Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we’ve lost sight of what a healthy child’s weight should be?

516 replies

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 01/02/2023 21:42

Walking through town today as kids were leaving school and I was quite shocked by the size of them (primary kids). But then I noticed that so many of them were overweight that in a way it isn’t surprising that maybe their parents haven’t noticed or realised there is a problem? When I was little kids were skinny things, now it seems the norm for them to be built like shot-putters! I know a few parents with overweight children but they insist they’re ‘strong’ or ‘solid’, or ‘they run around so much they just burn it off’. When so many kids look like theirs it probably isn’t surprising they think that?

OP posts:
Teateaandmoretea · 02/02/2023 08:31

Yabu for starting yet another thread on it and kicking off all the wailing about how to be healthy kids have to be rake thin.

Dd2 is in year 6 has just been weighed/ measured and her bmi percentile is 50%. She isn’t skinny at all, but nicely rounded and muscly but slim, obviously. Dd1 has always been skinny and was more like 25%. If your child was 85% and within healthy then I doubt there would be ribs on show unless your child was a particularly odd build.

BiasedBinding · 02/02/2023 08:30

“I don’t think it should be normal or acceptable to be overweight - I think it needs open discussion and not the be the elephant in the room that it is.”

yes worried OPs of threads like this always think it’s now “acceptable” to be overweight. Everyone knows it isn’t. Everyone who is overweight knows it isn’t. It’s ok, you don’t need to worry that all the overweight people out there think it is acceptable, they know everyone thinks it isn’t

there are millions of threads like this, they are all the same, there is no elephant in the room here

randomsabreuse · 02/02/2023 08:28

My daughter definitely flirts with being underweight. She's usually somewhere between 2nd and 5th BMI centile depending on growth spurt phase. The problem is that the healthy eating talk in school means (at 7) that she asks if her food is healthy and will happily leave half a portion of cake... I can always tell when she's about to shoot up as she suddenly starts eating all the food and demanding more!

DS eats more and I'm always surprised he's not overweight - his hips are narrow compared with his shoulders and ribs (broader than 7 year old) so we keep an eye on him far more than her.

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 02/02/2023 08:28

@Forgooodnesssakenow see to me even his diet when he is with you has too many snacks and carbs. BMI takes height into account so will be adjusting for that, so a ‘top end’ yet tall child is still in the same position as a shorter ‘top end’ child.

OP posts:
Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 02/02/2023 08:25

I hate threads like this, they always descend into a smug bashing of parents who let their kids get overweight, as if it's just a case of shit parenting rather than a societal problem.

I wouldn’t call it shit parenting but ‘society’ doesn’t cook your meals every night - if you’re a child then your parents do. There has to be a bit of personal responsibility somewhere, it serves nobody for everyone to just blame each other but essentially only the parents can do something about it.

I don’t think it should be normal or acceptable to be overweight - I think it needs open discussion and not the be the elephant in the room that it is.

OP posts:
Fundays12 · 02/02/2023 08:25

People definitely have no idea what's normal or healthy now. A lady I know tried to insist to her 4 years old was healthy sized. He weighed 4st at 4 years old and was stuffing 2 ice creams in his mouth at the time. He is now 8 and so fat he can't run and wears adult clothes. My eldest is under weight, my middle and younger a healthy weight but I know the middle one could get podgy if we didn't monitor and limit his mindless eating. They are all active kids but me and DH are active and within a healthy BMI.

I see so many kids and young people who are seriously over weight though and the body positive movement has done a huge disservice to our health and mind. I am prepared to get flamed for that but hear me out.

Body positivity is wonderful and I fully embrace it. I wish i had more body confidence when I was younger but obesity is not body positivity. It is dangerous for your health, costs the NHS millions a year and kills people. Body positivity to me is about healthy and active bodies, embracing our stretch marks, our scars, our cellulite, eating healthy to let our bodies run well and exercising so we let your bodies burn fuel and support our mental health. It is not getting so fat that you can barely move and are going to die young. Woman in general have curves which are beautiful and how we are built but obesity kills and there is a huge difference between curves and layers of fat.

FlamingoSocks · 02/02/2023 08:25

I’ve got a 6 year old who looks like the class TA. Over 98th centile for height, size 3 shoes, wears 8-9 clothes. Doesn’t seem fat but is just enormous. Teeters on overweight BMI. I do watch it with him. My brother is 6ft 7 and has a similar body type so assuming it’s genetic. Then the 11 year old who has always been a bag of bones except now he has become very muscly. Defined abs etc. Low end of normal BMI. Fed and raised the same.

One thing is I did have GD in my second pregnancy and I do sometimes wonder if it has an effect on DS2. It’s getting much more common now.

Forgooodnesssakenow · 02/02/2023 08:23

I've checked and my son is at the top end of healthy BMI but he's off the scale for height and wears age 6-7 at almost 5. He's very long torso and you can see the outline of his ribs. He tipped I to overweight after mil started having him a day a week while I worked

Normal day he has

Bf- toast, fruit, milk
Snack- yoghurt
Lunch- cheese sandwich, carrot sticks, apple
Snack- fruit and biscuit
Dinner- homemade chilli, rice, few tortilla chips
Suoper- milk and banana

Nursery days lunch is a hot meal and snacks are pretty similar.

When she has him if left to her own devices

Bf-toast, cereal, box of raisins, offers a croissant
Snack- crisps, chocolate, biscuits (not either or, all)
Lunch- McDonald's AND not just a happy mean she also orders extra fries, extra nuggets so he has extra and offers ice cream
Afternoon- takes him to a cafe for cake
Dinner-if we've left a healthy lunch and insisted on it she gets h a McDonald's so he's had that before we can offer dinner

He literally is turning down snacks and 1 days she gave him 4 fruit shoots. We've had a serious chat with her and proof shall be in the pudding next week This kid on à normal day if he gets sweets it's 3 jelly babies, she'll hand him a sharing bag. She's seriously obese (and I'm overweight so I'm not criticising but it's relevant). We're hoping nursery will have the extra day available soon and thankfully either way he'll be at school in August but if a child was fed like she feeds him every day they'd be massively obese.

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 02/02/2023 08:23

@Rememberal do they have the same portion sizes though? Do you give her the ice cream? Another issue is portion sizes, kids don’t seem to have ‘child portions’ any more.

And yes I agree about the snacking there always seems to be an endless supply of babybels, bananas and grapes on hand!

OP posts:
MaryBeardsShoes · 02/02/2023 08:22

Why do these posts always say "WE have lost sight of what healthy weight looks like" when what you mean is "YOU are all greedy disgusting pigs and I am soooo healthy."

AIBUYESYES · 02/02/2023 08:21

I hate threads like this, they always descend into a smug bashing of parents who let their kids get overweight, as if it's just a case of shit parenting rather than a societal problem.

well, given that parents are buying the food and giving it to their kids, it IS their responsibility!

You see them in the supermarket, with litres of coke or fizzy drinks in the trolley and a load of processed crap.

It might be lack of education behind it, but there is so much out there on healthy eating, it's hard to understand why so many people just 'don't get it'.

SaltanVinegar · 02/02/2023 08:20

It’s something I’ve been more aware of since my older one hit puberty. He was never overweight in primary school, and really quite skinny at times, but he gained weight over the last year or so and doesn’t like it himself. He is by no means huge, and many of his friends look bigger or the same as him, but he goes to the gym now and is reducing unhealthy foods. He doesn’t find it easy.

My younger one is still in primary school, and is among the slimmer kids, but I know now that can change fairly easily and am more mindful of exercise, snacking and poor food choices.

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 02/02/2023 08:20

Ponoka7 · 02/02/2023 07:43

My primary aged granddaughter is overweight. We are an active family, hiking in Wales every school holiday, days out in the likes of chill Factore, ninja warrior etc. We do things like just dance and gymnastics with her of an evening. She doesn't eat enough calories to be the weight she is. The GP won't get involved. So what do we do?
In other people's cases they can't afford good food. I've known a few people whose GP wants them to see a practice nurse about a low cholesterol etc diet, but they couldn't afford such a diet. Some people live in areas were parks etc aren't safe.

I think exercise is a misconception. It doesn’t have anything like the effect people think it does on weight - a kid can ‘run around all day’ but if they’re eating too much food, the wrong food or snacking, they can be overweight. Food is the main issue here, exercise is very much secondary to that.

OP posts:
AIBUYESYES · 02/02/2023 08:19

It also applies to adults.

I am short, and small framed.

I have had some comments about being 'too thin' yet I'm the same size I was as a teen (now in my early 60s.) I also have some belly fat, so I'm not skinny.

Any weight I put on would be fat and round my middle.

I also get fed up with people saying I am 'lucky' (to be slim) when in fact it's just hard work, not over eating and doing exercise.

I agree with you OP.

When I was at school, there was usually one 'fatty' in the class of 30. And yes, that's what they were called as they stood out as being the odd one.

Things have changed.

bluejelly · 02/02/2023 08:18

It is really sad and it is definitely getting worse (the stats are clear). On a societal level it is not an easy one to fix as the problems are nuanced and complicated and involve societal forces and powerful industries.
And it's very easy to blame individuals rather than the snack/sugar industry, the supermarkets, poverty and inequality etc.
Of course there is some individual responsibility (and that is a tough one to crack) but the way so many deeply unhealthy snacks and foods are deliberately targeted and marketed at children is abhorrent. They are literally marketing disease and they hide behind phrases like 'should only be eaten as part of a balanced diet' or 'enjoy responsibly'. If we genuinely only ate highly processed/sugar laden food once a month the rates of type 2 Diabetes would plummet - but then so would the business models of Walkers, Cadburys, McDonalds, chicken shops, the big supermarkets etc.

Primroseprimula · 02/02/2023 08:18

I hate threads like this, they always descend into a smug bashing of parents who let their kids get overweight, as if it's just a case of shit parenting rather than a societal problem.

Nothing will change until people can afford a healthy balanced diet and have enough time to even think about what their eating and cook from scratch. If you are skint/time poor the cheapest/quickest way to eat is lots of processed white carbs and sugar.

Cornelious2011 · 02/02/2023 08:17

My dd put in weight during lockdown. Not because of diet but because she was no longer swimming 3 times a week, doing ballet or just running around. I knew that once things got back to normal her weight would adjust which within 6 weeks it did. Where I live I don't see many overweight kids. It's quite a MC area and kids are very active and most involved in multiple clubs/ sports.

MooseBreath · 02/02/2023 08:14

midgetastic · 02/02/2023 08:05

No

Dangerous attitude

Many kids are overweight

Being overweight is a huge health problem

10% of the nhs budget is for type 2 diabetes alone - caused primarily by being fat
Instead of clapping for the nhs people could diet for them

Losing weight as an adult is almost impossible
Gaining healthy eating patterns is best done as a child

You are failing your child if you overfeed them . You are giving them in alll likelihood a lifetime of health problems and an early death

So many children are overweight it's so sad

But my child isn't being overfed. He eats healthily (5 a day, homemade, and correct portion sizes with limited sweets/biscuits). And he runs around all the bloody time, and when he's not running, he's jumping and dancing. Yet he is really heavy. His dad, grandad, and great-grandad are rugby builds and always have been.

So what am I to do?

Ponoka7 · 02/02/2023 08:13

smileladiesplease · 02/02/2023 07:48

I think you are talking nonsense op. I am nearly 60 and have grown up kids and grand kids. Been in a school playground picking up both for over 40 years. Kids seems just as mixed today in size as they ever were. As a teenager in the 80s the desired size was a size 12! I was an 8 and got teased.

As a 70s kid all sizes in my class from skinny to very fat.
My 22 year old dd has friends of all shapes and sizes.

Nothing new here. All this we were all skinnier in the past is nonsense

The desired size 12, is now the equivalent of today's size 8. So nothing has changed there. You were a today's size 4. I was overweight as a child/teen in the 70/80's. There were only two fat girls in our year, me and another girl. It's now an even split. I can remember when alcopops became popular, it did change the shape of older teen girls. Fast food hit around the same time.

I'm surprised that people can't get clothes to fit their children, though. My other GC is in the size for her age. Only in Next we have to size down one, but the clothes fit. You can see her bones and she would be described as slight.

Dguu6u · 02/02/2023 08:11

midgetastic · 02/02/2023 08:05

No

Dangerous attitude

Many kids are overweight

Being overweight is a huge health problem

10% of the nhs budget is for type 2 diabetes alone - caused primarily by being fat
Instead of clapping for the nhs people could diet for them

Losing weight as an adult is almost impossible
Gaining healthy eating patterns is best done as a child

You are failing your child if you overfeed them . You are giving them in alll likelihood a lifetime of health problems and an early death

So many children are overweight it's so sad

Love this: instead of clapping for the NHS, people should be dieting.

What I don't understand is that people are so ignorant that they are harming their kids by letting them become overweight.

Clara84 · 02/02/2023 08:11

I worry about this. My toddler is 'built'. I look at what they eat at nursery and it's constant food - meals and 'snacks'. We don't feed like that at home - it's 3 meals But I'm told that the food at nursery is to NHS guidelines.

My toddler came out a bruiser.....98 percentile for weight, around 75 percentile for length. DH is stocky. Following the 'curve' in the red book and toddler is bang on the line.

I'm told that it's following the line that is an indication of health. We're told that by HV that we're doing it right.

Thing is both DH and I are overweight - me by about 2-3 stone, so I have a niggling fear that people judge. I wasn't previously fat. DH has always been fat. It sounds silly but I feel a pressure now to get skinny so my child won't be judged in the same way. I just need to get my head sorted on a diet.

I know it's not a big issue right now in the age group - babies and toddlers are allowed to be chunky. But as they move to pre-schoolers and into reception, I do worry about how this will go.

I was a skinny child, as were my siblings and rest of my family.

Dguu6u · 02/02/2023 08:08

Agree - even though BMI isn't always accurate, you can clearly see that lots of kids are overweight, The parents are setting them up for a hard life of either health issues, or needing to constantly watch their weight.

Some of the parents are shockingly obese too and are passing that on to their kids.

FlimFlamBam · 02/02/2023 08:06

Overall people have last sight of what overweight means in children and adults. I remember being criticised for being underweight at work, I’m 5ft 4 and weighed about 9 stone and a couple of pounds. It seems as if being slim can be criticised but being overweight can’t be. Everything is totally skewed and I see my overweight friends now slipping in to prediabetes as we all hit later middle age and then being offended they are told to lose weight.

I just found my old school photo from the 1980’s online with me in as part of the schools memories and heritage section! Not one child is overweight and I lived in quite a deprived area.

midgetastic · 02/02/2023 08:05

MooseBreath · 02/02/2023 07:58

My DS (2y8m) is in the 75th centile for height and 91st for weight, but his ribs are clearly visible and he wears 2T size clothing. He feels way heavier than he looks (the health visitor was very surprised when she weighed him!), but he is definitely healthy.

I think if kids are active and eat healthily, worrying about weight is pointless. They have growth spurts and shoot up like weeds and often have "puppy fat" for no discernable reason.

No

Dangerous attitude

Many kids are overweight

Being overweight is a huge health problem

10% of the nhs budget is for type 2 diabetes alone - caused primarily by being fat
Instead of clapping for the nhs people could diet for them

Losing weight as an adult is almost impossible
Gaining healthy eating patterns is best done as a child

You are failing your child if you overfeed them . You are giving them in alll likelihood a lifetime of health problems and an early death

So many children are overweight it's so sad

SophiaLarsen · 02/02/2023 08:04

It's actually very frustrating for me as a parent to a child of healthy weight. This is because she has so many overweight friends around her that she thinks she is the unhealthy one! She thinks her arms are too skinny and knees too big etc. She judges herself because her ribs can be seen when she breathes in hard and she has a muscle line down the middle of her tummy. She's smack bang on the 50th percentile for weight and 90th for height. She looks great. But she thinks she's not normal.

Swipe left for the next trending thread