Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Vegan Shoes!

84 replies

PlatesofMeatFeet · 02/02/2023 21:18

A friend has just posted this on FB:

"Keep seeing signs for “vegan shoes”. Is it a way of just selling cheaper non leather shoes at an inflated price"?

I think I agree that it's just a marketing ploy to charge more for uncomfortable plastic shoes?

Or are we both being unreasonable? (Oh and her family are vegan)!

OP posts:
xogossipgirlxo · 03/02/2023 09:19

I would only buy vegan shoes that are breathable. If you buy fake leather shoes, calling them vegan is just a con. They've been in shops since always.

Ginisatonic · 03/02/2023 09:16

underneaththeash · 02/02/2023 22:50

We don’t eat processed animal food. If you’re vegan just flip the packet and you’ll see what you’re eating!

But why do you think vegan food comes from a packet? Some people may eat the fake meat products - not everyone does.

User17649787 · 03/02/2023 09:06

Unfortunately I hadn't noticed they were plastic so they had to go back as plastic makes my feet sweat and doesn't give.

MrsMikeDrop · 03/02/2023 09:03

ThisWOMANWontWheesht · 03/02/2023 08:44

And no you do not absorb calcium from non-diary sources in the same way

"Dairy" is literally for babies. Baby cows. How can it possibly be essential to humans? Many people, especially in parts of Asia and Africa have dairy or lactose intolerance yet can live long healthy lives.

Milk is full of growth hormones and saturated fat. It's thought to increase the risk of various cancers. The environmental impact of dairy farming is significant.

Heard of osteoporosis??

User17649787 · 03/02/2023 09:03

I bought a pair of shoes in Next clearance, the original price was £42, I don't know how they had been marketed originally but £42 is a bit of a stretch for cheap plastic shoes, which they were.

Wiennetta · 03/02/2023 09:02

User17649787 · 03/02/2023 08:40

Isn't the thread about the cheap end of the market bumping the price up rather than specialised vegan shops which have probably always been there.

@User17649787 Yes and agree that there’s definitely an interesting discussion about the greenwashing of cheap, faux leather shoes as ‘vegan’. I was responding to the random comments and generalisations by other posters including abo it vegan diets etc.

User17649787 · 03/02/2023 08:47

The thread is about shoes...

ThisWOMANWontWheesht · 03/02/2023 08:44

And no you do not absorb calcium from non-diary sources in the same way

"Dairy" is literally for babies. Baby cows. How can it possibly be essential to humans? Many people, especially in parts of Asia and Africa have dairy or lactose intolerance yet can live long healthy lives.

Milk is full of growth hormones and saturated fat. It's thought to increase the risk of various cancers. The environmental impact of dairy farming is significant.

User17649787 · 03/02/2023 08:40

Wiennetta · 03/02/2023 08:04

Wow! Another thread that turns into vegan-bashing!

Where to start?

-It’s useful for vegans to have shoes clearly labelled vegan, as just because something isn’t leather doesn’t mean it’s vegan (often glues are made from animal products)
-Not all vegan leather is plastic. There’s loads of much more environmentally friendly alternatives now, pinatex, apple leather, cactus leather etc etc.
-Not all vegan leather is cheap. Have a look at Immaculate Vegan and you’ll find plenty of high end, really well crafted vegan shoes, boots, bags etc. Like this cactus leather bag from Frida Rome.
-There are pretty significant concerns about the environmental impact of leather so all those that think vegan leather = naughty plastic and animal leather = fine, I’d highly recommend reading up on the subject. It’s really not that simple.
-Plenty of official guidance to support that the vegan diet can be healthy for all ages (like this from the BDA).
-It’s not as simple as vegan food = processed, = not processed. Plenty of vegans eat a whole food diet, lots of meat eaters don’t. There’s processed vegan food just as there are processed animal based food.
-It’s not as simple as vegan = healthy/unhealthy, omni = healthy/unhealthy. You can be healthy on either diet. Both require a fair amount of planning and understanding to be optimal.

Isn't the thread about the cheap end of the market bumping the price up rather than specialised vegan shops which have probably always been there.

Wiennetta · 03/02/2023 08:04

Wow! Another thread that turns into vegan-bashing!

Where to start?

-It’s useful for vegans to have shoes clearly labelled vegan, as just because something isn’t leather doesn’t mean it’s vegan (often glues are made from animal products)
-Not all vegan leather is plastic. There’s loads of much more environmentally friendly alternatives now, pinatex, apple leather, cactus leather etc etc.
-Not all vegan leather is cheap. Have a look at Immaculate Vegan and you’ll find plenty of high end, really well crafted vegan shoes, boots, bags etc. Like this cactus leather bag from Frida Rome.
-There are pretty significant concerns about the environmental impact of leather so all those that think vegan leather = naughty plastic and animal leather = fine, I’d highly recommend reading up on the subject. It’s really not that simple.
-Plenty of official guidance to support that the vegan diet can be healthy for all ages (like this from the BDA).
-It’s not as simple as vegan food = processed, = not processed. Plenty of vegans eat a whole food diet, lots of meat eaters don’t. There’s processed vegan food just as there are processed animal based food.
-It’s not as simple as vegan = healthy/unhealthy, omni = healthy/unhealthy. You can be healthy on either diet. Both require a fair amount of planning and understanding to be optimal.

ThisWOMANWontWheesht · 03/02/2023 08:02

Yep, it's a marketing ploy to bump the price up. There are, of course, very good vegan shoes that may be worth the price, but loads of cheap manmade crap now has "vegan" slapped on it as a marketing ploy.

And, because someone went there, anyone - whatever food choice category they fall into - can have a poor, inadequate diet if they are lazy or ignorant about nutrition. A good vegan diet is a million times better than a diet of ready meals, McDonald's and Krispy Kreme.

User17649787 · 03/02/2023 07:59

I would never buy leather sofas or cars with leather seats as I find them uncomfortable, I buy leather shoes though as plastic aggravates my Pompolyx eczema.

TraumaQueenMama · 03/02/2023 07:52

Wool often comes off the dead animal after slaughter. As there's no way to know if it came from a carcass or not vegans err on the side of caution.

It is also that wool is fairly worthless itself and like gelatin, is a by product. It's a by product of a process vegans (and many vegetarians disagree with) this can be because of conditions, the slaughter or various combinations of reasons.

Wool is also scratchy and horrible so I'd be giving it a miss even if it wasn't obtained from stripping down a dead animal.

Leather in particular has multiple issues including the way that it is produced has human rights implications as the fumes.produced in its production have health consequences for the humans involved in the tanning process. Where it's most produced in countries like India it's really not regulated, so although environment wise pleather may be problematic leather is not without its own issues.

And again,. personally I don't get why you'd have leather. Leather sofas for.example, too hot and sticky in summer, cold and not comfy in winter.

But if people want them that's their business. I don't and I think that should be fine.

DarkNecessities · 03/02/2023 07:46

Oh it probably is marketing but that’s ok, surely. There’s a difference between Vegan and Plastic.

Why are people bashing vegans and talking about diet?

User17649787 · 03/02/2023 07:38

It's marketing, plastic hasn't got quite the same ring about it

meetmeatmidnights · 03/02/2023 07:18

@AlansApprentice

It's made from plastic isn't it? Which is derived from oil? Which is made from the bones of tiny sea creatures?

At least it was plastic years ago 😂

MrsMikeDrop · 03/02/2023 05:02

LetTheLiquorTalk · 03/02/2023 02:16

Do you not google things when you don’t understand? There’s plenty of horrific footage showing sheep being kicked and punched whilst being sheared for a start.

Comments like this are so dumb. There's also plenty of farmers who don't abuse animals 🙄 You do know google gives you want to see based on algorithms right?? I despair for humanity when I read things like this 😒

MrsMikeDrop · 03/02/2023 04:59

Marketing. But also fair, I think anyone who is a vegan that wears animal products like leather is a total hypocrite (if they're doing it for animal welfare reasons)

LetTheLiquorTalk · 03/02/2023 02:25

All these people with vegan friends and vegan kids that say vegan things are bad. 🤔😅

SalaDaeng · 03/02/2023 02:22

DD loves doc martens. I didn't know they made vegan ones so I will have a look now.

SalaDaeng · 03/02/2023 02:21

My DC are vegan and have been for years. Having done loads of research they tell me that, environmentally, vegan shoes are slightly worse than leather. I haven't done the research so I can only take on board what they have told me. Ultimately though, they recycle, re-use, buy second hand clothes and re make into something else. I think it is up to all of us to do what we can and what we can afford. Plastic is a massive problem and needs a lot more attention.

LetTheLiquorTalk · 03/02/2023 02:20

MMoon23 · 02/02/2023 23:52

All the vegan hate on here!! Wow.

‘Vegan shoes’ are also helpful for vegans to know they are avoiding other animal products in the manufacturing process, not just leather. A big example would be the glue that is commonly used to bind shoes together, which is an animal product.

I think it’s the same with most shoes, you get what you pay for. My Vegan Dr Martens last me years and years and are ridiculously soft and comfy. You would not be able to tell that they are not leather. I’ve had my current pair for 6 years, worn every work day, and they will easily last for the same time again!

cheap shoes will always be cheap shoes. Irrespective of whether you think a vegan life is morally and nutritionally acceptable (it is).

I have a few pairs of Vegan dr martens. Comfiest shoes ever and never seem to wear!

LetTheLiquorTalk · 03/02/2023 02:16

5foot5 · 03/02/2023 01:02

Not trying to be goady at all but I really don't understand why vegans object to wool. The sheep are going to grow that wool anyway and will be really uncomfortable if they are not sheered. So why not wear it?

Do you not google things when you don’t understand? There’s plenty of horrific footage showing sheep being kicked and punched whilst being sheared for a start.

Marie2023 · 03/02/2023 02:05

underneaththeash · 02/02/2023 21:24

*they lack essential amino acids (so kids don't grow), calcium, B12, iron.
Vegan substitutes are really over processed and full of shite.
It's a really good thing to just eat non processed fruit and veg a few times a week - but not full time as we are omnivores and need a balanced diet

And no you do not absorb calcium from non-diary sources in the same way.

What a load of bollocks!

StrawHatOnTheParcelShelf · 03/02/2023 01:57

5foot5 · 03/02/2023 01:02

Not trying to be goady at all but I really don't understand why vegans object to wool. The sheep are going to grow that wool anyway and will be really uncomfortable if they are not sheered. So why not wear it?

The issue is with farming in general, and the exploitation of animals by humans. You don't have to look closely into any animal industry to find cruel practices.