Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be concerned about the balloon discovered hovering over Montana

262 replies

MeetPi · 03/02/2023 05:57

The balloon is said to be a Chinese spy balloon up to three football fields long. In the last few minutes, another balloon has possibly been spotted over Canada - where the first balloon apparently came through to the US.

Purportedly President Biden wanted to shoot the balloon down, but the Pentagon convinced him otherwise, as this could prove a risk to people on the ground.

www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/feb/02/pentagon-chinese-spy-balloon

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
notimagain · 04/02/2023 19:19

DogInATent · 04/02/2023 19:17

More likely the case that it's movements can't be predicted, and it's not obeying air traffic rules.

Quite possibly, meanwhile..from a few hours ago..

twitter.com/YCSO_SC/status/1621903240219475969?cxt=HHwWgoCy1euZlIItAAAA

DogInATent · 04/02/2023 19:17

notimagain · 04/02/2023 19:12

According to some MSM reports the FAA have just issued a ground stop (halt on departures/arrivals) for some airports in the Carolinas and also closed some airspace offshore.

Something up? Or coming down….?

More likely the case that it's movements can't be predicted, and it's not obeying air traffic rules.

notimagain · 04/02/2023 19:12

According to some MSM reports the FAA have just issued a ground stop (halt on departures/arrivals) for some airports in the Carolinas and also closed some airspace offshore.

Something up? Or coming down….?

Oakbeam · 04/02/2023 19:07

It's not a pressurised balloon like an inflated condom

I think cakeorwine’s post was tongue in cheek!

DogInATent · 04/02/2023 19:06

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 04/02/2023 18:04

@Oakbeam
'I looked into and they are really difficult to shoot down because anything that fire at them goes right through without exploding'

But surely once it has been punctured it would 'raspberry' across the sky in a hectic, unpredictable path, getting smaller until such time it falls to earth, perhaps somewhere in the Artic, where it will just lie like a massive discarded condom?

It's not a pressurised balloon like an inflated condom. It won't 'raspberry' across the sky. The difference in pressure between inside the balloon and outside the balloon is very, very small.

greenspaces4peace · 04/02/2023 18:50

second balloon now spotted over south america :)
i would guess there are more than two.

Oakbeam · 04/02/2023 18:49

At what height would it become 'fair game'?

The Russians shot down an American spy plane at reputedly 80,000 feet, so at least that.

cakeorwine · 04/02/2023 18:41

Catinabeanbag · 04/02/2023 16:22

I don't see what a 'spy balloon' could see that can't be seen from satellite, to be honest. Every country spies on everyone else anyway. I know Montana has some air force bases which house nuclear weapons,but you can have a good nosey at those on google earth. I'd wager that's not top-notch technology and what what governments can see / already know is far more sophisticated than that.

At what height would it become 'fair game'?

Satellites spy all the time. At some point, countries have to say that the vertical height above a country is not theirs.

Oakbeam · 04/02/2023 18:38

But surely once it has been punctured it would 'raspberry' across the sky

If only! It would certainly make my day. 😁

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 04/02/2023 18:04

@Oakbeam
'I looked into and they are really difficult to shoot down because anything that fire at them goes right through without exploding'

But surely once it has been punctured it would 'raspberry' across the sky in a hectic, unpredictable path, getting smaller until such time it falls to earth, perhaps somewhere in the Artic, where it will just lie like a massive discarded condom?

PUGMEISTER21 · 04/02/2023 17:36

It's not the size of three football pitches it's 120ft, three buses.

Catspyjamas17 · 04/02/2023 16:26

A spy balloon sounds likee something out of Despicable Me, or Austin Powers.

Catinabeanbag · 04/02/2023 16:22

I don't see what a 'spy balloon' could see that can't be seen from satellite, to be honest. Every country spies on everyone else anyway. I know Montana has some air force bases which house nuclear weapons,but you can have a good nosey at those on google earth. I'd wager that's not top-notch technology and what what governments can see / already know is far more sophisticated than that.

MissConductUS · 04/02/2023 16:08

the envelope might be problematic but from images in the public domain this thing appears has a fairly substantial payload package that a missile certainly wouldn’t just fly through.

Agreed. The most recent photo shown earlier in the thread a large set of solar panels under the balloon. Those would be fine radar reflectors. The AIM-120 uses a radar proximity fuze and has a 23kg blast fragmentation warhead. The balloon would be a sitting duck for an attack.

I do think that the US may just ignore it, at least until it drifts out over the Atlantic.

notimagain · 04/02/2023 15:39

@Oakbeam

I looked into and they are really difficult to shoot down because anything that fire at them goes right through without exploding

That would depend on how any missile is fused, the warhead and where it hits…the envelope might be problematic but from images in the public domain this thing appears has a fairly substantial payload package that a missile certainly wouldn’t just fly through.

One issue might be that the very act of trying to shoot this thing down might give the Chinese lots of useful intelligence, so the best course of action for the US might be shutdown anything sensitive (comms, military/industry testing etc) in the balloon’s vicinity and let the thing (eventually) go on it’s way

MistressoftheDarkSide · 04/02/2023 15:30

@Oakbeam

High five - very true ☺️

Oakbeam · 04/02/2023 15:29

Into it

Oakbeam · 04/02/2023 15:29

I read a report saying it was observed at 60,000ft. If that's the case then I reckon they could shoot it down

I looked into and they are really difficult to shoot down because anything that fire at them goes right through without exploding. The Canadians tried and failed with a weather balloon that had gone rogue. It ended up blowing into Russian airspace.

Oakbeam · 04/02/2023 15:25

Who knows. But it's curiosity that keeps us alive (unless you identify as a cat, obviously.....)

Even then, knowing brings them back.

feellikeanalien · 04/02/2023 15:04

I suppose no-one would notice if it flew over the UK because it's always so grey here.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 04/02/2023 14:52

I find it rather surreal that in this hi-tech age they're using a balloon....

And now I have an urge to listen to 99 Red balloons....

I mean, obviously it's outside of the sphere of our control, and may be the subject of over-inflated interest as we rubber neck from down here.....

A lot of hot air? Something sinister?

Who knows. But it's curiosity that keeps us alive (unless you identify as a cat, obviously.....)

HeavenIsAHalfpipe · 04/02/2023 13:19

Can't say I have lost any sleep over it tbh. Confused

GasPanic · 04/02/2023 13:16

The idea that they don't want to shoot it down because it may have come down over the highly populated areas of Montana and Alaska is clearly nonsense to me.

Either they a) can't shoot it down or b) want it intact.

I read a report saying it was observed at 60,000ft. If that's the case then I reckon they could shoot it down and probably up to about 80,000ft. Above 100,000ft I reckon they would have issues.

Ladyofthesea · 04/02/2023 13:16

No concern necessary. Every country is spying on everyone else. And they all know it. Totally normal.

Florenz · 04/02/2023 13:10

Apparently Tom Cruise went up there in his fighter jet and shot it down.