Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Key in the door syndrome.

115 replies

DandelionLady · 03/02/2023 00:10

Pushing 70. Having some bladder problems. Problem that would have been called in the past "key in the door" syndrome. Have good-ish bladder control, but recently losing that confidence because if I'm bursting for the loo, or in recent times, just standing up from the sofa to go for a wee, I don't have the failsafe control that I once took for granted. I'm in full control until I get into the loo and see the toilet bowl. Of course I'm quite worried about it.
Worried about going out and about because obviously "what if"?

Saw the doctor, and she said it's par for the course of getting older .No treatment required. Also I pushed out a 10lb baby. That's got to hurt!

So I looked on the NHS website, for some help for women with incontinence issues. And I read loads of it, before I got to the bit where the advice differs.
It asks, do you have a penis, or a vagina?

That hit me like a brick. Can't they just say are you a man or a woman?

No. It seems that they really can't. My next door neighbour but one is a GP of 25 years standing, and she says that on a probably bi-weekly basis she has to tie herself in knots in order not to offend

So on a site which deals with (what is almost always a female problem caused by childbirth) post birth incontinence, it asks me if I have a penis.

Well no, I don't. Most men don't have post birth incontinence. And you won't get any penis-havers on this site anyway. . So there's really no need to tiptoe around the subject. My struggle with post birth incontinence has nothing to do at all to do with men. So why ask me, on that site, whether I have a penis or a vagina?

You have all my medical records .I gave birth to a baby which is a small clue. I do not have a penis. It is all in my records dating back to 1960.

Granted I have a deep voice, and whiskers on my chin*
But I am not a man!!

*I don't really have whiskers on my chin. I pluck the buggers out!!
And have always had a deep and modulated voice. For a woman:}

OP posts:
corcaithecat · 03/02/2023 09:19

LemonBounce · 03/02/2023 05:22

Are you the representative for All Women? Because I've checked and I'm not offended. Oh and I have a vagina too.

Well maybe you could consider being offended?

Are you really ok with the words woman/women and girl/girls being erased from the English language for the sake of a small bunch of narcissistic men who are trying to convince us that they can actually change sex?

I sincerely hope you don’t have a daughter.

saraclara · 03/02/2023 09:02

So on a site which deals with (what is almost always a female problem caused by childbirth) post birth incontinence, it asks me if I have a penis.

Because the site is not purely about post birth incontinence. It's about incontinence in general.

Most men don't have post birth incontinence. And you won't get any penis-havers on this site anyway. . So there's really no need to tiptoe around the subject. My struggle with post birth incontinence has nothing to do at all to do with men. So why ask me, on that site, whether I have a penis or a vagina?

Again, you are wording your complaint less than honestly. The site isn't all about you, it's not just about post birth incontinence, it's about incontinence.

And more to the point, you're 70 @DandelionLady . You don't have post birth incontinence. That's the condition that women have in the months/ immediate year or two after birth.
You have what I have (I'm a similar age) as have many of my friends. An early let down of urine. Our brains see a toilet and let the urine go before we're ready.

ErrolTheDragon · 03/02/2023 08:58

GinClassHeroes · 03/02/2023 08:26

I’d kind of understand that the wording might be confusing if they were asking about headaches and started with “if you have a vagina, headaches may be worse around your period” or something - since the vagina is largely irrelevant. However, if the doctor is wearing you like a puppet I think it’s pretty relevant to know if his fingers are up your rectum or your vagina.

So 'male' would work best for someone with prostate problems, no penis and a 'neovagina', whereas describing in terms of penis/vagina wouldn't. Everyone knows what sex they actually are, even if you wish you could be the opposite.

Ohhmydays · 03/02/2023 08:55

ElephantSlide · 03/02/2023 01:02

Yes OP it’s maddening unthink. Total bullshit.

No one with a dick will have post-birth incontinence. For fuck’s sake.

And I agree with a PP: apparently it’s a hate crime to offend anyone except for women. Anyone can offend us whenever they like and if we complain we’re bigots.

Fuck this shit.

100% this. I have a cousin who is in the middle of transitioning to a trans man and even he doesn’t see why everyone gets so offended. He is of the same opinion as many, women give birth, carry baby not men, and that trans men should not be aloud to get pregnant. They want to be men and should be treated as such

GrumpyPanda · 03/02/2023 08:54

StarsSand · 03/02/2023 08:02

What could be more clear or simple than saying 'penis' and 'vagina' when it comes to urinary issues?

Ermm... you are aware, aren't you, that we don't pee through our vaginas? If you aren't, that really speaks volumes.

ErrolTheDragon · 03/02/2023 08:53

StolenCookie · 03/02/2023 08:31

Someone born female could have transitioned to male later in life. They may identify as a man but still have a vagina and still have incontinence issues related to that. That’s why asking “are you male or female” is irrelevant.

A woman can 'transition' to become a transman or a man can 'transition' to be a TW. The latter may no longer have a penis but still have a prostate. That person remains male - humans can't change sex, a male can't transition to female or a female to male.

ancientgran · 03/02/2023 08:53

FOJN · 03/02/2023 08:38

The advice you receive about incontinence does not depend on your gender identity. Women are more likely to experience stress incontinence as a result of childbirth and menopause and men are more likely to experience urge or overflow incontinence because of an enlarged prostate. These differences are explained by the differences in male and female anatomy and the treatment is different.

Some people may have surgery to construct the genitalia of their preferred gender but surgically constructed genitalia does not function in the same way and this group of people are likely to need more specialist help with continence problems. It is very important that we do allow people to think surgery changes biological sex; a transman in the US died because they did not know they needed to tell hospital staff they were born female when they presented to the ER with abdominal pain.

So maybe it needs to be more complicated and include if you've had surgery if that might necessitate more specialist help.

Oldnproud · 03/02/2023 08:49

picklemewalnuts · 03/02/2023 08:28

**neat and simple.

A nursery teacher who can't spell apparently.

But the nursery teacher didn't write apparently.

FOJN · 03/02/2023 08:43

OP I didn't know about key in door syndrome but your post has prompted me to do a bit of research which I found very helpful. I've been experiencing the same problem for a couple of years, I'm early 50's and I've not had children. I know it's not due to weakened pelvic floor muscles. I found this which made sense, the more I tighten my pelvic floor muscles the worse the urge to pee becomes.

hands-onhealthcare.com/what-is-key-in-lock-syndrome/#:~:text=Although%20it%20can%20seem%20counter,to%20more%20urgency%20frequency%20difficulty.

I'm going to do a bit more research.

FOJN · 03/02/2023 08:38

Kamia · 03/02/2023 08:25

Because some people identify as a woman but they have a penis. That's why they ask that question. Being male or female won't give them the information they need.

The advice you receive about incontinence does not depend on your gender identity. Women are more likely to experience stress incontinence as a result of childbirth and menopause and men are more likely to experience urge or overflow incontinence because of an enlarged prostate. These differences are explained by the differences in male and female anatomy and the treatment is different.

Some people may have surgery to construct the genitalia of their preferred gender but surgically constructed genitalia does not function in the same way and this group of people are likely to need more specialist help with continence problems. It is very important that we do allow people to think surgery changes biological sex; a transman in the US died because they did not know they needed to tell hospital staff they were born female when they presented to the ER with abdominal pain.

Bleachmycloths · 03/02/2023 08:37

My God, there’s some bull shit on this thread. I’m surprised I could be bothered to post this. But I have …

StolenCookie · 03/02/2023 08:31

Someone born female could have transitioned to male later in life. They may identify as a man but still have a vagina and still have incontinence issues related to that. That’s why asking “are you male or female” is irrelevant.

Spidey66 · 03/02/2023 08:30

Your GP can make a referral to the Women's Health Physios who can teach you pelvic floor exercises.

Also watch your caffeine intake which can make it worse.

GinClassHeroes · 03/02/2023 08:29

picklemewalnuts · 03/02/2023 08:27

I would start with a catch all sentence or heading.

Examination and Treatment will be different for men and women.
Men will...
Women will...

But I'm a nursery teacher. I like things beat and simole.

So you don’t think “penis” and “vagina” are clear?
I don’t think many nursery age children are reading NHS advice about urinary incontinence so I’m not sure why your job is relevant.

Sparklfairy · 03/02/2023 08:29

Last time I went to a walk-in for my depo injection (pre Covid) the form was so confusing and tied itself in knots.

What contraception do you want today? <Depo>
How do you identify? Male-born transwoman/Female-born transman/non-binary/Female-born woman/male-born man/prefer not to say/what felt like about 7 other options.

You hand the form in and a nurse has to decipher it. A person born a man cannot have the depo injection, and it just seemed to complicate the whole process simply because the NHS are desperate not to offend.

Somebody was paid taxpayer money to create that form AngryConfused

picklemewalnuts · 03/02/2023 08:28

**neat and simple.

A nursery teacher who can't spell apparently.

GinClassHeroes · 03/02/2023 08:27

Kamia · 03/02/2023 08:25

Because some people identify as a woman but they have a penis. That's why they ask that question. Being male or female won't give them the information they need.

No it isn’t. It’s because they are sticking their finger inside your vagina if you are a woman, or into your anus if you are a man. The body parts involved are relevant.

picklemewalnuts · 03/02/2023 08:27

I would start with a catch all sentence or heading.

Examination and Treatment will be different for men and women.
Men will...
Women will...

But I'm a nursery teacher. I like things beat and simole.

GinClassHeroes · 03/02/2023 08:26

I’d kind of understand that the wording might be confusing if they were asking about headaches and started with “if you have a vagina, headaches may be worse around your period” or something - since the vagina is largely irrelevant. However, if the doctor is wearing you like a puppet I think it’s pretty relevant to know if his fingers are up your rectum or your vagina.

Kamia · 03/02/2023 08:25

Because some people identify as a woman but they have a penis. That's why they ask that question. Being male or female won't give them the information they need.

ancientgran · 03/02/2023 08:25

GinClassHeroes · 03/02/2023 08:21

Have you read the page OP is referencing? Here is the “offensive” text. The body part is indeed relevant as the investigation directly relates to that body part.

Physical examination

A GP may examine you to assess the health of your urinary system. If you have a vagina, the GP will do a pelvic examination, which usually involves undressing from the waist down. You may be asked to cough to see if any urine leaks.

The GP may also examine your vagina. In many cases of stress incontinence, part of the bladder may bulge into the vagina, which is called a cystocele.

The GP may place their finger inside your vagina and ask you to squeeze your pelvic floor muscles.

These are the muscles that surround your bladder and urethra (the tube that urine passes through to leave your body). Damage to your pelvic floor muscles can lead to urinary incontinence.

If you have a penis, the GP may check the health of your prostate gland, which is located between the penis and bladder and surrounds the urethra.

You may need a digital rectal examination. This will involve the GP inserting their finger into your bottom so they can feel your prostate gland.

If you have an enlarged prostate gland, it can cause symptoms of urinary incontinence, such as a frequent need to urinate.

www.nhs.uk/conditions/urinary-incontinence/diagnosis/

Seems a pretty clear explanation.

picklemewalnuts · 03/02/2023 08:23

Ah, cross post.

No, I hadn't read the full text.

picklemewalnuts · 03/02/2023 08:22

Well they won't be looking on English language internet pages, I suppose. They get help from volunteers at the moment. I had them in mind as I was simplifying the paperwork for an event I'm involved with this week.

Where you need to specify organs, then yes the correct name should be given. Obviously.

When you are asking about men or women, then that's the simplest wording to use.

GinClassHeroes · 03/02/2023 08:21

picklemewalnuts · 03/02/2023 08:13

Well I'm ok with language, though my concentration is shot.

My dyslexic son, and the Iranian refugees I'm friendly with, would prefer shorter simpler sentences.

If someone needs to insert a finger anywhere then yes there's a need to be specific. If they are asking if you are a man of a woman then just say so.

Otherwise it's word salad.

I feel the same way about people using 'myself' instead of 'my'.

It's the medical equivalent of estate agents speak.

This person with a vagina would respond well to a complete refurbishment, but is perfectly liveable with a little cosmetic upgrade.

Have you read the page OP is referencing? Here is the “offensive” text. The body part is indeed relevant as the investigation directly relates to that body part.

Physical examination

A GP may examine you to assess the health of your urinary system. If you have a vagina, the GP will do a pelvic examination, which usually involves undressing from the waist down. You may be asked to cough to see if any urine leaks.

The GP may also examine your vagina. In many cases of stress incontinence, part of the bladder may bulge into the vagina, which is called a cystocele.

The GP may place their finger inside your vagina and ask you to squeeze your pelvic floor muscles.

These are the muscles that surround your bladder and urethra (the tube that urine passes through to leave your body). Damage to your pelvic floor muscles can lead to urinary incontinence.

If you have a penis, the GP may check the health of your prostate gland, which is located between the penis and bladder and surrounds the urethra.

You may need a digital rectal examination. This will involve the GP inserting their finger into your bottom so they can feel your prostate gland.

If you have an enlarged prostate gland, it can cause symptoms of urinary incontinence, such as a frequent need to urinate.

www.nhs.uk/conditions/urinary-incontinence/diagnosis/

StarsSand · 03/02/2023 08:16

picklemewalnuts · 03/02/2023 08:13

Well I'm ok with language, though my concentration is shot.

My dyslexic son, and the Iranian refugees I'm friendly with, would prefer shorter simpler sentences.

If someone needs to insert a finger anywhere then yes there's a need to be specific. If they are asking if you are a man of a woman then just say so.

Otherwise it's word salad.

I feel the same way about people using 'myself' instead of 'my'.

It's the medical equivalent of estate agents speak.

This person with a vagina would respond well to a complete refurbishment, but is perfectly liveable with a little cosmetic upgrade.

I'm sure your Iranian refugee friends have overcome bigger challenges than reading the words 'penis' and 'vagina' on some medical information.