Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think he should've called the police TW - violence of adult on child

35 replies

lornmower · 02/02/2023 22:49

When I was 4 I wouldn't settle one night so I can remember my mum came into my bedroom and slapped me hard repeatedly across the face - around 5-10 times if I recall. I was 3 months off my 5th birthday. My Dad just stood behind her and said nothing . I felt traumatised. Next day my mum was very overly affectionate towards me and 'apologised' so looking back she knew full well she'd done something very wrong. My Dad just sat there passively. Thinking back on this incident I think my Dad should've informed the police and left my mum. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
lornmower · 09/02/2023 17:31

Wetblanket78 · 09/02/2023 17:04

This was a daily occurance for me growing up. My mum took her temper out on us. If it wasn't our arse being hit with a slipper or wooden hairbrush. It was slaps across our face. Usually just for being kids.

Sorry you went through this - awful and very traumatic Flowers

OP posts:
Wetblanket78 · 09/02/2023 17:04

This was a daily occurance for me growing up. My mum took her temper out on us. If it wasn't our arse being hit with a slipper or wooden hairbrush. It was slaps across our face. Usually just for being kids.

lornmower · 03/02/2023 09:01

@Curriedpeanuts - so sorry you went through that. Because I was an only child of an emotionally abusive alcoholic I also 'shut down' - I can see that now

OP posts:
Curriedpeanuts · 03/02/2023 08:32

I am so sorry

I had similar, my parents smacked me a lot and although my dad never smacked me for not getting to sleep, he would threaten me that if I wasn't asleep in 10 minutes he'd come up and smack me and he always seemed so angry I was terrified.
I also wasn't allowed to get up to go to the toilet so I used to wee under my pillow instead.
When my dad figured that out, asked me what happened and I lied (because I knew I'd be in trouble) and said I spilled a glass of water, he chased me round the bedroom saying 'stop running, I'm not going to smack you' then when I stopped he smacked me . He repeated this a couple of times. Supposedly to teach me that it's not nice to lie.

I also shut off in my childhood and although I was very unhappy and isolated, I didn't show anything on the outside.

I'd been in foster care for my first year with multiple carers before they adopted me, so I think I probably shut off and relied on myself from then on anyway.

Took me many years to learn to open up.

In many other ways he was a great dad, he was affectionate and played with me, unlike my mum.

I would try again to talk to your parents and explain how it scared you and how traimatising it was. Even if they say they don't remember it, say you will remind them.

Easier said than done, I haven't confronted my parents about a lot of stuff because they also don't remember it and I don't want to upset them in their old age. My dad has generically apologised for how they were with me though, although it took him until he was elderly to do it, I think he reached a point where he knew we needed to have closure.

lornmower · 03/02/2023 07:56

So sorry to everyone who's experienced anything even vaguely similar to me Flowers

Another thing - even though I was only 4 and had been hit severely across the face repeatedly - I never cried at the time or showed any outward signs of distress - I went completely mute - trauma I suppose.
I remember when I was around 6 being worried that she'd come in and do something else to me

OP posts:
BMrs · 03/02/2023 07:04

80s child and my dad hit us with his belt a handful of times. I did speak to mum about it once and she says says she didn't know. I believe her as looking back, she was never home when it happened.

I just put it down to things that happened back then. I'm NC with Dad now (not related to that)

BlueWhiteStripe · 02/02/2023 23:50

bobbytorq · 02/02/2023 22:54

I'm surprised you remember this, especially what happened the next day.

Something traumatic happened to me at a similar age. I can tell you the plot line of the cartoon I was watching just before it happened. It’s etched in my brain.

lornmower · 02/02/2023 23:46

EmmaDilemma5 · 02/02/2023 23:41

Then it sounds like your dad was a weak person who, quite frankly, took the easier option.

I'm sure it hurt him, I'm sure he wanted better but yes, he failed to keep you safe and that's on him.

I guess real life is messy and there are a lot of complex reasons why people abuse others and are complicit with abuse.

OP - I don't think you're going to get answers from your dad sadly. Counselling may help you unpack what happened.

It wasn't your fault. You didn't deserve it. Your parents should have done better.

Thank you - your response means a lot - also for context I'm an only child so no other kids in house to witness

OP posts:
EmmaDilemma5 · 02/02/2023 23:41

Then it sounds like your dad was a weak person who, quite frankly, took the easier option.

I'm sure it hurt him, I'm sure he wanted better but yes, he failed to keep you safe and that's on him.

I guess real life is messy and there are a lot of complex reasons why people abuse others and are complicit with abuse.

OP - I don't think you're going to get answers from your dad sadly. Counselling may help you unpack what happened.

It wasn't your fault. You didn't deserve it. Your parents should have done better.

lornmower · 02/02/2023 23:26

@EmmaDilemma5 - to my Dad about this and he said he didn't remember it (while not making eye contact with me)

OP posts:
lornmower · 02/02/2023 23:24

Simulacra · 02/02/2023 23:15

There were multiple times per year that my step Dad (and other adults) should have called the police on my mother for violently assaulting me, but they didn’t. Nor did they intervene and try to get her 5ft 11 18 stone ass off my 5ft 6 stone one, either.

Result? Insane amount of injuries, CPTSD, NC with 95% of my family for enabling her drunk, coked up behaviour.

He did call the police when I eventually retaliated, aged 16, by grabbing a wine bottle and smacking her over the head with it, because I was on the floor, about to black out from her strangling me Hmm

I was “sent” to go and live with my Dad, a man she had alienated me from since I was 7, who’s court orders she had ignored, who I barely knew, and who she told a pack of lies about me to. Fortunately, he didn’t believe a word she said and he spent a fortune relocating us 250 miles away/on private therapy.

Blimey - the physical element of your situation sounds infinitely worse than mine - I'm sorry you experienced this. Flowers Glad your circumstances improved in the end

OP posts:
Simulacra · 02/02/2023 23:20

And yes you do remember traumatic incidents from a young age, unfortunately they become the strongest memories we hold, hence CPTSD,

lornmower · 02/02/2023 23:20

@EmmaDilemma5 - routinely emotionally abusive yes but violent 3 times

OP posts:
lornmower · 02/02/2023 23:18

Sorry my previous post meant to say I was 15 and 17 when the other 2 physical 'attacks' happened

OP posts:
lornmower · 02/02/2023 23:17

maddy68 · 02/02/2023 23:02

I am also quite forgiving. If it was a one off what was she going through at that time to trigger that response? Absolutely not excusing it but everyone has a breaking point

I would describe her as an abusive alcoholic. She was violent physically to me 3 times - I don't mean a smack - I mean came into my room and just hit me for nothing - other 2 times she was drunk and by this time was 15 and later 17 on the last incident. The rest was very hurts emotional abuse

OP posts:
Simulacra · 02/02/2023 23:15

There were multiple times per year that my step Dad (and other adults) should have called the police on my mother for violently assaulting me, but they didn’t. Nor did they intervene and try to get her 5ft 11 18 stone ass off my 5ft 6 stone one, either.

Result? Insane amount of injuries, CPTSD, NC with 95% of my family for enabling her drunk, coked up behaviour.

He did call the police when I eventually retaliated, aged 16, by grabbing a wine bottle and smacking her over the head with it, because I was on the floor, about to black out from her strangling me Hmm

I was “sent” to go and live with my Dad, a man she had alienated me from since I was 7, who’s court orders she had ignored, who I barely knew, and who she told a pack of lies about me to. Fortunately, he didn’t believe a word she said and he spent a fortune relocating us 250 miles away/on private therapy.

lornmower · 02/02/2023 23:13

@LunaTheCat - aargh sorry to hear that

OP posts:
lornmower · 02/02/2023 23:11

@LoveTheCat - happened in 90s

OP posts:
lornmower · 02/02/2023 23:09

@Merryoldgoat - thank you. I agree.

OP posts:
ThisGirlNever · 02/02/2023 23:09

Off topic, but a primary school teacher once disciplined me by violently shaking me - my feet were off the floor and my head was banging backwards and forwards. It was horrible. She screamed "I'll shake you till your teeth rattle!" in my face as she did it. I was seven years old and she'd heard me tut from the back of the room.

I was thinking about this the other day and was wondering if I should put in a complaint of abuse to the LEA.

It happened in 1985/1986 and I think the teacher is probably dead by now, so I'm not sure how constructive my complaint would be.

lornmower · 02/02/2023 23:08

@NRCOA - yes I have spoken to my Dad about that specific incident. He said - while not making eye contact with me - "I don't remember that"

He has said more generally though that in relation to my mums behaviour- he's said of himself "maybe I was too passive"

Sorry you've experienced it too Flowers

OP posts:
EmmaDilemma5 · 02/02/2023 23:07

TheOriginalEmu · 02/02/2023 22:58

I think obviously it was wrong and she shouldn’t have done it, but as to whether your dad should have reported her and left her…it would very much depend on if this was a regular thing, or a one off, what kind of person she is otherwise, what else might have been going on at the time etc.

i remember my dad smacking me hard as a child, but the reason I remember it so clearly is because it was a one off and he was and is a great dad. It was a mistake. So I let it go. Whatever you feel about your experience, I think counselling would help.

I'm so sorry OP, that must have been really scary, you deserved to be defended and I'm sorry you weren't.

I agree with this poster, I would try to look at the context. Was this a usually loving mother who snapped due to particularly bad mental health or a trigger one evening?

Or was she routinely abusive and used violence to control your behaviour?

There's no excuse for violence against a child and you are absolutely right to think your dad should have protected you. I have zero doubt that if my husband laid a hand on our children I would pull him back and force him away. My husband isn't abusive though so I'd have the confidence to know this was abnormal and I could get him to withdraw. I'm not sure there's an excuse for why your dad didn't intervene, even if it was just to pull your mother away from you.

Whether or not he should have called the police would depend I think. The reality is, that it would have meant your dad had to leave your mum and raise you alone. Perhaps he thought it wouldn't happen again. Perhaps he didn't think he could logistically raise you alone. It's a huge decision to make and perhaps he felt it was truly a one-off event (not that that makes it acceptable).

Are you parents still alive? Would you consider approaching them about this? I think, if you have the right relationship, it may be good to hear your dad's perspective on what happened.

maddy68 · 02/02/2023 23:02

I am also quite forgiving. If it was a one off what was she going through at that time to trigger that response? Absolutely not excusing it but everyone has a breaking point

lornmower · 02/02/2023 23:01

@*bobbytorg
*
the next morning as soon as I got up I went downstairs. My parents were both in the living room - mum on sofa - dad on chair sitting opposite each other. As soon as I walked in lounge mum had her arms outstretched to hug me and had an 'over the top' affectionate voice. She said she'd done it cos she thought the previous day I'd been rude to her friend. I 'accepted' the apology and didn't act outwardly distressed. My dad sat there passive and said nothing. It was July, so no nursery that day for me I wouldn't think but after that initial bit first thing in the morning I don't remember anything else that happened on that day

OP posts:
Railwayroad · 02/02/2023 23:00

Yep. 70s kid here. My Dad never hit me but my mum did. Smack on the legs, arm grabbing etc. awful really. It was just accepted as normal.