Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it slightly strange that school is encouraging this

96 replies

AsIfIWish · 02/02/2023 16:29

Just got a letter from our school (sent to all parents) about attendance, starting with congratulations for good attendance, but then going into more detail of what they actually want. One bit says:

"Sometimes your child may be too ill to attend; however they could go to school if they have one of the following symptoms:
• Headache
• Stomach ache
• Ear ache
• Cough
• Cold
• Sore throat

I don't expect my kids to be 'wimps' as my dad would say (and I only let mine stay at home if they seem to exhibit quite bad symptoms - e.g. my youngest sometimes mentions something mild and I encourage them to go and then they bounce out happily at the end of the day) but likewise I do find it a little odd to be seemingly encouraging kids to go to school when ill.

Maybe these things are aimed primarily at those parents who keep their child off for every little thing? What do you think and what are your schools' policies? This is a secondary school btw.

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 02/02/2023 22:25

Common sense isn't that common. Once you accept that, you realise why schools have to point these things out.

You'd think common sense would mean an obviously unwell child needs keeping off (so don't give them a ton of calpol and then magically be uncontactable all day, leaving your poor child upset and unwell at school/nursery) and if they've got a runny nose then send them in.

You've got to realise that some parents are the sort of parents who read "no trainers" in a uniform policy, go and buy an £80 pair of branded trainers and then complain that the school say they are trainers. School communications have to deal with that level of parental lack of common sense.

Ariautec · 02/02/2023 22:15

I'll keep posting on here FYI.
Department For Education have issued new guidance to schools and LA’s - to be fully in place by September 2023. This is to combat the significant drop in school attendance since the pandemic.

www.gov.uk/government/publications/working-together-to-improve-school-attendance

LetTheLiquorTalk · 02/02/2023 22:14

We get parents calling in because their child feels unwell - what does that mean? What's unwell about them? Be specific.

When my kids have been ill, I mostly just
say they’re unwell in recent years, as unfortunately the office staff like to gossip. Only when it’s been something like covid have I said the reason in more recent years.

So absolutely some parents need to be reminded that if a child is only mildly unwell, then dose them with pain relief and send them in. The school will call to collect if need be.

That hasn’t been done on a few occasions with my own kids and others I know unfortunately. I’ve arrived to pick my children up to find them asleep as they’ve felt so ill but school didn’t call me. My daughter was sick and they told her to have some water and go back to class. My friends son was injured in PE and despite not using his arm for the rest of the day and going to the nurse, they didn’t call home. He had actually broken it!

My parents were always strict about attending school and it definitely affects my work ethic as an adult.

If my kids don’t feel up to school, they don’t go. Their attendance is mostly good but there’s nothing worse than being around noisy kids if you feel rubbish. Some of my kids friends have parents who don’t let them have a day off unless they have a bad stomach bug. They say they dislike their parents and don’t respect them. I let my kids decide if they’re well enough once they were at secondary, they’re good kids and want to do well at school. They have a good attitude to their studies, one is doing a levels, works and volunteers so I don’t think you need to be super strict to have kids with a good work ethic. It’s just as important that they know for the future when to say they’re not well and need to rest.

lanthanum · 02/02/2023 22:08

It's a difficult one. I have let DD stay off with fairly minor symptoms, but clearly enough that the day would be unpleasant. She is bright and never had any difficulty catching up, and on each occasion we knew there was nothing major she would miss. I really didn't think the damage to her education was going to be enough to justify a miserable day. If she'd done it a lot, I'd have been less willing to let her stay off, but it was only occasionally.

However on one occasion she had a really rotten cold and I really didn't think she should be going in, but she had assessments in both the first two lessons. She insisted on going in, and a friend took her to the medical room after the second lesson, and she was sent home. That did demonstrate to me that she was willing to push through if there was a good reason.

Marleymoo42 · 02/02/2023 21:58

The school is due Ofsted and they know their attendance data will prevent them from getting the grade they want. No matter how hard they work or what grades they produce, it's all out of their control because attendance is seen as the school's issue not the parent's issue.

Of course there are a minority of parents who need support and incentives to get their kids to school. Often they are parents with mental health issues and a poor experience of school themselves.

90% of what schools do is a tick box exercise for Ofsted and doesn't reflect the human opinions of the school leaders.

BankOfDave · 02/02/2023 21:50

School governor here.

Schools have to have an attendance policy and you’d be surprised at the lack of common sense ‘some’ parents demonstrate, hence the prescriptive examples.

Ultimately it is what’s right for your child given a particular set of circumstances. Someone having a one off headache vs a series of cluster headaches under investigation with the GP is quite different.

Yellowtrouser · 02/02/2023 21:49

I wonder if this is on the back of Covid and people feeling they should stay at home with mild symptoms in case it was Covid. Now the school want to go back to the no of 4 years ago so students miss less?

SnackSizeRaisin · 02/02/2023 21:43

Storywriter · 02/02/2023 18:45

If this is a secondary they'll be worried about their ofsted rating and results. If the last few years have taught us anything it's that it's not a good idea to send people who are unwell into environments where disease spreads like wildfire. I wonder if the school still opens windows as a matter of course? What's their policy on Strep A? That starts as a bit of a sore throat.

Hmm. I disagree. If the last 2 years taught us anything, it's that we shouldn't isolate ourselves to try to avoid catching mild viruses. 2 years of lockdown and restrictions have resulted in extremely high rates of strep A, chicken pox, RSV. More children have died as a result of these than would ever have died of covid. Not to mention the mental health problems, social problems in young children, anxiety in adults, etc etc. (I know the lockdowns and restrictions were not to benefit children).

Longdarkcloud · 02/02/2023 21:08

To the posters saying a DC with a strep throat could go to school if on antibiotics:
In our area you’d need to keep the DC at home while you tried to get through to the surgery, waited for a triage call back and then either attended an appointment and got a prescription filled or waited to pick up a prescription phoned through to the pharmacy.
Turning up to the surgery without an appointment is banned and it can take literally hours to get through on the phone.

plumduck · 02/02/2023 20:35

SillySausage81 · 02/02/2023 17:05

Most of those can be very mild and bearable, or they can be debilitating. Many of them aren't contagious either (tummy ache, headache).

But if everyone took time off school/work every time they had one of those ailments, the country would grind to a halt! Most people with a mild cough or cold can definitely go to work/school.

In a local Facebook group the other day there was a mum asking how other mums coped with their pre-school kids being off sick all the time... it transpired her 3 year old had only been to pre-school for about 2 weeks out of the whole of the autumn term because she thought you had to keep them at home for every little cough and sniffle!!!

Those are the sorts of parents who need to be told "actually, you can send your kid in with mild sniffles".

Thing is during the covid times they were really hot on that at our nursery. So many PCR tests!

CoffeeWithCheese · 02/02/2023 20:29

Depends how affected the child was with the list of "approved" bugs as to if I'd keep them off or not - with DD1 it tends to be really obvious and I worry if she goes quiet and stops talking! It's my decision as a parent to make - not some gatekeeper at the school office though.

OoooohMatron · 02/02/2023 20:22

I wouldn't send my child in with an earache, it's so painful. I've had a couple as an adult and was in tears (not usually a wimp)! Other ailments on the list I'd send them in if mild.

fridaytwattery · 02/02/2023 19:52

I don't see anything wrong with that list. It's reasonably good guidance for those parents who feel that if their child has a sniffle they should keep them home. This is the season for sniffles/colds/coughs etc and it's perfectly normal for many people to just get on with life if it's mild. Building a natural immune system after Covid is going to take time.

A real problem is when a parent's anxiety over illness is passed into their child causing the child to be anxious. Perspective is needed.

georgarina · 02/02/2023 19:43

Stomach ache without vomiting/cough or sore throat without fever = mine would be in

EmmaDilemma5 · 02/02/2023 19:35

AnnesBrokenSlate · 02/02/2023 19:28

It's an odd and vaguely irresponsible list considering the sore throat, cough and cold could be Covid or strep - which are both contagious. Headaches and stomach-aches can also be pointers of more serious conditions. My DSIS is a paediatric and former high school nurse, she's wondering which medical professional suggested that list to them. It smacks of a school struggling with attendance and being quite reckless with their students' health. Although arguably most parents will ignore it and still make their own calls about their DCs' health.

Once on antibiotics a child can go into school with Strep. For the vast majority of people the infection is mild and doesn't do serious harm. Whereas missing school regularly is harmful.

EmmaDilemma5 · 02/02/2023 19:34

I work at a primary school where 25% of pupils are persistent absentees. This is a middle class, small school.

We get parents calling in because their child feels unwell - what does that mean? What's unwell about them? Be specific.

Or siblings off because one has a cough.

Sally has a cold and won't be in this week, she's tested negative for Covid but just in case...

Now I get that when you're ill you're not always able to function well enough for school. If a child is genuinely not themselves then it's much better to have a day to recover.

But you'd be surprised how many children are missing large chunks of their education through mild illnesses. This won't affect the school. In fact, teachers would rather not have to have any illnesses in class. But it will affect that child's long term opportunities in life.

So absolutely some parents need to be reminded that if a child is only mildly unwell, then dose them with pain relief and send them in. The school will call to collect if need be.

My parents were always strict about attending school and it definitely affects my work ethic as an adult.

Testina · 02/02/2023 19:32

“Maybe these things are aimed primarily at those parents who keep their child off for every little thing?”

Well there you go, you’ve answered your own question.

AnnesBrokenSlate · 02/02/2023 19:28

It's an odd and vaguely irresponsible list considering the sore throat, cough and cold could be Covid or strep - which are both contagious. Headaches and stomach-aches can also be pointers of more serious conditions. My DSIS is a paediatric and former high school nurse, she's wondering which medical professional suggested that list to them. It smacks of a school struggling with attendance and being quite reckless with their students' health. Although arguably most parents will ignore it and still make their own calls about their DCs' health.

Sleepless1096 · 02/02/2023 19:21

I send my DC in with everything except vomiting, fever and excludable diseases.

Hellodarknessmyoldpal · 02/02/2023 19:18

At secondary age you should be able to have a sensible conversation about how they are feeling. If kids stayed off as soon as they had any of those symptoms they'd never be in.

LetTheLiquorTalk · 02/02/2023 19:18

My kids school has shown themselves to be more interested in attendance than wellbeing so I just ignore anything about attendance from school now. I’m a responsible parent and don’t need their input.

Any school that is ok with a member of staff telling kids that covid is over so they should be in school every day when one of the kids had just lost a parent to covid can fuck off. Oh, and period pain isn’t a reason to be off school either apparently.... according to a male member of staff, who would definitely know. 🙄

WandaWonder · 02/02/2023 19:15

Like anything parents can use their brains, the school is trying to suggest students don't need to stay off everytime they sneeze type thing

If I parent really thinks a child is that unwell to go to school they don't send them

DemonHost · 02/02/2023 19:08

It does depend, ear-ache can be horrendous - the worst on that list in my experience.

Kanaloa · 02/02/2023 19:07

I mean they aren’t saying the kids must attend with these illnesses - just that they can. So if your child has a headache/cold etc you use your judgement and decide whether they’re able to attend with medicine or whether they are too unwell and should rest at home.

Tangerinie · 02/02/2023 19:05

GettingStuffed · 02/02/2023 17:12

My dad was a teacher and I was sent in with everything, except actual vomiting. The number of times I was sent home was unbelievable. Mind you my reputation at work was that if I rang in sick I must have been really sick , noone questioned me if I did, rarely, pull a sickie.

My mum was a nurse and my dad was a doctor. If we said we were sick they whipped out the thermometer/stethoscope/torch to find evidence 😂. If no evidence and we weren't collapsed in a heap we had to go in

Swipe left for the next trending thread