Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Some woman enable misogyny

91 replies

2023newyearnewname · 02/02/2023 10:20

Why do some women excuse men and their misogyny and giggle it away/make light of it as if it's nothing and ignore the violence towards women.

An example on The Jeremy Vine show this morning. Talking about the Tom Jones song. One presenter said well you should hear how a rapper talks about women and want they want to do to them. My generation (Z I thing she said) just take no notice and don't get upset about it. Isn't she just part of the problem eg accepting of men speaking about violence and acts towards women and what they might do to them. Surely she cannot have missed the face that many children listen, the growth in children watching porn and violent porn towards women and the increase in choking sex, violent sex etc/

Or am I just unreasonable, should I just not speak up and accept women should shut up and laugh along with the rappers. Youngish black woman wasn't offended at all about what the rapper says he wants to do with women etc. I found it a bit odd.

OP posts:
FayCarew · 02/02/2023 15:20

I got slammed on a neighbourhood app for pointing out that the 'girls looking for houses to clean' were women not girls.

bridgetreilly · 02/02/2023 15:17

Because women also grow up in a profoundly sexist society. We have to unlearn it too.

10HailMarys · 02/02/2023 15:15

I think it’s a colossal over-simplification to say that this kind of thing is enabling misogyny. If anything, I think to lay the blame on women for ‘enabling’ misogyny is in itself quite misogynistic, and there is a strongly misogynistic tone to a lot of the replies on this thread.

Song lyrics are equivalent to a work of fiction. Something like Delilah (or, eg, Where The Wild Roses Grow by Nick Cave & Kylie Minogue) is a song in which a fictional character is talking about a terrible thing they’ve done. Singing along to it doesn’t imply approval or tolerance of violence against women, any more than singing along to Johnny Cash’s Folsom Prison Blues implies that someone approves of ‘shooting a man in Reno just to watch him die’ and/or is enabling gun violence. What about Mack The Knife? I am enabling an epidemic of gangland stabbings by humming along to Bobby Darin? What about drugs, am I enabling addiction by listening to Lou Reed singing about heroin? What about books and films? Is everyone who loves The Silence Of The Lambs enabling cannibalism?

And before anyone chips in to tell me I wouldn’t say this if I’d been a victim of violence, I’d like to point out that I have survived domestic violence, have also been seriously sexually assaulted by a stranger. I’m also heavily involved in campaigning against VAW through the women’s network (of which I was a founder member) at my place of work.

Some people find a song like Delilah or certain rap lyrics distasteful or upsetting or have a hard time separating them from reality. That is OK. You feel what you feel and there’s nothing wrong with that. But there is also nothing wrong with believing that a fictional account of a character’s violence is entirely separate from any advocation or violence in real life, and condemning other women as misogyny enablers because they feel differently to you is judgemental, divisive and unfair.

Littlechickenhead · 02/02/2023 14:09

MiL is a misogynist, she freely admits that she thinks most women are useless and a waste of space. If you ever say anything vaguely derogatory about men, she will immediately jump in with a ‘what about women then, eh? Eh?’ reply. Last week, we were all talking about fathers who abandon their kids and refuse to pay maintenance. Someone commented that in the majority of cases, it’s men who do this and she immediately took umbrage and started trying to argue that just as many women abandon their kids too. She’s also argued that rape victims can be culpable if they go out after dark and get drunk. Given that she was a single parent, it beggars belief.

IncompleteSenten · 02/02/2023 13:57

Stockholm syndrome.

2023newyearnewname · 02/02/2023 13:54

@felulageller

"felulageller · Today 13:05
In my experience gen z women are much more sexist, conservative and misogynistic than older millennials/ genx ers.
Things have really gone backwards!"

The lady on the show definitely implied that her generation would just shrug off comments which were far worse and directed at women. What a man might do to them or want to do to them. I wonder why some generations accept this.

OP posts:
2023newyearnewname · 02/02/2023 13:50

@SandraCumin

I don't think that misogyny is a black or white issue I think it's a man/woman issue. I was commenting on what a woman said about how a particular individual described women and what he would do to them. This isn't about racism at all. Men and women can be misogynistic or enable it which is what this thread is about. You appear to have missed the point completely.

I have at no point said that some cultures are inferior to others and I don't believe they are. You are focussed on something else, perhaps write a thread about that issue. This is about whether some WOMEN enable misogyny. Try reading it again and reading the responses!

OP posts:
SandraCumin · 02/02/2023 13:17

2023newyearnewname · 02/02/2023 12:59

For the record the woman that used the example of acceptable misogyny was a black woman commenting on a black artist - does that help.

Yes but your aren’t. All you are doing is help perpetuate the racist idea that some cultures are inferior to others. You should take this thread down.

takeonme · 02/02/2023 13:12

RudsyFarmer · 02/02/2023 11:11

I have a theory about this having been both sides of the fence.

When I was younger I genuinely didn’t really see a problem with porn or misogynistic men subjugating young women in music videos. Now I’m menopausal it’s like the curtains been lifted and I understand everything some women have been saying for ages.

I have no idea if it’s life experience or hormones but I no longer see things in the sane way. Personally I think there’s something about being young and fertile that makes you just more up for sexual hedonism. You giggle along because life’s just a bit more Carry On generally.

Then you get older, a bit less up for sex overall, and you realise that behind every bloke roughly handling a women in a music video is an attitude that that female is there solely for his dick to penetrate. It starts to mentally jar. Then you look around and realise the world’s actually geared for men to have their fun. The patriarchy does exist. It’s really odd. The rose tinted glasses are just smashed and broken.

I relate to this so much. I think my younger self bought into misogynistic crap. I think my older self is far more aware of it. But that’s also to do with social changes: my younger self grew up in the ‘90s.
Having said that, the shift from being a young, fertile woman to loosing your fertility, knocks those rose tinted spectacles off…

Kanaloa · 02/02/2023 13:10

Yes many women are. I mean you only have to look at threads about useless baby husbands on here to see them out in force. But mainly I just feel sorry for them. A man hating women or seeing them as inherently worth less is simply being selfish, prioritising himself and loving himself the most, to keep a system that works well for him. Imagine the self hatred you’d need to agree that you’re the lesser being and be complicit in your own oppression.

felulageller · 02/02/2023 13:05

In my experience gen z women are much more sexist, conservative and misogynistic than older millennials/ genx ers.

Things have really gone backwards!

2023newyearnewname · 02/02/2023 12:59

For the record the woman that used the example of acceptable misogyny was a black woman commenting on a black artist - does that help.

OP posts:
2023newyearnewname · 02/02/2023 12:58

@SandraCumin

"Interesting that you have chosen rap as your example of acceptable misogyny. Are you white by any chance?"

I used the example given by the guest on the Jeremy Vine show. I commented on what she said, HER EXAMPLE and was shocked by what she said about how a particular rapper says about what he would do to woman and how he talks about them. I think you missed that bit?

OP posts:
WhoNeedsSleepNotISaidMyBody · 02/02/2023 12:57

shiningstar2 · 02/02/2023 10:23

Arhh!! Pressed wrong button. Meant to press YANBU. You actually have 100% YRNBU if you ignore my clumsy fingers 😁

@shiningstar2

just go back & press the other option. You can swap as many times as you like!

SandraCumin · 02/02/2023 12:54

Interesting that you have chosen rap as your example of acceptable misogyny. Are you white by any chance?

ResearchMakesMeCry · 02/02/2023 12:51

RudsyFarmer · 02/02/2023 11:11

I have a theory about this having been both sides of the fence.

When I was younger I genuinely didn’t really see a problem with porn or misogynistic men subjugating young women in music videos. Now I’m menopausal it’s like the curtains been lifted and I understand everything some women have been saying for ages.

I have no idea if it’s life experience or hormones but I no longer see things in the sane way. Personally I think there’s something about being young and fertile that makes you just more up for sexual hedonism. You giggle along because life’s just a bit more Carry On generally.

Then you get older, a bit less up for sex overall, and you realise that behind every bloke roughly handling a women in a music video is an attitude that that female is there solely for his dick to penetrate. It starts to mentally jar. Then you look around and realise the world’s actually geared for men to have their fun. The patriarchy does exist. It’s really odd. The rose tinted glasses are just smashed and broken.

Yeah this happened to me also. Boyfriends in the past have told me how crafty and deceitful men can be to get sex... so I've also taken that on board.

2023newyearnewname · 02/02/2023 12:50

@DysmalRadius

I wouldn't blame women, more that it is enabled by some, maybe on purpose or probably for most as a part of their upbringing, they are unaware of how they defer to men, women's place in society, how accepting they are of men watching porn/violence against women and dismissing it, how some feel that women are 'lesser than' men, the use of the society labels 'dumb blonde', 'silly little woman', etc

I was quite surprised by how accepting the young woman was of how a rapper refers to women and what he wants to do to them as ok and normal and just dismissive of it. She suggested young people are ok with it and just accept it as she does.

Substitute being offensive or suggesting violence to others groups of people and would that be tolerated

OP posts:
2023newyearnewname · 02/02/2023 12:43

@Mamamia7962 You completely missed the point of my AIBU - did you read the post, it was about the female guest comments?

"Mamamia7962 · Today 10:42
It's a song that tells a story from the man's perspective. I think when people sing it they don't really analyse the lyrics it's just a great tune and Sir Tom has a brilliant voice. I am sure that song has not incited any acts of violence towards women.
Where do you draw the line? Nursery rhymes, the old woman in the shoe who whipped her children and sent them to bed without any food? Goosey goosey gander where an old man is thrown down the stairs for not saying his prayers?"

OP posts:
DysmalRadius · 02/02/2023 12:24

It's hardly surprising that women who have been brought up in an abusively patriarchal society have internalised the message that their wants and needs are less important than the men who have structured society in their favour.

We're none of us raised in a vacuum, but I don't think women are more to blame for men's violence against them than men are.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 02/02/2023 12:12

AdamRyan · 02/02/2023 10:46

"I felt the knife in my hand and she laughed no more" is quite violent

There is a difference between singing it and promoting it. Using it as a team anthem type of thing in sport is promotion imo

Stoke fans will never stop singing it. But their lyrics have been changed anyway..

Fingerlessmitts · 02/02/2023 12:02

2023newyearnewname · 02/02/2023 10:31

I was a victim of a serious sexual assault when I was younger and I hoped that things might move on a bit. I had the you walked home in a short skirt and heels comments. Seriously some think that it is ok them for a man to attack if particular clothing is worn.

According to my niece many boys watch porn in her year (11) and choking women and verbal abuse towards them is a thing at present apparently. I mean seriously what the heck.

I defer the focus on school skirts doesn’t help things here either. Girls are naughty for having short skirts - the conditioning starts early

shiningstar2 · 02/02/2023 11:53

Thanks @2023newyearnewname just changed my vote 😁

RudsyFarmer · 02/02/2023 11:11

I have a theory about this having been both sides of the fence.

When I was younger I genuinely didn’t really see a problem with porn or misogynistic men subjugating young women in music videos. Now I’m menopausal it’s like the curtains been lifted and I understand everything some women have been saying for ages.

I have no idea if it’s life experience or hormones but I no longer see things in the sane way. Personally I think there’s something about being young and fertile that makes you just more up for sexual hedonism. You giggle along because life’s just a bit more Carry On generally.

Then you get older, a bit less up for sex overall, and you realise that behind every bloke roughly handling a women in a music video is an attitude that that female is there solely for his dick to penetrate. It starts to mentally jar. Then you look around and realise the world’s actually geared for men to have their fun. The patriarchy does exist. It’s really odd. The rose tinted glasses are just smashed and broken.

Phoenixrising2020 · 02/02/2023 11:04

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Beaglesonlyplease · 02/02/2023 10:57

I should have added “for instance” after my example (having had exactly that said to me on MN).
Or the comments about Amber Heard or Meghan Markle..

Swipe left for the next trending thread