Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we’ve lost sight of what a healthy child’s weight should be?

516 replies

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 01/02/2023 21:42

Walking through town today as kids were leaving school and I was quite shocked by the size of them (primary kids). But then I noticed that so many of them were overweight that in a way it isn’t surprising that maybe their parents haven’t noticed or realised there is a problem? When I was little kids were skinny things, now it seems the norm for them to be built like shot-putters! I know a few parents with overweight children but they insist they’re ‘strong’ or ‘solid’, or ‘they run around so much they just burn it off’. When so many kids look like theirs it probably isn’t surprising they think that?

OP posts:
CleaningOutMyCloset · 02/02/2023 08:04

I don't think it's just children we've lost sight of either, I think adults are the same. People used to always comment on how skinny I was and I needed a decent meal, but I was mid BMI (I'm not now menopause has hit) and a healthy weight.

Crabbity · 02/02/2023 08:04

MooseBreath · 02/02/2023 07:58

My DS (2y8m) is in the 75th centile for height and 91st for weight, but his ribs are clearly visible and he wears 2T size clothing. He feels way heavier than he looks (the health visitor was very surprised when she weighed him!), but he is definitely healthy.

I think if kids are active and eat healthily, worrying about weight is pointless. They have growth spurts and shoot up like weeds and often have "puppy fat" for no discernable reason.

I’ve got one of these too. PE twice a week, swimming once a week, three other sporty extracurricular classes and runs round like a loon the rest of the time. Looks visibly slim (and I’m not just saying that…) ribs are visible, legs Twiggy would have been jealous of. And yet she’s 98th centile for weight, and from memory hovering above the 75th for height. She was a heavy, slim baby, a heavy, slim toddler and so the trend continues now she’s at school. My youngest on the other hand is built like a bird and weighs about as much as one too. Genetics have to play a part in there somewhere.

liann34 · 02/02/2023 08:03

Well YANBU but its pretty well known, isnt it? There was a meme going around a while ago comparing the Augustus Gloop character from the old and new Willy Wonka films, who is supposed to be hugely fat, showing the difference.

SugarLatte · 02/02/2023 08:03

Yep and to add I have to buy ‘slim fit’ clothes for my younger 2, they’re not slim they’re normal! My eldest is early 20’s and they’re the same build she was as a child and she never needed slim fit clothes, tbh I don’t think they existed, they’ve just made normal clothes into slim fit, so normal ones are now plus fit and plus fit are double plus fit!

Ostryga · 02/02/2023 07:59

Yes! It frustrates the hell out of me. Dd is slim and I actually thought she was underweight and worried because she’s so much smaller than her friends. When I took her to the dr to check everything was fine they looked at me like I was mad as she’s the perfect weight. It’s become so ingrained that kids should have ‘puppy fat’ when it’s not true.

SavoirFlair · 02/02/2023 07:58

I can see on social media what they eat as she always posts at the weekends and it's all massive portions of junk.

The problem is, these types equate it with “love”. They want to show the sheer abundance in their worlds - how much “fun” food is.

It’s all so wrong but if you comment on it (who would dare to!) you’re seen as elitist, or you’re told you have more money and time and choices or whatever… 🙄

MooseBreath · 02/02/2023 07:58

My DS (2y8m) is in the 75th centile for height and 91st for weight, but his ribs are clearly visible and he wears 2T size clothing. He feels way heavier than he looks (the health visitor was very surprised when she weighed him!), but he is definitely healthy.

I think if kids are active and eat healthily, worrying about weight is pointless. They have growth spurts and shoot up like weeds and often have "puppy fat" for no discernable reason.

countrygirl99 · 02/02/2023 07:58

smileladiesplease · 02/02/2023 07:48

I think you are talking nonsense op. I am nearly 60 and have grown up kids and grand kids. Been in a school playground picking up both for over 40 years. Kids seems just as mixed today in size as they ever were. As a teenager in the 80s the desired size was a size 12! I was an 8 and got teased.

As a 70s kid all sizes in my class from skinny to very fat.
My 22 year old dd has friends of all shapes and sizes.

Nothing new here. All this we were all skinnier in the past is nonsense

I'm 64 and I completely disagree with you.

SugarLatte · 02/02/2023 07:57

Totally agree. My 4 children all what I would call totally normal build but get called ‘skinny’ or ‘anorexic’. Even had DSD mother tell my DH in one of her rants that my children are malnourished! But the ironic thing is DSD is 9 yrs old and she is the malnourished one, she lives on a diet of beige junk and endless snacks and is obese, she’s wearing adult size 12 at 5 foot tall.

Her parents are buying their heads in the sand (yes DH included) I’ve given up trying to gently suggest things as it just gets met with things like ‘if I want to treat her when she’s with me then I will’ (Disney dad). She sits watching telly or playing on an iPad all day because then dh (and it’s the same at her mums) doesn’t have to bother with her. She refuses to come out if me and my youngest 2 are off out doing something so I’ve stopped trying.

Paddingtonsmarmlade · 02/02/2023 07:57

Yep I can't get clothes to fit ds, he isn't tall for his age, age 6. He is still in 4 to 5 swim trunks and they still have to be tie front so they can be tightened. Ok in the summer when he can wear shorts, trousers are difficult, school ones are skinny extra long aged 5-6 for length and then tighten to the maximum. Anything the right length hangs off him.

dd is stockier than ds but still hard to get length required but at least dresses don't fall down if baggy.

closingscore · 02/02/2023 07:56

I don't know what goes through people's minds sometimes.

I've got a friend with two young boys about 11/8 years old and they're both massive. I can see on social media what they eat as she always posts at the weekends and it's all massive portions of junk.

ferneytorro · 02/02/2023 07:56

smileladiesplease · 02/02/2023 07:48

I think you are talking nonsense op. I am nearly 60 and have grown up kids and grand kids. Been in a school playground picking up both for over 40 years. Kids seems just as mixed today in size as they ever were. As a teenager in the 80s the desired size was a size 12! I was an 8 and got teased.

As a 70s kid all sizes in my class from skinny to very fat.
My 22 year old dd has friends of all shapes and sizes.

Nothing new here. All this we were all skinnier in the past is nonsense

Thats simply not true.

Saschka · 02/02/2023 07:54

I do think expectations are different- DS is 25th centile, and him and one other boy are literally head and shoulders shorter than the other kids in his class (year 1). I get loads of comments on how skinny and short he is - he is 9th centile for weight and 25th for height, so completely normal BMI and well within normal range at a population level. But in his class, definitely tiny.

The kids are much taller and more solid (lots of kids on age 8-9 clothes aged 5-6). Overweight parents, so I suspect as the kids get older many of them will end up properly overweight.

Sirzy · 02/02/2023 07:54

We have such a snacking culture too which doesn’t help. It seems every social activity from baby groups up has to revolve around snacks. It’s as if we are scared to let children feel a little bit peckish.

Siameasy · 02/02/2023 07:54

Yup another thing you’re not allowed to say.
My DD does 12hrs of gymnastics a week but I still monitor her diet closely. Proof that you can’t out run a bad diet-there are several fat gymnasts in her club. Many of her co-gymnasts get KFC after every session and bring in sharing bags of crisps.

This highly addictive food is now available 24:7. If you’re NOT fat it’s a miracle.

SavoirFlair · 02/02/2023 07:52

smileladiesplease · 02/02/2023 07:48

I think you are talking nonsense op. I am nearly 60 and have grown up kids and grand kids. Been in a school playground picking up both for over 40 years. Kids seems just as mixed today in size as they ever were. As a teenager in the 80s the desired size was a size 12! I was an 8 and got teased.

As a 70s kid all sizes in my class from skinny to very fat.
My 22 year old dd has friends of all shapes and sizes.

Nothing new here. All this we were all skinnier in the past is nonsense

And I think you are talking nonsense @smileladiesplease -

See this for evidence:

theatlantic.com/health/archive/2015/09/why-it-was-easier-to-be-skinny-in-the-1980s/407974

“a study published recently in the journal Obesity Research and Clinical Practice found that it’s harder for adults today to maintain the same weight as those 20 to 30 years ago did, even at the same levels of food intake and exercise”.

Look - I see it with my own eyes - so so many more overweight teens especially girls. It is a thing.

Fleabigg · 02/02/2023 07:52

I’m in a middle class area and most of the children still look a healthy weight to me, but the few overweight looking preschoolers I know were the “chunky” ebf babies whose mothers were being praised to the hills by the health visitor for it.

CatSpeakForDummies · 02/02/2023 07:51

randomsabreuse · 02/02/2023 07:24

My older one is skinny. Still fits in age 3-4 for width at 7 (but only one weird extra extra long skirt for length) . I struggle to buy dresses that don't fall off.

My younger one looks a lot chunkier but it's all shoulders. He's wearing his sister's hand me down jeans and they're all skinny fit.

So I wouldn't judge from how kids look in clothes - younger one looks a chunky thing dressed then you see all the ribs in the bath!

You should try the European brands, which haven't been vanity sized for chunkier kids. Vertbaudet even has a skinny option for a lot of clothes, which is actual skinny rather than "British skinny."

Renoir56 · 02/02/2023 07:51

I think it's partly the constant snacking and availability of food, especially ready made food and takeaways. I hate harking back to the past but I'm in my 50s and there just wasn't as much food around when I was growing up. We didn't snack constantly and we got sweets once a week. I only remember one overweight child in my class of 30 at secondary school. I've recently noticed that there are a lot of teenage girls and young women who are very overweight. It's good that they have confidence in themselves but it's not healthy and will cause them problems in the future.

Rememberal · 02/02/2023 07:49

The older my DDs have gotten the more I wonder if it's to do with genetics. Not their weight as such, but just how intrinsically hungry they are? Mine are 12 and 8 with two different fathers and they wear the same size clothes (though older DD is much taller).

They're with me at least 6 nights a week (sometimes 13 of 14) so it's not like the difference is happening at their dads house. I feed them the same but the difference is the oldest one has always been a natural "picker" like myself while the other one will polish off her plate and ask for an icecream. She is constantly snacky and thinking about food whereas my oldest will often forget to eat.

All the females in DD1s DFs family are tall and willowy size 6/8s whereas all the females in DD2s DFs family are short apple size 16/18s. I'm short and slim. They both have bodies like their dads mothers / sisters etc.

It's very strange and makes you wonder. I mean it's obviously calories in vs calories out but what makes it easier for one and harder for the other to get that balance right?

smileladiesplease · 02/02/2023 07:48

I think you are talking nonsense op. I am nearly 60 and have grown up kids and grand kids. Been in a school playground picking up both for over 40 years. Kids seems just as mixed today in size as they ever were. As a teenager in the 80s the desired size was a size 12! I was an 8 and got teased.

As a 70s kid all sizes in my class from skinny to very fat.
My 22 year old dd has friends of all shapes and sizes.

Nothing new here. All this we were all skinnier in the past is nonsense

SmileWithADimple · 02/02/2023 07:46

I agree with @Sceptre86 that the problem starts very young. When your baby DC drops down the percentiles there is a lot of concern and pressure to get them to gain weight even if they are perfectly healthy in all other ways. I experienced this with DS1, who was born on the 75th percentile and dropped down to the 25th. He's now 17yo and still skinny but very active and healthy. I think this gets new mums into the mindset of trying to feed them up and seeing weight gain as a positive thing.

maddiemookins16mum · 02/02/2023 07:45

YANBU, it’s the constant snacking and huge portions. We were at a friends last week, the 8 year old (overweight) had 4 sausages, 3 potato waffles and half a tin of beans. Probably twice as much as ‘recommended’. Then 2 yoghurts for pudding.

hungerganes · 02/02/2023 07:45

My DD was a very healthy weight but had comments about being too skinny. So you can visualise it, when she was 3 years old she would wear size 2y until about 4 or 6 months after her 3rd birthday then she would be in size 3y. She's hardly a skeleton. We're also quite petite from both sides of the family, short and a small frame with slender limbs, it's normal for our family to be on the smaller side of normal but still had comments.

Babsexxx · 02/02/2023 07:44

Well no your not wrong however not a lot of parents are well educated when it comes to portion sizes either there was a disgraced mum sharing all to the papers that would listen in regards to her 10 year olds more than sufficient school dinner not being enough when it was more than enough!

My sons a big eater and he could easily get out of hand weight wise if I allowed it but I don’t so he’s not! I have a fruit bowl constantly full and a melon always in the fridge and they are in our house unlimited foods, take it or leave it and just always make sure children are well hydrated as this causes a lot of confusion with hunger to! All common sense stuff.

Swipe left for the next trending thread