Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy DS a dress

89 replies

tjg0 · 03/02/2023 00:58

I'm a dad to 3 boys, their mum passed away 5 years ago so I'm bringing them up alone. The youngest is 13, he's always been different to the other boys, more quiet and sensitive, not really interested in the same things as them which I've always been fine with and have encouraged his interests.

Middle son (15) and youngest share a room which I know isn't ideal, this evening I told them to tidy their room which they (finally) did. Whilst tidying middle son found a dress which youngest admitted is his, middle laughed at him and called him names, said he'd tell people at their school etc which I did talk to him about. Youngest then threw the dress in the bin. He said he didn't want to talk about it but later came downstairs and said he does but not yet as he doesn't want his brothers listening so we agreed to talk at the weekend. I told him I'm not angry as he thought I would be, but I am shocked as it is unexpected.

I was thinking of buying him another dress and surprising him with it to show him I'm not angry etc but I'm not sure in case his brothers find out which he is worried about - I personally don't think eldest would care but middle has already shown he does.

WIBU?

OP posts:
pavinganeweoadtowalkon · 03/02/2023 10:18

Male punks wore skirts in the late 70s/early 80s. Granted, they were mostly kilts, but still 'skirts'. The Vivienne Westwood (RIP sweetheart) brand is still making them.

2bazookas · 03/02/2023 10:17

I'd retrieve the dress and wash it. Don't do any more until you've had that talk.

BabyOnBoard90 · 03/02/2023 10:17

I wouldn't, but your life and your child. Up to you, if it'll make him happy

MintyFreshOne · 03/02/2023 10:13

Prescottdanni123 · 03/02/2023 10:08

@MintyFreshOne

I wear men's trousers sometimes. And jumpers/hoodie etc if I like them and they fit ok. So what? The only reason why people think men look ridiculous in dresses is because they have been brainwashed into thinking it is ridiculous for men to wear dresses. This incredibly strict gender stereotyping around clothes/toys/colours etc causes so many problems.

I actually have lived in a country where ‘men wear dresses’ (more countries than you’d think so not outing myself here). But they are not ridiculous looking as they are properly tailored to a man’s straight up and down shape and accentuate the cleaner lines of the male body (so to speak)

Men look awkward in items tailored to a woman’s body as it gapes and pulls at unusual and frankly unflattering points. Skirts are so much easier to work with if you are a man determined to wear female-coded garments.

Prescottdanni123 · 03/02/2023 10:08

@MintyFreshOne

I wear men's trousers sometimes. And jumpers/hoodie etc if I like them and they fit ok. So what? The only reason why people think men look ridiculous in dresses is because they have been brainwashed into thinking it is ridiculous for men to wear dresses. This incredibly strict gender stereotyping around clothes/toys/colours etc causes so many problems.

Prescottdanni123 · 03/02/2023 10:06

@MintyFreshOne

I wear men's trousers some

MintyFreshOne · 03/02/2023 10:05

Any why do you think trousers are now made tailored for women but dresses aren't?

I’m not making a value judgement, just explained why women don’t look ridiculous in trousers but men look ridiculous in dresses. They look ungainly at best.

Skirts are better as they be adjusted with a more appropriate top, and I often see these as part of menswear runway collections, but it never translates to anything ready-to-wear

(this is a bit derailing, apologies to OP)

Because wearing clothes typically worn by men is a way to better yourself as a woman, look cooler, more professional. Along with doing "male" hobbies, subjects or careers

yeh this is true tbh but I also can’t shake my stereotype of a man in a dress being a total pervert. I would keep my distance from any man wearing women’s clothing, rightly or wrongly.

pavinganeweoadtowalkon · 03/02/2023 10:04

You sound like a great dad.

My friend's son used to wear dresses as a child. Dressing up clothes eg Belle and other Disney princesses. He used to try on my 'partying' clothes when he was at mine (his mum didn't thank me for giving him a full sequinned dress as it shed all over her house!) He is gay but never wanted to be a girl - he just the likes glitter and glamour. He hasn't worn dresses for years now (27) but still loves a bit of glitter make up. He's marrying his partner next year and I can't wait to see what he wears! It will definitely be extravagant.

His parents and none of us (his parents friends) never questioned it. He has a twin sister and they just used to dress up the same.

I'm friends with Boy George and he never wanted to be a girl/woman either, again he just wanted to wear what he wanted to wear, sometimes dresses. I've known him since I was 14 and he always wore makeup. He's bloody fantastic at applying it but has a make up artist now obv.

Let him chose a dress himself though. Teenagers don't like clothes being chosen for them!

Hope you manage to talk your middle son around. My friends son also had an older brother and he never questioned it. Boy George has older and younger brothers who never questioned it, nor his parents. His lovely mum made a lot of his stage clothes in the 80s, his brother now makes a lot under the brand B RUDE.

DisplayPurposesOnly · 03/02/2023 09:43

All this focus on a dress. Has no- one heard of skirts?? How about a kilt?

(I'm joking but also serious. Dresses aren't the only 'female' option. A skirt can be worn with his usual t-shirts/jumpers etc. Kilts are traditionally worn by men.)

Good luck with your chat with your son. It'll be interesting to find out his thinking 🙂

anon2022anon · 03/02/2023 09:36

I'd have no problem at all with buying a dress/ fishing his out the bin and giving it a wash. I'd be having a good talking to your middle son. I would also make it clear that wearing a dress does not make him transgender, and that as a boy, he can wear whatever the hell he likes, just like girls can. But he still needs to remember he's male.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 03/02/2023 09:35

Dont buy him one but offer a budget to pay for one that he chooses

I also think you need to be speaking to your middle son about how he treated his brother just for having an item of clothing that's actually common for men to have in other cultures...even if it wasnt though he needs to realise how serious this is, his behaviour is the reason why people feel they have to hide who they are which can have really serious consequences

Hazey19 · 03/02/2023 09:34

Just wanted to say you sound like a lovely dad. But also yes I would let him choose his own xx

SleepingStandingUp · 03/02/2023 09:31

MintyFreshOne · 03/02/2023 03:52

The only reason that it's perfectly normal for women to wear trousers but men are apparently hilarious in a dress is because of a deep down prejudice that being a woman is inferior, and aspiring upwards in that hierarchy is understandable but aspiring downwards is incomprehensible

No, it’s because they sell trousers that are tailored to women so they don’t look ridiculous. Dresses are still made for the female body so it’s never gonna look good on a man unless they make a menswear version. Just how it is, and why they look so ridiculous in them.

Any why do you think trousers are now made tailored for women but dresses aren't?

Because wearing clothes typically worn by men is a way to better yourself as a woman, look cooler, more professional. Along with doing "male" hobbies, subjects or careers. It's why female architects are lauded and male nurses are asked if they're gay (when they actually mean a paedophile) and banned from treating some peoples children. Because that's a woman's job and only a crap man who isn't very manly who is a pervert would lower themselves to do it.

Agree with the PP about shops catching on and selling prettier stuff for lads, but unfortunately lots of adults would never buy it or would basically support the kid being bullied (don't buy that for your son, he'll get bullied)

User76765 · 03/02/2023 07:13

Your son is a boy. He will always be a boy/man. You need to tell him that anyone can wear whatever they want but he will always be a boy and that will never change. I’d tell him that until fairly recently in history pink was very much a man’s colour and in the 1980s men often wore earrings and eyeliner. Tell him fashion is a personal thing and allows us to express our individuality and what one person likes, another will hate. Then give him a hug, tell him you’re proud of him and you know he’s going to grow up to a great man who is interesting and confident and that you love him.

Then move on. It’s a non issue. Don’t fall into the trap of pigeonholing your child.

Dacadactyl · 03/02/2023 07:12

No, I wouldn't buy him a dress personally, but I'd be very closely monitoring what he's been looking at online.

Charley50 · 03/02/2023 07:10

It's a shame that high street stores don't market some dresses at males, or make a feminine male range, with floaty fabric. To me that is the logical next step for society. Some men and boys like feminine clothing, it shouldn't matter and it should be designed for male bodies.

MintyFreshOne · 03/02/2023 07:06

Trez1510 · 03/02/2023 04:18

🙄

OP please ignore this nonsense and focus on the majority of posts where posters are giving you genuine, useful advice on how best to deal with whatever transpires after your chat with your son. Good luck. 👍

What specifically do you find objectionable about this advice?

PleaseCleanTheWholeToilet · 03/02/2023 04:30

The main priority is talking to your son who called him names and said he will tell everyone at school
You need to make sure you tell him that he is not to breath a word to anyone and talk to him about feelings and differences and supporting family members / his brothers etc

Slobbet · 03/02/2023 04:28

I wouldn't buy him a dress as I wouldn’t want him to feel obliged to wear it or feel obliged to look the stereotype of feminine. He can make these choices himself.

id be concerned if your son assumed he must be born in the wrong body just because he’s more sensitive and more feminine then his older brothers. Men can be stereotypically feminine or masculine and one isn’t better then the other. Your son is perfect just the way he is. impartial counselling might be of help, enabling him to make sense of things. There might be some connection with his mothers loss or peer pressure.

Trez1510 · 03/02/2023 04:18

TheSandgroper · 03/02/2023 01:17

Buying the dress (or providing the funds to do so) is fine as far as it goes and you do say DC has always walked his own path but, in your chat, do try to find out what the school has been teaching him.

If the message is “you may not be a boy, you may be a girl, you may be something else”, then you have a problem. Be sure that the message is “dress how you want but you are a boy now and will be a man soon”.

🙄

OP please ignore this nonsense and focus on the majority of posts where posters are giving you genuine, useful advice on how best to deal with whatever transpires after your chat with your son. Good luck. 👍

JustGiveMeTwoMinutes · 03/02/2023 04:09

I think the point that this may be a way of staying connected to his mum is a valid one to keep in mind when you are talking to him. I would go in with an open mind and not assume anything

octoberfarm · 03/02/2023 03:54

You sound absolutely lovely. I would probably let your boy know that you were going to buy him another dress but as you weren't sure what he liked, you wondered if he wanted to pick one online for you to order instead. I bet he will be so chuffed by your open minded support. It sounds like you've already spoken to the brother making fun but just to echo others, I really would come down on that like a ton of bricks, with a firm reminder that it is his job to be on his brother's team and have his back, not rally people against him like a bully. It's okay for him not to understand but under no circumstances should he be making life harder for his brother. I'd just be really clear that it won't be tolerated.

He's lucky to have you, OP. Hope the chat goes really well Flowers

MintyFreshOne · 03/02/2023 03:52

The only reason that it's perfectly normal for women to wear trousers but men are apparently hilarious in a dress is because of a deep down prejudice that being a woman is inferior, and aspiring upwards in that hierarchy is understandable but aspiring downwards is incomprehensible

No, it’s because they sell trousers that are tailored to women so they don’t look ridiculous. Dresses are still made for the female body so it’s never gonna look good on a man unless they make a menswear version. Just how it is, and why they look so ridiculous in them.

SchoolTripDrama · 03/02/2023 03:26

Please don't. Poor kid will be bullied so badly

Roseyposeypudding · 03/02/2023 02:21

This is so lovely it literally made me emotional. You sound like such a lovely dad!