Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone else afraid of breastfeeding?

156 replies

flawless29 · 02/02/2023 11:28

I faced a difficult decision at week 34 of pregnancy, after investing hours researching and thinking about breastfeeding. Initially, I felt strongly that I did not want to breastfeed, which may seem immature, but it was my genuine and honest feeling.

I spoke with my midwife about the benefits of breastfeeding for both me and my baby. Logically this made perfect sense to me. Yet emotionally, thought of breastfeeding made me feel awkward and shy – so much so that I didn't even want anyone else in the room when feeding.

On the other hand, formula-feeding came with its own worries such as not being able to provide the best nutrition for my baby or missing out on certain experiences only available through breastfeeding.

The majority of my family is preoccupied with work or school making it hard for me to discuss this difficult decision with someone close by. Feeling isolated, I wondered if I was too selfish if I decided not to breastfeed and go for formula-milk instead?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Jivizdravi · 23/07/2023 15:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

AmbleInAnnBoleyn · 13/07/2023 22:37

flawless29 · 13/07/2023 11:29

I am surprised to see the comments on this post , but many thanks for the encouraging and heartfelt comments ❤️. I already have a baby who is almost 4 months old 👶, and I am breastfeeding him 🍼. I have some difficulty feeding outdoors , otherwise, we both are fine 😊. Thanks a lot 🙏

Many congratulations on the birth of your baby.

Needsomeadvice33 · 13/07/2023 22:33

Just anecdotally but I always have noted that the most colicky babies around me are ff and the more content and settled ones and bf.

Alway1insomethingstat · 13/07/2023 11:35

Your feelings are valid.
so valid.

You should do what you feel is right for you.
I’ll be honest, the thought of whipping my boob out infront of people was not something I felt comfortable about… HOWEVER, after the labour I really lost all sense of bodily embarrassment lol. They saw EVERYTHING.

I breastfeed because, for me, it’s the easier option than making a bottle or expressing (hate hate hate!) for a bottle.
baby won’t touch a bottle now and does not like formula (pukes) so not great if I need to leave baby but it’s fine. I’m happy and baby is thriving.
the pain of breastfeeding initially wears off. I also wear a full cover when we’re out in public if I don’t have something that is discreet enough to get my nip out.

you have to do what’s right for you. trust your body and your own instincts

flawless29 · 13/07/2023 11:29

I am surprised to see the comments on this post , but many thanks for the encouraging and heartfelt comments ❤️. I already have a baby who is almost 4 months old 👶, and I am breastfeeding him 🍼. I have some difficulty feeding outdoors , otherwise, we both are fine 😊. Thanks a lot 🙏

OP posts:
Lavender14 · 12/07/2023 20:39

It's not selfish at all, it's your choice how you wish to feed your child. What I will say though is I come from a family where no one breastfed. Everyone used formula and I only knew one or two people who breastfed. I had the same worries as you did- feeling exposed, people staring and how would I ever feel comfortable doing it in front of other people. I decided I wanted to do it because I had gd and that increased my risk of diabetes a lot and for the nutritional benefits for ds but I was really nervous about it. So I completely understand where you're coming from.

In the early days, it is easier to do it alone and we reduced our visitors so that I could feed privately. I made myself go to a breastfeeding support group the first week I got home and while I didn't keep going to it, it was a good start for me having somewhere that I could feed ds among other mummies who were doing the same in a variety of ways. It made me feel much more confident that noone batted an eyelid.

When I went out in public I used a scarf to cover myself and ds and when I visited family I used a quiet room in their house to feed him in. I still do this at my in laws because I know fil doesn't know what to do with himself around bf, but now I am so so much more confident. I don't need the scarf any more, I'm more aware of how to dress to suit how covered up I want to be and I have never had anyone look twice at me thankfully. Lots of places now have nursing/ baby change rooms too so you get to learn where those are.

It's 100% your choice how you feed your baby and you need to do what's right for you, but I just wanted to let you know i felt that way and now we're 7 months in to bf and now I really love it and I'd be delighted if we get to the year mark. It's hard especially at the start so I would say that if you want to do it you do need to commit and get the right support in place and know where your nearest La leche league group is or who the lactation consultant in the hospital is. I also had some sessions with a surestart bf support group coordinator before I gave birth so I got lots of info on troubleshooting and how to do it before the time came and I had a lovely midwife who was able to help me get ds latched in hospital. Not pressuring in any way, I was raised on formula and am perfectly healthy but I just wanted you to know you're not alone with those worries and it doesn't mean you can't work it in a way that suits you. Some mums feel really confident bf in public right away but I think a lot take a while to get used to it and some prefer to always feed more privately which is totally fine too. You do what suits you!

RosesAndHellebores · 12/07/2023 13:59

My dc are grown up. When I had them there was a very strong mantra for bf amongst hcps (midwives and hvs) who had had little training and the emphasis was on it being natural, perfect and everyone could do it. They were incapable of providing help or support and things like bf counsellors and cafes did not then exist.

My friends who bf without issue raved about it and criticised ff. They had not on the while suffered badly cracked nipples, mastitis or a breadt abscess.

When ds was 8 weeks I switched to ff. It was so much easier and quicker than what I had been going through and my well being improved exponentially and the baby settled too.

I bf dd for 9 months. It was easier, I had learnt what to do. I had learnt to nod and smile at midwives and hvs. Also she did not have ds's wide, flat palate, identified at his first trip to the dentist when he was 2.

Mothers must do what they are most comfortable with. A happy, well mother is best for baby.

Despite ds being ff and dd bf they both had childhood eczema, bronchiolitis, trouble with their ears, etc. They also both have wide feet, blue eyes and blonde hair along with cracking intellects, a good work ethic and Oxbridge degrees. Some of it's hereditary, some of it's due to nurture. Mostly they just need love.

Do what you feel most comfortable with.

JulieHoney · 12/07/2023 13:53

Zombie thread from February - the OP will have had the baby weeks ago

Heartbreaktuna · 12/07/2023 13:42

It' worth giving BF a try. The oxytocin produced during breast feeding is completely addictive and not something I was really aware of. No better feeling in the world ❤️
Not sure what 'shakey evidence' is?
Unless other posters are implying that the nutritional components of breast milk, immuno- protective and developmental factors, including immune cells and stem cells, are not clinically evidenced?

2mummies1baby · 12/07/2023 13:26

You should absolutely do what you feel comfortable with- the only thing I'd say is that, if you can breastfeed, it's bloody convenient. No faffing about with bottles in the middle of the night or when you're out and about. If you can get your baby to take breast and bottle (so others can feed him/her too while you're asleep/out) then you're onto a winner- my DD taking both has made my life so much easier.

Mrswang · 12/07/2023 13:06

You are definitely not being selfish or unreasonable in any way , I am pregnant with baby number 5 and I am not breastfeeding if this makes you feel any better, a happy mam makes a happy baby and if your not feeling happy when feeding baby , if you come to dress feeding baby is it even worth it , if you feel happier and you get a more pleasurable experience from formula feeding then I know what I'd choose , but whatever you choose is absolutely fine .x

SovietKitsch · 03/02/2023 21:52

Do what you need to do? But why not try it for a few days? If you hate it, just stop. But you might be glad you tried.

Coffeeandchocs · 03/02/2023 21:50

Totalwasteofpaper · 03/02/2023 08:19

See i dont think this is helpful.

You are vulnerable and all over the place when pregnant.
I was pushed into it with all the "give it a try" chat.

What exactly is "a try" and when will you know you "tried" "enough" ???

Having been talked into "giving it a try"
Then i listened to the "it gets easier" crowd.
Then i got told how it helped you bond. (Assocating your baby with pain and failure surprisingly did not help me bond)
Then i had the "give up if you want to theres no shame" chats. (This didnt feel great or ring true as "Giving up" inherently implies failure!!!)

I wasted 7-10hours a day for 4 months making myself miserable and panicking about how much they had.. their growth... was the tongue tie properly corrected?
Most Midwives know little to nothing on breastfeeding which i find bizarre. they just give generic platitudes and make encouraging sounds 🤷🏻‍♀️

Even if you find it easy sounds like you dont want to breastfeed...

Honestly do what you want...

How is it not helpful to encourage someone who isn’t sure about what they want to give the option, that may later become unavailable, a try?
If the OP tries breastfeeding first and decides they don’t like it or it doesn’t work best for them (completely valid reasons to stop, by the way) they can move onto bottles.
If the OP gives their baby formula and later decides, whether that’s weeks or months down the line, that they wished they’d breastfed, it won’t be possible (or at least for most who don’t have time/inclination to induce relactation).

It makes sense to try the option that is only available for a limited amount of time before the other option that can always be resorted to.

It sounds very much like you had a bad experience and, whether intentional or not, are projecting that onto the OP.

PifandHercule · 03/02/2023 13:31

Contact a lactation consultant as they help new mums with this all the time. Good luck!

caggie3 · 03/02/2023 12:51

Fake news*

caggie3 · 03/02/2023 12:50

Whilst the New York case of the little boy passed on high levels of PFOA through breast milk is extremely sad and I feel horrific for the family, it's nothing to do with actual breast milk it's to do with a town having chemical contaminated water for years, their water treatment plant was situated several hundred yards away from a manufacturing plant full of toxic chemicals, lack of proper safety testing allowing it to go undetected for years and has caused a mass increase in illnesses and cancers in that town. If he'd had formula bottles made for him they too would of passed on the chemicals. To come on here and say that breast milk passes on forever chemicals based off of that tragic case is scaremongering and fair news at its finest and you should have that comment taken down. Unbelievable honestly.

cheatingcrackers · 03/02/2023 11:51

Totalwasteofpaper · 03/02/2023 08:19

See i dont think this is helpful.

You are vulnerable and all over the place when pregnant.
I was pushed into it with all the "give it a try" chat.

What exactly is "a try" and when will you know you "tried" "enough" ???

Having been talked into "giving it a try"
Then i listened to the "it gets easier" crowd.
Then i got told how it helped you bond. (Assocating your baby with pain and failure surprisingly did not help me bond)
Then i had the "give up if you want to theres no shame" chats. (This didnt feel great or ring true as "Giving up" inherently implies failure!!!)

I wasted 7-10hours a day for 4 months making myself miserable and panicking about how much they had.. their growth... was the tongue tie properly corrected?
Most Midwives know little to nothing on breastfeeding which i find bizarre. they just give generic platitudes and make encouraging sounds 🤷🏻‍♀️

Even if you find it easy sounds like you dont want to breastfeed...

Honestly do what you want...

Well, a lot of posters on this thread have said they didn’t really fancy breastfeeding but then they gave it a try and loved it. Putting yourself through weeks of physical and/or mental pain isn’t really giving it a try - that’s committing to something. Giving it a try is latching the baby on after birth and seeing what happens and how it feels.

Im sorry you had such an awful experience, but, again, many women have a wonderful time breastfeeding - including a lot on this thread who didn’t even plan to do it.

ArtVandalay · 03/02/2023 09:37

If you were my friend, I’d say at least give it a go. If it’s not for you, switch to formula.

For me, breastfeeding remains one of the best things I remember about having babies.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 03/02/2023 09:31

Squamata · 03/02/2023 09:28

Are you talking about microplastics etc? They get into everything, food, water, the world is a toxic place. Breastmilk is one of the least toxic things in it.

Avoiding chemicals by giving your baby mass-produced formula in plastic bottles seems a bit odd? Nothing wrong with formula but it's definitely less eco friendly than bf!

Yes essentially PFAS are things like micro plastics, fabrics, cleaning product elements etc.

Id say breastmilk is probably the
oat resistant substance at source to PFAS because it’s a live substance that filters the crap out.

I don’t mind a healthy debate but scaremongering with total bullshit really just pisses me off

Squamata · 03/02/2023 09:28

DealOrNoelsDeal · 03/02/2023 08:50

That’s why I said there’s plenty of research, but that was a user friendly article. Please feel free to do some of your own research.

However, I will no longer be responding as I believe your username tells me all I need to know about attempting a discussion with you, and you’re jumping on my every statement with zero intent to do your own research. Which is kind of my point about pro-breast feeders.

enjoy your day.

Are you talking about microplastics etc? They get into everything, food, water, the world is a toxic place. Breastmilk is one of the least toxic things in it.

Avoiding chemicals by giving your baby mass-produced formula in plastic bottles seems a bit odd? Nothing wrong with formula but it's definitely less eco friendly than bf!

Squamata · 03/02/2023 09:23

I mean, putting a baby to your breast feels weird the first time but growing a baby in your womb and pushing it out of your vagina (or having it taken out through surgery) is weird too!

Breastmilk has components that support the baby's immune system. If breastmilk was a brand of formula, everyone would buy it!

Breastfeeding reduces your cancer risk and reduces risk of pnd.

However, breastfeeding can also be awful to establish for the first few months. Not always, but sometimes. If the stress is bad enough then it can out balance the positives.

I had one baby where feeding was very hard, tongue tie and needed to combo feed for a while etc. Then second baby just came out and latched on with zero problems.

With both, once feeding was established it felt like a nice g&t on a hot day - relaxing and relieving. Better than faffing with bottles!

I'd say give it a go and do whatever suits you.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 03/02/2023 08:52

DealOrNoelsDeal · 03/02/2023 08:50

That’s why I said there’s plenty of research, but that was a user friendly article. Please feel free to do some of your own research.

However, I will no longer be responding as I believe your username tells me all I need to know about attempting a discussion with you, and you’re jumping on my every statement with zero intent to do your own research. Which is kind of my point about pro-breast feeders.

enjoy your day.

My username is a quote from a book 😂

”Im not winning this argument so I’m flouncing”.

Font come and spout crap about things that aren’t happening. There isn’t ‘plenty of research’ to suggest women who DON’T live in a town with contaminated water have PFAS in their breast milk. There is however research to suggest that cows from anywhere can have PFAS in their breastmilk (which is used to make formula). Don’t scaremonger with fake news, and when challenged post an article that doesn’t even begin to prop up or prove your nonsense

DealOrNoelsDeal · 03/02/2023 08:50

That’s why I said there’s plenty of research, but that was a user friendly article. Please feel free to do some of your own research.

However, I will no longer be responding as I believe your username tells me all I need to know about attempting a discussion with you, and you’re jumping on my every statement with zero intent to do your own research. Which is kind of my point about pro-breast feeders.

enjoy your day.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 03/02/2023 08:48

There is no formula in the world that is better for a baby than breast milk is. That is a fact.

Again, FF is an absolutely valid choice but let’s not lie to ourselves and pretend it’s the same substance with the same benefits as breastmilk. Aside from the fact that it’s factually incorrect it’s pretty offensive to treat grown women like children and tell lies to avoid upsetting them.

Redebs · 03/02/2023 08:47

If you're going to give birth to a little person, they do deserve the best your body can provide.
Nothing better than your own, warm milk, perfectly matched to your growing baby's needs and full of antibodies from your own immune system.
If you're feeling shy, then take your time to get practice at home. You'll soon find you can pop the baby under a top discretely for a feed without anyone else even realising.
Please trust your own body. You might need help with getting started (hint: it's all about baby latching on properly and feeding frequently) but there's nothing to compare with the convenience and health benefits to you and your baby.