Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be concerned about the balloon discovered hovering over Montana

262 replies

MeetPi · 03/02/2023 05:57

The balloon is said to be a Chinese spy balloon up to three football fields long. In the last few minutes, another balloon has possibly been spotted over Canada - where the first balloon apparently came through to the US.

Purportedly President Biden wanted to shoot the balloon down, but the Pentagon convinced him otherwise, as this could prove a risk to people on the ground.

www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/feb/02/pentagon-chinese-spy-balloon

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
MeetPi · 11/02/2023 00:41

Another object has been shot down over Alaska.

This one was smaller - about the size of a car - and supposedly cylindrical rather than balloon-shaped. It's come down over an icy, uninhabited area of Alaska, making retrieval easier.

www.reuters.com/world/us/us-says-it-shot-down-object-over-alaska-size-small-car-2023-02-10/

OP posts:
SamanthaCaine · 05/02/2023 17:46

Biden is considering shooting this one down too.

To be concerned about the balloon discovered hovering over Montana
notimagain · 05/02/2023 17:29

You mean like the hundreds of spy satellites the US have in orbit currently in a synchronous mesospheric geo-orbit over China/Russia?

Say what?

The "Synchronous" bit I get ( various types relevant such as geo synchronous and Sun Synchronous)..other than that Last thing I heard the mesosphere was part of the Earth's mantle...and "geo-orbit?" Orbit around the Earth.....?

maybe the stratospheric flyovers the US Air Force conduct regularly with a fleet that maintains more than 30 U2 spy planes??

Actual overflight over most potentially hostile countries by U-2s stopped being viable in the very early 60s.

MaxFortune · 05/02/2023 17:11

What will you worrying achieve?
None of us normal folk, worldwide, have any influence on events.
The fault is ours, the electorate, permitting unqualified oinks to get jobs that give them wealth and power at our expense.
Who in their right mind thinks a footballer or singer or YouTube influencer should be paid more than the nurse keeping you alive, or the bin man removing your rubbish to reduce pollution and disease?
What skill set have actors, for example, got to run a country like USA? None.
Don't worry, we are all going to hell in a hand cart, probably a self-driving one, soon.

InsiderDad · 05/02/2023 13:50

milkyaqua · 05/02/2023 13:29

Mate, you're not following the news are you? It flew over missile sites.

You mean like the hundreds of spy satellites the US have in orbit currently in a synchronous mesospheric geo-orbit over China/Russia?

Or the same satellite systems the Chinese/Russians also have in orbit?

Or maybe the stratospheric flyovers the US Air Force conduct regularly with a fleet that maintains more than 30 U2 spy planes??

Thinking that high altitude level spying doesn't go on between military superpowers all day every day is a little naive.

milkyaqua · 05/02/2023 13:29

InsiderDad · 05/02/2023 10:48

What is it about your life that makes you think you're worth spying on?

Unless the Chinese particularly like spying on deer, trout and mountains.... I wouldn't worry too much about it.

Mate, you're not following the news are you? It flew over missile sites.

InsiderDad · 05/02/2023 10:48

What is it about your life that makes you think you're worth spying on?

Unless the Chinese particularly like spying on deer, trout and mountains.... I wouldn't worry too much about it.

BarrelOfOtters · 05/02/2023 08:49

Elprincesso · 04/02/2023 22:15

Ha! It's not April Fools Day is it? Surely with all the crap electronic stuff China produces they can produce something a wee bit more discreet to spy with then a frigging gigantic balloon?? 🤔 For once I think I actually do believe them when they say "calm down, calm down, its just a weather ship blown off course". Seriously though, when I read the headlines about it being a 'spy balloon' I just instantly imagined Austin Powers in a hot air balloon - no idea why!! 🤣

I’ve been thinking that then read this….twitter.com/thekimulation/status/1544527308282896385?s=61&t=EA3XsIA8UD4LXYz1D767cA

they are really complex….

SamanthaCaine · 05/02/2023 08:41

MissConductUS · 05/02/2023 00:48

They also operate at much lower altitudes. There isn't much weather to study at 80k feet above sea level.

Tell that to the Chinese spokesperson as that's what they're claiming 😂

Ifailed · 05/02/2023 06:54

an aircraft can’t go higher than 50,000

Concorde used to cruise at Mach 2 at 60,000 feet. Military aircraft like he F-22 Raptor can reach 65,000.

MissConductUS · 05/02/2023 00:48

milkyaqua · 05/02/2023 00:10

Allegedly it was a civilian weather balloon, blown off course.

Weather balloons are much smaller.

They also operate at much lower altitudes. There isn't much weather to study at 80k feet above sea level.

ThistleTits · 05/02/2023 00:35

@Augend23
My thoughts exactly. Makes not an iota of sense. All seems very 50s Sci fi to me.

Isittimeformynapyet · 05/02/2023 00:19

ChaToilLeam · 03/02/2023 07:57

They need a very, very long pin.

That's very, very funny 😂

SamanthaCaine · 05/02/2023 00:17

AnnieSnap · 05/02/2023 00:02

They found a second one today though

Honestly I don't know. I'm reading opinions that this might be China embarrassing the west and demonstrating how easy it is to enter airspace.

Either way those more in the know think that balloon tech is limited and can already be achieved far more stealthily by existing spy satellites.

news.sky.com/story/chinese-spy-balloons-the-puzzling-theories-and-why-none-bode-well-for-us-china-relations-12802738

All nations have spy satellites which are known to each other. Every nation also has networks of spies located in other countries all the time. All of this is accepted by each nation as part of life. This kind of thing is odd by its blatant visibility to the public, which suggests it's not what we think it is.

milkyaqua · 05/02/2023 00:10

Allegedly it was a civilian weather balloon, blown off course.

Weather balloons are much smaller.

AnnieSnap · 05/02/2023 00:02

SamanthaCaine · 04/02/2023 23:51

Yes they have but have called for calm as they're saying it's an accident. Allegedly it was a civilian weather balloon, blown off course.

I've genuinely no idea if they're being truthful. It's easy to jump to conclusions but when it comes to spying, they're all as bad as each other.

They found a second one today though

MeetPi · 04/02/2023 23:58

I'm pleased to hear it's been brought down. Hopefully - eventually - we'll hear a bit more about the balloon's function. I don't believe the 'meteorological' spin. I'm aware satellites are so advanced they can read along with the newspaper you are holding, but a balloon - being lower down and more static - may be tracking sound. Just an idea.

OP posts:
MeetPi · 04/02/2023 23:52

@Shauny098

I say this with love….

STOP WATCHING THE NEWS!!!!!!

Thanks for your concern, Shauny. I prefer knowledge over ignorance, though, and am careful to not minimise my news sources to, say, just left-wing outlets. I read from a healthy spectrum.

OP posts:
SamanthaCaine · 04/02/2023 23:51

AnnieSnap · 04/02/2023 23:32

@SamanthaCaine I don’t trust the Americans either. Haven’t China admitted that these balloons are theirs? I heard that was the case.

Yes they have but have called for calm as they're saying it's an accident. Allegedly it was a civilian weather balloon, blown off course.

I've genuinely no idea if they're being truthful. It's easy to jump to conclusions but when it comes to spying, they're all as bad as each other.

MibsXX · 04/02/2023 23:45

Many years ago, after I'd left home and was on way back to visit my parents in Dorset in the early hours of dawn, whilst driving through Wimborne on way to them, there was a glint of light that caught my eye... looked up and there was a large cigar shaped plane thing not too high above where I was...it had very short stubby wings and shone like aluminium might in sunlight. I stopped to watch, It was quite slow. There was a brief mention in a small paragraph near the back pages of the telegraph a few weeks later of Russian aircraft entering and leaving our airspace. Thats all they said. We do this too, sometimes it's military, sometimes it scientists doing ground surveys for earthquakes etc. Am pretty sure all sides know about these flights and probably warn each other in advance... why else does no country actually shoot them down as soon as they enter airspace?

Stardu · 04/02/2023 23:35

So there’s war in Europe, and now the American military have shot down Chinese military equipment. Did not think we’d see this in my lifetime.

Slow handclap for the human race’s approach to tackling climate change and the increase in pandemics floods and fires that is bringing.

Sigh.

AnnieSnap · 04/02/2023 23:32

@SamanthaCaine I don’t trust the Americans either. Haven’t China admitted that these balloons are theirs? I heard that was the case.

Stardu · 04/02/2023 23:31

Pop!

Balloon’s been shot down.

Do I think it was a weather balloon?

No I do not.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 04/02/2023 23:31

Why would you care? Do you live in the US?

SamanthaCaine · 04/02/2023 23:27

AnnieSnap · 04/02/2023 23:14

They say they will recover important equipment that will provide lots of data @SamanthaCaine Let’s hope that’s the case. The world is crazy isn’t it?

Crazy indeed.

It's easy to jump to conclusions given China's reputation but it's obvious that a deliberate spy balloon would heighten already fragile relations.

They (the US) have recovered the equipment and will pick it all apart so any hint of spying should be obvious. I just don't think that's the Chinese's style. They're experts at playing the long game over decades and already have more sophisticated means of acquiring surveillance.

They may well have deliberately sent a civilian balloon to test the water or steer attention away from something else but don't think they're as clumsy as the Americans.

Naturally I don't trust the Americans to report any truth of what they find either!