Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Right to attend prom based on attendance at after school GCSE revision sessions- to think this sucks?

116 replies

MonitorL1zard · 02/02/2023 23:24

It’s amazing that the school provides after school GCSE revision classes but is it fair to attach the right to go to prom to attendance at these?

OP posts:
CaptainMyCaptain · 03/02/2023 07:21

XenoBitch · 02/02/2023 23:27

I hate that Prom is even a thing nowadays.

Yes. Over priced dresses. Limos. What happened to the school disco?

Sindonym · 03/02/2023 07:20

Terrible idea. Penalises those who are young carers or who have transport issues (eg live in rural areas) or who have commitments outside school. My middle son did a lot of extra curricular activities (related to the field he is now studying in and where he hopes his whole career will be). The timing of those was not in his control.

Mind you neither of my younger kids were remotely interested in attending prom. The youngest could have done with some organised revision & would have been able to attend these sessions - he would have used this as a reason not to go (so then everyone iwould get off his back about prom)

AreYouShittingMe · 03/02/2023 07:15

Seems unfair to me. My DS goes to his, because he knows he struggles to self motivate to revise and it's evidence he has been revising. This makes for a more harmonious household for us.
However, as PP have said, that are lots of reasons why some children can't make the sessions or would prefer to revise by themselves.
A reduced ticket price would be fairer, but as PO have suggested, the only exclusion criteria should be extreme bad behaviour.

Cosyblankets · 03/02/2023 07:10

When i was a teacher at a difficult comp and did revision lessons, the benefit was the smaller class of kids who genuinely wanted to be there without any disruption.

BibbleandSqwauk · 03/02/2023 06:50

@Nimbostratus100 I'm also a teacher and disagree with your post. We run clinics, surgeries and exam focused revision sessions all through y11 . From half term these will also include large group ones where you focus on one aspect or look at a past question. It's not just repeating the scheme of work, it's using revision booklets, quizzes, model answers and mark schemes, totally different to teaching the content first time through.
Having said that , the issues raised on here about the practicalities of access / travel are very real.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 03/02/2023 03:20

XanaduKira · 02/02/2023 23:29

I don't think it's a bad idea - good way to incentivise them to do extra study as prom is a privilege after all.

Depending on where the school is located, its totally unfair.

If your dc stay for after school lessons, how will they get home? The only way in rural areas for many children to get home is on the school bus. Working parents can't necessarily pick up at, say, 4pm.

DaveyJonesLocker · 03/02/2023 03:05

That's ridiculous! Not everyone revises in the same way. It won't even be helpful for a good chunk of kids. And not all kids need to revise at all. What a stupid system.

TrickorTreacle · 03/02/2023 02:59

XenoBitch · 02/02/2023 23:27

I hate that Prom is even a thing nowadays.

I agree.

I put that the OP as YABU for using the word prom.

Even if the school calls it a prom, in UK English, it is a ball.

5foot5 · 03/02/2023 00:33

Well, what strikes me is that those students who are sufficiently engaged in their education that they will go to these classes and therefore qualify for the prom, are the students who are more likely to go on and have a successful life and probably have lots of memorable parties ahead of them.

However, the other students, for whom secondary education has not gone so well and who are therefore less motivated, may well have a future with less opportunity for fancy parties and big occasions. Hence I think it is a bit mean to exclude students who could fall in to this category

MonitorL1zard · 03/02/2023 00:28

Nimbostratus100 · 03/02/2023 00:24

this makes no sense to me as a teacher. A revision session with everybody attending it is.... just another lesson? Why are teachers being expected to teach another lesson in the week, and why are pupils being made to attend? It isn't possible to cover new parts of the curriculum in a "voluntary" after school session. So it is a lesson going over old content with the whole class, and people who didn't get it before, are not particularly likely to get it doing it again in the same way..

A revision session to me is a couple of students arranging a time, before school, after school, lunch time, to come to me bringing specific questions the need help with, preferable two or three to one, certainly no more than 6- when I can concentrate on individuals and their particular misconceptions or struggles, and do a short, intense 30-40 minutes with them.

I wouldnt take extra lesson with big groups, they can reread their notes together and help each other skim through general content - it that is how they want to do it- no benefit to anyone me being there too

Thank you.

OP posts:
MonitorL1zard · 03/02/2023 00:25

Soontobe60 · 02/02/2023 23:57

Also discriminatory against children from less affluent families. And don’t say that it doesn’t have to cost a lot. Because who wants to turn up in a borrowed frock, home made fake tan, stick on nails and in your mum’s 10 year old car when the cool crowd get to have a beauty package, £250 frock, hair extensions and a limo ride.
it’s absolutely cringe.

I agree with both of these points.

I can see how anxiety provoking discussions about dresses, make-up and transport could be.

I was thinking it’s a get-together to mark the end of school that should be open to everyone. It’s not that simple is it!?

OP posts:
Nimbostratus100 · 03/02/2023 00:24

this makes no sense to me as a teacher. A revision session with everybody attending it is.... just another lesson? Why are teachers being expected to teach another lesson in the week, and why are pupils being made to attend? It isn't possible to cover new parts of the curriculum in a "voluntary" after school session. So it is a lesson going over old content with the whole class, and people who didn't get it before, are not particularly likely to get it doing it again in the same way..

A revision session to me is a couple of students arranging a time, before school, after school, lunch time, to come to me bringing specific questions the need help with, preferable two or three to one, certainly no more than 6- when I can concentrate on individuals and their particular misconceptions or struggles, and do a short, intense 30-40 minutes with them.

I wouldnt take extra lesson with big groups, they can reread their notes together and help each other skim through general content - it that is how they want to do it- no benefit to anyone me being there too

MonitorL1zard · 03/02/2023 00:19

I’m glad I’ve posted this. I’m seeing much bigger problems than mine that are putting things into perspective.
I’m coming from the angle that some people are introverts who find school exhausting. After secondary school such people can choose their environment to a certain extent.
However, the other points people have raised here (young carers, poverty, lack of resources) will continue to have an impact.
Thank you for helping me to think this through.

OP posts:
BensonStabler · 03/02/2023 00:15

It’s not fair on young carers i agree. Also those that struggle with learning and attention, I had to revise in my own way at my own pace, in peace and quiet, group revisions wouldn’t have done me any favours.

PrinceHaz · 03/02/2023 00:12

I don’t agree with it being used as a reward or a bargaining tool. It’s nice to have something like this for them to mark the end of an era. I would only exclude on the basis of a very serious misdemeanour.

Thatiswild · 03/02/2023 00:07

@Soontobe60 very true.

Thatiswild · 03/02/2023 00:04

@deeperthanallroses they're not unusual unfortunately.

Where we live there are children whose parents are having to make the decision as to which days to send them in on the bus depending on timetable and subjects as they can’t afford to pay for public transport every day. As a school governor I know this is genuine and it’s not just a couple of kids. Accessibility is an huge problem in secondary schools. Our school will try to help anyone in this situation but that is only if they actually identify this - lots of people don’t want to admit that they’re in this situation. It’s distressing but it’s true.

If there is only a free (to those eligible) school bus at 3 then they’re already missing out on enough by having no transport home. Our school fund a later bus so that no one is excluded from after school clubs on the basis of transport, but we are very fortunate to have an inclusive school who take their community’s needs seriously.

Several of my child’s friends travel on two non school buses home to an empty house, they may not feel comfortable doing that later in the evening at the age of 11.

Incentivising study is great but I think this type of idea excludes too many students and could actually make their revision less effective - yanbu.

Soontobe60 · 02/02/2023 23:57

coralgeo · 02/02/2023 23:51

Discriminatory against those who study better at home.

Also discriminatory against children from less affluent families. And don’t say that it doesn’t have to cost a lot. Because who wants to turn up in a borrowed frock, home made fake tan, stick on nails and in your mum’s 10 year old car when the cool crowd get to have a beauty package, £250 frock, hair extensions and a limo ride.
it’s absolutely cringe.

ErrolTheDragon · 02/02/2023 23:55

Bad idea for all the reasons already mentioned, young carers were who came to my mind. Though they might not be able to go to a prom anyway.

Tygertiger · 02/02/2023 23:53

Prom - or leavers’ do, whatever we want to call it - if schools have it, then it is a rite of passage for the pupils and something they will always remember. It should be open to all with no exceptions except for serious bullies and not dangled like a carrot or used as a threat. It certainly shouldn’t be linked to the school’s Progress 8 score as is going on here.

coralgeo · 02/02/2023 23:51

Discriminatory against those who study better at home.

ChicCroissant · 02/02/2023 23:48

DD's school have offered a day trip dependant on general attendance and the attendance at the extra lessons. I can't remember if it applies to Prom too, probably not. The extra lessons during and after school and the subsequent lack of breaks are likely to lead to more illness IMO, so it's going to be interesting to see how it plays out!

SalmonEile · 02/02/2023 23:48

deeperthanallroses · 02/02/2023 23:35

These situations must be pretty unusual, gcse students are old enough to catch pt, ask a friend for a lift since everyone else is at the session too. Im sure schools could deal with genuine hardship cases.
I like this approach- why shouldn’t the ones who just want to party be incentivised to attend the study sessions?

They might be pretty unusual, they might not

they might not have a friend they can ask - there’s threads on here regularly from parents who are sick of giving lifts to kids who’s parents can’t reciprocate

there might not be appropriate public transport and
even if there is why should a student/family be penalized for not wanting to pay out for public transport when the parent is collecting a younger sibling an hour earlier (for example) and the student isn’t one who ‘just wants to party’ and perfectly capable of studying at home

im not being argumentative im just assuming the above scenario is a reality for some otherwise the OP wouldn’t be posting

RampantIvy · 02/02/2023 23:46

DD's old school was in a rural market town. Once the school buses left at 3pm there were no public transport options for many of the pupils, so her school didn't lay on any compulsory after school revision sessions.

There was no study leave until the third week of exams, so they did revision sessions in between the exams.

It suited DD better to revise at home, and after the spring bank half term week I don't think the school checked attendance and on days I wasn't working I could pick her up from school after an exam to revise from home.

AliceMcK · 02/02/2023 23:45

Not fairs to kids who can’t attend for various reasons, clubs activities, work, family priorities…

Swipe left for the next trending thread