, whilst yes it can take months and months if there are problems or rubbish solicitors, but the first house we offered on fell through at the last minute before exchange. That was in October, so that was about 4 months. Our offer on this house was accepted in November, so hasn't actually taken all that long. I also know someone who sold in June last year and completed in August. We also sold my grandad's house in March last year and I think we completed in May, though admittedly there was no chain.

OP posts:
Isobel201 · 05/02/2023 09:00

I'm in a position where I'm selling my first home and have already moved back into my dad's house as he moved up north to live with a new partner. I have just accepted an offer on it, so I'm hoping it doesn't take another 8 months to complete considering its taken a year just to get to this stage. I do get the stress the DH is in to some extent, although I had the advantage of being able to move out and sort things out pre-sale. I hope you do complete next week, I need the money to pay off some debts so I'm hoping with it being a first time buyer it won't take as long as that.

Dibbydoos · 05/02/2023 08:22

I used to do a daily door-to-door commute of 1 and 3/4 hour into London with 2 under 4's. It's doable, but is hard. I did it for 5 years then had enough £ to go self-employed. A means to an end. Your DH will get a job closer to home, perseverance beats resistance!

Your DH is responding normally to a house move - it is stressful - but then unacceptably to packing, so you may need to get some help in. Would that reduce his stress level? I asked family and friends to help, they did it was worth taking them out for a meal as a reward!

FranMack · 05/02/2023 08:21

You already know he will regret not moving so you need to carry on. Your issue is keeping DH on track until you move. So you need to have a good talk with him. He must know himself that he lets the stress get to him. Remind him of the positives that will lessen his stress - no more horrible neighbours, no more noise, easy parking, future scope for the new house etc etc. Reassure him about the job situation, believe me, I've had to do the same for a while but a job will come up eventually. Go for it otherwise you will all end up in an unhappy state.

stayathomer · 05/02/2023 08:03

I don’t want to shake things for you but just a ‘make sure you’re sure’ thing- especially with the commute. We bought in 2007. I remember Christmas 2006 I had a feeling and everyone said to me it was too late. For so many reasons it was the hugest mistake of our life and if I could go back and only lose that initial €5000 I would be the happiest person in the world!!

Icandefinitelydothis · 05/02/2023 07:31

N12 · 04/02/2023 20:52

Wow - what a massive lack of sympathy towards the guy who works nights and is about to have +2hours added to his commute every day.

If this will push him over the edge, investigate lowering your mortgage payments to allow him to see if he can do one less shift a week to help him cope. You can always renegotiate the term later without financial penalty if you want to increase payments later when he hopefully finds a job closer to the new home.

Try to look for solutions together that could make his life better.

Christ, it's no wonder suicide is so common in men with the way so many in this thread think they should be treated when they are struggling mentally.

This! Exactly bloody this.

i was almost tempted to make a list of the hideous comments.

As I’ve mentioned above, he sounds unwell. Suggest a GP appointment and even offer to go with him for support.

To those saying he needs to tell her what’s going on with him… he has!

He is finding this TOO STRESSFUL. He’s actually used the words. There’s no reading between lines needed. He's clearly UNABLE to engage productively. He needs help not being told to get a grip (that’s one of the nicer ones).

Imagine of this was a woman on here with an initial post saying she was clearly unwell and her husband has told her to ‘hold her nerve’ ‘get a grip’…. Even suggesting that she was being manipulative and had an attitude! There would be uproar, he’d be abusive and she’d be told to LTB.

changeme4this · 05/02/2023 04:37

I can understand his frustration. Our DD has been looking at open homes for months and months, 4 offers in and she has had one accepted with lots of too’ing and fro’ing. No pricing guide, others made offers too which was well outside of owners expectations.

however land agents are a law unto themselves and hardly worth the money they charge for their input.

HWarner · 05/02/2023 04:35

WOW, I see a lot of selfish women in this comment. As someone who moved 1.5 hours away from all my family and friends to keep my husband from the commute. I think you should reconsider. I used to commute an hour to work...until I fell asleep at the wheel and nearly hit someone head on. No house is worth losing your hubby, either to stress, an accident, or divorce when he feels like he can't take anymore. Wait until he is assured of a closer job and for the rates to come down. Also get hubby some therapy, it sounds like he needs it for his mental wellbeing; couples therapy as well to learn how to deal better together as these issues arise. To me there is nothing more important than my husband's and children's safety, and mental health. The wait also gives you a chance to look for a job as well. Your perfect house may not even be on the market yet.

housemaus · 05/02/2023 02:45

anon666 · 04/02/2023 23:47

You'll have to carry him through. Sorry about this OP.

I'm not legitimising his behaviour but it's a reaction to overwhelming anxiety.

I used to have it without realising over stuff like holidays.

Hopefully he will pull his finger out eventually once it's underway.

Agreed.

DH is the same way and pushing him on it/'reading the riot act' as a PP said would just shut him down more because it would compound the fear and he would 'freeze' up, not be able to pack or plan or rationalise anything.

Reassurance about the drawbacks, acknowledging his worries, and then quietly getting on with it anyway would be the way forward for me.

Rosiefifi · 05/02/2023 01:24

mustgetoffmn · 05/02/2023 00:41

In the whole scheme of things getting your home sorted is a far more permanent and important decision than the commute/ job situation. The latter can be addressed and OP has pointed out that DH will get alternative employment relatively easy. Finding a better home not so easy. It’s clear and stated that DH is having a stress related reaction. This will temporarily affect their job searching as it’s likely the MH makes it difficult for them to cope with that much change. Very typical of ND. I am involved with very close relative in same state about having to move and it turns into an irrational and annoying obstinacy. Home first, job sorted after. It’s clear OP is dealing with this the right way good luck to them all will be well

If he can get a new job quickly that's a big if with the same pay. if not OP will have to muck in and work more. I would rather have my DH alive than living in the perfect house. I don't think you have ever worked night shifts with very long hours ? It's bone achingly exhausting a 2 hour commute on top is very risky.

Patineur · 05/02/2023 00:50

girlswillbegirls · 04/02/2023 21:57

That is very unfair comment, he has got a family, but so does she. Adding two hours to your commute is a very good reason not to move. It's a massive change.
And I do think the OP mentioned he works shifts on top of it. I did this in the past, you need to experience that extreme tiredness to understand it. It's not fair one person putting up with all the stress of making lots of mmoneyand long commmutes for buying a bigger/detached/nicer house.

I do think OP the stress of your husband is reasonable. He knows he can't just get "any job" but one that pays him well, so he can pay for a nice house/area. And he knows he won't be able to enjoy it with that sort of commute.
Postpone that purchase till either you make more money, or you have a better plan around that commute.
Sorry I am with him on this one.

Adding two hours to the commute for what is likely to be a very short time is not a valid reason to junk all the very good reasons they have for moving. It's not as if it's necessarily the end of the world if he has to take a slightly lower paying job initially, given that he will save on the costs of commuting and OP will be moving to better paid work.

mustgetoffmn · 05/02/2023 00:41

Rosiefifi · 04/02/2023 21:07

To be honest no if he can't find a job adding 2 hours onto a long shift to commute is very dangerous.. it can cause you to fall asleep and crash the car. I don't blame him for wanting to pull out of the house sale there's no way I'd be willing to add on 2 hours to my work day for extra driving. Would you be willing to do the same?

In the whole scheme of things getting your home sorted is a far more permanent and important decision than the commute/ job situation. The latter can be addressed and OP has pointed out that DH will get alternative employment relatively easy. Finding a better home not so easy. It’s clear and stated that DH is having a stress related reaction. This will temporarily affect their job searching as it’s likely the MH makes it difficult for them to cope with that much change. Very typical of ND. I am involved with very close relative in same state about having to move and it turns into an irrational and annoying obstinacy. Home first, job sorted after. It’s clear OP is dealing with this the right way good luck to them all will be well

Atsocta · 05/02/2023 00:16

12DS · 04/02/2023 19:05

You probably didn’t listen to his ambivalence earlier in the process and subconsciously conflated your family’s needs with your desires. He probably wanted to avoid conflict and should have spoken up earlier.

And you didn’t read the post!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread