Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we’ve lost sight of what a healthy child’s weight should be?

516 replies

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 01/02/2023 21:42

Walking through town today as kids were leaving school and I was quite shocked by the size of them (primary kids). But then I noticed that so many of them were overweight that in a way it isn’t surprising that maybe their parents haven’t noticed or realised there is a problem? When I was little kids were skinny things, now it seems the norm for them to be built like shot-putters! I know a few parents with overweight children but they insist they’re ‘strong’ or ‘solid’, or ‘they run around so much they just burn it off’. When so many kids look like theirs it probably isn’t surprising they think that?

OP posts:
Renoir56 · 02/02/2023 11:55

What is interesting is that so many people here are making excuses for why children, and adults too, are overweight. For the majority of people if you eat more than you need you put on weight. I've put on weight recently from eating all the Christmas chocolates etc. Extra calories I don't need. I know the reason why.

People are overweight because they are eating too much (with a few exceptions). The difficulty with children and young adults being overweight is that it becomes harder to lose weight as you get older and it sets a pattern for life. I was very slim until my mid 30s then I started to put on weight. Now in my 50s and a bit overweight because my body really doesn't need that much food any more. If I ate what I wanted I'd be massive. I worry about the young women I see who are obese in their teens and their twenties and the impact it will have on their health.

Whatislove82 · 02/02/2023 11:54

RosettaTheGardenFairy · 02/02/2023 11:52

My kids are Dutch, and over here they are normal but when we took them to the UK for the summer to see wider family, I couldn't believe how skinny they were compared to other kids we saw. Their cousins who are the same age, every park we went to, every shopping centre etc. the British kids seemed so much bigger. I can't speak for the whole of the UK, this was us travelling around NW England. I'm not sure where the UK is going wrong - I've never noticed this difference anywhere else we've travelled.

Come to my affluent SE town where very sporty focussed and can’t swing a cat for organic fruit and veg shops… I honestly can’t recall any overweight children at my children’s large independent and very sporty school

Icanbuymyselfflowers · 02/02/2023 11:54

My DC is tube fed now 10 and has been since birth. We often get skinny comments and yet medically she is a healthy very perfect weight, always baffles me !

DownInTheDumpster · 02/02/2023 11:53

I think it is easy when you have skinny children to say 'oh parents are abusing and harming their children' when they are overweight but it's not as easy as that.
I have always been a size 8-10. Put on very little weight with both pregnancies, ate very well. Both babies born on 98th centile. Both EBF for one year. Both fed healthy food, homemade.
They were 98th centile at birth
At one year when barely eating food
At 2 year check
Now at 6 and 3. They are both very active, do swimming and gymnastics. Walk everywhere. Eat healthy homecooked food, minimal sugary snacks. DH and I both health weights and walk/cycle everywhere so good role modelling.
Where did I go wrong? When did I become abusive, horrible and a shit parent.
They don't look obese. They can run as fast as their friends, they eat healthier than virtually anyone I know and I asked the HV for a portion size booked when DC1 was 2 so I follow that to ensure no overeating. Never encouraged to finish food, intuitive eaters.
So these posts make me so sad as I feel I've done something horribly wrong when their whole lives I have tried to 'do it' right. And they both look healthy and well. But they are technically overweight on the BMI.

RosettaTheGardenFairy · 02/02/2023 11:52

My kids are Dutch, and over here they are normal but when we took them to the UK for the summer to see wider family, I couldn't believe how skinny they were compared to other kids we saw. Their cousins who are the same age, every park we went to, every shopping centre etc. the British kids seemed so much bigger. I can't speak for the whole of the UK, this was us travelling around NW England. I'm not sure where the UK is going wrong - I've never noticed this difference anywhere else we've travelled.

Reclaimtheoutdoors · 02/02/2023 11:49

BiasedBinding · 02/02/2023 08:30

“I don’t think it should be normal or acceptable to be overweight - I think it needs open discussion and not the be the elephant in the room that it is.”

yes worried OPs of threads like this always think it’s now “acceptable” to be overweight. Everyone knows it isn’t. Everyone who is overweight knows it isn’t. It’s ok, you don’t need to worry that all the overweight people out there think it is acceptable, they know everyone thinks it isn’t

there are millions of threads like this, they are all the same, there is no elephant in the room here

I know, I’m a confused by these kind of assertions. My weight which was already creeping upwards since 2015 skyrocketed over the early stage of the pandemic and I seen a marked change for the worse in how people treated me. I used to eat ALL the cake in my office in my 20s and I was applauded for how I ate
it and was still “skinny as a rake”. Fast forward 6 years and I had a colleague who thought it was okay to warn me against eating a single bag of crisps. She would not have said that if I was still slim.

I’ve lost a lot of weight again and I see strangers/acquaintance are a lot more pleasant to me 😐

TooSmallForTheMembrane · 02/02/2023 11:48

pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18846050/
This is also quite interesting as it shows how the way that data is processed makes a significant difference to conclusions.

FrancescaContini · 02/02/2023 11:48

TheChoiceIsYours · 02/02/2023 11:19

What people largely overlook is that bf babies being less likely to be obese later doesn’t mean breast feeding prevents obesity.

It could just as easily mean that parents who breastfeed are statistical more likely to be better educated and more affluent (because in UK culture they are the ones who breastfeed more often). And more affluent educated parents are more likely to feed their children well, send them to sports clubs and care about their weight/have time and energy and money to do something about it.

Not looking to engage in bf V ff debate - as per my previous post I have done both and couldn’t care less what people do as long as it’s right for them and the baby is fed. But it really bothers me when people spout ‘evidence’ of what bf does when the studies don’t adjust for different socio economic groups or look at siblings from the same family unit. Of course bf babies end up healthier, doing better at school and generally better off if it’s the wealthier families who are doing the bf 🤦🏼‍♀️

The point I made earlier re EBF babies was regarding worldwide data which of course incorporates data from countries both rich and poor, so your idea (a bit of a smug MC trope 🤦‍♀️) that EBF is generally only done by more affluent women is only the case for a very narrow range of countries, on a worldwide scale.

Worldwide, women of all education levels and socioeconomic backgrounds EBF their babies.

It’s a bit outdated now but The Politics of Breastfeeding by Gabrielle Palmer goes into some detail on these issues if anyone is interested in a more in-depth view.

Rainbowclimbinghigh · 02/02/2023 11:47

Lindy2 · 02/02/2023 07:42

I try to keep mine on a healthy balanced diet as they are both prone to put on weight. The thing I've found most difficult though is other people.

They go to the park with a friend and the other mum or mums hand out sweets or biscuits, they go to a friend's house and there's sweets again or a trip to the sweet shop, clubs hand out sweets as rewards, someone's birthday at school (almost every day) more sweets. It's bloody endless.

Yes, I agree.

I'm quite petite and always been on the lower end of a normal BMI so never really thought much about the role of genetics in people's metabolism etc, but my eldest DC is prone to putting on weight easily (my youngest is a beanpole, takes after me!); she takes after my DH's side of the family (short and stocky!). So I do try and take (stealthy!) action if I can see she's looking a bit plumper than usual. She was on the 80th percentile for BMI at her reception check, so in the normal weight category, but only just. (Was always on the 75th percentile for both weight and length/height from birth, but then genetics took over and her height has gone down to about 25-50th percentile).

So it's a fine line, but not helped by other parents (and also grandparents 🙄) thinking that just because it's okay for their children, it's okay. It's hard to say no without making a big deal out of it.

TheChoiceIsYours · 02/02/2023 11:44

TooSmallForTheMembrane · 02/02/2023 11:43

@TheChoiceIsYours

pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19693959/

Here’s a sibling study.

Thanks very much, I’ll have a read - I’m open to being convinced!

Kolakalia · 02/02/2023 11:44

TheChoiceIsYours · 02/02/2023 11:19

What people largely overlook is that bf babies being less likely to be obese later doesn’t mean breast feeding prevents obesity.

It could just as easily mean that parents who breastfeed are statistical more likely to be better educated and more affluent (because in UK culture they are the ones who breastfeed more often). And more affluent educated parents are more likely to feed their children well, send them to sports clubs and care about their weight/have time and energy and money to do something about it.

Not looking to engage in bf V ff debate - as per my previous post I have done both and couldn’t care less what people do as long as it’s right for them and the baby is fed. But it really bothers me when people spout ‘evidence’ of what bf does when the studies don’t adjust for different socio economic groups or look at siblings from the same family unit. Of course bf babies end up healthier, doing better at school and generally better off if it’s the wealthier families who are doing the bf 🤦🏼‍♀️

Absolutely.

Studies showing breastfeeding is correlated with lower risk of obesity don't mean breastmilk or breastfeeding prevents obesity. When they analyse it further there's zero evidence that bf or ff has any impact on weight either way. The truth is that households that are able to/choose to bf are more likely to have other factors that reduce the chances of their child being obese later in life. Same as with IQ. There's absolutely no causative relationship between bf and IQ proven, but households that bf also have other factors that make it more likely their children will score highly on IQ tests. It's really sad how the science has been distilled to such an extent in the effort to aggressively promote bf that the general public have been told that breastfeeding increases IQ and reduces the risk of obesity. It isn't true and it can put pressure on parents to bf who don't want to or aren't able to or are really struggling with it because they mistakenly believe it will help their child later in life.

TooSmallForTheMembrane · 02/02/2023 11:43

@TheChoiceIsYours

pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19693959/

Here’s a sibling study.

TheChoiceIsYours · 02/02/2023 11:42

Scottishskifun · 02/02/2023 11:36

I don't care how people feed but stating a possible link to obesity and comfort eating due to bf on demand because a pp think that is against the studies and there is a wealth of them out there.

We are talking about childhood obesity and yes the studies do link that.
Go read the studies for yourself.
There are other studies there including using opaque bottles for formula reduced overfeeding of babies. There are loads of them to go read it's not spouting evidence it's just stating the studies show the opposite of the posters thoughts!

It wasn’t me who made that comment, I don’t personally believe that either bf or ff has any bearing on weight in later life, I think it’s other factors that happen to correlate with bf.

If anyone can point me to a sibling study, or one that is otherwise adjusted to account for socio economic differences, proving a link between bf and reduced obesity then I’m all ears.

There is such a strong link between socio economic status and feeding method in this country that any study that doesn’t adjust to account for that isn’t worth the paper it’s written on.

Anecdotally the only sibling study I managed to find when I researched this was one done in the US which concluded no statistically significant difference in any outcomes between bf and ff babies. With the exception, if I remember correctly, of asthma which was worse in bf babies although they had no idea why.

I’m not anti bf AT ALL btw, I did it exclusively for nearly a year, think it’s great for lots of people - but I am against people constantly going on about ‘all the evidence’ when everything I’ve managed to find out indicates that the evidence is largely fundamentally flawed!

allthethingsyousaid · 02/02/2023 11:41

Whatislove82 · 02/02/2023 11:29

😂

what's there to laugh about? cakes from supermarkets have loads of added ingredients. classed as ultra processed food, plus they taste awful.
homemade is slightly healthier if given the choice.

Kolakalia · 02/02/2023 11:40

Yanbu.

I think as adult weight has crept up we've lost sight of a healthy weight for adults. So many people argue against their BMI category claiming they're just muscular or the age old 'it's out of date' mentality, stating they're a healthy weight when they're actually overweight or even obese. I remember reading some research where they talked to adults who were overweight and obese and many of them thought they were a healthy weight!

So it stands to reason there'd be a knock on effect when it comes to kids. Overweight and obese adults are more likely to raise overweight and obese kids, and the more common it is the more 'normal' it is. I remember in primary school in the 1990s just one child was visibly overweight and it was very obvious as it wasn't the norm. Nowadays at any school pickup you can see it's a huge percentage of the class that are overweight. It's swung so far the other way some people think if you can see a kid's ribs they're desperately underweight when it's actually normal for kids to be lean enough to see their ribs.

Along with the increase in staying indoors and using screens, lack of outdoor spaces, lack of parental knowledge around cooking healthy meals, it's a ticking time bomb for the NHS.

Sleepless1096 · 02/02/2023 11:39

Loving the idea of all those greedy indolent babies "snacking" unnecessarily on breastmilk 😂!

TheChoiceIsYours · 02/02/2023 11:37

TooSmallForTheMembrane · 02/02/2023 11:34

This is not what the evidence says.

Large cohort studies show that EBF (not just BM) considerably lowers the likelihood of obesity in later life. This is thought to be because the infant is in control of their appetite and they are not suppressing their leptin receptors, like bottle fed infants, and therefor continue to understand when to stop eating in later life.

Were those studies sibling studies? Or adjusted to account for socio economic differences? I’ve personally never been able to find any convincing evidence of the benefits of bf that does the above, so am always interested to ask this!

Scottishskifun · 02/02/2023 11:36

TheChoiceIsYours · 02/02/2023 11:19

What people largely overlook is that bf babies being less likely to be obese later doesn’t mean breast feeding prevents obesity.

It could just as easily mean that parents who breastfeed are statistical more likely to be better educated and more affluent (because in UK culture they are the ones who breastfeed more often). And more affluent educated parents are more likely to feed their children well, send them to sports clubs and care about their weight/have time and energy and money to do something about it.

Not looking to engage in bf V ff debate - as per my previous post I have done both and couldn’t care less what people do as long as it’s right for them and the baby is fed. But it really bothers me when people spout ‘evidence’ of what bf does when the studies don’t adjust for different socio economic groups or look at siblings from the same family unit. Of course bf babies end up healthier, doing better at school and generally better off if it’s the wealthier families who are doing the bf 🤦🏼‍♀️

I don't care how people feed but stating a possible link to obesity and comfort eating due to bf on demand because a pp think that is against the studies and there is a wealth of them out there.

We are talking about childhood obesity and yes the studies do link that.
Go read the studies for yourself.
There are other studies there including using opaque bottles for formula reduced overfeeding of babies. There are loads of them to go read it's not spouting evidence it's just stating the studies show the opposite of the posters thoughts!

TooSmallForTheMembrane · 02/02/2023 11:34

Cuppasoupmonster · 02/02/2023 11:17

Yes but that’s breastmilk, not breastfeeding habits IYSWIM. I didn’t say breastmilk makes a baby overweight and I know you can’t overfeed in this sense. I’m just wondering if the extreme end of ‘feeding on demand’ ingrains a mentality that any negative emotion must require food (for both child and parent).

This is not what the evidence says.

Large cohort studies show that EBF (not just BM) considerably lowers the likelihood of obesity in later life. This is thought to be because the infant is in control of their appetite and they are not suppressing their leptin receptors, like bottle fed infants, and therefor continue to understand when to stop eating in later life.

xogossipgirlxo · 02/02/2023 11:33

It's not only kids, same applies to adults.

Vallmo47 · 02/02/2023 11:30

I agree that the British have lost sight overall of what a healthy weight is. It’s no surprise this is translated into also affecting the younger generations. My primary aged child’s school tries to teach the children the importance of healthy eating while completely contradicting their own words by offering many unhealthy foods as part of their rewards. I literally discussed this with the head teacher at the gate this morning - every single week the reward for good behaviour in Year 6 is baking or cookie decorating, the “carrot” for attending SATS club is that they give out hot chocolates AND biscuits. When I suggested fruit they said it wouldn’t attract as many kids AND it’s too expensive. Society is failing us, when people cannot afford the healthy options they don’t happen as much, if at all. It’s a huge problem!

Scottishskifun · 02/02/2023 11:29

Cuppasoupmonster · 02/02/2023 11:17

Yes but that’s breastmilk, not breastfeeding habits IYSWIM. I didn’t say breastmilk makes a baby overweight and I know you can’t overfeed in this sense. I’m just wondering if the extreme end of ‘feeding on demand’ ingrains a mentality that any negative emotion must require food (for both child and parent).

Again go read the studies!

That particular study is exclusively breastfed not breastmilk data from 30,000 children in Europe tracked.

Breastmilk adapts to age of child and conditions it's not like having a feed is the equivalent of having a biscuit for comfort eating.

Whatislove82 · 02/02/2023 11:29

allthethingsyousaid · 02/02/2023 11:28

Daily slice of cake is a homemade cake btw

😂

FlumpyLump · 02/02/2023 11:28

My son is 12 and has ARFID combined with painful joints (possibly hyper mobility that he has a paediatric appointment in September for).
He uses crutches on very bad days at school.

He is overweight (which could also be the cause of his joint pain, but he had the same pains when he was a healthy weight).

His diet consists of very beige unhealthy foods. There are only a few “safe” foods. It’s either eat them or starve because he literally won’t eat anything else without vomiting as soon as it reaches his mouth.

He wants to be more active and is very aware that he is overweight, but with a poor diet and pain it makes things very difficult.

Hopefully, we can get some answers at the hospital appointment in September and help him.

allthethingsyousaid · 02/02/2023 11:28

Daily slice of cake is a homemade cake btw