Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That threads starting "how do people afford....house, car, holiday, etc" are annoying

108 replies

bobbytorq · 03/02/2023 09:45

I don't understand the purpose of the above threads. Is it because people really don't know and think there is some magic answer that eludes them? When people post about how they can afford it, they then get accused of lying or bragging. The simple answer is that people who have expensive things usually have enough money to pay for them. I'm lucky to have lots of friends whose income ranges from minimum wage up to seven figures. There is no hierachy/power/status attached to that and it's just a fact that my friend who earn more can spend more.

OP posts:
BertieBotts · 03/02/2023 12:38

illtakeit · 03/02/2023 11:32

Seriously??? OK I rob the bank on a regular. That's my big secret 🤔
I don't want to sound mean but people can't really be that thick surely?

See I think this is the naive comment.

It's nothing to do with intelligence - why would it be? If something it outside your sphere of experience, if you don't know anybody who inherited money, whose parents paid for expensive things, if you assume everyone has debts (from student times or from emergencies when on a lower income), pays full childcare, has no emergency cushion. If you have a different idea of what a "good salary" is.

How could you know these things? It's not to do with intelligence, it's life experience. Money is a taboo subject meaning typically you will only know how yourself, your partner, siblings and parents make and spend their money, anybody outside of this you can only guess.

PandasAreUseless · 03/02/2023 12:38

But it's not always as simple as someone having more money. It can be about appetite to risk too.

I earn very decent money and might think to myself "I know she makes half my salary, so why does she have SUCH a nice car?"

The answer is that I'm risk averse so bought my crap little car outright for £3k, and she's much more tolerant of risk and can commit £450 a month to a lease deal and still sleep at night.

Wobblytrees · 03/02/2023 12:31

BettyBoo123456 · 03/02/2023 10:17

I agree with this. We see others who appear to be living a fabulous lifestyle and think how do they do it am I missing a trick somewhere.

Sometimes its just people have different priorities. They may holiday in a fairly exotic location or appear to go away very frequently (but stay somewhere really basic and cheap or with relatives or friends all cramped in a small space). They put the best photos on Facebook and it can be misleading.

Or some people eat very very cheaply year round and are very frugal generally and splurge on what they see as priorities a nice holiday or a car etc giving an illusion of an expensive all round lifestyle.

I do think theres something in this - for example, some people I know prioritise nice cars and fancy holidays but aren’t that bothered about their house. We drive shitty old cars but have a house that we spent a lot on because we love being at home and having people over. My husband can’t stand snooty people so holiday wise we can’t go mega high end like some of my friends do as he’d hate it.

I think a lot of it is about priorities

Applesandcarrots · 03/02/2023 12:27

AmeliaEarhart · 03/02/2023 12:03

I think it works both way though. In cases where inherited wealth or outside help plays a part, it can be healthy to acknowledge those advantages. It’s not always a case of spite or envy or wanting to belittle other’s achievements. It can be just an objective acknowledgment that we live in an unequal society.

The thing is that it is not often objective acknowledgement, it's often simply made up fact.
On every thread about anything noce you will have posters simply declaring that it must be inheritance/tax evasion/selling firstborn whatever, just never anything like "saved up for it by not buying something else".

It is a big thing on here

2bazookas · 03/02/2023 12:23

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 03/02/2023 10:13

Of course it’s a genuine question and the fact some people don’t find the answer obvious while other people can’t see how it’s NOT obvious is testament to how economically divided our country has become.

I'd say its testament to how educationally-divided Britain is becoming.

Thanks to expanding contempt for schools, teachers, qualifications, life and social skills which is fostered and fed on and by social media.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 03/02/2023 12:19

I don't so much hate the threads as all the disingenuous replies saying "duh they earn more than you"

I think these threads illustrate the lack of financial education and transparency in this country and the massive inequality.

It is about so much more than just headline salary but even then people often have a really poor concept of what people earn for different jobs.

There is the issue of whether they have two salaries, whether they get a bonus, or comission, or overtime payments or perks such as a company car. Whether they have additional incomes, say rental from a second property or a share in a family business. Whether they have help from parents or an inheritance etc.

Then there's what they have to pay for, do they need paid childcare, do they have a mortgage or rent, when did they buy their house, do they own their car, do they have a student loan, other debts?

There are huge differences between people's wealth that have nothing to do with salary.

For example I used to work with someone who was in a low paid role but a lifestyle that didn't match. Even the fact they lived at home didn't explain it. When I got to know them it transpired that they had an income from dividends in a family business and had savings from a brief professional sports career plus parents who were prepared to fund their kids, often paying for holidays as well as helping with house purchases, education costs and so on.

I can think of people who have all kinds of things paid for by parents as adults. Horse livery, dog walkers, childcare, cars, holidays, house deposits, uni fees, business set up.

Then there's property prices, the way property has gone in recent years accounts for huge differences. Buying a house a couple of years earlier can mean a huge gain. If a couple each had a small London flat in the early 2000s and subsequently sold them to buy a house up north they will be able to afford much more than a couple on the same income where one or both rented or lived with their parents during the same years.

Inheritance makes a huge difference too. An inheritance of over £100k is not that uncommon when you think about the price of a fairly bog standard house these days.

Education on financial matters is a huge issue too. People who grew up being taught debt is wrong so they won't use any form of debt to spread payments. People who will have savings sitting in low interest bank accounts because they need easy access and can't tolerate any risk. Others will be willing to lock money up to access better rates as they have access to credit or alternative funds if necessary. The wealthier will be willing to take risks and will get the benefit of investing in stocks and shares increasing their wealth further.

So many factors beyond salary.

AmeliaEarhart · 03/02/2023 12:03

illtakeit · 03/02/2023 11:52

OK I want to be a bit more serious because I honestly want to understand that line of thinking.

For posters who asks such questions, does it ever occur to them that maybe, just maybe that those who can afford these things are on a higher income that they are? Some may have 2 incomes in the household? Hence why they can afford those things?

For example - A threads from SAHM of 3 wondering how her DHs 30K salary doesn't leave them any extra to be able to afford holidays. How on earth would it?

I always feel like the answer is simple but they're looking for some magic bullet and there isn't. Do they want to hear about the careers of people are who are on higher incomes or how they too can breakthrough in those sector to make such income as well? I doubt it.

Maybe they just want to hear something like - "Inheritance" so they can say something along the lines of "Oh I just knew it wouldn't be possible without free money".

I think it works both way though. In cases where inherited wealth or outside help plays a part, it can be healthy to acknowledge those advantages. It’s not always a case of spite or envy or wanting to belittle other’s achievements. It can be just an objective acknowledgment that we live in an unequal society.

illtakeit · 03/02/2023 11:52

SleeplessInEngland · 03/02/2023 11:35

Ok, so you robbed a bank but I'm sure not everyone who has such conspicuous wealth did that.

OK I want to be a bit more serious because I honestly want to understand that line of thinking.

For posters who asks such questions, does it ever occur to them that maybe, just maybe that those who can afford these things are on a higher income that they are? Some may have 2 incomes in the household? Hence why they can afford those things?

For example - A threads from SAHM of 3 wondering how her DHs 30K salary doesn't leave them any extra to be able to afford holidays. How on earth would it?

I always feel like the answer is simple but they're looking for some magic bullet and there isn't. Do they want to hear about the careers of people are who are on higher incomes or how they too can breakthrough in those sector to make such income as well? I doubt it.

Maybe they just want to hear something like - "Inheritance" so they can say something along the lines of "Oh I just knew it wouldn't be possible without free money".

DashboardConfessional · 03/02/2023 11:49

People have savings. I'm now 40ish and have not been moving up the property ladder every 3 years like some people, so our mortgage is now 1 6th of our take home. DS now gets free hours so we can save the nursery money. Obviously we were not in this situation as new grads at 23 when our bills and food were 90%.

I do think there are "sweet spots" where housing and childcare is relatively cheap, there are jobs and one parent can afford to be part time like I am. Where I live in the SW is one.

Scalottia · 03/02/2023 11:36

Applesandcarrots · 03/02/2023 11:32

Absolutely.
Same way like no one buys house without bank of mum and dad, no one is slim without probably having masaive issues and god forbid if you are happy! You are probs just hiding your DH is cheating with local football team, your kids have drug issues and your house is about to be repossessed....

Absolutely agree. It seems a bit 'misery loves company' to me - that may come off as nasty but I am not sure how else to explain it.

SleeplessInEngland · 03/02/2023 11:35

illtakeit · 03/02/2023 11:32

Seriously??? OK I rob the bank on a regular. That's my big secret 🤔
I don't want to sound mean but people can't really be that thick surely?

Ok, so you robbed a bank but I'm sure not everyone who has such conspicuous wealth did that.

EllieQ · 03/02/2023 11:34

GabrielAgreste · 03/02/2023 10:38

Totally agree with this - the financial landscape is shifting so rapidly that it can be baffling.

Also, unless you grow up in a financially savvy family, it’s much harder.

Mine were teachers & really had no clue. I had a shit credit rating when I was younger because (taught by them) I’d never had any form of debt - just had a bank account and always stayed in the black. Had to get a CC and pay off in full each month for a year to get my ratingup to get a mortgage.

DH used to work with a guy who was c. 10 years older than us and lived in a house that was literally called “village name Manor”. Couldn’t understand how he was so rich, turned out he’d been given 10k by parents (a decent amount but not enough to make such a difference, you’d think) when he reached 21 (early 90s), bought a warehouse apartment in a crappy area of London with the deposit & watched it increase in value by 10x over 15-20 years. He was a totally normal guy who had made a couple of smart decisions, so I do understand people thinking there may be shortcuts they are missing.

Agree with these comments about the reasons for having more money, and the impact your family’s attitude to money. I grew up in a working-class area in the 89s/ early 90s, so everyone I knew had parents who did the same kinds of job (mostly manual labour) and lived in council houses or small terraced houses. I remember one girl who had more money (judged by always having the latest toys) - her parents were teachers, and she lived in an ordinary three-bed semi. Looking back, they probably didn’t have that much money, it was just more than most of us had.

It wasn’t until I went to university that I realised there were people whose parents would pay all their tuition fees & rent, or buy them a house to live in with rooms rented out to friends, or give them money for a house deposit - it was an alien world to me. This has lingered into my adult life, to be honest. I’m often surprised by how much money people can earn doing jobs I’d never heard of when I was doing A Levels and thinking about university.

I do tend to assume that people are like us and pay for everything themselves, then I realise that people have had large amounts of money for a deposit, or childcare done by grandparents, or grandparents paying for school shoes or uniform and coats, that kind of thing. Meanwhile, my DH has recently had a chat with his parents to see if they’re managing with increasing costs or if we should be giving them some money every month. Completely different.

Sleepless1096 · 03/02/2023 11:34

I agree that these threads are pointless but I also think it's a valid point that people are unaware of the extent of income inequality in this country. Some of our friends work in finance, where the norm is not only a six figure salary but also to receive several times that in bonus. That makes affording several sets of school fees/ lots of nice holidays/new cars etc. quite easy. And as people have commented, may people will also have family wealth/inheritances or gifts from parents.

Applesandcarrots · 03/02/2023 11:32

MrFlibblesEyes · 03/02/2023 11:18

I think sometimes (not always) it's a validation thing. The poster wants all the responses to say 'don't worry, everyone else is just maxing out their credit and can't really afford these things either, they will all get their comeuppance' rather than exploring the actual reasons that some people have things they don't!

Absolutely.
Same way like no one buys house without bank of mum and dad, no one is slim without probably having masaive issues and god forbid if you are happy! You are probs just hiding your DH is cheating with local football team, your kids have drug issues and your house is about to be repossessed....

illtakeit · 03/02/2023 11:32

SleeplessInEngland · 03/02/2023 11:30

Obviosuly they have exra money. But I imagine if people are wondering this they're wondering how they have the extra money.

FFS.

Seriously??? OK I rob the bank on a regular. That's my big secret 🤔
I don't want to sound mean but people can't really be that thick surely?

Limboparents · 03/02/2023 11:32

Think this happens in real life as well, not just weird MN posts. My parents had what would be considered working class jobs, but amassed quite a bit of Wealth on paper through various properties. Whereas DPs parents were solicitors. DPs parents always like to insinuate that my parents must have been involved in something dodgy to have what they have because in reality DPs parents don’t have much to show for their ‘higher paid jobs’.

Its down to various things such as their high paying middle class jobs not actually paying much more than my parents working class jobs. My parents being more savvy when it came to over paying mortgages, my dad being more handy meaning he could renovate properties himself, my grandparents doing childcare so my parents didn’t have huge nursery fees, my parents driving cars into the ground and then buying another 2nd hand one. And mainly my parents not splitting up so they didn’t have to start paying a mortgage again in their 50s.

bobbytorq · 03/02/2023 11:31

Luredbyapomegranate · 03/02/2023 11:24

Oh don’t be silly.

If you think someone has the same income as you but has a higher standard of living, it’s not unusual to wonder if there’s a trick to managing that that you should no.

There’s nothing wrong with it, and nothing British about it, it happens everywhere.

I think the issue there is thinking that people are on the same incvome as you. People I know in same/similar jobs are on hugely different salaries. Public sector is a little easier to calculate but even then, you don't know payscales. A couple of teachers I know do the same job but one is main pay scale and the other is upper payscale with a large TLR adding another 15k to an already higher salary. When I worked in the NHS, there was disparity between posts and salaries became more difficult to know when people moved on to te VSM payscales. One of my friends is a senior solicitor for a bank and earns a 6 figure salary and another is a senior solicitor for another bank and earns a 7 figure salary.

OP posts:
BertieBotts · 03/02/2023 11:30

I think it can be quite mystifying though. It is difficult to see outside your own sphere of experience.

Family help must make a phenomenal amount of difference. Having help towards things (or things bought outright) such as a house deposit, car, driving lessons, wedding, even uni living costs/tuition fees (rather than student loans) would have freed up loads of money to put towards savings for example, family help with childcare makes a huge difference to someone's net income, these things are not small and yet if you assume everyone has them/forget that other people have them (because you don't) then it can be hard to imagine the difference in lifestyle.

When you constantly have to pay out for basic living expenses and just the normal life emergencies (funerals, urgent travel, car accident, loss of work through injury, appliance dying on you) then you don't have a chance to build up savings for more emergencies let alone save for nice things.

And people usually socialise with others around their same income level, which can give a distorted impression that "the average person" is earning roughly the same as you, and of the scale of "normal incomes". That's why for one person £30-40k will seem like a really high income and for another it will seem impossibly small, and for a third person it might seem quite average/normal. If you think of 30-40k as high, then you probably won't even consider somebody on 100k+ to be a "normal person" at all, you imagine they must be impossibly rich with a highly luxurious lifestyle.

Applesandcarrots · 03/02/2023 11:30

mamnotmum · 03/02/2023 10:02

I think it's more a 'am I missing something?' Sort of question.

Everything is so expensive at the moment so obviously something has to give. It's always going to be the luxuries that take the hit first. People all have different incomes and outgoings and also start from a different place - some might have been given deposits for houses or had inheritance etc and I think people forget that. They just see holiday photos on Facebook and think 'I must be missing something'

They are missing something though.

Not the fact some people are given money, but the fact everyone's priorities are different.

My friend likes to spend on clothes but rarely can afford holidays. I spend on holidays and rarely can afford branded clothes.

I am well confident someone else is looking at these "am I missing something" people thinking "how the fuck are they affording x" as well.

Moreover, one would really believe from here that we are all either on 150k a year or breadline with nothing in between....

SleeplessInEngland · 03/02/2023 11:30

illtakeit · 03/02/2023 11:28

Very very annoying honestly!

How can people afford it? Because they have extra money! How else FFS?

Obviosuly they have exra money. But I imagine if people are wondering this they're wondering how they have the extra money.

FFS.

illtakeit · 03/02/2023 11:28

Very very annoying honestly!

How can people afford it? Because they have extra money! How else FFS?

Luredbyapomegranate · 03/02/2023 11:24

SavoirFlair · 03/02/2023 09:58

It’s just typical of the mainly British readership and forum posters here.

The curtain twitching. Endless distrust of everyone. Inability to celebrate another’s success. A belief that if someone appears outwardly wealthy, they must stack it all up on credit or are in denial or liars etc.

Oh don’t be silly.

If you think someone has the same income as you but has a higher standard of living, it’s not unusual to wonder if there’s a trick to managing that that you should no.

There’s nothing wrong with it, and nothing British about it, it happens everywhere.

WandaWonder · 03/02/2023 11:21

Well I am really a head Mafia leader and embezzle gold chocolate coins so olympic athletes can try and eat them

Well I want to reply with this anyway

I don't get it I just think people need something to moan about

Anyotherdude · 03/02/2023 11:21

bobbytorq · 03/02/2023 10:38

I get people wanting to better themselves but the questions tend not to provide that information. If people asked questions about how to earn more money or be more frugal then that would make more sense than ones that elicit answers that simply state "because I can afford it".

I was making the point that this is the sort of question that (irrationally) I was asking myself. Because I was depressed, and not thinking rationally, and worried I would never be able to move on - just trying to show you why someone might ask that kind of question so you could gain an insight and maybe some empathy towards such questions, instead of dismissing them as merely “annoying”…

MrFlibblesEyes · 03/02/2023 11:18

I think sometimes (not always) it's a validation thing. The poster wants all the responses to say 'don't worry, everyone else is just maxing out their credit and can't really afford these things either, they will all get their comeuppance' rather than exploring the actual reasons that some people have things they don't!

Swipe left for the next trending thread