Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the uk is on its knees

732 replies

Ilovemycatalot · 02/02/2023 13:43

Just this. Every day negativity. No one is happy with life or working conditions. The country is at an all time low. Living standards getting worse by the day people getting poorer. I know we are not in poverty like some countries but honestly can’t see us ever returning to decent living standards unless you’re the few top percent earners. Tell me I’m being dramatic perhaps I am but can’t see much of a way back from this .

OP posts:
Alexandra2001 · 08/02/2023 08:27

Emotionalstorm · 08/02/2023 08:13

Having kids shouldn't be a right. You should only have them if you can afford them and have the stability. If you want them and cannot afford them then you need to work harder. It sounds like many younger people want to have kids and not put in the work (i.e. have their cake and eat it too).

A couple of things... people make silly choices or life gets in the way e.g death, accident, illness and divorce... what do you suggest? we leave them to go without, the kids to wander the streets... as many do already if they end up in care.

We are an aging population, if we don't have more kids, then we will have and are having far more immigration & we all know the issues that brings.

We simply do not have 135k skilled people to work in the NHS or the 350k needed in social care (by 2027) and thats before we get to people needed in hospitality, food processing, logistics, engineering, software/IT etc.

There are approx 370k long term unemployed, many are unemployable, the rest of the 1.2m are short term moving between jobs.

Emotionalstorm · 08/02/2023 08:13

Having kids shouldn't be a right. You should only have them if you can afford them and have the stability. If you want them and cannot afford them then you need to work harder. It sounds like many younger people want to have kids and not put in the work (i.e. have their cake and eat it too).

Lilavanblue · 08/02/2023 07:44

TrinnySmith · 07/02/2023 06:41

It's hard to avoid low wages when every man and his dog wants to buy everything for the least amount of money - hence people go to local shops then look on the internet for the cheapest product and buy from there.
We are our own worst enemies. We also pay cash in hand much of the time to keep it cheap - taxman (and us) miss out.

We buy everything from the east China etc, because they have the lowest paid workers and thus the lowest prices. I don't see how we can compete wiht that.

That’s a very good point.
Sure, some people have no choice but to compare prices and go for the cheapest option. But there is definitely also a “everyone loves a bargain!” and “”I’ll wait for the sales” mentality - and yet people expect local shops to pay great wages?

TrinnySmith · 08/02/2023 07:22

How do they pay for Care Homes? Some stash under the bed?

Coxspurplepippin · 07/02/2023 21:12

BeautifulPaintings '. I think a lot of people inherit their houses here,'

So that's how people can live in beautiful detached houses working low wage jobs, no? Not because there's anything particularly special about the utopia you live in.

Goldpaw · 07/02/2023 21:11

EffortlessDesmond · 05/02/2023 16:32

@Goldpaw, I really don't think the Tory mindset has won. IMO it is essential that we all take responsibilty for our lives. Have children when your relationship is stable and you can afford to feed and rear them to adulthood.

So do you think most British people are lazy and feckless?

Southwestten · 07/02/2023 20:47

Most people are on low paying jobs but because of this set up, they live lovely lives and because the area is SO beautiful noone ever sells their land, just passes land down through.

BeautifulPaintings does this country not have any inheritance tax?

Clavinova · 07/02/2023 20:23

beautifulpaintings
I think I missed something because I don't understand the lazy comment

You implied that anyone with a low paid job in retail in your country could afford to buy/rent a detached house.

But in our area, using one of your examples, I know two people who work in a local shop (similar to a supermarket, but smaller), they both live in detached houses in a beautiful countryside area, and do their lovely hobbies at weekends

In fact, thinking about it - I know a few single women like that as well - and they live in lovely detached houses in beautiful English countryside (one of them overlooks a vineyard) and they do their lovely hobbies at weekends - but they didn't buy their detached houses solely from earned income working for other people in a gift shop/clothes shop (as they do now) or indeed working as a care worker/at the till of a supermarket. They previously had better paid jobs and wanted something less demanding when they got older, are divorced/widowed or inherited from parents.

Clavinova · 07/02/2023 19:50

beautifulpaintings
I can't say as it's too outing

How can it possibly be 'outing' - you've only told us that you left the UK five years ago and you know two people who work in a local shop.

beautifulpaintings · 07/02/2023 18:34

WhoDatDen · 04/02/2023 09:41

@beautifulpaintings what country are you living in? I want to change my Co Op job and go and live out there where I can afford a detached house in a country where they give me lots of handouts with scant contribution from me. Where is this please?

I can't say as it's too outing 😄But to be fair its a cultural as well as cost of living thing. I think a lot of people inherit their houses here, &/or live so close to family that they just get a much cheaper way of life, with free childcare and so on (most people I know literally live next door or down the road to multiple family members). Plus it's the countryside so not like the cities most likely....Most people are on low paying jobs but because of this set up, they live lovely lives and because the area is SO beautiful noone ever sells their land, just passes land down through generations. Bills are not that high so you can have a lower wage here, live month to month, but it doesn't feel as scary if that makes sense to not have a savings buffer.

Saying that there's no way they'd still live like they do in England with their jobs...cost of living is so much lower here for a start...quality of life is very good, and the healthcare and senior care is so good. Public services and all that are strong, so I just feel like there's much less stress, a feeling of more support, people have comfortable retirements so are just so much more able to help with the grandkids and all that....

There's always downsides of course! But just wanted to let @clavinova know that we aren't all French people desperately striking and wallowing in a pit of European misery!

beautifulpaintings · 07/02/2023 18:20

Clavinova · 03/02/2023 19:59

beautifulpaintings
But in our area, using one of your examples, I know two people who work in a local shop (similar to a supermarket, but smaller), they both live in detached houses in a beautiful countryside area, and do their lovely hobbies at weekends. Because you can live on a basic wage here and still have a lovely life

Are the people who don't live in detached houses in your country lazy or unlucky? Or does everyone live in a detached house?

That's a weird question. Why would you call anyone lazy?

I'm just telling you an example from our local area, but I get that it upset you because you don't like the idea of anyone in Europe doing well for themselves!

And of course not everyone lives in detached houses. There's lots of lovely places to live here - semis, apartments, etc - like in every country. I think I missed something because I don't understand the lazy comment.

TrinnySmith · 07/02/2023 06:41

It's hard to avoid low wages when every man and his dog wants to buy everything for the least amount of money - hence people go to local shops then look on the internet for the cheapest product and buy from there.
We are our own worst enemies. We also pay cash in hand much of the time to keep it cheap - taxman (and us) miss out.

We buy everything from the east China etc, because they have the lowest paid workers and thus the lowest prices. I don't see how we can compete wiht that.

Ariautec · 06/02/2023 17:57

And even end of bloody life - we can't even grieve.

My friend’s mum died on the 21st of December, just before Christmas. The cremation took place today.
Disgraceful wait for public services.

Br1256 · 06/02/2023 17:41

Re strikes in France yes they are happening but the recent ones have been because the French Government wants to raise the retirement age from 62 to 64 ….whereas in England it is …….

The average working week is 35 hours …whereas in England it is ….

if u work more than 35 hours the time accumulates to give a day off …whereas in England it is just expected..

France spend more on the infrastructure so they have decent trains etc

and so on

i

AllOutofEverything · 06/02/2023 13:24

National minimum wages are higher in real terms than they have ever been.

littlestrawberryhat · 06/02/2023 13:13

THisbackwithavengeance · 02/02/2023 17:26

What a ridiculous thing to say. So leave?

Why are you on MN, a British website/talk forum conversing with mainly British people if you hate everybody so much?

Honestly, I don't get it. If your life is that shit, then move elsewhere where it's not shit.

But I guess you're just shit stirring anyway. Good for you.

Can't leave now, cos of Brexit!!

fetchacloth · 06/02/2023 13:05

Lostinalibrary · 05/02/2023 09:58

Not quite. Labour started it by the overly generous tax credit system. You can trace the rot back to then. Ever since, it’s been impossible to reduce state reliance properly as they held wages down.

@Lostinalibrary absolutely correct and has been allowed to continue for far too long at great detriment to the taxpayer.
Tax credits were introduced to top up low wages created by the introduction of the Minimum Wage and has made some business owners seriously rich.
How is it right that taxpayers are subsidising employers to this extent, because that's what it is.
With diminishing wages, were are now in a situation where the put-upon taxpayer is unable to properly fund the public services we all rely on,
This country is in a serious mess and it would take a very strong government to sort it out.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 06/02/2023 10:57

Im not being pedantic.

The thing was already in place

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supplementary_Benefit

GPTec1 · 06/02/2023 10:55

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 06/02/2023 09:57

Supplementary benefit appeared in the mid 60’s. it was known as Sup Ben not income support.

Talk about being pedantic!!! Heath gave us family income supplement and the point is, forms of income support were introduced long before Blair.

Happy?

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 06/02/2023 09:57

Alexandra2001 · 05/02/2023 18:19

@Nyasia I never mentioned a political party.... i was responding to the poster who said so many are on benefits.

But as you mention political parties... .... Income Support was bought in by the Tories in 1972, under Edward Heath, income support has been called many names over the last 50 years, the latest is Universal Credit.

If there was no income support, employers would still pay the min they can get away with, just as they did before 1972, why do you think it was bought in???

At least Labour tried with the MW to increase the pay of those on very low wages and guess who opposed that? Yep business leaders and the Tories.

I wish people appreciated this instead of just quoting what they read in the Mail or on FB etc.

We ve had low wages for many years in this country but only the Tories gave us Austerity and 12 years of 0 to 1% public sector pay rises (on average)

Supplementary benefit appeared in the mid 60’s. it was known as Sup Ben not income support.

LibrariansGiveUsPower · 06/02/2023 09:45

shropshire11 · 02/02/2023 13:52

I can see your point. But it’s important to keep a relative view. All countries go through ups and downs - in the 1970s we had much worse strikes, power cuts, a worse fiscal position, and the constant threat of nuclear war. In the 1940s people literally had rationing and bombs falling on their heads.

Right now we are in a bit of a down. We can’t just rely on being a relatively advanced country that has good schools. Other countries have caught up. It won’t be the case that living standards automatically go up for everyone every year. But this is the reality of a globalised economy.

With any luck the next government will have a better handle on things and sort out some structural problems. But it won’t come from some magical thinking that we can pay nurses £100k. It’s going to involve hard choices, just like it did in the 1940s and late 1970s to turn the country around.

In the meantime, we live in a beautiful country with relatively low crime, almost no guns. We are at peace and fairly secure. Things could be a lot worse and the constant whingeing is a big part of the problem - we are talking ourselves into a crisis.

Perfectly put.

this is a crunch point but we’ve been through worse.

EffortlessDesmond · 06/02/2023 09:35

I sympathise for your friend @beguilingeyes . Altzheimer's is a cruel disease, perhaps one of the worst of the numerous misfortunes that can befall a person, and yes, of course your friend deserves society's support, not least for saving society the greater cost of full time care.

When my DH arrested at 50, he lived only because he was already in an ambulance: 90% will die instead.

However, I do think that large companies, notably supermarkets, systematically take the piss in offering PT work up to 16 hours per work, rather than at 20... because 18 hours weekly is the point where employers have to fund pensions, holidays and statutory sick pay. So much cheaper for them.

beguilingeyes · 05/02/2023 23:05

EffortlessDesmond · 05/02/2023 16:32

@Goldpaw, I really don't think the Tory mindset has won. IMO it is essential that we all take responsibilty for our lives. Have children when your relationship is stable and you can afford to feed and rear them to adulthood.

Have children when your relationship is stable. So what happens if your husband dies, or loses his job? Or any of the one hundred unexpected things that throw a spanner in the works.
A friend of mine has has to give up work to care for her mother who has Alzheimer's. Should we let them starve?

Alexandra2001 · 05/02/2023 18:29

EffortlessDesmond · 05/02/2023 16:32

@Goldpaw, I really don't think the Tory mindset has won. IMO it is essential that we all take responsibilty for our lives. Have children when your relationship is stable and you can afford to feed and rear them to adulthood.

Agree but we also have to have the means to pick up the pieces when people are not responsible and the best way to limit the numbers who behave badly is education and early interventions.

We also need to be able to step in when life gets in the way...... illness, accident, death, divorce or when disability occurs in children.

OR we go for the Poor/Work House option... which i believe some would be very happy with, after all, we can't have the homeless and beggars getting in our way coming from the Opera can we?

Alexandra2001 · 05/02/2023 18:19

Nyasia · 05/02/2023 09:16

Labour bringing in tax credits is the reason that wages are so low. Employers don’t need to pay a living wage when they know that the government will top up their employees pay.

@Nyasia I never mentioned a political party.... i was responding to the poster who said so many are on benefits.

But as you mention political parties... .... Income Support was bought in by the Tories in 1972, under Edward Heath, income support has been called many names over the last 50 years, the latest is Universal Credit.

If there was no income support, employers would still pay the min they can get away with, just as they did before 1972, why do you think it was bought in???

At least Labour tried with the MW to increase the pay of those on very low wages and guess who opposed that? Yep business leaders and the Tories.

I wish people appreciated this instead of just quoting what they read in the Mail or on FB etc.

We ve had low wages for many years in this country but only the Tories gave us Austerity and 12 years of 0 to 1% public sector pay rises (on average)