Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be concerned about the balloon discovered hovering over Montana

262 replies

MeetPi · 03/02/2023 05:57

The balloon is said to be a Chinese spy balloon up to three football fields long. In the last few minutes, another balloon has possibly been spotted over Canada - where the first balloon apparently came through to the US.

Purportedly President Biden wanted to shoot the balloon down, but the Pentagon convinced him otherwise, as this could prove a risk to people on the ground.

www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/feb/02/pentagon-chinese-spy-balloon

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
MissConductUS · 03/02/2023 14:02

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

MissConductUS · 03/02/2023 13:52

unsureatthispoint · 03/02/2023 13:21

Can't they 'haul' it back down?

Who is they? The Chinese could probably get it to descend by releasing some gas from the balloon. I can't imagine a way the US could haul it down. Shoot it down, certainly.

unsureatthispoint · 03/02/2023 13:21

Can't they 'haul' it back down?

unsureatthispoint · 03/02/2023 13:20

It looks like one of those giant panda flying things

GasPanic · 03/02/2023 13:16

DogInATent · 03/02/2023 12:50

But my guess is there are two issues, one is whether they have something to go high up enough to shoot it down.
Altitude isn't a problem. The US has anti-satellite weapons they can launch from planes.

They know it's Chinese from the track it's taking. It's followed the major air streams across the Pacific. The Japanese made use of the same predictable winds to launch incendiary bomb balloons against the US.

Well without wanting to get too technical, hitting a satellite is a completely different task than hitting a static target.

Balloons like this are probably fairly low in altitude maybe 10s of km and moving fairly slowly, less than 100 kph. Satellites are higher up, maybe 100s of km and moving very quickly, maybe 17,000 kph. It's a completely different trajectory and launch pattern and rocket requirements. For example to hit a satellite you probably have to launch the missile miles before the target actually passes you, so it catches up with it to destroy it. An anti satellite missile may not even arm itself until it is 50km above the earths surface.

This thing could be sitting in a dead zone probably above surface to air/air to air missile range, but well below satellite range. If it is say at around 100,000 to 200,000 ft it could be really difficult to take down. Plus my guess is the Americans want it in as many bits as possible.

So in short, maybe they can shoot it down. Or maybe they can't. I'm pretty sure that if they couldn't they would not want to advertise it.

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 03/02/2023 13:01

StressedToTheMaxxx · 03/02/2023 09:03

The photos are a little disappointing, I was expecting to see a balloon like from the film 'Up'. How boring.

That was lots and lots of balloons though.

Maybe they could attach lots and lots of balloons to this balloon, so that it floats off into space?

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 03/02/2023 12:55

I am now rethinking my picture of the sophistication of Chinese spy technology. Balloon-spying seems very 19C 😁

DogInATent · 03/02/2023 12:50

But my guess is there are two issues, one is whether they have something to go high up enough to shoot it down.
Altitude isn't a problem. The US has anti-satellite weapons they can launch from planes.

They know it's Chinese from the track it's taking. It's followed the major air streams across the Pacific. The Japanese made use of the same predictable winds to launch incendiary bomb balloons against the US.

notimagain · 03/02/2023 12:10

Dotjones · 03/02/2023 10:57

I'm not sure whether they have grounds to shoot it down. It's a debated point as to the altitude where national airspace ends. Satellites for instance are clearly not treated as invading national airspace. This balloon is higher than aircraft usually fly. If the US shot down something above its airspace that could be seen as an aggressive act in the same way one country destroying another's satellite could be.

Of course decades back there was talk (Eisenhower?) of some sort of open skies agreement whereby intelligence gathering aircraft would be allowed to overfly other nations without being engaged...satellites made that idea a bit irellevant..

Then of course there was the boot on the foot with the Powers U-2 (attempt to overfly Soviet Russia)....and over the years as others have said this sort of intelligence gathering has gone on, modes various, on an almost daily basis..so whilst this has gone mainstream in terms of Press coverage it's certainly not something to catastrophise about - which some seem to.

@GasPanic

But my guess is there are two issues, one is whether they have something to go high up enough to shoot it down.

"They", as in the US, will most definitely have Surface to Air Missile and Air to Air Missiles that can go up that high - the States has even demonstrated an anti-satellite capability...Debris might be more of an issue.

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 03/02/2023 12:05

Are they sure it is Chinese? I thought they used lanterns? 🤔

MeetPi · 03/02/2023 11:33

I'd like to point out that we only know what the US and Canadian governments have told us. For example, we don't know how the balloon was identified as Chinese in the first instance.

Separating truth from propaganda is difficult. I try to cross-check from a number of sources, but with something like this you can only do so much.

OP posts:
Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 03/02/2023 11:24

Well men, really. I bet there were precisely no Chinese women involved in the development and deployment of this balloon.

Well that is probably not true but bearing in mind that there has never been a female member of the Standing Committee in China I think it's pretty safe to say that the decision to send the balloon was probably made by men.

MeetPi · 03/02/2023 11:22

@DogInATent

And supposedly it's the balloon that's got you concerned, and the balloon that you'd like us all to become worried about.

It's the sum amount of military activity of China globally over the past few years that has me concerned - not just this incident. I'm not sure why you're determined to downplay that.

OP posts:
unsureatthispoint · 03/02/2023 11:15

Badger1970 · 03/02/2023 11:10

I'd be a bit worried if that was floating around near my house, just in case it came down.

The Alexa comment made me chuckle.... DH kept calling her Alexis and she wasn't impressed. The two of them bickering meant that Alexis was soon consigned to the spare bedroom.

😂

Badger1970 · 03/02/2023 11:10

I'd be a bit worried if that was floating around near my house, just in case it came down.

The Alexa comment made me chuckle.... DH kept calling her Alexis and she wasn't impressed. The two of them bickering meant that Alexis was soon consigned to the spare bedroom.

Ryder68 · 03/02/2023 11:07

Just heard on the radio that China is 'looking into the balloon sighting reports' 🤔

NotAnotherBathBomb · 03/02/2023 11:05

Switchwitch · 03/02/2023 06:01

I'm amazed they can have a balloon that tracks people and spies on nuclear sites but my Amazon Alexa tries to play me house music rather than time my pasta on the hob.

😭

GasPanic · 03/02/2023 11:00

unsureatthispoint · 03/02/2023 10:33

Why don't they just clear the area and bring it down? They would do it with a plane. It can't be that difficult, surely

It's probably very high up, so it would be a massive area.

But my guess is there are two issues, one is whether they have something to go high up enough to shoot it down.

The other is if they do shoot it down, debris will be scattered over a wide area. Not so bad if it is bits of balloon. Very bad if it is powered by nuclear RTGs.

Dotjones · 03/02/2023 10:57

I'm not sure whether they have grounds to shoot it down. It's a debated point as to the altitude where national airspace ends. Satellites for instance are clearly not treated as invading national airspace. This balloon is higher than aircraft usually fly. If the US shot down something above its airspace that could be seen as an aggressive act in the same way one country destroying another's satellite could be.

MeinKraft · 03/02/2023 10:52

I thought spies were supposed to be subtle. Nothing subtle about that balloon! Imagine if your house was under it Shock

Igotjelly · 03/02/2023 10:49

unsureatthispoint · 03/02/2023 10:46

Really? We have to tolerate stuff on our airspace because of fear of 'geopolitical ramifications'? How about if we sent a bunch of baloons their way? I bet that would go down well. Our leaders are beyond wet

Well considering that 'geopolitical ramifications' can vary from another country being a bit pissed off, to China actively supporting Russia in its war against Ukraine (which could change the course of the war), to China undertaking military activity against the US, then yes I think sometimes its better to suck it up. I'm sure those informing the President are able to risk assess better than any of us....

FloydPepper · 03/02/2023 10:48

RichardsGear · 03/02/2023 07:13

Well men, really. I bet there were precisely no Chinese women involved in the development and deployment of this balloon.

And todays award for “randomly blame a man for no reason” goes to…

unsureatthispoint · 03/02/2023 10:47

I bet they wouldn't have sent happy baloons if Trump was in power (whatever you might think of him)

unsureatthispoint · 03/02/2023 10:46

Igotjelly · 03/02/2023 10:42

Because at present they have clearly assessed that the geopolitical ramifications (as well as any physical risk) of such a move outweighs the risks associated with whatever information its collecting/message its designed to send.

I would be extremely surprised if there isn't significant sensitive diplomatic activity with Beijing at this very moment.

Really? We have to tolerate stuff on our airspace because of fear of 'geopolitical ramifications'? How about if we sent a bunch of baloons their way? I bet that would go down well. Our leaders are beyond wet

Igotjelly · 03/02/2023 10:42

unsureatthispoint · 03/02/2023 10:33

Why don't they just clear the area and bring it down? They would do it with a plane. It can't be that difficult, surely

Because at present they have clearly assessed that the geopolitical ramifications (as well as any physical risk) of such a move outweighs the risks associated with whatever information its collecting/message its designed to send.

I would be extremely surprised if there isn't significant sensitive diplomatic activity with Beijing at this very moment.