Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That threads starting "how do people afford....house, car, holiday, etc" are annoying

108 replies

bobbytorq · 03/02/2023 09:45

I don't understand the purpose of the above threads. Is it because people really don't know and think there is some magic answer that eludes them? When people post about how they can afford it, they then get accused of lying or bragging. The simple answer is that people who have expensive things usually have enough money to pay for them. I'm lucky to have lots of friends whose income ranges from minimum wage up to seven figures. There is no hierachy/power/status attached to that and it's just a fact that my friend who earn more can spend more.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ThisGirlNever · 05/02/2023 16:05

@strivingtosucceed

I agree with what you've written. I've moved on more than one occasion to find work. I've scrimped and saved, eaten yellow sticker items for years (and had friends turn their noses up at them!). I've studied extremely hard for professional qualifications and have paid to attend training courses, with no guarantee I'd get a job at the end of it all. It's paid off and I'm now a home owner (mortgage) with a fairly well paid job.

Not everybody has the ability to attain the skills required for my job and even less have the inclination to study the subject and dedicate the time to become an expert. That's why it's well paid. But that doesn't mean there aren't other opportunities available. No matter what field you work in, there are opportunities to progress.

I think too many people are happy to 'hope' for a better life, rather than actually making it happen. There is always somebody else to blame as well, rather than asking yourself some tough questions regarding what you could do to improve things.

strivingtosucceed · 04/02/2023 10:31

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 04/02/2023 09:45

Being able to spend time on study and self improvement is a luxury not everyone has though.

You can have the drive to come home from your 11 hour shift and start studying but you have to be able to afford the course fees and you have to be able to set time aside, which you may not be able to if you have other responsibilities.

Plus you need to know what to study to improve your opportunities. Careers advice is woefully poor in this country especially if you are an adult looking to retrain.

Nobody is saying that the Stockbroker hasn't worked hard or made sacrifices to get where they are but there is more to it than that. That's why people get mystified, they think to themselves "I worked hard at school, I went to uni, I got a good job and I put in the hours what am I missing?".

Yes but other people not having the knowledge of how to do things doesn't mean you didn't work hard because you did have the knowledge. It's very easy to make excuses for people but ultimately if a person wants to change something about their life, they have to do something different and they may have to endure less-than-ideal circumstances while they're making those changes.

For example, in my group of 12 friends that are now scattered worldwide only 2 (including me) have bought a house as singles and 2 as a married couple. Some of the others have commented to me about how lucky I am to be able to afford a place while they still rent. Except i've:
-done multiple professional certifications and switched professions to get a better job
-spent my last bit of money relocating to another country for better prospects which then paid off
-bought most clothes & electrics only in sales
-bought a refurbished phone and went sim only PAYG for £10 a month
-bought yellow sticker food for dinner and mystery shopped for most of my lunch meals
-mostly went out using deals & vouchers
-didn't turn on my heating until it got unbearable
-learned to cook using YouTube etc etc

I'm bummed I only just started dating my partner as we could have possibly bought together and future-proofed the house a bit more, but i'm happy I maximised my purchase with the tools I had and would never snidely bitch at my married friends being able to do so.

My friends have a mixture of benefits and disbenefits over me, but ultimately I don't doubt that all of them could have bought property by now if they had made some of the sacrifices that I did. And that same reason is why some will always look to have more than others, the sacrifices they made (along with some luck).🤷🏾‍♀️

Maroon85 · 04/02/2023 10:23

Samanabanana · 03/02/2023 11:15

To be fair, it fascinates me how people afford the things they do. Our household income is vv good, but we drive a Skoda and were just saying yesterday how we are unlikely to be able to afford a second hand electric car any time soon! So although I'd never ask it does make me wonder where people get their money from Grin

I do wonder the opposite, though like you I'd never ask what people are spending all their money on! Our household income isn't vv good by any stretch of the imagination (though it's definitely not awful). Yet yesterday we were discussing whether to buy a brand new electric car, which we certainly could afford.
No inheritance here ever, no secret income - just our regular jobs, we didn't buy our house for a tiny amount and benefit from huge price increases and we have fairly large childcare costs still.

LolaSmiles · 04/02/2023 09:58

They're interesting threads if you find the replies where people share useful information that allowed them to balance their finances to do the thing/have the thing that they value.

It's more annoying when it becomes a weird mix of "obviously it's credit" and "we are the jealousy" / " we work hard for our money so why shouldn't we".

Applesandcarrots · 04/02/2023 09:55

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 04/02/2023 09:45

Being able to spend time on study and self improvement is a luxury not everyone has though.

You can have the drive to come home from your 11 hour shift and start studying but you have to be able to afford the course fees and you have to be able to set time aside, which you may not be able to if you have other responsibilities.

Plus you need to know what to study to improve your opportunities. Careers advice is woefully poor in this country especially if you are an adult looking to retrain.

Nobody is saying that the Stockbroker hasn't worked hard or made sacrifices to get where they are but there is more to it than that. That's why people get mystified, they think to themselves "I worked hard at school, I went to uni, I got a good job and I put in the hours what am I missing?".

Google, student loans (they are not just for uni), bursaries (some cover things like childcare) needs must.
From own experience, UK has actually really good options for adults to retrain or study to go up a level compared to many places.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 04/02/2023 09:45

Applesandcarrots · 03/02/2023 23:59

Well said the "I've worked hard for it" narrative is so toxic. Are we really saying that a carer in a residential care home works less hard than a stockbroker?

I don't think it's exactly toxic.
When people say they worked hard for something it isn't just workimg hard at work. It's also coming home from your 11 hour shift in restaurant, have a shower and then do your access course work or your uni work. I made quite a few people at uni working full time and do umi. It can be any course, language, accountancy, conveyancing, managment etc. Lots of people spend lots of time on doing this. That is working hard.
Even the stocbroker has to spent time learning to make money. After work.

This is not saying people don't work hard at work some do for very little money.
Just when people say "i worked hard to do x" they may not mean just work hard work at work.

Being able to spend time on study and self improvement is a luxury not everyone has though.

You can have the drive to come home from your 11 hour shift and start studying but you have to be able to afford the course fees and you have to be able to set time aside, which you may not be able to if you have other responsibilities.

Plus you need to know what to study to improve your opportunities. Careers advice is woefully poor in this country especially if you are an adult looking to retrain.

Nobody is saying that the Stockbroker hasn't worked hard or made sacrifices to get where they are but there is more to it than that. That's why people get mystified, they think to themselves "I worked hard at school, I went to uni, I got a good job and I put in the hours what am I missing?".

LimeCheesecake · 04/02/2023 09:34

TheEverdelightfulsamantha · 03/02/2023 15:44

in Real life though, I do often wonder how people afford things - like a couple who earn about the same as DH and I based on job titles and industries (guesswork) - have a huge house and pay two lots of school fees - I am intrigued as to how they do that… I assume family money but I can’t ask in real life so reading peoples answers here helps me thinking about different options! I am nosy, and envious , and I think that’s ok…

This is interesting - because job titles can often not give you a clear idea of what people earn - eg I know the IT manager where I work earns between £30-35k (from the advert last year), DH is currently helping with the recruitment for a job based in North East UK for a title IT Manager with a base of £85-100k and other “Roles in IT with Manager in the title” can be over £200k - it really can vary a lot with a similar title once you get away from public sector jobs where a certain title puts you in a set band and changing wage band requires a more fancy job title.

rubberduckiee · 04/02/2023 00:11

Or things like choosing luxury retailers (both small and big ticket items) with lifetime complimentary care and warranties. In contrast he would have to spend a fortune on replacing things over the years.

rubberduckiee · 04/02/2023 00:06

I get the "am I missing something" thing. I grew up wealthier than DH. As fresh grads we both started off earning OK salaries for London but he just didn't know how to maximise money so to speak (investments and dividends, using the right credit cards for big ticket purchases in order to easily and quickly earn enough air miles for luxury long haul flights, etc). He was often bewildered at how I could afford such ultra nice things on the same salary as him (no parental help then).

Applesandcarrots · 04/02/2023 00:01

*met not made😂

Applesandcarrots · 03/02/2023 23:59

Well said the "I've worked hard for it" narrative is so toxic. Are we really saying that a carer in a residential care home works less hard than a stockbroker?

I don't think it's exactly toxic.
When people say they worked hard for something it isn't just workimg hard at work. It's also coming home from your 11 hour shift in restaurant, have a shower and then do your access course work or your uni work. I made quite a few people at uni working full time and do umi. It can be any course, language, accountancy, conveyancing, managment etc. Lots of people spend lots of time on doing this. That is working hard.
Even the stocbroker has to spent time learning to make money. After work.

This is not saying people don't work hard at work some do for very little money.
Just when people say "i worked hard to do x" they may not mean just work hard work at work.

Crumpledstilstkin · 03/02/2023 21:14

I think a lot of them are people who have done everything they've been told to do and still can't afford those things wondering what they've missed. I know I've wondered that when we've worried about money on what seems like it should be a great wage and it seems like all my friends aren't worrying. The answer has been a mix of things - credit, family money, buying even 5 years earlier, better house price rises, fewer kids, better split of wages, family childcare, etc. If I'd had all those things I'd be in a house three times the price and still have more than an extra £1k a month.

Neededanewuserhandle · 03/02/2023 19:25

I like the "how do you afford" threads - obviously there is some bitching and some lying, but it's interesting hearing about other people's lives and spending priorities.

TheChosenTwo · 03/02/2023 18:11

I’ve clicked on a few threads like Those before, they always strike me as the op just wanting to be told that everyone is living on credit.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 03/02/2023 18:02

SweeSakura · 03/02/2023 17:37

Quite right that people clamp down on this. Yes hard work is an element but good fortune (luck) is also an element too. And many people work incredibly hard with little financial reward, for all kinds of reasons.

I've just read an excellent book on how flawed it is to see wealth as a virtue or to think that those without it in any way deserve to be looked down on .

(And I say that as someone who has been successful,.and I can think of so many parts of that that were sheer good fortune - from being born to supportive MC parents, no major traumas in my formative years, no major health issues (till recently), being part of an organisation that has grown when other similar ones have had major restructures, having a supportive boss who worked around me when an abusive ex meant I was homeless with young children. So yes I have worked hard but I don't doubt many people have worked equally hard or harder but just not had the good fortune. )

Well said the "I've worked hard for it" narrative is so toxic.

Are we really saying that a carer in a residential care home works less hard than a stockbroker? If it is all about hard work why can't the carer afford to buy a house? It isn't because she's feckless or lazy or wasteful, it is because no matter how hard she works she is in a poorly paid industry.

We need to examine some of the attitudes that lead to some of the hardest working people in society being paid the least and we need to recognise that there is a huge amount of luck and privilege that separates the haves from the have nots.

It doesn't mean that the stockbroker hasn't worked hard but they have almost certainly had a number of advantages.

Applesandcarrots · 03/02/2023 17:42

Yeah. There is a difference between working hard and working "smart". Aome luck needed.

But I get what pp meant about saying working hard for something being shut down. Making everything about luck diminshes the work and thought someone put into it.
Doesn't mean others don't work hard but often it is all kind of "well it's all about luck isn't it".

SweeSakura · 03/02/2023 17:37

Jimboscott0115 · 03/02/2023 16:53

And hell hath no fury like MN when you dare to say 'i've worked hard for it' whatever the threads about.

Saying you've worked hard for something isn't the same as saying others haven't worked hard but reading comprehension challenges and jealousy can drive posters here to madness.

Quite right that people clamp down on this. Yes hard work is an element but good fortune (luck) is also an element too. And many people work incredibly hard with little financial reward, for all kinds of reasons.

I've just read an excellent book on how flawed it is to see wealth as a virtue or to think that those without it in any way deserve to be looked down on .

(And I say that as someone who has been successful,.and I can think of so many parts of that that were sheer good fortune - from being born to supportive MC parents, no major traumas in my formative years, no major health issues (till recently), being part of an organisation that has grown when other similar ones have had major restructures, having a supportive boss who worked around me when an abusive ex meant I was homeless with young children. So yes I have worked hard but I don't doubt many people have worked equally hard or harder but just not had the good fortune. )

Lampzade · 03/02/2023 16:56

It is bloody envy and jealousy.

Jimboscott0115 · 03/02/2023 16:53

And hell hath no fury like MN when you dare to say 'i've worked hard for it' whatever the threads about.

Saying you've worked hard for something isn't the same as saying others haven't worked hard but reading comprehension challenges and jealousy can drive posters here to madness.

Lampzade · 03/02/2023 16:52

MrFlibblesEyes · 03/02/2023 11:18

I think sometimes (not always) it's a validation thing. The poster wants all the responses to say 'don't worry, everyone else is just maxing out their credit and can't really afford these things either, they will all get their comeuppance' rather than exploring the actual reasons that some people have things they don't!

Exactly
When some posters try to explain the reasons they are in fortunate positions they are accused of bragging .

DeeCeeCherry · 03/02/2023 16:38

It's stupid. We don't all live or work in the same way. All this curtain twitching envy is a brain drain, surely.

Both myself and DP have new cars, paid off for them. But I'm in my 50s, worked for years. DP earns well. DCs grown up. Less outgoings, don't need anymore "stuff" in the house. We have savings. I don't have a credit card and I'm not a spendthrift (used to be tho!). I had a small inheritance, enough to buy the car. So of course we can now afford some things that we obviously couldn't so much before.

If a neighbour gets a new car I may think "nice car" but it wouldn't even occur to me to wonder how they afforded it. Who cares? People should focus on improving their own lives if they're that bothered, instead of grieving because someone else has "more stuff". Nosey effers.

safeplanet · 03/02/2023 16:30

I'm in London, some of the family wealth is insane.

workinmums · 03/02/2023 16:27

safeplanet · 03/02/2023 16:08

It's true in my case I everyone I know 🤷🏻‍♀️

Interesting. My parents didn’t have 2 pennies to rub together, they still don’t 😂

It would have been nice to get an inheritance but oh well! We saved for 2 years for our mortgage deposit.

We can afford holidays etc because we both have a 9-5 with a decent salary and have been working our way up over the years. We have savings because we don’t spend everything. Nothing more to it.

SleepingStandingUp · 03/02/2023 16:23

Sometimes it's a lack of lateral thinking. Sometimes it's a dig about how shit working class people are with money and it'll digress into how MC people endure without to save up but WC just bung it on credit because they'll too low class to wait.

the80sweregreat · 03/02/2023 16:21

Back in the late 80s we had a gift of a 1000 towards a house. We were lucky , but not as lucky as friends who were given 80k and their house is worth nearly 500k now.
We definitely had it harder and we had some help. The others we knew had it slightly easier
That's the breaks. Of course there are people much better off than us and some who would love to own home and renting ( as my son is and that rent will go up again this year too)
The gap is much wider now though , at least working class children like Dh and I had a chance of modest home ownership. It's much harder now. 1000 towards a deposit is a drop in the ocean these days. You need a lot more.