Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To complain about dancing in an acting class

66 replies

AmIreallyBeverly · 02/02/2023 13:01

Just that. 12yr old has a weekly drama class for almost 2yrs. She really enjoys it and is confident. It's run by a proper theatre company. We pay.

It is meant to be a fun but some children (parents?) take it very seriously.

They are doing a play. 14 of the 20ish children will be non-speaking "extras". The main characters are always given to the same people which is frustrating but it happens.

The problem is that all the extras do, is a series of dances in the background.

My daughter is quite clumsy and is very self-conscious about how she struggles with dancing at school. She's been in tears over it. Normally I'd tell her to just suck it up but she is getting really upset about this.

FYI they also do dance classes, musical theatre, "serious" acting classes etc.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AmIreallyBeverly · 13/03/2023 15:14

Update - I didn't complain but other parents did. A letter was sent out from them saying it's the first play the teacher has written and they are still tweaking it but that the dances will be removed.

OP posts:
CharlotteStreetW1 · 12/03/2023 15:32

My dad went to RADA in the 50s and it included ballet lessons.

JarByTheDoor · 02/02/2023 15:24

This seems a bit rubbish to me, even if you think of dance as an integral part of theatre and something that needs to be in the classes (and I would feel differently about how vital dancing is and its mandatory inclusion depending on whether they were classes labelled theatre vs. drama vs. acting).

For me to relate it to something I'm more familiar with, I guess I could think of how as a kid, athletics was a mixed bag for me because I liked and was okay at the jumping and throwing events (though not stellar), but disliked and was bad at the running events because my asthma wasn't well-controlled and I found it embarrassing that I was very slow and sometimes had to stop and breathe.

So if there had been a local athletics organisation, running serious athletics clubs for kids with lots of interest and talent who might go into elite sport, plus dedicated running event classes, and also a recreational class for those who just want to have fun and learn some new athletics skills, I might've joined the recreational one, especially if the way things were generally done at that class was to just do the field events with no track running at all. Some running events being introduced several years in might have irked me, but I'd probably have accepted that it's part of athletics and that it would contribute to my overall athletic ability.

I would not have been very happy if, after several years of enjoying the recreational club, practising my throwing and jumping, and fun low-stakes competitions in throwing and jumping events — and possibly an inferred tacit understanding that at that organisation, if you wanted to do running events, you joined the running classes or the elite classes — I was told that because I'm only middling in the group when it comes to throwing and jumping, I will be doing nothing but solid running for the next several months, slogging and wheezing ineptly round the 400m track again and again, while everyone oohs and aahs at the half-dozen best throwers and jumpers in the middle.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 02/02/2023 14:57

waterrat · 02/02/2023 14:47

4months of rehearsing for a play that she has no real part in? Sounds appalling i would have to complain

She has a part...a dancing part, which she doesn't want.

I do think it sounds like the theatre group have chosen/written the wrong play for this particular group, but perhaps they have their reasons. Who knows?

Theatre is a team effort, and sometimes kids do have to rehearse for months in bit parts that they don't really want. That's just the way it works. The "extra"/"ensemble" roles are still an important part of the whole thing and someone has to do those roles. My dd certainly endured a number of pretty crap parts before she got anything decent, but she threw herself into doing the best she could in the roles that she had been given. If you don't like that, then drama may not be for you.

BMW6 · 02/02/2023 14:56

Of course dancing (and singing) is part of acting classes and theatre!

It's all about using all your body to convey your character to the audience with confidence and nuance. Actors don't just stand still detailing their lines - they move around the stage as directed, and are sometimes required to dance or sing as their part demands.

Any period drama usually features both, for example.

waterrat · 02/02/2023 14:47

4months of rehearsing for a play that she has no real part in? Sounds appalling i would have to complain

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 02/02/2023 14:45

Aintgotthatswing · 02/02/2023 14:41

Massive eye roll emoji.

Eye roll all you like.

I wouldn't expect a tennis class to offer tennis with no running in order to be inclusive of kids who don't like running. I wouldn't expect a gymnastics class to exclude cartwheels and handstands for the kids who are scared of going upside down. Why would I expect a theatre class to exclude something as integral as movement and dance? It goes with the territory.

Justalittlebitduckling · 02/02/2023 14:44

Of course the same kids always get the bigger parts, they are the best actors. Theatre schools are always like that. If your daughter isn’t enjoying it, and it’s damaging her confidence rather than building it, and she should quit the class. I don’t see the point of making a fuss about it.

CementTrucker · 02/02/2023 14:44

@Aintgotthatswing I agree with your posts. A lot of the responses on here read as though op’s daughter is at stage school or doing a drama degree and must either suck it up or stop. It’s a children’s hobby class, where surely participation matters far more than developing every skill. Op has said the school does more serious classes where I’d expect more less flexibility.

Aintgotthatswing · 02/02/2023 14:41

Massive eye roll emoji.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 02/02/2023 14:37

Aintgotthatswing · 02/02/2023 14:30

Sometimes rules need re-thinking. What's this group doing? Training kids to be compliant fodder for a ruthless industry and teaching them to get used to feeling inadequate? Maybe it should be more about nurturing young people by letting them try something they want to try and working with them to make an enjoyable experience they will probably remember forever.

Or pushing them out of their comfort zones and helping to build their resilience and confidence in the longer term? It all depends on how you frame it.

My dd has gained enormously from having to learn skills that didn't come naturally to her. She learnt the value of perseverance and practice, the importance of putting herself out there and risking looking a bit stupid, the need to learn how to deal with failure and bounce back stronger. I don't think we do kids any favours by designing everything around their insecurities so that they don't ever feel uncomfortable or out of their depth.

The bottom line is, if you sign up to do drama, movement and dance is very likely to be a part of that. It goes with the territory. If you don't like that, find another hobby.

Aintgotthatswing · 02/02/2023 14:31

Theatre skills are not just for a select bunch who kind of already have those skills.

Aintgotthatswing · 02/02/2023 14:30

Sometimes rules need re-thinking. What's this group doing? Training kids to be compliant fodder for a ruthless industry and teaching them to get used to feeling inadequate? Maybe it should be more about nurturing young people by letting them try something they want to try and working with them to make an enjoyable experience they will probably remember forever.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 02/02/2023 14:28

Aintgotthatswing · 02/02/2023 14:19

It's acting. In a play. For kids. There is plenty of scope for whoever is running it to make sure all the kids there have a positive experience and don't go away feeling they are somehow wrong for whatever reason.

I guess I would kind of agree with you if it was a class production of the type that you do in primary school, where the primary aim is to let everyone get involved and have a positive experience.

However, this is a theatre group, their aim is presumably to teach kids theatre skills. Movement and dance are an integral part of this. If kids don't enjoy it, they don't have to do it.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 02/02/2023 14:23

Aintgotthatswing · 02/02/2023 14:15

Absolutely kids have to and will anyway learn that we all have strengths and weaknesses but I don't think it's about letting anyone just 'have a go' with a pat on the head. Someone who, for example, is differently abled might be fantastic at acting and good at all the nuances that involves - they're not going to be dancing and it doesn't matter. Obviously there can be dancing for the ones who want to dance but I don't see why it should be mandatory.

Obviously, when they're older and start auditioning for parts, they're not going to be given parts that they're no good at. But a regular kids' theatre group will aim to give them exposure to all of the different aspects of theatre.

The issue right now is that the dancing role is the only part available in this particular production for those who haven't got a speaking part. And maybe those with speaking parts were chosen because they had particular talents in that area. Either way, one of the first rules of drama is to learn to accept that you won't always get the part that you want!

Fruitfriend · 02/02/2023 14:20

YANBU
Some dancing/movement is a normal part of drama class, and being pulled out of comfort zones (or at least learning that you need to tolerate the boring bits to get the fun stuff) is good for resilience and development.
14/20 kids IN AN ACTING CLASS doing no acting for 4 solid months is not normal or reasonable. If daughter wanted to rehearse for a dance recital you would presumably have found her a dance class?
I would raise this gently with management, and if they don't modify the production the find a new class and be very clear about why daughter is leaving.

CementTrucker · 02/02/2023 14:19

If this is an informal class having a quiet word with whoever leads it about how your daughter is feeling would be a good idea. Maybe the role could be adapted in some way or she could do some behind the scenes stuff for this production? Dance hasn’t featured up to now, so it would be a shame if she had to drop out or put up with this level of stress for a ‘fun’ hobby.

I attended some drama classes as a child and I’d have been the same as your child. I even attended a drama class as a teenager even though I didn’t get involved in all activities because I was primarily interested in public speaking. I was the only one in the class who did it for that reason. Even did Lamda public speaking exams the others focussed on acting. I’d hope that fun and inclusion are more important than anything else in the sort of group you’re describing and there can be some flexibility.

Aintgotthatswing · 02/02/2023 14:19

It's acting. In a play. For kids. There is plenty of scope for whoever is running it to make sure all the kids there have a positive experience and don't go away feeling they are somehow wrong for whatever reason.

FrostyPalms · 02/02/2023 14:17

Aintgotthatswing · 02/02/2023 14:01

She might have dyspraxia, or be naturally clumsy or just not like it and those things should not mean she's shut out from acting. God almighty, we are supposed to be getting away from those kinds of exclusions aren't we?

Of course she shouldn't be shut out from acting if she wants to participate, but if her clumsiness/dyspraxia means that she doesn't enjoy this aspect of it then it's not the activity for her.

Aintgotthatswing · 02/02/2023 14:15

Absolutely kids have to and will anyway learn that we all have strengths and weaknesses but I don't think it's about letting anyone just 'have a go' with a pat on the head. Someone who, for example, is differently abled might be fantastic at acting and good at all the nuances that involves - they're not going to be dancing and it doesn't matter. Obviously there can be dancing for the ones who want to dance but I don't see why it should be mandatory.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 02/02/2023 14:08

Aintgotthatswing · 02/02/2023 14:01

She might have dyspraxia, or be naturally clumsy or just not like it and those things should not mean she's shut out from acting. God almighty, we are supposed to be getting away from those kinds of exclusions aren't we?

Well, I'm not sure really. I'm all for inclusion in the sense of letting anyone have a go, e.g. dance classes that don't kick you out if you're not perfectly coordinated. However, I don't think that should mean that dance is edited out of the curriculum entirely.

As someone with probable dyspraxia, I found a lot of sports activities very challenging, but I don't think the bits I struggled with should be edited out. Sometimes kids have to learn that we all have natural strengths and weaknesses, but with practice, all of us are capable of improving. That is a good lesson to learn!

Aintgotthatswing · 02/02/2023 14:01

She might have dyspraxia, or be naturally clumsy or just not like it and those things should not mean she's shut out from acting. God almighty, we are supposed to be getting away from those kinds of exclusions aren't we?

FrostyPalms · 02/02/2023 14:00

AmIreallyBeverly · 02/02/2023 13:53

Not everyone feels that way. Especially as I sometimes wonder to myself if she has mild dyspraxia or whether she is just very, very clumsy.

I understand, I really do.

I have one child with dyspraxia who is very clumsy. I have another child who is studying acting at a prestigious university - a four year course in which movement is a required class all four years. There are some hobbies, and indeed professions, that my dyspraxic child would just never be able to be successful in. One of those is theatre/drama/acting, because of the body awareness and control required.

AmIreallyBeverly · 02/02/2023 13:59

By proper dance I mean she has to sort of line dance and do a clappy beer hall sort of thing with slapping thighs and jumping about. The sort of thing you'd expect in a musical. A bit different to sliding like a snake. It came from nowhere.

I've seen a few Shakespear plays. Never at The Globe but in different places with different ditectors and none have included dancing. I think some probably had the odd song maybe.

Anyway, thanks again. We'll see what they say and take it from there.

OP posts:
MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 02/02/2023 13:56

AmIreallyBeverly · 02/02/2023 13:53

Not everyone feels that way. Especially as I sometimes wonder to myself if she has mild dyspraxia or whether she is just very, very clumsy.

I get that. I suspect I'm dyspraxic and I have two left feet. I get that it's potentially embarrassing for her. Nonetheless, I recognise that movement and dance are an integral part of drama.

Luckily for dd, she doesn't seem to have inherited my clumsiness. She did struggle with singing for a while though...but instead of moaning about it, she took lessons and got good at it!

Swipe left for the next trending thread