Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Rape jokes - AIBU?

131 replies

dalecooper · 02/02/2023 16:25

I feel a bit shaken and want to know if I have just made a massive deal out of nothing or if I was justified.
I was talking to a male friend who I have not seen for ages and who I used to go out with for a bit a long while ago. We get on really well and he is generally a really sound guy.
We were talking about men coming onto women and he made a joke about how women dress and I said that sounded predatory. He said that was the joke and he was being sarcastic but he got that I didn't want to hear it and he wouldn't say anything like that again but in the next breath made another flippant comment about rape. Not saying he agreed with it or anything, just a flippant comment which I didn't like.

I said no women find rape jokes funny and that men shouldn't either.
He backed off but then said actually some women DO find it funny and that I should not appoint myself spokeswoman for my gender.

This made me really angry. I thought about it for about an hour and then messaged him to say any man that makes rape jokes or is so casual about it has real issues and that NO women do find rape jokes funny and I was not trying to be any kind of spokeswoman.

I ended by saying to him "Don't contact me again". I have not heard from him since - but it has only been about 45 minutes...

DO any women really find rape jokes funny? I cannot honestly believe that any woman would. Would you have reacted in the same way? Was I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
Carlycat · 03/02/2023 01:35

He's a woman hating twat. I'd bin the fucker and tell him why. Women need to up their fucking expectations from men

Carlycat · 03/02/2023 01:32

Ofcourseshecan · 02/02/2023 16:42

Trigger warning.
One of my sexual-assault experiences included being knocked down, punched and kicked, then grabbed by the neck and my head rammed against a wall several times, then the attacker knelt on my back, grabbed my hair and jerked my head backwards several times presumably trying to break my back.
I survived (with injuries) because he panicked and ran off.
I know, hilarious. But like the OP, I just don’t seem to get rape jokes.

I'd torch the fucker. Huge hugs to you Flowers.

WineIsMyMainVice · 03/02/2023 01:16

YADNBU!!
Well done for calling it out!!

MrsMikeDrop · 03/02/2023 01:07

CementTrucker · 02/02/2023 22:44

Yep, thank goodness someone’s standing up for the rights of some women to enjoy rape jokes. And how dare you presume to speak for other women,op! When you think about it, maybe he’s the feminist here. All very reminiscent of those men who passionately speak up for women who love being prostitutes in the face of the threat from spoilsport fascist feminists. Some men seem to get very exercised when certain, very specific female ‘freedoms’ are questioned.

While I agree with pps saying that unfortunately getting bogged down in the do-or-don’t-ALL-women-hate-rape-jokes debate has allowed this tosser to dodge the real point, this particular (pedantic, sanctimonious) sentiment is actually as offensive as the original joke in its way.

Please stick to your guns and lose this guy from your life.

Apologies, but this did make me laugh at the ridiculousness of the situation ... "thank goodness someone's standing up for the rights of some women to enjoy rape jokes" Even if it was a misunderstanding, the guy is a bit of a dick for not letting it go, think you're better off rid of him. No great loss to you OP.

JarByTheDoor · 02/02/2023 23:18

JudgeRudy · 02/02/2023 21:46

@JarByTheDoor "But that message carries a subtext: he is better than those men because he chooses not to rape and to make poor excuses for it. The joke is a subtle, probably unintentional reminder that the reason he has not raped you is that he has chosen not to, and he probably could if he wanted to (and that the most pathetic of excuses would protect him from consequences). I doubt he meant to send that message but it's kind of implicit in the fabric of the joke.".........but this is just you're interpretation not an accepted psychological analysis.
I seriously doubt that was going through his head at all. I imagine he was most likely thinking "What? You seriously think l could be predatory? Yeah that's right I'm a wolf in sheep's clothing and get my rape cloak on when I fancy sexual assaulting some poor woman (sarcastically)."

I'm not talking about what was going through his head, or any psychological analyses. (I notice you did, though. Not even sure where you're getting this psychology thing from.

I'm talking about the layers of meanings of what people are saying when they talk to each other, what's explicit and implicit and how human communication has a lot of tricky ways of getting different types of things across to other people.

Still assuming the friend was mocking misogynist rapists:

We can understand the joke in that we get why a nasty misogynist would find "maybe-equals-yes" type jokes funny. We can then also understand it on the level where we laugh at the irony of a decent bloke pretending to sound like a misogynist in order to mock them.

We can also understand it on the level of what a person is communicating about themselves via what they choose to say. When you mock or criticise someone in some way for something, you generally implicitly position yourself in relation to the person you're mocking or criticising — different, or opposing, or better, generally something like that. We automatically listen for this kind of social and relational communication lying beneath what people say.

The ways that we use what we say to communicate with each other on multiple levels means that when it's coming from a man towards a woman, the friend's rape joke — even if intended as anti-rapist — can easily result in discomfort if the woman feels she's being implicitly invited to consider what makes this man different to rapists.

Or of course the conversation might not develop that way, different people might prioritise different aspects of what's being communicated, or they might understand it in different ways…

What I'm saying is that arguing, "But the joke was against rapists and mocking misogynists so it's fine" doesn't work well as a blanket statement, especially when the circumstance is a man joking about rape to a woman shortly after she discloses a recent uncomfortable situation with a man. There are lots of ways ways that making even an anti-rape rape joke can result in communication that hurts someone or gives an unintended negative impression, resulting in upset people and damaged relationships; I was just talking about one way that could happen, as an example.

NowDoYouBelieveMe · 02/02/2023 23:08

Depends who the joke is 'on'.

If the joke is laughing at rapists, or how terrible the criminal justice system is at prosecuting it, or highlighting how our society is steeped in rape culture, I might find it funny (not all jokes are funny).

If the joke is laughing at victims or making out rape is not serious or awful or something, then no, I wouldn't find it funny and I would judge the person telling it negatively.

CementTrucker · 02/02/2023 23:06

@MargaritMargo - that office joke is only tangentially about rape, though. The subject of the joke isn’t rape, it’s how David Brent’s mind instantly goes somewhere appalling and the yawning chasm between Brent and his employees who all grasp how unacceptable and weird what he’s just done is, and the humour comes from the abrupt shift in mood and his childish, petulant behaviour. I think it’s a very clever and very funny scene, but it’s not a rape joke.

Unfortunately, many men do find rape funny and I have heard jokes about it. They have a completely different effect on me.

JudgeRudy · 02/02/2023 23:00

LookingOldTheseDays · 02/02/2023 22:49

No - he made two separate rape jokes, and the second was made after she told him why she was uncomfortable with it.

This has got boundary pushing written all over it. The initial joke. Then pressing her to explain why it made her nervous, rather than simply accepting it. Then making the second joke.

.............
He said 'depends what she was wearing' and something about girls not meaning what they say and everyone knows that two no's and a maybe really mean yes. This was the initial joke and I then said 'that's what predators say'

He said yes that was the joke and then I said that that sort of joke made me nervous. He wanted to know why - was it because I thought he was predatory. I said it as because if men think like that I just don't particularly want to have anything to do with them and also that you can get a nasty surprise from the 'nicest' of guys.

That is when he made a further joke about having a rape-cloak.

We are both reading the same words. Putting it in bold doesn't make it different. We've both shared our interpretations with each each other and others and they're very different. I agree thatcsomeone who has no regard or someone else's boundaries isn't a nice person. I just don't believe that's what's happened here.
I'm not engaging further. Have the last post if you wish.

LookingOldTheseDays · 02/02/2023 22:51

Men who don't respect women's boundaries, or who expect women to explain and justify their boundaries, are not good men. Particularly when the boundary in question relates to the topic of rape.

LookingOldTheseDays · 02/02/2023 22:49

JudgeRudy · 02/02/2023 22:43

Again, we see it differently. He did stop when he saw she was upset. She said he was offensive. He took note and stopped and listened as she explained (presumably because he cared). It should have ended there but she continued so she by virtually accusing him of being a sex pest. Now HEs offended but SHE continued, so hes sniped back with a sarcastic comment. Still she continued by cutting contact with him.

I think his only mistake was to presume she would know he was he was joking and had not intended to upset her. Arguably the joke was in poor taste but he did not continue to disregard her boundaries, he made a remark in response to her accusation. I'd be very passed off if someone as good as told me I was a sex pest. That's awful. Far far worse than the misplaced joke.

Let's agree to disagree on interpretations but agree they're perhaps not ideal friends.

No - he made two separate rape jokes, and the second was made after she told him why she was uncomfortable with it.

This has got boundary pushing written all over it. The initial joke. Then pressing her to explain why it made her nervous, rather than simply accepting it. Then making the second joke.

.............
He said 'depends what she was wearing' and something about girls not meaning what they say and everyone knows that two no's and a maybe really mean yes. This was the initial joke and I then said 'that's what predators say'

He said yes that was the joke and then I said that that sort of joke made me nervous. He wanted to know why - was it because I thought he was predatory. I said it as because if men think like that I just don't particularly want to have anything to do with them and also that you can get a nasty surprise from the 'nicest' of guys.

That is when he made a further joke about having a rape-cloak.

CementTrucker · 02/02/2023 22:44

007DoubleOSeven · 02/02/2023 16:41

then said actually some women DO find it funny and that I should not appoint myself spokeswoman for my gender.

I would actually be angrier about this and I get angry enough at rape jokes

Yep, thank goodness someone’s standing up for the rights of some women to enjoy rape jokes. And how dare you presume to speak for other women,op! When you think about it, maybe he’s the feminist here. All very reminiscent of those men who passionately speak up for women who love being prostitutes in the face of the threat from spoilsport fascist feminists. Some men seem to get very exercised when certain, very specific female ‘freedoms’ are questioned.

While I agree with pps saying that unfortunately getting bogged down in the do-or-don’t-ALL-women-hate-rape-jokes debate has allowed this tosser to dodge the real point, this particular (pedantic, sanctimonious) sentiment is actually as offensive as the original joke in its way.

Please stick to your guns and lose this guy from your life.

JudgeRudy · 02/02/2023 22:43

LookingOldTheseDays · 02/02/2023 22:26

He didn't assure her he wasn't.

He actually repeated the behaviour with another joke. That's boundary pushing, when the woman he is interacting with has made her feelings clear.

You know what else involves ignoring women's boundaries, right?

Again, we see it differently. He did stop when he saw she was upset. She said he was offensive. He took note and stopped and listened as she explained (presumably because he cared). It should have ended there but she continued so she by virtually accusing him of being a sex pest. Now HEs offended but SHE continued, so hes sniped back with a sarcastic comment. Still she continued by cutting contact with him.

I think his only mistake was to presume she would know he was he was joking and had not intended to upset her. Arguably the joke was in poor taste but he did not continue to disregard her boundaries, he made a remark in response to her accusation. I'd be very passed off if someone as good as told me I was a sex pest. That's awful. Far far worse than the misplaced joke.

Let's agree to disagree on interpretations but agree they're perhaps not ideal friends.

MargaritMargo · 02/02/2023 22:35

Rape isn’t a funny subject.

But that doesn’t mean you can’t have humour in unfunny subjects.

Have you never seen that scene in The Office (British version) where they are doing the customer service training and David Brent is so frustrating with the trainer he screams “I THINK THERES BEEN A RAPE UP THERE!!!!”

that scene is absolutely hilarious. It’s funny af.

rape is not funny though. It’s all in the context and delivery isn’t it. No one is laughing and pointing at victims of rape.

No one finds rape funny, but it can be the subject of a joke, in a way which is not derogatory or playing down its seriousness

LookingOldTheseDays · 02/02/2023 22:26

JudgeRudy · 02/02/2023 21:34

That's not how I'm reading him. In my opinion from what we've been told it sounds like he was joking (not deliberately telling a joke) in response to something she had said. He seemed offended that she would think he was predatory. He assured her he wasn't.Theres no indication that he is.

He didn't assure her he wasn't.

He actually repeated the behaviour with another joke. That's boundary pushing, when the woman he is interacting with has made her feelings clear.

You know what else involves ignoring women's boundaries, right?

Sazzling · 02/02/2023 22:26

dalecooper · 02/02/2023 22:19

Sazzling I have to say that your comment makes little sense. I am not responding strongly 'to any and every thing'. I did have a response to the way in which he flippantly bantered about rape.

I love dark humour. I love Ricky Gervais. I am not a sunny twee innocent type who can't see the humour in things. Quite the opposite actually.

I have been thinking about it a lot this evening and in his message back to me he was very patronising. As though I should chill out and not make such a big deal of it. Like I was the problem. He didn't actually apologise to me at all. I think that is terribly arrogant of him. He does not know what I have experienced in my life or what my friends and family have experienced. He is joking about something that could affect me and those closest to me.

Some dark jokes are ok but not others?

You can't do that. It's also no fun living in some competitive woke world where people are trying to be offended. Just ask him not to tell jokes like that to you and move on.

LookingOldTheseDays · 02/02/2023 22:23

Sazzling · 02/02/2023 21:52

People feeling the need to react strongly to any and every thing is part of the divisions we have as a country and which won't work out well for us.

You think reacting strongly to discussions or jokes about rape is weird?

A large percentage of women have been raped. It's not weird to then react strongly to it.

dalecooper · 02/02/2023 22:19

Sazzling I have to say that your comment makes little sense. I am not responding strongly 'to any and every thing'. I did have a response to the way in which he flippantly bantered about rape.

I love dark humour. I love Ricky Gervais. I am not a sunny twee innocent type who can't see the humour in things. Quite the opposite actually.

I have been thinking about it a lot this evening and in his message back to me he was very patronising. As though I should chill out and not make such a big deal of it. Like I was the problem. He didn't actually apologise to me at all. I think that is terribly arrogant of him. He does not know what I have experienced in my life or what my friends and family have experienced. He is joking about something that could affect me and those closest to me.

OP posts:
Sazzling · 02/02/2023 21:52

People feeling the need to react strongly to any and every thing is part of the divisions we have as a country and which won't work out well for us.

NeonBoomerang · 02/02/2023 21:50

You aren't being unreasonable.

Not all women are offended by rape jokes though. My sense of humour is quite warped. I've been raped more than once, if it's relevant.

CaffeineFreeEverything · 02/02/2023 21:47

@Isheabastard

I love your phrase ... "We need more stroppy, opinionated women in this world, not less"!

JudgeRudy · 02/02/2023 21:46

JarByTheDoor · 02/02/2023 18:50

That doesn't really automatically make it okay. OP told the friend about a very recent situation where she was vulnerable and receiving unwanted male attention. Friend made a joke, and let's say it was targeting and mocking men who make bad excuses for rape. This is a man, talking to a woman who may have recently felt threatened by another man, using humour to convey to a woman, "I am not like the men who choose to rape and to make poor excuses for it; I look down on them". But that message carries a subtext: he is better than those men because he chooses not to rape and to make poor excuses for it. The joke is a subtle, probably unintentional reminder that the reason he has not raped you is that he has chosen not to, and he probably could if he wanted to (and that the most pathetic of excuses would protect him from consequences). I doubt he meant to send that message but it's kind of implicit in the fabric of the joke.

@JarByTheDoor "But that message carries a subtext: he is better than those men because he chooses not to rape and to make poor excuses for it. The joke is a subtle, probably unintentional reminder that the reason he has not raped you is that he has chosen not to, and he probably could if he wanted to (and that the most pathetic of excuses would protect him from consequences). I doubt he meant to send that message but it's kind of implicit in the fabric of the joke.".........but this is just you're interpretation not an accepted psychological analysis.
I seriously doubt that was going through his head at all. I imagine he was most likely thinking "What? You seriously think l could be predatory? Yeah that's right I'm a wolf in sheep's clothing and get my rape cloak on when I fancy sexual assaulting some poor woman (sarcastically)."

LightSpeeds · 02/02/2023 21:40

I would be shocked if any of the men in my life made comments like your 'friend' made. They just don't say those sorts of things and are respectful towards women.

Maybe you were surprised that your friend said those things as maybe you didn't think he was 'like that'.

I'd be staying on my high horse with him. There's currently a growing tidal wave of abuse, misogyny and entitlement in men towards women. This is just one more man surfing that wave.

LimeTwists · 02/02/2023 21:38

He sounds like an absolute dickhead. An immature, stupid dickhead. He can’t even accept that you as an individual might find his hilarious rape jokes anything other than funny. As for the woman he knows who was raped who finds rape jokes funny: either he’s a liar or he cannot read her discomfort and polite ‘haha’. It is not possible to conceive that a raped woman would find rape jokes funny. I mean, think about it. Wtaf.

RiverSkater · 02/02/2023 21:37

You called him out and he's turned it on you as not having a sense of humour because other women would laugh.

If they did then it would be to appease a wanker like him.

CaffeineFreeEverything · 02/02/2023 21:34

No decent woman finds them funny!