Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be concerned about the balloon discovered hovering over Montana

262 replies

MeetPi · 03/02/2023 05:57

The balloon is said to be a Chinese spy balloon up to three football fields long. In the last few minutes, another balloon has possibly been spotted over Canada - where the first balloon apparently came through to the US.

Purportedly President Biden wanted to shoot the balloon down, but the Pentagon convinced him otherwise, as this could prove a risk to people on the ground.

www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/feb/02/pentagon-chinese-spy-balloon

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
MistressoftheDarkSide · 04/02/2023 23:19

Just been poking around a well known conspiracy site.... there are three threads on this buzzing away with Stateside observers postulating all sorts.....

From how many balloons there are to whether it was potentially carrying some sort of payload.....

I remain open minded but still intrigued..... got nowt else to do tonight so will be keeping an eye on it - it's kind of Schroedingers diplomatic incident as far as I can tell - it both is and is not important.....

May we all live in strange and interesting times eh?

AnnieSnap · 04/02/2023 23:14

They say they will recover important equipment that will provide lots of data @SamanthaCaine Let’s hope that’s the case. The world is crazy isn’t it?

AnnieSnap · 04/02/2023 23:12

notimagain · 04/02/2023 22:58

Yep, agree it does...

With the one exception of geostationary orbits (for which you need to be out at about 35,000 km from the Earth, so of limited use for most types of surveillance ) satellites can't loiter at all...they go blatting around the Earth at about 8 kilometres a second so they can only get a very quick close'ish look at an area of interest with maybe one pass a day.

If you want more extended periods of surveillance and perhaps a closer look/listen than a satellite can provide then aircraft and to a limited extent balloons can still prove useful but are more vulnerable.

But an aircraft can only circle. The balloon is more effective when staying put is required and it can hover at 60,000 feet (an aircraft can’t go higher than 50,000), making it more difficult to spot and shoot down (in theory).

SamanthaCaine · 04/02/2023 23:07

AnnieSnap · 04/02/2023 22:45

@SamanthaCaine yes. My point still stands

Not arguing the point, just that satellites don't all pass by quickly.

But obviously depends on what the application is.

The sceptical west will naturally suspect surveillance but we're unlikely to ever know the truth, given the wreckage has been squirrelled off.

MissConductUS · 04/02/2023 22:58

AnnieSnap · 04/02/2023 22:45

@SamanthaCaine yes. My point still stands

It does. A geosynchronous orbit puts the sensors very far from the target.

The WSJ has video of the shoot down. You can hear the warhead go off about 9 seconds in. This should be in front of the pay wall.

www.wsj.com/video/video-us-shoots-down-suspected-chinese-spy-balloon/6CD3B1DB-17B3-45D7-9D9E-3A27F850A3FB.html

notimagain · 04/02/2023 22:58

AnnieSnap · 04/02/2023 22:45

@SamanthaCaine yes. My point still stands

Yep, agree it does...

With the one exception of geostationary orbits (for which you need to be out at about 35,000 km from the Earth, so of limited use for most types of surveillance ) satellites can't loiter at all...they go blatting around the Earth at about 8 kilometres a second so they can only get a very quick close'ish look at an area of interest with maybe one pass a day.

If you want more extended periods of surveillance and perhaps a closer look/listen than a satellite can provide then aircraft and to a limited extent balloons can still prove useful but are more vulnerable.

AnnieSnap · 04/02/2023 22:45

@SamanthaCaine yes. My point still stands

SamanthaCaine · 04/02/2023 22:31

AnnieSnap · 04/02/2023 22:23

Satellites are over over one location for moments. The Balloon can hover for long periods. It’s better than anything else at collecting information from a particular area.

There are different types of orbit.

FYI

www.esa.int/Enabling_Support/Space_Transportation/Types_of_orbits

AnnieSnap · 04/02/2023 22:23

Augend23 · 03/02/2023 06:10

I guess I don't really know what the balloon will do that a satellite can't? It sounded from that article like they weren't really sure if that either?

Satellites are over over one location for moments. The Balloon can hover for long periods. It’s better than anything else at collecting information from a particular area.

milkyaqua · 04/02/2023 22:16

Johnduttonsbuttocks · 04/02/2023 22:11

Have you got a smart phone? Cookies on your laptop? You are already being spied on.

Are you a country?

Elprincesso · 04/02/2023 22:15

Ha! It's not April Fools Day is it? Surely with all the crap electronic stuff China produces they can produce something a wee bit more discreet to spy with then a frigging gigantic balloon?? 🤔 For once I think I actually do believe them when they say "calm down, calm down, its just a weather ship blown off course". Seriously though, when I read the headlines about it being a 'spy balloon' I just instantly imagined Austin Powers in a hot air balloon - no idea why!! 🤣

Johnduttonsbuttocks · 04/02/2023 22:11

Have you got a smart phone? Cookies on your laptop? You are already being spied on.

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 04/02/2023 22:06

@DogInATent
'It's not a pressurised balloon like an inflated condom. It won't 'raspberry' across the sky. The difference in pressure between inside the balloon and outside the balloon is very, very small.'

That's good to know, so it must be one of those new-fangled 'lighter-than-air' machines that we keep reading about in the newspaper. At least when they leak the helium, being so light, it leaves the earth's gravitational field so that we won't all start sounding like Mickey Mouse when we talk. 🐭 Phew.

AdventFridgeOfShame · 04/02/2023 21:44

Shauny098 · 04/02/2023 21:05

I say this with love….

STOP WATCHING THE NEWS!!!!!!

I say this with love...

ignorance is not bliss

Watch the news, watch the Indian news, watch some African news, watch some East Asian news, watch the news, all of it. Inform your self, smelling salts are not essential.

milkyaqua · 04/02/2023 21:40

*bank of sensors

milkyaqua · 04/02/2023 21:39

GasPanic · 04/02/2023 13:16

The idea that they don't want to shoot it down because it may have come down over the highly populated areas of Montana and Alaska is clearly nonsense to me.

Either they a) can't shoot it down or b) want it intact.

I read a report saying it was observed at 60,000ft. If that's the case then I reckon they could shoot it down and probably up to about 80,000ft. Above 100,000ft I reckon they would have issues.

Well, it has been shot down now, they say, but over the Atlantic. The balloon is estimated to be the size of three US school buses, but its ban of sensors estimated to be the size of two US school buses, which would not land softly on anyone or anything. Hard to control where a balloon and its hardware land, when shooting it down from high altitude.

The US military opted not to shoot down the balloon because of the safety risks to people on the ground given the size of the payload and potential for debris, officials said.

Shauny098 · 04/02/2023 21:05

MeetPi · 03/02/2023 05:57

The balloon is said to be a Chinese spy balloon up to three football fields long. In the last few minutes, another balloon has possibly been spotted over Canada - where the first balloon apparently came through to the US.

Purportedly President Biden wanted to shoot the balloon down, but the Pentagon convinced him otherwise, as this could prove a risk to people on the ground.

www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/feb/02/pentagon-chinese-spy-balloon

I say this with love….

STOP WATCHING THE NEWS!!!!!!

Pupinski · 04/02/2023 20:44

Switchwitch · 03/02/2023 06:01

I'm amazed they can have a balloon that tracks people and spies on nuclear sites but my Amazon Alexa tries to play me house music rather than time my pasta on the hob.

😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣

NoLongerYoung · 04/02/2023 20:40

How did they know it was Chinese before China admitted it?

MissConductUS · 04/02/2023 20:38

It would also make it easier to retrieve the wreckage for examination of the payload.

I hope they make the results public.

notimagain · 04/02/2023 20:34

That would make sense, both in terms of reducing the chance of damage on the ground and also in terms of the legal side of airspace “ownership”.

MissConductUS · 04/02/2023 20:20

notimagain · 04/02/2023 19:53

CNN and other sources now saying it’s been brought down (if true wonder if that was done as soon as it coasted out but before it left US Sovereign airspace)

Probably as soon as it was feet wet.

notimagain · 04/02/2023 19:53

CNN and other sources now saying it’s been brought down (if true wonder if that was done as soon as it coasted out but before it left US Sovereign airspace)

Igotjelly · 04/02/2023 19:52

And it’s down, breaking news

MissConductUS · 04/02/2023 19:41

NPR is confirming the FAA ground stop and the balloon's position over the Carolinas.

Regarding the Twitter post by the York County Sherriff, I'm sure he posted that because there have already been small arms fire aimed at it.