Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not think it’s fair to get a dog

78 replies

circleontheleft · 03/02/2023 14:57

Me and DH have wanted a dog for as long as I can remember. Both grown up with dogs and are animal lovers, and we’d really like a pet. We did our research in the pandemic when WFH was established, but never took the step towards getting a puppy.

The topic has come up again recently and DH is really eager, reasoning that it will bring happiness to our lives and encourage us to walk (which we already do!)

I have shared my reservations with him but he is more optimistic than me and thinks we can use doggy daycare, which I know will come with a large cost.

One of us is a shift worker and the other works a 9-5, hybrid role where the working location is variable. Some days are longer than this, some shorter and some work from home. No way to guarantee this more than a week in advance. It does work so that there’s almost always one person at home. We have retired ILs living locally who would help but it’s not fair to expect it of them when SIL already demands they look after her dog at the drop of a hat. I don’t think this is enough certainty for a puppy and the burden isn’t for our relatives to bear if they want to make other plans.

I know the amount of time and energy that goes into raising a dog with a good temperament and would feel very guilty leaving a dog for any longer than a couple of hours, as their humans are really their world aren’t they!

I’d love a dog and think they’re fantastic but think it’s a kinder decision to continue looking after retired ILs dog when we know we have a weekend off, or annual leave etc. We’re planning to TTC quite soon, too, so not fair for a puppy to get pushed out - even if some dogs love babies.

I might be overthinking it, but AIBU to stand on with this?

OP posts:
InspectorPaws · 03/02/2023 15:06

CalistoNoSolo · 03/02/2023 15:02

I was going to suggest getting an older rescue dog rather than a puppy, but if you're going to have children imminently then maybe not get a dog at all.

A rescue is likely to require a lot more work to settle than a puppy because it’ll have hang ups and trauma.

InspectorPaws · 03/02/2023 15:05

You sound like you’re more than set up to get a dog. We have a dog and our behaviourist says they should be asleep 80-90% of the time and that, in her experience/opinion, having owners around them constantly is really bad for them because they’re constantly “on” which inhibits their ability to relax, sleep and be calm. They used up very stressed (like overtired children). She actually encourages us to leave the dog alone unless engaging in active dog activities (like dog walking, dog training or playing with the dog). If you’re going to be at home the whole day, you should actually have the dog have a safe space in a different room to go to for calm. This is especially the case for breeds who struggle to relax or calm (like working breeds) that you would instinctively believe need more interaction but are actually happier with a lot less than you’d think.

Puppies obviously require more than this for toileting and settling in but you and DH could each take a week off work and then there’s definitely someone at home for the first two weeks (almost three if you pick up on a Friday) and then you’re almost always able to be at home anyway.

CalistoNoSolo · 03/02/2023 15:02

I was going to suggest getting an older rescue dog rather than a puppy, but if you're going to have children imminently then maybe not get a dog at all.