Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Having second thoughts about doing IVF after i've just found out this information

116 replies

Hdaniels11 · 02/02/2023 15:56

I've been in the infertility world for about 3 years and have been thinking about IVF for a while. I've been looking into it and google and everywhere i look it says IVF babies have a 50% increased risk of heart defects. WHAT? Is that true? do he literally never heard anything about that until now.
50% is massive!

I also learnt that Babies born from IVF have a much higher risk of any type of childhood cancer, as well as hepatic tumours compared with children born from natural conception.
I know ANY child or person can inevitably get cancer at any time but seeing all this stuff about their being a higher risk is scaring me.

I would love some insight into how accurate this is?
Has anyone got children made from IVF with these issues?
Aibu to be worried

OP posts:
Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 02/02/2023 18:01

FrownedUpon · 02/02/2023 16:23

More chance of SEN as well unfortunately.

My son was born via IVF. At a recent parents meeting with his teacher she told us that she thinks he is the brightest child in the class. He’s only 7 but he is excelling at most things and is especially good at reading and maths. I play chess with him and he often wins against me. He was born a few weeks premature and is little for his age but other than that is fine

Eixample · 02/02/2023 17:58

50% of a very small number is still a very small number. It isn’t massive at all.

Misty999 · 02/02/2023 17:54

Step away from Google and go for your IVF if you want a child there are no guarantees in life. The option to have IVF is a privellage

PurBal · 02/02/2023 17:54

Interesting statistics if true. But what’s the “absolute” risk? Double the risk sounds high, but if it goes from 1% likelihood to 2% is it really that big?

Longdarkcloud · 02/02/2023 17:51

Sorry I don’t have a link but within the last 2 weeks there was a report in the Guardian re scientific research which showed IVF children are no different regarding meeting developmental targets from naturally conceived children.

Stroganoffo · 02/02/2023 17:51

Is it because of the older age really which is increasing the risk , more chances of twin pregnancy, pregnancy complications rather than it being just because of IVF ?

Porkandbeans1 · 02/02/2023 17:47

I considered IVF and chose not to go through with it. I haven't read about the increased risks you have mentioned in your post but for me it was the success rate. It is incredibly expensive and invasive with only a 19 percent success rate for my age group.

LivesinLondon2000 · 02/02/2023 17:40

Very surprised to hear this. I know lots of ivf babies and don’t know of any with significant health conditions at all.
I do know that being a twin is linked to various adverse health outcomes but even so, none of the twins I know have anny health issues either.
it’s not something I’d worry about personally

BigMadAdrian · 02/02/2023 17:39

I also have a naturally conceived dc who had a congenital heart defect. We were told that statistically this made it more likely that a subsequent dc would also have a defect - 1 in 70, rather than 1 in 100 for a baby who didn't have a sibling with CHD. We still had another child. And, although dd was poorly as a baby, her defect was repaired and she is perfectly well now.

Coffeedoesntcutit · 02/02/2023 17:33

My non-IVF baby was born with a heart defect, during the first COVID lockdown. He had it repaired at 4 months old and is a thriving almost 3 year old now with no after effects. Yes it was horrendously stressful at the time (1 hour visiting per day when he was in intensive care etc) but as someone who has struggled to remain pregnant and experienced multiple miscarriages I am so so grateful to have him and would not be put off from IVF if this is something that would help me on that basis.

IVF has never been a consideration for me so I can't empathize on that level but I do think you need to think about the fact that there is risk with all life. Your child is not going to go through life without experiencing some difficulty at some point with some aspect of their physical or mental health - we can't control everything and need to learn to live with the ups and downs and decide whether the potential joy that children can bring is worth the possible risks.

Pssspsss · 02/02/2023 17:29

ReneBumsWombats · 02/02/2023 16:28

Does IVF make it more likely that an embryo that wouldn't normally be strong enough to implant naturally does in fact implant? I was under the impression that with IVF, implanting is a trickier part of the process than getting a viable embryo, but I don't have experience of this so I don't know.

Hmm, well they give you progesterone to make your womb the most hospitable it can be to help implantation.

but they really only select pretty strong embryos. It’s been a while but I think they got 9 eggs from me, 6 fertilised, 2 did nothing, 2 started dividing and then stopped, and 2 got to a stage on day 3 post fertilisation where they could be implanted but had started to slow down so they went for replacement on day 3 as opposed to waiting for day 5.

of the two embryos replaced one implanted and we went on to have a healthy baby.

fwiw our fertility is classed as unexplained but I’m fairly convinced after studying my cycles the issue is my progesterone levels drop off too quickly after ovulation not giving the fertilised eggs a chance to implant. The fact that an embryo implanted with high doses of progesterone during my IVF had my almost certain that’s what it was

LondonJax · 02/02/2023 17:26

Our son is IVF and has a heart defect. Congenital heart disease includes hole in the heart right through to major defects needing surgery. DS's is aortic stenosis which means instead of three leaflets to the aortic valve he has two so the valve didn't open properly. He's had two procedures at a London hospital, day surgery, and is now a teenager. He may have to have a valve transplant later in life. But my dad had open heart surgery for a bypass and his mum had a pace maker so heart issues are in the family.

BUT...1 in 100 babies have congenital heart disease in the UK at birth (holes in the heart being the most common). My cousin, who is in his 70s, had a hole in the heart that was only picked up in a routine check at 52 years old! And Arnold Swazenegger has exactly the same valve problem as our DS - and I doubt he was IVF.

So who knows? A straw poll of parents who we met through a heart charity we belong to, associated with the hospital DS was treated by, says the majority of children were not IVF. It's not scientific obviously - just a chat at a conference.

Our DS found out three of his friends are IVF babies - no heart problems.

Singmesomethingnew · 02/02/2023 17:25

I think you should put something in the title, op, this could be distressing reading for people having done/doing ivf.
My amazing Dd was conceived through ivf and reading all this is just upsetting, especially the way it’s been written.

RunRaggedRightNow · 02/02/2023 17:21

I didn’t know this before embarking on IVF and my IVF child has a heart defect (it seems that even the medical professionals don’t know this as the heart defect wasn’t picked up during my many antenatal scans or even in the immediate post natal period!)

However, I don’t think the knowledge would have stopped me. There is also a wide spectrum of heart defects - my IVF baby’s one actually self resolved after about 18 months. So even if your baby was in the 1.5% it’s not necessarily anything to worry about.

HistoryFanatic · 02/02/2023 16:58

Are you really sure you want children if you are put off by such a tiny risk?

ArrrMeHearties · 02/02/2023 16:57

I conceived ds2 naturally and he had a heart anomaly so it happens with falling pregnant naturally too

Kitkatcatflap · 02/02/2023 16:55

IVF twins here - they will be 16 in 3 months. They were both 7 weeks early but played football and basket ball when younger, they swim in lakes (we live in Scandinavia) do regular school jogs and ski. One had baby asthma but grew out of it, the other had eczema but grew out of it. All good so far?

My DH and I both have a history of heart disease in our families but it never stopped us trying for a family. We are aware of it and have both had recent monitoring as a precaution. We were never discouraged from trying by clinic and trust me they do extensive tests.

Are you really sure you want to do IVF? It's expensive, invasive and not an automatic jackpot - it's natural to feel apprehensive, especially after trying to conceive for 3 years

Good luck OP.

FictionalCharacter · 02/02/2023 16:53

ReneBumsWombats · 02/02/2023 16:28

Does IVF make it more likely that an embryo that wouldn't normally be strong enough to implant naturally does in fact implant? I was under the impression that with IVF, implanting is a trickier part of the process than getting a viable embryo, but I don't have experience of this so I don't know.

No. Embryo transfer is just that. The embryo is transferred into the uterus and left to impart on its own, it isn’t somehow implanted artificially. The majority fail to implant.

Booktime · 02/02/2023 16:51

l Haven’t heard these stats before but from my personal experience:

aged 23 had Ivf (ICSI) .. perfectly healthy baby currently in KS2 and exceeding all expected school targets

was slower than others in his nursery walking but this is normal in kids to vary ivf or not.

The Ivf process itself however is very gruelling but for me was 1million trillion percent worth it.

Ad others have said the stats sound scary but a 50% increase of 1 is 1.5

Scaevola · 02/02/2023 16:49

Laiste · 02/02/2023 16:21

Plus it seems the high incidence of multiple birth with ivf skews the data.

Look at the metanalysis - they looked at incidence of singleton/multiple births to eliminate this as a confounder

plumduck · 02/02/2023 16:48

Careful what sources you read

PicaK · 02/02/2023 16:39

There's also the risk of the needle being misplaced and you dying. That gave me food for thought. Again incredibly small odds but we knew someone who came very close to death for that reason.
Thing is - like everything with ivf - it's binary. You will or you won't have a child, they will or won't have a problem. It takes a while to get your head round. If they offer counselling I'd use it as it helps.

Crabbity · 02/02/2023 16:36

Relative vs absolute risks OP, there are some great resources to explain it in helpful terms, e.g. patient.info/news-and-features/calculating-absolute-risk-and-relative-risk

Absolute bane of my professional life is the media’s inability to appreciate the difference between the two and the anxiety it subsequently causes.

Best of luck whatever you decide.

ReneBumsWombats · 02/02/2023 16:28

Does IVF make it more likely that an embryo that wouldn't normally be strong enough to implant naturally does in fact implant? I was under the impression that with IVF, implanting is a trickier part of the process than getting a viable embryo, but I don't have experience of this so I don't know.

ReneBumsWombats · 02/02/2023 16:25

I wonder if the data is skewed because people who have IVF are likely to be older, and so it's the issue of older gametes creating the risk?