Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Some woman enable misogyny

91 replies

2023newyearnewname · 02/02/2023 10:20

Why do some women excuse men and their misogyny and giggle it away/make light of it as if it's nothing and ignore the violence towards women.

An example on The Jeremy Vine show this morning. Talking about the Tom Jones song. One presenter said well you should hear how a rapper talks about women and want they want to do to them. My generation (Z I thing she said) just take no notice and don't get upset about it. Isn't she just part of the problem eg accepting of men speaking about violence and acts towards women and what they might do to them. Surely she cannot have missed the face that many children listen, the growth in children watching porn and violent porn towards women and the increase in choking sex, violent sex etc/

Or am I just unreasonable, should I just not speak up and accept women should shut up and laugh along with the rappers. Youngish black woman wasn't offended at all about what the rapper says he wants to do with women etc. I found it a bit odd.

OP posts:
PaperFun · 02/02/2023 19:25

I don’t like it when I see women laughing off wolf-whistling and catcalling and saying it’s a compliment.

It is a power thing designed to make women feel uncomfortable and I wish people would not downplay it.

watchfulwishes · 02/02/2023 19:19

BigMandsTattooPortfolio · 02/02/2023 19:06

The worst, most ugly, most loathesome and revolting lyrics I’ve ever come across are those by The Rolling Stones. Many of their songs are steeped in racism and misogyny, yet no one bats an eyelid about them.

Interested in this, I have never really listened to them - which songs particularly?

VladmirsPoutine · 02/02/2023 19:18

If we are to accept that patriarchy underpins much if not all of how society works then it's not beyond doubt that many women will have adopted this view as the norm because that's very much how it has always been. I agree there is need to challenge these views, of course, but I think there's a very long way to go.

watchfulwishes · 02/02/2023 19:18

2023newyearnewname · 02/02/2023 10:31

I was a victim of a serious sexual assault when I was younger and I hoped that things might move on a bit. I had the you walked home in a short skirt and heels comments. Seriously some think that it is ok them for a man to attack if particular clothing is worn.

According to my niece many boys watch porn in her year (11) and choking women and verbal abuse towards them is a thing at present apparently. I mean seriously what the heck.

The reason people say that about e.g. clothing is it makes them feel safer - 'if I do the right thing it won't happen to me'. It is bullshit but comes from a place of fear. Very sorry to hear about your experience Flowers I don't think it was caused by anything you did.

The violent porn watching is very sad for boys and very scary for girls.

TheGoogleMum · 02/02/2023 19:14

Many songs talk about violent things we don't approve of.
I realise I enjoy the song 'Pumped Up Kicks' but it's about a school shooter so the lyrics are very problematic. Enjoying the song doesn't mean I condone that kind of violence.

BigMandsTattooPortfolio · 02/02/2023 19:06

The worst, most ugly, most loathesome and revolting lyrics I’ve ever come across are those by The Rolling Stones. Many of their songs are steeped in racism and misogyny, yet no one bats an eyelid about them.

sendbobs · 02/02/2023 19:04

Botw1 · 02/02/2023 10:28

Lots of women are mysoginists.

Hardly surprising given the sexist society we live in.

Look at the Brit awards and Lorraine Kelly blithely stating that it's just the way it is that the best artists are men

Look at the amount of women who happily give up work and make themselves entirely dependent on men?

Or who say things like oh, no he wouldn't be able to cope with looking after his children.

Look at the amount of women who believe jealousy is a good thing

Who blame the other woman rather than their oh

Who think women who have been sexually assaulted asked for it

Etc etc

Replying to ^

sendbobs · 02/02/2023 19:03

Most of these really aren't misogynistic

Lorraine Kelly- yes. Dumb thing to say, unless you listen to a particular genre like rap. In which case, it's personal taste, not men are better.

Staying at home to raise kids is a personal choice and nobody else's business. Bit ironic to claim somebody else's choice is misogyny because you don't like it.

Some men are useless and can't look after their children- where is the misogyny? That's based on their specific relationship and whatever issues the dad has that means he can't tolerate his own children.

Women can be jealous. One persons boundary is another's control. Don't know who's think jealousy is actually a good thing either way.

Women have every right to not like the OW who has broken woman code herself- interestingly that didn't make it to your list though. It has nothing to do with hating the women in most cases. You love your partner. You want to believe that they are sorry and can change. Exactly the same in same sex relationships. Not often misogyny.

Yes, if you think anyone deserves SA that is misogyny. Luckily, most people don't believe this and even fewer would openly declare it

SandraCumin · 02/02/2023 18:55

phoenixrosehere · 02/02/2023 18:08

Not really. You are making it out as a black woman = all black women think it’s acceptable. It always seems to be black people and rap music used as an example while ignoring the same issues in rock music which has been around longer than rap music and still has questionable lyrics.

I’m glad somebody else picked up on the racist dogwhistling seeping out of the original post. Rap music isn’t even half as problematic as some of the other genres out there such as country & western which is rife with bigotry, homophobia and misogyny.

phoenixrosehere · 02/02/2023 18:41

10HailMarys · 02/02/2023 15:15

I think it’s a colossal over-simplification to say that this kind of thing is enabling misogyny. If anything, I think to lay the blame on women for ‘enabling’ misogyny is in itself quite misogynistic, and there is a strongly misogynistic tone to a lot of the replies on this thread.

Song lyrics are equivalent to a work of fiction. Something like Delilah (or, eg, Where The Wild Roses Grow by Nick Cave & Kylie Minogue) is a song in which a fictional character is talking about a terrible thing they’ve done. Singing along to it doesn’t imply approval or tolerance of violence against women, any more than singing along to Johnny Cash’s Folsom Prison Blues implies that someone approves of ‘shooting a man in Reno just to watch him die’ and/or is enabling gun violence. What about Mack The Knife? I am enabling an epidemic of gangland stabbings by humming along to Bobby Darin? What about drugs, am I enabling addiction by listening to Lou Reed singing about heroin? What about books and films? Is everyone who loves The Silence Of The Lambs enabling cannibalism?

And before anyone chips in to tell me I wouldn’t say this if I’d been a victim of violence, I’d like to point out that I have survived domestic violence, have also been seriously sexually assaulted by a stranger. I’m also heavily involved in campaigning against VAW through the women’s network (of which I was a founder member) at my place of work.

Some people find a song like Delilah or certain rap lyrics distasteful or upsetting or have a hard time separating them from reality. That is OK. You feel what you feel and there’s nothing wrong with that. But there is also nothing wrong with believing that a fictional account of a character’s violence is entirely separate from any advocation or violence in real life, and condemning other women as misogyny enablers because they feel differently to you is judgemental, divisive and unfair.

I think you’ve summed it up quite nicely and I agree with you.

It reminds me when people blamed movies, music, and video games as excuses for why their children committed crimes because it was easier to blame them than looking into what they as parents were teaching on an individual level and failing to point out the difference between truth and fiction.

Growing up, there were tons of songs I sang along to with my parents that I didn’t know the meaning of and still didn’t realise it until after I had kids. When I did understand the lyrics as I got older, nothing ever made me think I was supposed to go out and do the things described or accept them either nor would I have gone out with a man that thought those things were acceptable.

MorrisZapp · 02/02/2023 18:35

I've often said this on here but my granny was the most misogynist person I've ever known. She just placed no value on women at all. I remember her complaining in a shop and saying 'I'm not wanting to speak to the girly! Fetch the mannie!' (Aberdeen accent).

She used to give my brother a bigger Easter egg than us. Bloody outrageous.

2023newyearnewname · 02/02/2023 18:30

@Thepeopleversuswork totally agree

OP posts:
Phoenixrising2020 · 02/02/2023 18:23

MaryEllen, I referenced her age as I am no longer a spring chicken myself and I was shocked that she had that attitude with a mature perspective on life. She was with a man and it actually made me really sad for her and I was shocked. The last time I heard a woman do that I was 20 and she was in a really abusive relationship. I didn't have time to write all that earlier.
Like a PP said, the whole sort of Carry On attitude is expected to an extent in youth, but this woman sounded as though she really hated other women. It is visibly obvious that I am a woman and it felt very threatening.

I wouldn't mention age gratuitously, it was relevant to my thoughts on the matter. I was in a rush but I clicked on this thread because it reminded me of it. I will try to be clearer about such things in future, thank you for pointing out that it seemed that way. I am embarrassed and I will ask for the post to be deleted.

Even so, it's a worrying issue that there are women who either think, or seem to think this way.

2023newyearnewname · 02/02/2023 18:19

@takeonme and @RudsyFarmer

I agree. Older women in my experience are less tolerant of misogynistic behaviour. That was my original point which some have missed - the younger woman excused it and said her generation ignore it. Sadly my ignoring it goes unanswered and may get worse still

OP posts:
2023newyearnewname · 02/02/2023 18:16

@Littlechickenhead

Wow that is awful. What on earth makes MIL have those believes. Why does she hate women/judge women/assume they are at fault rather that the person who did it. Very odd.

OP posts:
2023newyearnewname · 02/02/2023 18:15

My reply was to another poster who thought I was racist because I MADE THE COMMENT ABOUT THE RAPPER - I didn't the guest on the show made the comment. I was commenting on her comment. The other poster assumed that I made the comment about a black man and I was a white woman. Assumptions again.

Oh my - I am perfectly well aware that not all black men or black women are misogynistic.

I am not ignoring other types of music and focusing on rap - the guest presenter gave the example not me. I wasn't focusing on the genre of music but on the COMMENT that a woman made excusing how a particular man spoke about what he wanted to do with and to women and her reaction to that was ok.

There's a lot of not reading going on. It's NOT ABOUT THE MUSIC TRACK or the type of music played.

OP posts:
Needanewnamebeingwatched · 02/02/2023 18:13

shiningstar2 · 02/02/2023 10:23

Arhh!! Pressed wrong button. Meant to press YANBU. You actually have 100% YRNBU if you ignore my clumsy fingers 😁

You can just press the correct one and it should change

phoenixrosehere · 02/02/2023 18:08

2023newyearnewname · 02/02/2023 12:59

For the record the woman that used the example of acceptable misogyny was a black woman commenting on a black artist - does that help.

Not really. You are making it out as a black woman = all black women think it’s acceptable. It always seems to be black people and rap music used as an example while ignoring the same issues in rock music which has been around longer than rap music and still has questionable lyrics.

Thepeopleversuswork · 02/02/2023 18:06

Of course. We live in a patriarchal society and most women have been socialised to believe their needs are secondary to those of men and their role in life is essentially to support men and raise their children.

It’s absolutely endemic in society and it takes bravery, confidence and self belief which a lot of women don’t have to see past it.

It’s also much easier to live your life on feminist principles if you are financially independent of men. The majority of women are not and even if they recognise misogyny there are limits on how they can react to it without jeopardising theirs and their children’s security and wellbeing.

Avaynia · 02/02/2023 17:59

I think there are a few reasons.

  1. We’re all a product of our cultures and societies. Certain things are normal and we don’t question them. Women stopping work because of children, things like that. Or they suit us and we don’t want it to change. Others don’t have cause to question anything until there’s a triggering event, such as PP who said they cared more as they got older and gained more experience.
  2. Everyone sees things differently. I’m American and black. Surrogacy is normalized here. So it’s not as immediately shocking to me as it would be to women elsewhere. Also, it’s similar, to me, to military recruitment. The military goes into schools, usually full of poor minorities, and tells the boys they’ll pay for their college and they can support their family with this money, and they’ll have healthcare and people sign up because they’re desperate. To me, it’s more about the rich vs the poor rather than just misogyny. No rich person is going to hire me as a surrogate because I’m black. They’re going to exploit poor white women like in the Ukraine. I’m sure there are any number of issues that other women see as not a straightforward example of misogyny and they’ll be written off as supporting misogyny simply because of that. Everyone decides who’s right according to their own lines.
  3. Everyone has different priorities. No amount of screaming about trans people is going to get me to care about it. No amount of telling me it’s about all women is going to get me to care about. Do I think it matters that women need spaces of their own? Yes. Do I think it’s the most important issue in the world and that I should forsake everything else? No. My country just got rid of abortion rights. That’s more important to me. I will note vote for republicans who want to restrict abortion further no matter what their stance is on anything else. I’m not going to put other issues above that.
  4. Women like me are fed up with White Feminists who complain about the minimizing tactics men use against misogyny only to turn around and do the same thing to minority women. The whataboutery of white people experience racism too. But you can’t be sexist against men. Or my white privilege isn’t absolute/isn’t real because I’m poor, disabled, gay, etc. But all men have privilege all the time. Or I’m not responsible for other people’s racism/I hate the UK being called a racist county. But all men have a responsibility to educate themselves about sexism and stand up for women. Wanting to be equal to white men is not the same thing as wanting equality for women and I’m not willing to throw my hat in with those women because they’re not fighting for me. So I probably am one of those women who would be written off as enabling misogyny because I don’t put my efforts and energy in the places I’ve been told I’m supposed to.
  5. Also similar to above, I find radical feminists to be just as arrogant, obstinate, and aggressive as liberal feminists. Terf is apparently a slur that I should find offensive, but it’s fine to call women handmaidens and traitors and cool wives. Also it’s apparently so awful to say Karen because that hurts real women and is sexist, but Wendy is fine because it didn’t go viral and those same women are happy to contribute to the bastardization of the word woke.

In conclusion, ¯\(ツ)/¯

ShyMaryEllen · 02/02/2023 17:54

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Were you shocked that it was an older woman because you expected better, or just referring to her age gratuitously?

I saw the programme, OP. I find that JV is one-dimensional, as he sets up the panel to give, when taken alongside the phone calls, what are supposed to represent a range of comments, yet they are clearly primed to sit on one 'side' or another of an imaginary fence. I didn't recognise the woman who thought the words were ok, but she was described as an author rather than a presenter or journalist, so maybe she doesn't have the experience of feigning nuanced yet oppositional feelings that the others have learnt? She didn't have a coherent argument, just that it was a good song and wasn't worse than rap artists' offerings.

I don't dispute that some women enable misogyny though. As PPs have said, it suits some to do so, particularly when they are young and pretty (as the woman on JV was). There have always been women who think that being 'one of the guys' has more status than having girlfriends. There is a brief period when women can seem to have the upper hand, too, so she may not have experienced sexism yet. When she's lived a couple of decades, is being talked over at work, has less of a hold over men, is earning less than they are, and someone else is being feted as the voice of modernity she may well have changed her mind.

DuchessOfSausage · 02/02/2023 16:46

'He helps with the housework and the kids'
not 'We both are householders and parents, and share the tasks'

itsgettingweird · 02/02/2023 16:26

Well everything in general woman excuse men for.

"Oh I can't let him go to Tesco because I can't trust him to get the right stuff" (eg men can't shop)

"If I don't organise all the cards he'll forget to get his mum one" (like her birthday and Xmas etc only started happening when you got together)

"Oh he's useless at doing/ can't do/ doesn't do laundry" (he never had clean clothes before you met?

If woman stopped enabling men to take zero responsibility once they have a woman in their lives I do think a majority of them would respect woman more.

CantAskAnyoneElse · 02/02/2023 16:22

PicnicBunny · 02/02/2023 15:29

Women are the gatekeepers of the patriarchy.

What does this mean?

PicnicBunny · 02/02/2023 15:29

Women are the gatekeepers of the patriarchy.