Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have become terrified of dog walks

213 replies

GoneToday · 02/02/2023 22:07

I absolutely adore my dogs and walks are (or were) the highlight of my day.
I walk them in a variety of lovely
places - very rurally, semi rural and also in large parks. I’ve walked dogs my whole life.
I mostly walk alone as I don’t live locally to any dog owning friends and I work shifts so it’s not easy to arrange regular dog walking friends as my times vary.
The last couple of weeks I’ve began to feel very uneasy on dog walks, the trees and fields that used to feel peaceful and beautiful have begun to feel ominous and almost foreboding.
I know there has been a poor missing woman who has vanished from a dog walk, plus a local sex attack in a very ‘safe and quiet’ village field in daylight.
However, I have heard horror stories before and although I’ve felt awful for the individual I’ve never felt personally under much threat.
My dogs are small, soft dogs and are no way physically protecting. I feel at my whits end.
I’m not prone to drama or excessive anxiety but Aibu to feel that dog walking as a lone female is not safe?
Maybe IABU, I just can’t shake the feeling and it’s genuinely ruining my life which sounds dramatic but I don’t know what to do with my dogs now as I spend walks feeling scared. I do have complex trauma history but that was decades ago and I’ve walked dogs happily for years since then.
Any thoughts welcome.

OP posts:
octoberafternoons · 03/02/2023 17:59

The police news conference today sounded like the current case of the missing woman doesn't involve another person and is sadly a tragic accident (involving the river).

I understand the fear though. I live near lots of green space but don't feel confident going anywhere isolated on my own. I'm not fit enough to outrun most men or strong enough to defend myself physically. There have been a few local incidents and assaults in recent years, so it doesn't feel like an unfounded fear.

heartchakra · 03/02/2023 17:55

Completely understand. Sad fact. I too used to walk my dogs in local woodland but no longer. Just realised how vulnerable I am. Ditto local fields. I now stick to roads and well used areas and don't walk early on dark winter mornings.

Bamboozle123 · 03/02/2023 17:54

There was someone murdered whilst walking their dog in a completely random attack in my village.

I still walk my dog day and night alone. How could you live in fear of others? You'd never do anything.

I think you should seek help for your anxiety OP.

Ludo19 · 03/02/2023 17:52

I walk my friends boerboel who is about 65kg and a unit of a dog. I walk him (on lead) in a very remote area fields with a ruined mansion house because he's still growing and not good etiquette with other dogs but we're getting there. There are farms that i can see close by. I'm still unsure but he would 100% protect me as I'm part of his family if that makes sense. There had been someone sleeping rough in the ruined stable block, he sensed them before me and had his hackles raised. I thought he'd seen a deer or rabbit. He was puffing and making a noise, not growling, he positioned himself in front of me and stopped dead, the chap emerged and saw us and went back into the ruin. I was glad I had him with me.

Notplayingball · 03/02/2023 17:51

Meant to add that I deliberately vary the route and time of day I walk my dog but still feel same way as OP. Makes no difference.

Notplayingball · 03/02/2023 17:49

YANBU to feel that way at all. Just this week the place I often walk my dog (giant breed) had a guy acting strangely in the distance (daylight hours, around 12pm, no one else was around at this point so I did a U turn and went a different route - followed my gut instinct and walked towards a woman with two small dogs.) I just won't walk in a park if there's no one else around. I never walk in isolated areas on my own either.

lljkk · 03/02/2023 17:43

I spend a lot of time on (calm) rivers. As soon as I saw that river in the telly footage I knew it had to be a suspect.

PoshHorseyBird · 03/02/2023 17:35

I walk my dog in very isolated places as he doesn't like other dogs but he is an enormous German Shepherd and I'm lucky that I feel very safe with him. Do you have any dog owning friends that you could walk with? Maybe walk in busier areas? Hire out an enclosed dog field? The ones I use you can drive in and lock yourself in.

DOBARDAN · 03/02/2023 16:56

I have been feeling as you do for quite some time. Due to my own lived experiences and news items reporting of women who have been attacked, I will not venture out walking on my own, unless on residential streets, and then only in daylight hours.
Its such a shame, but what is the point of walking somewhere like a park, field, or in woods, if you can’t relax and enjoy it.

NoseyNellie · 03/02/2023 16:47

SchoolTripDrama · 03/02/2023 15:24

@NoseyNellie As if self defence poses & kicks are going to help against a strong man throwing his arms around you tightly and dragging you powerfully and quickly! Come on....

No, of course not - and most men would also be caught out by a sneak attack. The point I was making was about victimology and reducing your risk (since eliminating risk totally is impossible). The attacker is ideally looking for someone quiet & compliant - they don’t want fuss or noise. As women were encouraged to take up as little space as possible - to be polite - to not challenge men. I distinctly being told when I was a young teen that if I was attacked I should ‘let him do what he wants - better to be raped than dead’… Well f*ck that - I will go down fighting and if I do end up dead I work at least have the bastards dna under my fingernails.

magicstar1 · 03/02/2023 15:40

I'm lucky enough to have a GSD so don't feel nearly as vulnerable while walking. She hates anyone walking behind us...she stops, turns and watches while growling. That's usually enough to put anyone off stalking us. But on a night walk, in the park, I'll carry a can of pepper spray. I know it's illegal, but I have it anyway. I also have a small baton hanging from the treat bag. That's in case we're attacked by a dog and can't get it away.

SchoolTripDrama · 03/02/2023 15:30

XenoBitch · 02/02/2023 22:18

I walk my dog in the day, and it is a local park where there are usually families and other people anyway.

I agree with sticking to daytimes but what hasn't helped my anxiety is that this poor missing woman went at 9:30am! 😳

SchoolTripDrama · 03/02/2023 15:24

@NoseyNellie As if self defence poses & kicks are going to help against a strong man throwing his arms around you tightly and dragging you powerfully and quickly! Come on....

SchoolTripDrama · 03/02/2023 15:22

I'm terrified of my elderly mother walking her dog. She won’t hear of my concerns though, laughs them off! She goes through woods and everything!

StridTheKiller · 03/02/2023 15:21

Ignore your gut at your peril OP.

BeachBlondey · 03/02/2023 15:16

I do dog boarding, so I always have lots of dogs to walk. You just need to be sensible. My winter routine is different to my summer routine. In the summer, I do my first walk at 7am. In the winter, the first walk is much later, as late as 830am, because I won't go out in the dark. In the summer, dogs have their dinner at 5pm, followed by a walk. In the winter, dinner time is 330pm, so the dogs can be walked whilst it's still light. I don't go in to the woods alone. There's absolutely no need. Stick to well lit, busy places. You can always find grassy areas that are over looked by houses.

nutbrownhare15 · 03/02/2023 15:15

I grew up watching crime thrillers where it was a female victim and male stranger most of the time. As a result I have never felt able to walk alone in countryside so will always stick to open busy parks and streets. I also hate walking after dark and limit it as much as possible It is worth noting that the risk is very small but if it happened would be so catastrophic I won't risk it. This is part of being female for me which I think men just cannot understand.

DingDonkey · 03/02/2023 15:08

I was visiting my parents last summer and took my 4 or 5 month old baby out for a walk through some fields. I had him in my arms and the whole time I was walking I wasn't enjoying this time with my son, I was thinking of Julia James. Men are scary.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 03/02/2023 14:55

oakleaffy · 02/02/2023 23:42

Dogs of that heft ought to keep marauders at bay.. Better than my little Whippet!

Your lovely Whippet might surprise you.

I was once walking our two very soft and very daft small dogs in the dark near our old home. It was rural but definitely a residential area with pavements, mostly covered by street lights and several houses along the route so I felt quite safe.

I was just coming up to a particularly dark section of the route when the softest, daftest of the two went absolutely ballistic barking, snapping and pulling to get at something behind me. Other daft dog quickly followed suit. I jumped out of my skin and turned around to come almost face to face with a runner who got far too close (at least that was the assumption I made at the time, I’m not so sure now). I hadn’t heard him coming at all and couldn’t believe he’d managed to get so near without me noticing. Whether he was a danger to me or not, my usually over friendly dogs terrified him and I think he’d think twice now.

Up until that point I’d always thought that if something went wrong I was on my own with that pair. It was very reassuring to be proved wrong.

ThighMistress · 03/02/2023 14:47

I feel the same, having been attacked over 30 years ago, plus having quite a few nasty experiences since.

Women shouldn’t have to live like this, but what on earth can be done about lone weirdos hanging about? They are and have always been a fact of life; the car enabled them to spread their evil around whereas in past times they would have been “known” in their area.

I agree wit pp that since lockdown there are far more walkers and joggers: sadly a lone male always puts me on high alert. Poor ds enjoys a walk but says he feels for women and does a big thing of crossing the road/giving them a wide berth if he encounters anyone. Mind you, a young fellow in the street randomly punched him last week so I suppose we are all vulnerable Sad

Freshstarts22 · 03/02/2023 14:32

GinClassHeroes · 02/02/2023 22:43

This is rubbing me up the wrong way. It’s not her husbands place to police her movements - she wasn’t doing something inherently dangerous. Millions of women - and men - do the same thing each day. Let’s blame the attacker (if there is one - although admittedly it does look likely, sadly) rather than the woman or her husband.

Im with you on the posting it on social media thing though, it’s the point that her husband should have somehow stopped her that is annoying me.

Can I ask why it’s likely? I thought the police had said they don’t suspect foul play. Tbh will know a lot of stuff they haven’t realised so I think the fact they’ve said this makes it very unlikely.

Sartre · 03/02/2023 14:29

I understand because I try not to go running in the dark for this very reason. I drove past a woman running in the dark (only 5pm but obviously dark at this time of year) a few weeks ago and she was running through a really dodgy area alone with headphones on. She also had dark clothing which isn’t the safest. I wasn’t sure whether she was brave or stupid, veered towards the latter. I tend to run in daylight and stick to main roads.

Do have to remind myself that random attacks are vanishingly rare, you’re most at risk from your own partner statistically.

Supernova23 · 03/02/2023 14:21

No. But I have a large German Shepherd that is very alert to strangers and looks the part, so I'm not worried.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 03/02/2023 14:11

girlfriend44 · 02/02/2023 23:00

You have a duty to your partner and family to try and keep safe if that means no rural walking alone then so be it.

It's not safe it's been proved, a family is in the position where they Don't know where their loved one is tonight.

I’m sorry but this is unfair to all women. How can we say what is/isn’t safe? One woman has gone missing which is utterly heartbreaking, but if God forbid something terrible has happened to her as a result of a third party then it certainly isn’t her fault or responsibility. It’s the fault of the criminal who hurt her (although I’m still hoping against hope that isn’t the case).

One woman going missing doesn’t mean that all women should never venture outside alone again. I walk or run outside most days. I have dogs but they are older now and can’t/won’t walk as far as I do. While I agree with trying to stick with busy/populated routes that isn’t practical when you live in the back end of beyond. I’m busy and it’s already difficult enough to fit my outdoors time in around the daylight (there are no streetlights anywhere nearby) so if I had to drive to go for my walk or to run it probably wouldn’t happen.

I’ve had a few moments when I’ve scared myself with the sound of wood cracking, trees rustling or the odd ‘strange’ (but usually perfectly lovely) man on the same path as me but I truly love and need this time in fresh air so I’ve had to think logically and accept that the chances of anything happening to me are tiny. And fwiw, my dh was far more worried about me running alone when we lived in a city. He doesn’t think twice about it now because it’s so peaceful and rural.

I’ve read the advice from a pp to take a self defence class and I think that may be useful, I use a tracker in case of accident and I’ll continue to wear my Aftershox so I’m aware of my surroundings. But I refuse to stop spending time on my own in beautiful surroundings. Bottom line for me is that even with the anxiety it can bring, I do feel better outside than sitting at home. And surely my first duty is protect my own mental health so that I am able to support my loved ones to
the best of my ability.

SpringtimeCherries · 03/02/2023 13:39

For example, twice I’ve been grabbed, once abroad I was grabbed in broad daylight in a foreign city, in daylight, and pushed against a wall by a man. It was near a touristy area but in an alleyway type place.

I absolutely screamed my head off in a really aggressive way, shouting ‘fire’, ‘get off me’, and I wriggled and moved around as much as I could. It felt really weird to do it, even then in a way my body was not wanting to be so dramatic as I’m quite a quiet, introverted person. But what I think it does is spell ‘trouble’ to the would be attacker. Who knows I could have been unlucky and my attacker would not have stopped, no matter what I did.

But I think many attacks are ‘escalations’ - so I think being a very difficult ‘victim’ who attracts possible attention, or makes it difficult to even be grabbed in the first place (running/avoiding) raises the risk for the attacker and that might be just enough for them to decide that I am not a good ‘victim’. Some attackers do seem to look for easy prey - so don’t be easy prey.