Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be concerned about the balloon discovered hovering over Montana

262 replies

MeetPi · 03/02/2023 05:57

The balloon is said to be a Chinese spy balloon up to three football fields long. In the last few minutes, another balloon has possibly been spotted over Canada - where the first balloon apparently came through to the US.

Purportedly President Biden wanted to shoot the balloon down, but the Pentagon convinced him otherwise, as this could prove a risk to people on the ground.

www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/feb/02/pentagon-chinese-spy-balloon

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
MeetPi · 04/02/2023 00:30

Another image - this one is a close-up, enhanced shot of the balloon clearly showing the instrumentation underneath. This part is extremely large in itself and likely one of reasons the US doesn't want to bring it down.
(Image credit .@Stormchaser_ts)

To be concerned about the balloon discovered hovering over Montana
OP posts:
Oakbeam · 04/02/2023 00:29

What idiots! And where are they going to send it after. Into the sea to float around 3 football pitches wide. Ridiculous idea.

It isn’t that big and I dare say that they will be eager to recover it.

Orangepolentacake · 04/02/2023 00:26

BroadwayMalady · 03/02/2023 08:01

I read this initially as a balloon hovering over Madonna!

Who are we, the ones that read Madonna instead of Montana?! What is this phenomenon??

Orangepolentacake · 04/02/2023 00:23

Allthelego · 03/02/2023 06:38

Clicked before I read the title properly. Was sad it’s not hovering over Madonna.

Omg same, read Madonna, how weird

MissConductUS · 04/02/2023 00:21

MeetPi · 03/02/2023 23:57

@UdoU

What has that got to do with the US?

(Re: China's activities in the South China Sea.)
This feeds into the entire geopolitical picture, as I explained earlier. Perhaps google it. The US is involved in defence of the area, too.

The US recently announced an agreement with the Philippines government to access military bases there, which provides proximity to Taiwan. Sending the balloon to the US is thought to be a gesture from the Chinese to show that they are properly pissed off about it.

MeetPi · 04/02/2023 00:20

It's now over Missouri. The image below shows where it roughly is, and the blue line is the track of a USAF aircraft circling it.

To be concerned about the balloon discovered hovering over Montana
OP posts:
LemonSwan · 04/02/2023 00:06

You can tell I am in a bad mood today. I just despair! What is the point of this and what a waste of material/ plastic/ resources. So much for global warming, and poverty.

LemonSwan · 04/02/2023 00:04

What idiots! And where are they going to send it after. Into the sea to float around 3 football pitches wide. Ridiculous idea.

MeetPi · 03/02/2023 23:57

@UdoU

What has that got to do with the US?

(Re: China's activities in the South China Sea.)
This feeds into the entire geopolitical picture, as I explained earlier. Perhaps google it. The US is involved in defence of the area, too.

OP posts:
itsgettingweird · 03/02/2023 16:29

Switchwitch · 03/02/2023 06:01

I'm amazed they can have a balloon that tracks people and spies on nuclear sites but my Amazon Alexa tries to play me house music rather than time my pasta on the hob.

Grin
jcyclops · 03/02/2023 16:28

Has it got "Virgin" written on the side? Has anyone seen Beardie?

By the way, it's not the balloon itself that would cause a problem if it is shot down, but the payload which could be around a tonne, and the debris from the missile used.

MrsCarson · 03/02/2023 16:18

greenspaces4peace · 03/02/2023 15:35

from what I read it’s huge, 3 USA size football fields. If it was brought down, birds wildlife trees homes people houses so so much potential damage. The weight of it must be significant.

It's Montana, it might hit a cow or an Antelope.

LittleRedYarny · 03/02/2023 16:17

I think you’re right… but that is only because he’d be willingly handing over everything they asked for and more.

DogInATent · 03/02/2023 15:57

greenspaces4peace · 03/02/2023 15:35

from what I read it’s huge, 3 USA size football fields. If it was brought down, birds wildlife trees homes people houses so so much potential damage. The weight of it must be significant.

Not really. I've had to look this up.. the balloon for the Baumgartner high altitude jump was much larger (40 acres of fabric, or 30 US football pitches worth) but the capsule weight was limited to less than 1,400kg.

Helium/hydrogen doesn't have a huge amount of lift potential, and at high altitude it needs a very big balloon to allow it to expand at the low atmospheric pressures. It's not like a toy rubber balloon, it's more like inflating a rubbish sack.

If it came down it might smother someone, but it's not going to crush them.

Ponderingwindow · 03/02/2023 15:49

I’m not going to get worked up about potential spying or surveillance. That is happening constantly.

I will be much more concerned if it turns out the primary goal isn’t information gathering.

MissConductUS · 03/02/2023 15:46

There will be some SAMs and/or fighter/AIM combinations in the US inventory that could reach it...

I agree. The AIM-120 has a maximum range of 75km. That's assuming favorable launch geometry.

www.military-today.com/missiles/aim120_amraam.htm

The F-16 has a ceiling of 50,000 feet. The AIM-120 fired on a near-verticle path should easily reach 120k feet from there.

greenspaces4peace · 03/02/2023 15:35

from what I read it’s huge, 3 USA size football fields. If it was brought down, birds wildlife trees homes people houses so so much potential damage. The weight of it must be significant.

notimagain · 03/02/2023 15:31

GasPanic · 03/02/2023 13:16

Well without wanting to get too technical, hitting a satellite is a completely different task than hitting a static target.

Balloons like this are probably fairly low in altitude maybe 10s of km and moving fairly slowly, less than 100 kph. Satellites are higher up, maybe 100s of km and moving very quickly, maybe 17,000 kph. It's a completely different trajectory and launch pattern and rocket requirements. For example to hit a satellite you probably have to launch the missile miles before the target actually passes you, so it catches up with it to destroy it. An anti satellite missile may not even arm itself until it is 50km above the earths surface.

This thing could be sitting in a dead zone probably above surface to air/air to air missile range, but well below satellite range. If it is say at around 100,000 to 200,000 ft it could be really difficult to take down. Plus my guess is the Americans want it in as many bits as possible.

So in short, maybe they can shoot it down. Or maybe they can't. I'm pretty sure that if they couldn't they would not want to advertise it.

@GasPanic

I don't want to get too technical either but I'm not buying that this balloon is sat in some magic dead zone..certainly not even it's at around 100k feet (which, plus or minus maybe 20k or so is about as high the best balloons carrying any decent payload have historically to reach).

A tough target compared with some objects I agree but on the plus side not hidden away in ground returns, and pretty much static so not many dynamic demands any missile post launch when up in the thin air.

There will be some SAMs and/or fighter/AIM combinations in the US inventory that could reach it...

DogInATent · 03/02/2023 14:52

GasPanic · 03/02/2023 13:16

Well without wanting to get too technical, hitting a satellite is a completely different task than hitting a static target.

Balloons like this are probably fairly low in altitude maybe 10s of km and moving fairly slowly, less than 100 kph. Satellites are higher up, maybe 100s of km and moving very quickly, maybe 17,000 kph. It's a completely different trajectory and launch pattern and rocket requirements. For example to hit a satellite you probably have to launch the missile miles before the target actually passes you, so it catches up with it to destroy it. An anti satellite missile may not even arm itself until it is 50km above the earths surface.

This thing could be sitting in a dead zone probably above surface to air/air to air missile range, but well below satellite range. If it is say at around 100,000 to 200,000 ft it could be really difficult to take down. Plus my guess is the Americans want it in as many bits as possible.

So in short, maybe they can shoot it down. Or maybe they can't. I'm pretty sure that if they couldn't they would not want to advertise it.

It was purely a demonstration that altitude isn't a problem.

Low radar cross-section and the somewhat flimsy construction of a balloon probably is. The gas envelope would have to be comprehensively shredded to bring it down quickly. A 'wounded' balloon slowly shedding gas could take hours to descend.

Sirius3030 · 03/02/2023 14:44

unsureatthispoint · 03/02/2023 10:46

Really? We have to tolerate stuff on our airspace because of fear of 'geopolitical ramifications'? How about if we sent a bunch of baloons their way? I bet that would go down well. Our leaders are beyond wet

Yay! Let’s start the balloon war! What’s the worst that could happen after all!?

DontbesuchanarseGlenda · 03/02/2023 14:42

@NeverDropYourMooncup
omg, they’re here to read us their poetry 😮

UdoU · 03/02/2023 14:34

MeetPi · 03/02/2023 08:45

Perhaps look up what China has been building in the South China Sea.

What has that got to do with the US?

Are you even in the US?!

MissConductUS · 03/02/2023 14:29

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Apologies, I've posted this on the wrong thread and asked MNHQ to remove it.

notimagain · 03/02/2023 14:28

EasterIssland · 03/02/2023 14:16

From bbc
China's foreign ministry said it was used for "mainly meteorological" purposes.
China "regrets the unintended entry" of the balloon into US airspace, it added.

Ah the old met research flight excuse......0/10 for originality.

When Powers got shot down that was the US cover story for a few days..

EasterIssland · 03/02/2023 14:16

From bbc
China's foreign ministry said it was used for "mainly meteorological" purposes.
China "regrets the unintended entry" of the balloon into US airspace, it added.

Swipe left for the next trending thread