Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we’ve lost sight of what a healthy child’s weight should be?

516 replies

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 01/02/2023 21:42

Walking through town today as kids were leaving school and I was quite shocked by the size of them (primary kids). But then I noticed that so many of them were overweight that in a way it isn’t surprising that maybe their parents haven’t noticed or realised there is a problem? When I was little kids were skinny things, now it seems the norm for them to be built like shot-putters! I know a few parents with overweight children but they insist they’re ‘strong’ or ‘solid’, or ‘they run around so much they just burn it off’. When so many kids look like theirs it probably isn’t surprising they think that?

OP posts:
RedToothBrush · 02/02/2023 15:00

Catspyjamas17 · 02/02/2023 14:46

People haven't lost sight of what is normal. What is normal has changed, when more people are overweight than those who aren't. If anything people saying being overweight is abnormal and shameful have lost sight of what is normal.

Vanity sizing always get trotted out on these threads. If people have changed, obviously the sizes stocked in shops changes so that shops don't size out most of their customers*.

So what if being a size 14 now makes me a 16 in 1990 and an 18 in 1965? I'm not in 1990 or 1965, thank fuck. I do weights, I've never been able to get my limbs into vintage clothes even when I was BMI 19 and less than a size 8 (in 1999). Why would it help me in my life if I couldn't buy clothes in regular shops? More than half the women in the country wouldn't be able to buy clothes if 14+ was outsize.

*That said it was hard to get sportswear to fit when I was a size 16/18. It's bad enough to get clothes as things are without sizing out half of the market.

It being 'normal to be overweight' and having a go at people saying it's abnormal is fucked in the head and part of this stupid denialism.

It is abnormal for humans to be as large as Brits are now - why?

Because it's leading to health problems and quality of life problems further down the line.

It's not about dress sizes, it's about a full grown health crisis.

Saying that it's normal for people to get cancer so why are people treating it as abnormal is about the same level of insanity. Being obese just isn't good for humans.

Oigetoffmylawn · 02/02/2023 14:46

BungleandGeorge · 02/02/2023 14:18

A lot of people who comment on these threads appear to have quite disordered thoughts and eating habits. Not surprising I guess.
food is fuel, most people would do better without most of the crap micromanaging of food and just get back to intuitive eating. Some people have deficits in recognising hunger/ full signals and will probably need professional help

I agree with this.

I definitely have issues with recognising full/ hunger signals. It hasn't always been this way though and its only in the last 8 years that I have gained weight - but I am constantly thinking about food now, it is constant internal chatter in my head. I am now on medication which has stopped this incessant background noise and its like "I used to feel like this" and I never had an issue with my diet or weight because I used to eat intuitively. I no longer eat intuitively, because I don't have the intuition any more. I don't know what switched it off, its definitely hormonal/ medical though.

Catspyjamas17 · 02/02/2023 14:46

secretllama · 02/02/2023 14:10

This , in spades!

People haven't lost sight of what is normal. What is normal has changed, when more people are overweight than those who aren't. If anything people saying being overweight is abnormal and shameful have lost sight of what is normal.

Vanity sizing always get trotted out on these threads. If people have changed, obviously the sizes stocked in shops changes so that shops don't size out most of their customers*.

So what if being a size 14 now makes me a 16 in 1990 and an 18 in 1965? I'm not in 1990 or 1965, thank fuck. I do weights, I've never been able to get my limbs into vintage clothes even when I was BMI 19 and less than a size 8 (in 1999). Why would it help me in my life if I couldn't buy clothes in regular shops? More than half the women in the country wouldn't be able to buy clothes if 14+ was outsize.

*That said it was hard to get sportswear to fit when I was a size 16/18. It's bad enough to get clothes as things are without sizing out half of the market.

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 02/02/2023 14:42

Swimming lessons is where it really shows. Of the 30 or so kids that swim at the same time as my kids I see a massive difference between these really skinny 70s style kids (the majority) ridiculously muscled kids (5-10%, I genuinely swear a couple of boys in my daughter's 5-8 class have six packs), and obese kids (2-4%, maybe).

My son is short, he was a typical butter-ball breastfed baby but it melted off him between 18m-3 years. He's now 30% for heigh, 50% for weight, so short and slightly stocky.

My daughter was the same, but she's now tall for her age and athletically built. She is 6, needs age 8 in height and age 5 in width. It's really tough. Her quads and calf muscles look like a body builders though, it's crazy. She weighs low in proportion to her height, but high for her age if that makes sense.

I think the things that trigger kids to be overweight are...

  • trauma, ill health as a baby. Parents feed them up.
  • poverty or not prioritising healthy lifestyle within your budget
  • sedentary lifestyles, electronic lifestyles.

I think parental obesity goes one of three
ways, either you get the "don't know any betters", the "we're all big in our family so what's the point in trying" types, or the "over my dead body are you turning out like me" types.

Oigetoffmylawn · 02/02/2023 14:41

YANBU.

What I find astounding is how parents refuse to accept their child is overweight when presented with actual evidence of BMI centiles.

Having said that, people say DS is "big" and "chunky" but he's actually 46th centile (done 2 weeks ago at a pediatrics appointment) so clearly isn't particularly large or chunky. They also say my daughter is "petite" but she's the same height and weight my son was at her age (42nd centile) and they called him chunky then!

I do not think people should be commenting on children's weight/ bodies in earshot of them though.

Dixiechickonhols · 02/02/2023 14:40

I live in a relatively affluent area and run a girls activity group and most children I see aren’t overweight. A few miles down road in one of most deprived towns in England it always hits me how many are overweight. If you look at child weight stats yr 6 the difference between affluent and deprived areas is very noticeable.

BungleandGeorge · 02/02/2023 14:18

A lot of people who comment on these threads appear to have quite disordered thoughts and eating habits. Not surprising I guess.
food is fuel, most people would do better without most of the crap micromanaging of food and just get back to intuitive eating. Some people have deficits in recognising hunger/ full signals and will probably need professional help

allthethingsyousaid · 02/02/2023 14:17

viques · 02/02/2023 12:15

Why do they need snacks if they are eating healthy nutritious meals? If they do need snacks after exercise then a banana or apple contains trace elements , vitamins , minerals, fibre and natural sugar rather than fat, carbs, salt and refined sugars in crisps chocolate and cake. Even homemade. Daily treats cease to be treats and become normalised into something expected .

haha! ok you try giving my DS14 an apple after he's run 5km cross country in the rain or time trails where is he left breathless. Or after a 100km cycle ride.
Also my DD12 who will cycle for half an hour in the cold and dark to get to the climbing centre, then climb for an hour and cycle 30 min back home again. She also does cross country - fasted in her year. An apple won't suffice.
Some people do need the quick acting sugary calories. They are both nearly underweight. I only worry about tooth decay, so I do limit the sugar, but otherwise I'm not demonising treats, they exercise on a daily basis,

Terven · 02/02/2023 14:15

Wanderingowl · 02/02/2023 13:29

Nope. Fructose from whole fruit is not metabolised in the same was as fructose syrup. As for healthy fats, if the milk, yogurt and cheese is all from whole milk, then that's all very health fat. As for carbs, well the best carb is potato, very significantly. Followed by oats. But wheat is fine and there is little wrong with a growing child eating bread and cereal in the same day as long as they aren't overly processed and sugary.

In humans, 70% of fructose is metabolised by the liver and 4-5 fruits are too much for a small child,I would even recommend adults eat that amount. No the best carb is not potato, on the contrary, potato is high in starch which is transformed to sugar by the body (gluconeogenesis). Yogurt is fine as long it is not full of sugar.
The example is a high sugar diet but it’s hidden if you’re not aware that carbs equal sugar.

Rainbowclimbinghigh · 02/02/2023 14:12

KickHimInTheCrotch · 02/02/2023 13:46

I see this with my DC. They get fed more or less the same meals and get similar amounts of exercise but my oldest has the tendency to lay down body fat and when she's due a growth spurt she will probably be slightly overweight on BMI. My youngest hasn't got a scrap on him and when he climbs up for a cuddle he's all elbows and ribs. My eldest is just like me, the youngest is like his dad. You can't blame it all on poorly educated, lazy parents.

Yes, same for us. Eldest DC was on 80th percentile for BMI at her reception check (now in year 2) and very much looks 'solid' (sorry! 😆), particularly in winter, I think she might sometimes tip over into overweight category, though I do keep a very close eye. She's on I think around 30th percentile for height. She very much takes after DH and his mum in stature who are all short (DH is 5'7 and his mum 5'1) and only have to look at food to put on weight.

Youngest is currently in reception and there's not much between them in height. I think he will come out at about 40-50th percentile for BMI. He takes after me who is 5'4 (so average height for a woman) and a size 8. I have a very petite frame and apart from in pregnancy the heaviest I have ever been is 9.5 stone (and looked overweight even though I wasn't!).

secretllama · 02/02/2023 14:10

PAFMO · 02/02/2023 07:26

Yanbu but British society as a whole has lost sight of what's normal and if you factor in vanity sizing in clothing and people's misunderstanding of "average" together with the need to be offended about everything, it's a lost cause.
The average British woman is a size X. That X signifies the woman is overweight gets hidden in the "but everybody else is the same" narrative.
With children it's far more insidious.

This , in spades!

usernamealreadytaken · 02/02/2023 14:08

Primroseprimula · 02/02/2023 08:18

I hate threads like this, they always descend into a smug bashing of parents who let their kids get overweight, as if it's just a case of shit parenting rather than a societal problem.

Nothing will change until people can afford a healthy balanced diet and have enough time to even think about what their eating and cook from scratch. If you are skint/time poor the cheapest/quickest way to eat is lots of processed white carbs and sugar.

When two parents working f/t on average or low wages can afford the money and time to feed their children properly, it's not a social problem it's a parent problem. There will be a few exceptions, but generally I'll stick my neck out and say it's priorities.

I, and millions of others, was brought up on a council estate (we would have been in poverty by any measure) and we ate a lot of veg, fresh or tinned (never frozen; we didn't have a freezer), didn't have meat every day and I only knew one or two fat people - they weren't the norm. We often didn't have enough food but this seems to be far healthier than eating too much rubbish. Snacks were rare (three meals a day, sometimes two), sweets were a treat at the weekend or occasionally after school - five penny sweets from the shop. We walked to school and back every day, and played out in the street.

Lilbunnyfufu · 02/02/2023 14:00

StephanieandKate · 02/02/2023 07:22

People comment about my skinny kids. They are actually a healthy weight. People don't know what that looks like anymore, and feel like they should tell me to feed my kids more when actually they are totally fine. Yeah you can see ribs, but they've also got muscle, and get a few more pounds before a growth spurt before leaning out when they shoot up again. They would still look pretty stocky compared to kids in the 1950s say

I've had a few comments about my ds being skinny but he's a good weight.

usernamealreadytaken · 02/02/2023 13:54

Ponoka7 · 02/02/2023 07:43

My primary aged granddaughter is overweight. We are an active family, hiking in Wales every school holiday, days out in the likes of chill Factore, ninja warrior etc. We do things like just dance and gymnastics with her of an evening. She doesn't eat enough calories to be the weight she is. The GP won't get involved. So what do we do?
In other people's cases they can't afford good food. I've known a few people whose GP wants them to see a practice nurse about a low cholesterol etc diet, but they couldn't afford such a diet. Some people live in areas were parks etc aren't safe.

It could just be that she'll be one of these slightly chubby youngsters who suddenly have a growth spurt and grow in to themselves. It sounds like you and the family are doing all the right things!

It's really hard to judge how much a child should weight and how many calories they should be and are actually eating. Guessing DGD is around 10 years old, she should be around 40kg and would need around 1400-1800kcal a day to be healthy. School lunches aim to be around 30% of daily calorie requirements so would be around 450-600, so the rest of the calories will be coming from home - do you have any idea how well she eats, other than not enough to be her weight? If she drinks a lot of milk that will give her a lot of calories, and perhaps she's not burning as much as you think as often as needed?

KickHimInTheCrotch · 02/02/2023 13:52

Chazx · 02/02/2023 13:02

i dont see many solid, overweight or obese kids at the school mine go to - maybe 1 in 20? when i go to nearest large city, the amount of overweight people and obese is not surprising - it's become the norm!!

I've found the opposite. My DC used to go to a large city primary and there were very few overweight kids. One or two in the whole school who really stood out and obviously a range of weights in the rest. My DS has moved to a smaller village primary and I now see more chubbier kids than ever. Not sure why- I think more are driven to school generally but that's not going to be the only factor.

KickHimInTheCrotch · 02/02/2023 13:46

Rememberal · 02/02/2023 07:49

The older my DDs have gotten the more I wonder if it's to do with genetics. Not their weight as such, but just how intrinsically hungry they are? Mine are 12 and 8 with two different fathers and they wear the same size clothes (though older DD is much taller).

They're with me at least 6 nights a week (sometimes 13 of 14) so it's not like the difference is happening at their dads house. I feed them the same but the difference is the oldest one has always been a natural "picker" like myself while the other one will polish off her plate and ask for an icecream. She is constantly snacky and thinking about food whereas my oldest will often forget to eat.

All the females in DD1s DFs family are tall and willowy size 6/8s whereas all the females in DD2s DFs family are short apple size 16/18s. I'm short and slim. They both have bodies like their dads mothers / sisters etc.

It's very strange and makes you wonder. I mean it's obviously calories in vs calories out but what makes it easier for one and harder for the other to get that balance right?

I see this with my DC. They get fed more or less the same meals and get similar amounts of exercise but my oldest has the tendency to lay down body fat and when she's due a growth spurt she will probably be slightly overweight on BMI. My youngest hasn't got a scrap on him and when he climbs up for a cuddle he's all elbows and ribs. My eldest is just like me, the youngest is like his dad. You can't blame it all on poorly educated, lazy parents.

Yuja · 02/02/2023 13:35

Hmm, there are only 2 children in DDs year (5) who are overweight and non in DS (year 3) - the others are all slim and normal sized. Although, I work in secondary schools and I would say that there are a noticeable number of overweight teenagers these days.

kittybloom · 02/02/2023 13:34

When DC1 started state primary school in 2013 in SW London, I remember thinking it was a myth about growing childhood obesity because there was probably one overweight child in each class which pretty much mirrored my time at school in the 1980s.

Roll on to 2022 and DC2 is about to leave Y6 from the same school. The increase is shocking. Really shocking. I've seen a real jump for the children in Ys 3 -5 particularly the girls.

DC2 is underweight and we are challenged regularly (which is fine, I understand why). But I think DC2 stands out more now than in earlier years because a fair few around at the school appears to be growing disproportionately large.

I feel so sorry for those overweight children. Yes, for some of them it'll slip off naturally in their teenage years and perhaps for some it doesn't stop them leading a healthy life. But for many it impacts on health, ability to be properly active and self esteem.

I agree with some of the earlier posters as to the multiple reasons we got there.

SockGoddess · 02/02/2023 13:33

I think there are many issues contributing, as PPs have outlined, but another is artificial sweeteners and low fat products. There's accumulating evidence that they confuse the body's hormonal systems, you don't feel full or you don't get the nutrients your body is expecting, and you end up craving more sweet and fatty food and your body may also store more fat (as it's responding to a perceived unreliability of nutrients). Unfortunately millions of parents, schools and authorities are wedded to the idea of "no added sugar" and reducing sugar - OK in itself but not helpful when it means loads of artificial sweeteners instead.

I am 100% sure this will all hit the fan eventually and we'll move away from them, but right now they're everywhere. I avoid for myself and my kids as much as possible.

daffodilandtulip · 02/02/2023 13:31

Also the factor that all children today are angels, whose parents can't say no to anymore.

Wanderingowl · 02/02/2023 13:29

Terven · 02/02/2023 13:20

“Bf- toast, fruit, milk
Snack- yoghurt
Lunch- cheese sandwich, carrot sticks, apple
Snack- fruit and biscuit
Dinner- homemade chilli, rice, few tortilla chips
Suoper- milk and banana”

This is not a healthy diet. Five a day is very misleading , it does not mean 5 fruit a day. Fruit is usually very high in fructose which is a sugar metabolised in the liver which is bad. Five vegetables and one fruit a day it’s what it should be.
What kind of yogurt do you give him? If it’s a flavoured one it’s probably full of sugar. 4g is equal to one tsp of sugar. Flavour your own yogurt with berries or vanilla extract.

No healthy fats whatsoever in this example, try something like avocado.. Too many fast carbs. He’s having bread for both breakfast and lunch. Replace the breakfast with for example porridge oats that you make from scratch, not the ready made ones.

if he get gets a nice home cooked dinner he shouldn’t need supper.

MIL’s diet is appalling, not much to say about that other than good luck getting him another nursery day.

Nope. Fructose from whole fruit is not metabolised in the same was as fructose syrup. As for healthy fats, if the milk, yogurt and cheese is all from whole milk, then that's all very health fat. As for carbs, well the best carb is potato, very significantly. Followed by oats. But wheat is fine and there is little wrong with a growing child eating bread and cereal in the same day as long as they aren't overly processed and sugary.

RedToothBrush · 02/02/2023 13:28

queenofthewild · 02/02/2023 13:20

I'm a size 8 in most high street shops.

I was helping DM sort her wardrobe the other day. Lots of lovely clothes she bought in the 90s, labelled size 12. I couldn't fit into any of them. Vanity sizing really is a thing.

My DS is easy to buy uniform for - I buy him skinny fit extra long. But clothes for wearing outside school all fall down. He doesn't look at all skinny to me. He's pure muscle. Buying clothes for healthy sized children is almost impossible.

Hmm. I still have clothes I bought in the 90s. Size 8. I still fit them.

Odd.

RedToothBrush · 02/02/2023 13:26

Terven · 02/02/2023 13:20

“Bf- toast, fruit, milk
Snack- yoghurt
Lunch- cheese sandwich, carrot sticks, apple
Snack- fruit and biscuit
Dinner- homemade chilli, rice, few tortilla chips
Suoper- milk and banana”

This is not a healthy diet. Five a day is very misleading , it does not mean 5 fruit a day. Fruit is usually very high in fructose which is a sugar metabolised in the liver which is bad. Five vegetables and one fruit a day it’s what it should be.
What kind of yogurt do you give him? If it’s a flavoured one it’s probably full of sugar. 4g is equal to one tsp of sugar. Flavour your own yogurt with berries or vanilla extract.

No healthy fats whatsoever in this example, try something like avocado.. Too many fast carbs. He’s having bread for both breakfast and lunch. Replace the breakfast with for example porridge oats that you make from scratch, not the ready made ones.

if he get gets a nice home cooked dinner he shouldn’t need supper.

MIL’s diet is appalling, not much to say about that other than good luck getting him another nursery day.

The one that gets me is the endless 'snacktime' at school and nursery.

Normalising snacking is a massive part of the issue.

Schools seem to use it as a way to (badly) manage behavioural issues too. Meanwhile my son who refuses to eat at school got phobed off for years until we started to go down the ADHD route and now they are paying some attention...

Ponoka7 · 02/02/2023 13:24

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 02/02/2023 08:20

I think exercise is a misconception. It doesn’t have anything like the effect people think it does on weight - a kid can ‘run around all day’ but if they’re eating too much food, the wrong food or snacking, they can be overweight. Food is the main issue here, exercise is very much secondary to that.

That's why we wanted the GP involved. She was EBF and then weaned on proper food. I was vegan at the time and my DD weight trains. She's had no access to junk. She does have a milk protein allergy though and has had bowel issues needing minor surgery. Nice bit of stereotyping though.

RedToothBrush · 02/02/2023 13:21

fruitbrewhaha · 02/02/2023 13:00

Of course you're right OP. But it's not just kids.

I live in an affluent area, commuter belt. It's not like that here, people are, on the whole not fat. But when I travel further afield I'm shocked at how fat people are elsewhere. It's not hard to deduce that this is a poorer person's problem. Wealthy people aren't experiencing this issue. It is pretty obvious that this is in part down to education but mainly shit living standards. Being poor in the UK is rubbish. It's miserable and people reach for shit food or booze to make them feel better.

Plus you can buy a packet of biscuits for 45p but 6 apples is £1.30.

With everything that's going on and don't think this is going to get any better soon.

You can get 6 apples for 89p at Aldi.

You can get a packet of biscuits for half that but generally they retail at closer to 89p for the majority of items at Aldi. A sixth of a packet of borbons versus an apple is going to dent your appetite differently. The apple may well be better value for money but realising this isn't that simple.