Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have become terrified of dog walks

213 replies

GoneToday · 02/02/2023 22:07

I absolutely adore my dogs and walks are (or were) the highlight of my day.
I walk them in a variety of lovely
places - very rurally, semi rural and also in large parks. I’ve walked dogs my whole life.
I mostly walk alone as I don’t live locally to any dog owning friends and I work shifts so it’s not easy to arrange regular dog walking friends as my times vary.
The last couple of weeks I’ve began to feel very uneasy on dog walks, the trees and fields that used to feel peaceful and beautiful have begun to feel ominous and almost foreboding.
I know there has been a poor missing woman who has vanished from a dog walk, plus a local sex attack in a very ‘safe and quiet’ village field in daylight.
However, I have heard horror stories before and although I’ve felt awful for the individual I’ve never felt personally under much threat.
My dogs are small, soft dogs and are no way physically protecting. I feel at my whits end.
I’m not prone to drama or excessive anxiety but Aibu to feel that dog walking as a lone female is not safe?
Maybe IABU, I just can’t shake the feeling and it’s genuinely ruining my life which sounds dramatic but I don’t know what to do with my dogs now as I spend walks feeling scared. I do have complex trauma history but that was decades ago and I’ve walked dogs happily for years since then.
Any thoughts welcome.

OP posts:
CantAskAnyoneElse · 03/02/2023 07:11

But what do you do?

You remind yourself of facts.
Women being assaulted, raped and/or murdered are overwhelmingly done by men they know.
So if your not afraid of your dad, boyfriend, husband, sons (there is a rise on sons killing their mothersamp.theguardian.com/society/2023/jan/15/women-killed-by-sons-violence-children-parents-britain-abuse) , male friends or co- workers, then why be scared of men you don’t know?
Statistically you’re mire safe around men you don’t know.

nij.ojp.gov/topics/articles/most-victims-know-their-attacker

www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1994-01-31-mn-17362-story.html

PandasAreUseless · 03/02/2023 07:09

My favourite thing to do is go for a long ramble with my dog. We properly explore, going off the beaten path and finding new areas together. Noone knows where we are and it doesn't bother me one bit.
I'd never let fear prevent me from doing something so good for the soul.

Remember, the person who is statistically most likely to harm you is the man you live with.

Leonberger · 03/02/2023 06:54

The only way I enjoy my walks anywhere is having a massive dog. Without one, I don’t think I would really walk anywhere that wasn’t very public!

Zanatdy · 03/02/2023 02:49

I hear you. Stories like the poor lady missing is worrying when you walk your dogs alone. But remember how many women walk dogs daily with no concerns. I have an attack alarm hanging off my dog walking bag which I can pull the cord on if need be. Thankfully for me even though my dog isn’t a huge vicious breed he would definitely try and attack anyone who tried to hurt me.

I rarely walk alone now, met a local lady in the park one day 5yrs ago and we are great friends now. We walk daily on the weekends. If I do walk alone I avoid the woods and stick to the open fields. I wouldn’t go deep into the woods alone personally.

PeanutButterSmoothie · 03/02/2023 01:46

The odd thing is that grappling usually doesn't look as flashy to the uninitiated as stuff like kung fu (which ironically usually isn't anywhere near as effective as plain old boxing). But there's a lot of technique/strategy going on, even if it's admittedly not as fun to watch as striking arts.

A really basic example would be the little girl in first video at the 55 second mark. The boy is trying to get around her guard, presumably into 'mount' position (sitting on chest), but she keeps spinning and using her legs to keep him away, pushing on his hips. This is really basic but is the kind of thing that would stop a rapist getting on top of you and possibly allow you to get out or trip them up etc.

PeanutButterSmoothie · 03/02/2023 01:36

oakleaffy · 03/02/2023 01:07

Our small and slender Mum when she was in her Forties escaped a Military would be rapist by biting him HARD on the shoulder.

She said she was pinned down, next to a ravine {South of France}..she had tried to talk her way out of it {She speaks French} but the man was having none of it.
Mum said she was very clear headed, and thought ''I must stay alive, and not fall down the Ravine''... She wanted to mark him in case she was killed.

After the hard bite that broke the skin, he got up and rode off.
Mum was so lucky that he didn't hurt her in retaliation.

The bite probably needed medical attention.

Once one is on the floor, one is at a huge disadvantage, so the techniques you mention sound good..but as you say, physical fitness and practice is necessary.

Wow, sounds like he didn't expect her to take the initiative.

Yes, in terms of BJJ (and martial arts in general) there isn't really any shortcut. But they do work, with the caveat that no two encounters are the same and an individual that would win 9/10 times can get poked in eye/kneed in groin/bump head whilst falling etc.

BJJ really is a great art though. I did struggle to put submissions (joint locks etc) on most men tbh due to their strength, but they also struggled to submit me as a decent practitioner is a bit like an octopus as you can see in the video. Hard to pin down and hard to punch as they smother you - obviously these videos weren't involving striking but when used in mma matches it still works as striking doesn't have much power when your opponent is basically hugging you.

Even now, having not trained for a few years, I'm pretty confident the large majority of men would struggle to rape me as I'm good at tangling people up. In a real situation you'd do something like use your bodyweight/leverage to force their arm out the way and ram your thumb right into their eye socket. With untrained people this would often be quite easy as they're totally unused to how to grapple and usually try and push against you rather than use leverage.

oakleaffy · 03/02/2023 01:11

Attack happened in the Massif De l'Esterel. Mum was out walking, taking pictures of wild flowers.

Wetblanket78 · 03/02/2023 01:07

There's that lady missing but then they go and put the Rachel Nickell doc on tonight who was on a dog walk. Bad timing I thought.

oakleaffy · 03/02/2023 01:07

PeanutButterSmoothie · 03/02/2023 00:56

In terms of self defence I'd agree that trying to learn to fight men is pointless due to the massive strength (and usually aggression) disparity.

I've studied quite a few martial arts over the years - MMA, Krav Maga, Kali/Filipino boxing were the ones I got half decent at. Have done a lot of hard sparring with head gear/gloves, often against men. The first two styles are mixed styles so I also learnt techniques from Brazilian jujitsu, western boxing, and Thai boxing, etc.

For pure 'self defence' (not the same as 'fighting') I think things like Krav Maga are the most effective as they focus on things like situational awareness and drilling quick and effective 'dirty' techniques like ramming fingers right into the eyes, headbutting, and then legging it. But really you won't get proficient unless you commit the time and train with intensity (and lots of schools are pretty shit too tbh).

IMO the most effective art by far for women is Brazilian jujitsu because it's 99% rolling around on the ground and controlling your opponent, so very good at helping avoid getting pinned and raped, especially if you incorporate dirty techniques like biting/pulling ears and clawing/poking eyeballs.

You'd think grappling would favour physical strength more than striking arts do, but whilst it can certainly help sometimes, especially with beginners, BJJ is actually designed to use leverage and allow a weaker individual to fight somebody heavier. When the UFC was style vs style (before everybody started cross training in 'mixed martial arts') the Gracie brothers who created BJJ went undefeated for eight years straight.

There's a video online of one of the early BJJ masters defeating a huge aggressive 250lb bodybuilder whilst weighing only 150lb himself. He smothers the guy's punches and tires him out pretty easily.

A lot of women would likely be put off rolling around with men and the high amount of close bodily contact. However, generally clubs don't tolerate dodgy guys and if you find a good club where you feel at home it can be a really good experience. Alternatively, you could maybe try and mainly train with women but also spar with your partner/husband, but as with most things you need to put in loads of effort to get good. Probably more effort than most women are prepared to commit, but if you want to answer to dealing with men then this is probably it.

One vs one it's pretty much the best single art but not good against multiple attackers. Hence, men are usually advised not to take a street fight to the floor due to the risk of attacker's friend kicking them in the back of the head etc. But for women the main risk imo is being raped.

A few links. Ignore the egregious claim that you can learn it online (surprised to see somebody clearly so proficient claim this and really they should be ashamed)

Our small and slender Mum when she was in her Forties escaped a Military would be rapist by biting him HARD on the shoulder.

She said she was pinned down, next to a ravine {South of France}..she had tried to talk her way out of it {She speaks French} but the man was having none of it.
Mum said she was very clear headed, and thought ''I must stay alive, and not fall down the Ravine''... She wanted to mark him in case she was killed.

After the hard bite that broke the skin, he got up and rode off.
Mum was so lucky that he didn't hurt her in retaliation.

The bite probably needed medical attention.

Once one is on the floor, one is at a huge disadvantage, so the techniques you mention sound good..but as you say, physical fitness and practice is necessary.

Mannymoomin · 03/02/2023 01:01

It’s very scary being a female, it shouldn’t be but it is.
I think it’s scarier now than it ever used to be, simply because we’re more aware of what does happen thanks to the news.

I don’t know if it’s been suggested OP, but have you thought of carrying an air tag? It might help knowing that you’ll be traceable, not that we should have to resort to airtags!

SelinaKant · 03/02/2023 01:00

oakleaffy · 03/02/2023 00:57

I wanted to mention the addition of a lighter.. But thought the post would be removed!

There is a risk of ''blowback'' if that's the right term, so probably not that safe.

Knowing my luck, I'd set myself on fire.😆

oakleaffy · 03/02/2023 00:57

SelinaKant · 03/02/2023 00:52

Hardcore! 😆

I wanted to mention the addition of a lighter.. But thought the post would be removed!

There is a risk of ''blowback'' if that's the right term, so probably not that safe.

PeanutButterSmoothie · 03/02/2023 00:56

In terms of self defence I'd agree that trying to learn to fight men is pointless due to the massive strength (and usually aggression) disparity.

I've studied quite a few martial arts over the years - MMA, Krav Maga, Kali/Filipino boxing were the ones I got half decent at. Have done a lot of hard sparring with head gear/gloves, often against men. The first two styles are mixed styles so I also learnt techniques from Brazilian jujitsu, western boxing, and Thai boxing, etc.

For pure 'self defence' (not the same as 'fighting') I think things like Krav Maga are the most effective as they focus on things like situational awareness and drilling quick and effective 'dirty' techniques like ramming fingers right into the eyes, headbutting, and then legging it. But really you won't get proficient unless you commit the time and train with intensity (and lots of schools are pretty shit too tbh).

IMO the most effective art by far for women is Brazilian jujitsu because it's 99% rolling around on the ground and controlling your opponent, so very good at helping avoid getting pinned and raped, especially if you incorporate dirty techniques like biting/pulling ears and clawing/poking eyeballs.

You'd think grappling would favour physical strength more than striking arts do, but whilst it can certainly help sometimes, especially with beginners, BJJ is actually designed to use leverage and allow a weaker individual to fight somebody heavier. When the UFC was style vs style (before everybody started cross training in 'mixed martial arts') the Gracie brothers who created BJJ went undefeated for eight years straight.

There's a video online of one of the early BJJ masters defeating a huge aggressive 250lb bodybuilder whilst weighing only 150lb himself. He smothers the guy's punches and tires him out pretty easily.

A lot of women would likely be put off rolling around with men and the high amount of close bodily contact. However, generally clubs don't tolerate dodgy guys and if you find a good club where you feel at home it can be a really good experience. Alternatively, you could maybe try and mainly train with women but also spar with your partner/husband, but as with most things you need to put in loads of effort to get good. Probably more effort than most women are prepared to commit, but if you want to answer to dealing with men then this is probably it.

One vs one it's pretty much the best single art but not good against multiple attackers. Hence, men are usually advised not to take a street fight to the floor due to the risk of attacker's friend kicking them in the back of the head etc. But for women the main risk imo is being raped.

A few links. Ignore the egregious claim that you can learn it online (surprised to see somebody clearly so proficient claim this and really they should be ashamed)

Sitdowncupoftea · 03/02/2023 00:55

Do you wear a dog bag. I live rural. I got caught out and ended up going through the woods in the dark. The other option was the country lane which is twinned with Silverstone race track! I have a heavy solid torch in my bag. There are things you can legally have in your bag that you can use to defend yourself. Some spray for example.

stevalnamechanger · 03/02/2023 00:53

This is legal ... to use on rogue dogs ;) www.thesafetysupplycompany.co.uk/p/9551082/walk-easy-we331-bouncer-personal-attack-deterrent---wea-we331.html

stevalnamechanger · 03/02/2023 00:52

This occurred to me last year at 7am when I saw a man in the Forrest , no dog .. walking in jeans ( who goes for a rural walk in jeans - odd to me) - he made me feel quite strange

Consider posting on local fb page for walking buddies

SelinaKant · 03/02/2023 00:52

GinClassHeroes · 03/02/2023 00:16

My aunt used to carry deodorant and a lighter. She demonstrated it to me once. The noise alone scared the crap out of me.

Hardcore! 😆

LadyVictoriaSponge · 03/02/2023 00:51

I feel the same particularly since the Julia James murder, I know statistically it’s highly unlikely to happen but I bet most women at some point in their life have been made to feel vulnerable or under threat from men whilst out alone, I’ve had men follow me in my car whilst driving at night and tried to run me off the road (this was back in the eighties when I was young and no mobiles), walking in a town centre at night a group of men in a car tried to accost me, I’ve been flashed at out walking my dog in the past couple of years, phoned the police who were beyond disinterested, those are just a few, I could list more unsettling events, I was just fortunate they didn’t develop into anything more serious, so yes it’s unlikely we will be killed but I think it’s very likely we will feel justifiably intimidated by men whilst out alone.

oakleaffy · 03/02/2023 00:49

Statistically young men are more at risk from other young men.
Damilola Taylor, Stephen Lawrence, Marlon Thomas.

oakleaffy · 03/02/2023 00:46

SelinaKant · 03/02/2023 00:05

It would be illegal to carry that under the Firearms Act Section 5. On a different subject however, it is always good for grooming to have a handbag sized can of Elnet on you so you can always look your best. 😏

It's nuts that Pepper spray is considered a ''Firearm'' in UK..After I was attacked, an American friend offered to send me some, and I had to decline.
{I have walked through dodgy parts of town with a can of hairspray in my hand as a younger person}

Plantatree · 03/02/2023 00:41

Some years ago, on a relatively busy local road, a young woman was dragged into a car after getting off a bus and unfortunately murdered. The crime was spotted by a following car but she was found too late. This was in the early evening, horrifying. Since then, I have definitely felt more nervous when dog walking.

Msgrieves · 03/02/2023 00:40

Bah. Guess so.

girlfriend44 · 03/02/2023 00:35

JupiterFortified · 02/02/2023 23:12

Oh come on. Yes men do get attacked but if we’re talking about lone people being attacked/sexually assaulted and potentially murdered then women are virtually always the victim.

My husband doesn’t have to worry when walking down the street at night. I do. It’s as simple as that.

Of course men worry, they can get set upon or mugged and do.

Look at Stephen Lawrence for one at the bus stop.

Salome61 · 03/02/2023 00:21

I'm rural and just a few side streets in the village have street lights so I used to drive my dog down to the village for his evening walks in the winter. I'm widowed and live alone and older and always carried an alarm, a whistle, and a permanent paint spray plus my phone.

GinClassHeroes · 03/02/2023 00:16

SelinaKant · 03/02/2023 00:05

It would be illegal to carry that under the Firearms Act Section 5. On a different subject however, it is always good for grooming to have a handbag sized can of Elnet on you so you can always look your best. 😏

My aunt used to carry deodorant and a lighter. She demonstrated it to me once. The noise alone scared the crap out of me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread