Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we’ve lost sight of what a healthy child’s weight should be?

516 replies

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 01/02/2023 21:42

Walking through town today as kids were leaving school and I was quite shocked by the size of them (primary kids). But then I noticed that so many of them were overweight that in a way it isn’t surprising that maybe their parents haven’t noticed or realised there is a problem? When I was little kids were skinny things, now it seems the norm for them to be built like shot-putters! I know a few parents with overweight children but they insist they’re ‘strong’ or ‘solid’, or ‘they run around so much they just burn it off’. When so many kids look like theirs it probably isn’t surprising they think that?

OP posts:
Scottishskifun · 02/02/2023 09:18

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 02/02/2023 09:06

I don’t understand how any child can be a ‘beanpole’ yet overweight according to BMI which factors in height? I’m not being rude I just don’t understand how that is possible. I do wonder as some of the kids I know whose parents describe them as ‘beanpoles’ are actually average or slightly above, again because we’ve lost sight of what a healthy weight looks like.

He's towards the overweight end not yet tipped into it. BMI calculators are a fairly blunt tool and for a small percentage of children and adults don't factor in other elements and therefore skewed.
My DS you can see his ribs which is normal for children of a healthy weight. I don't know whether it's bone density or what but honestly trousers fall off nothing fits because he's slim. The shorts with the button adjustable waist bands are on the tightest they will go.
Yet if I do a BMI calculator alone he's at 85%!

Artemi · 02/02/2023 09:18

I'm not a parent yet but it's something I do worry about - how to tread the line between our culture of processed fast food and conversely the image focused celebrity diet culture, particularly for girls.

I feel very lucky that I was instilled with a healthy attitude to food, but even then growing up as a teenage girl and young woman you pick up so much internalised shame. I do think that if I'd not had a good grounding as a child I could have developed a binge eating disorder

Clymene · 02/02/2023 09:17

StephanieandKate · 02/02/2023 07:22

People comment about my skinny kids. They are actually a healthy weight. People don't know what that looks like anymore, and feel like they should tell me to feed my kids more when actually they are totally fine. Yeah you can see ribs, but they've also got muscle, and get a few more pounds before a growth spurt before leaning out when they shoot up again. They would still look pretty stocky compared to kids in the 1950s say

Gosh that's so weird because one of my kids has been on the 3rd centile for weight since he was a toddler and teeters on the edge of underweight at times.

No one has ever ever commented on his weight. Not once.

allthethingsyousaid · 02/02/2023 09:17

Fleabigg · 02/02/2023 07:52

I’m in a middle class area and most of the children still look a healthy weight to me, but the few overweight looking preschoolers I know were the “chunky” ebf babies whose mothers were being praised to the hills by the health visitor for it.

Is this some kind of dig at breastfeeding?

You can't overfeed a ebf baby and FWIW my "chunky" ebf baby is a skinny, near the bottom of normal weight 12yr old.

Unikeko · 02/02/2023 09:16
Biscuit
Aleaiactaest · 02/02/2023 09:16

It is a class and poverty issue. There are hardly any obese children in private schools across the country both because the schools tend to exercise them most days and because the parents are often rich & educated and can afford a healthy diet. There are far fewer obese children in grammar schools and state primaries with a very low percentage of free school meals.
Fast and processed food is easier and cheaper. Cramming a certain class of people into the same schools and same jobs leads to obesity and poor health outcomes throughout life and costs the NHS more money.

There is also such a thing as a fat/starvation gene which you can inherit if you come from a poor background. It has been observed in the Netherlands due to the 1940s famine. It is also partly why a Chinese or Indian person who carries the gene is more likely to become Type 2 diabetic even if they don’t look properly fat to us. Anyway, it is a very complex area. www.nytimes.com/2018/01/31/science/dutch-famine-genes.html

Good nutrition, exercise, good education for all is at the heart of a healthy population that is productive. There should be a huge drive to eat local and seasonal healthy foods again in appropriate quantities.

Tessasanderson · 02/02/2023 09:15

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 02/02/2023 09:07

No, I disagree. Exercise really doesn’t offset lots and lots of food anywhere near as much as people think it does. A lot of the overweight kids I know are always on the go or out on their bikes, it really doesn’t mop up after a bad diet or too much food.

I have been involved in childrens sport for 30 years. I know how much a child can put away and still remain fit and healthy. As long as it is a balanced diet a child can put away an enormous amount without putting on weight if they are active. When i say active i mean properly active. That is the issue i am highlighting. Kids these days dont get much oppertunity to be active, get the heart rate up etc. They spend most of their lives in the back seat of a car being driven everywhere. Most would never choose to take the stairs rather than a lift etc.

CatSpeakForDummies · 02/02/2023 09:15

I think people wildly overestimate how much physical activity there is in a child's sports class, or PE. They think how tired they would feel, as an adult who can swim, swimming non stop for 45 minutes. In fact, in a lot of classes the kids spend more time lining up for a turn than they do actually using any energy. They would get more benefit from walking to and from the class (fitness wise).

Once they are about 9-10, this changes but it's honestly not the fit and healthy lifestyle people claim it is. Not when you consider how much time they are sedentary, in cars etc. Kids were actually more active when they walked everywhere but had less structured classes.

RudsyFarmer · 02/02/2023 09:14

Unless you’ve watched your child get seriously ill and disappear before your eyes SO quickly you’ll never know how glad you are that they have a little bit of puppy fat.

I’m happy my eldest isn’t whippet thin and I’m trying (and failing) to give my small one a little covering too.

freckles20 · 02/02/2023 09:14

@Winniethepoohandtiggertoo fair enough. But I can assure you that DS is broad but skinny and overweight in terms of BMI but is now under the care of an nhs dietician and neurologist to help him gain weight.

He is what I'd describe as broad. So the width of his shoulders is much longer than average, his feet and hands are huge.

I guess that if you could see just DS' skeleton it would be wider and the bones would be bigger and more substantial (but not longer) than skeletons of people of the same height.

So maybe like comparing the frame or skeleton of a German Shepherd to that of a greyhound- both similar height and length but one has a very different frame to the other and can be much heavier but still a healthy weight.

JaceLancs · 02/02/2023 09:14

I do think a lot of it is portion sizes
when I was growing up in the 60s and 70s there wasn’t as much junk food about and it was more expensive
DM worked FT so didn’t have huge amounts of time to home cook but I remember what would now be eaten as a one person pizza split between 4 of us with lots of salad
Birds Eye burgers pack of 4 - we got one each with a 1/4 of a tin of beans and a slice of bread
thankfully the fruit bowl was always full

pitterypattery00 · 02/02/2023 09:13

smileladiesplease · 02/02/2023 07:48

I think you are talking nonsense op. I am nearly 60 and have grown up kids and grand kids. Been in a school playground picking up both for over 40 years. Kids seems just as mixed today in size as they ever were. As a teenager in the 80s the desired size was a size 12! I was an 8 and got teased.

As a 70s kid all sizes in my class from skinny to very fat.
My 22 year old dd has friends of all shapes and sizes.

Nothing new here. All this we were all skinnier in the past is nonsense

Unfortunately it's not nonsense. The data are clear - on average adolescents today are considerably bigger (as measured by both BMI and waist circumference) than their counterparts a few decades ago.) This does not mean there were no overweight children in the past or underweight children today. It means that at a population level we are fatter than we used to be.

Addressing overweight in early life is so important in order to get children on a healthier trajectory. Obesity is very difficult to treat and sadly very very few obese children become normal weight adults.

Forgooodnesssakenow · 02/02/2023 09:13

Scottishskifun · 02/02/2023 09:02

DS1 is very tall and slim have to buy 5-6 trousers to fit in the leg at just turned 4 but they fall off him due to the waist measurements. I have to adjust every waistline.
BMI calculator puts him towards the overweight end but he is honestly a bean pole and the skinniest in his class. His snacks are fruit or a oatcake and he doesn't get junk food. He's off the scale height wise for his age.

Many children are getting taller and I don't think BMI calculators or the percentile charts have been adjusted in a while which doesn't help! My 16 year old DN is 6.4ft and he's also a bean pole!

Put h in the BMI calculator but change his age to 7 see what it says.

NeverTrustAPoliceman · 02/02/2023 09:12

Yep. When I was a child in the 60s we were nearly all skinny. If you couldn't see someone's ribs they were labelled fat. Junk food was a treat and we played out for hours.

Life is very different now.

XelaM · 02/02/2023 09:11

Maybe it's a primary school issue 🤷‍♀️because it's not something I noticed in my daughter's secondary or in her friendship group outside of school. There are very few (less than a handful) of noticeably overweight kids in her school who stand out. All the girls appear to be very conscious of their looks and all the boys are skinny or sporty-looking. Admittedly, outside of school most of her friends are massively into horse riding, so can't e overweight or they wouldn't be allowed to ride. But even her friends from primary who went to other secondary schools range from fly-weight to slim.

SnakeOiler · 02/02/2023 09:10

I remember reading something by a doctor that you should be able to see your children’s ribs. But unfortunately truly healthy and slim people are few and far between these days, 90% of everyone I come into contact with on any given day are carrying a bit too much. A size 10 is the biggest we ever used to be really in the 70’s, it was shocking to be bigger. Now it’s shocking to see a size 6-8.

obviously that’s filtered down to our children. Far too many convenience foods from cereal to bread to pasta sauces.

I feel it’s all linked to women working. As in-feminist as it may seem, when women stayed home and cooked good meals, we were all healthier.

MrsGhandi · 02/02/2023 09:09

viques · 02/02/2023 09:08

I agree, there is a tv holiday ad atm with a very overweight little boy in it. And of course it’s not his fault, poor kid, but it’s a bit ironic that in the advert two of his scenes involve food. “Hey parents, it’s ok to feed your overweight kid lots of sugary snacks and let them loose on the all you can eat buffet. Chill out, the kid’s on his holiday.”

Normalising unhealthy attitudes to food and obesity is wrong. Watch food adverts with kids in them, often being served huge adult sized portions, I can only think of one where a school aged child is served food on a smaller plate than the adults in the advert. The government has rightly stopped junk food advertising in kids tv programmes , but seem to forget that kids watch tv at all times of the day and their seems to be a no holds barred attitude from the food producers with regards to how kids are portrayed.

I know what ad you mean and we have talked about it. It's like he is put in for comedy effect.

Catharticvheesetoastie · 02/02/2023 09:09

WashAsDelicates · 02/02/2023 07:41

I don't think it's a new thing, though it has got much more prevalent since Covid. Twenty years ago I asked my HV for advice, as so many people had been commenting that my ds was 'too skinny'. She gave me a rule of thumb for whether a child is a healthy weight: on an undressed child you should be able to see their ribs frequently, hip bones occasionally, nasal bone never. Many people seem to think that you should never be able to see a child's bones. Which may be true for a toddler, but not for a school-age child.

This is really useful as one of mine is really shooting up height wise and I worry about being able to see his ribs a lot .. he’s the classic 50th centile weight to 98th height

MrsGhandi · 02/02/2023 09:08

Of course genetics play a part in it and of course we will always have the odd exception to the family norm but let's face it - we know what the OP is talking about - fat kids with fat parents. Lifestyle. It is diet and portion size combined with lack of exercise. Poverty plays a big part too as it is these families who are the least able to cook well and probably eat a diet which is too high in carbs and sugar. There's hardly much of nutritional value in Poundland is there? As someone else has said to there is a greater acceptance of being overweight in the younger generations- a messy bun, plumped up lips and false eyelashes seem to make everything OK. It's a big problem and there are no easy answers.

viques · 02/02/2023 09:08

I agree, there is a tv holiday ad atm with a very overweight little boy in it. And of course it’s not his fault, poor kid, but it’s a bit ironic that in the advert two of his scenes involve food. “Hey parents, it’s ok to feed your overweight kid lots of sugary snacks and let them loose on the all you can eat buffet. Chill out, the kid’s on his holiday.”

Normalising unhealthy attitudes to food and obesity is wrong. Watch food adverts with kids in them, often being served huge adult sized portions, I can only think of one where a school aged child is served food on a smaller plate than the adults in the advert. The government has rightly stopped junk food advertising in kids tv programmes , but seem to forget that kids watch tv at all times of the day and their seems to be a no holds barred attitude from the food producers with regards to how kids are portrayed.

FrancescaContini · 02/02/2023 09:07

maddiemookins16mum · 02/02/2023 08:53

I’m 58. At school in the 70s, there were very few ‘fat’ kids, in fact it was rare enough that the fat child was noticeable (and sadly, known as the fat boy/girl in Mrs Brown’s class). We ate breakfast, lunch and tea. Water from the playground fountain. A glass of squash and two cow biscuits after school (maybe, not always). Now parents can’t leave the house for a short trip somewhere (shop, school pick up, etc etc) without taking snacks. You only need to look at the supermarket shelves in the baby aisle to see the ‘snacks’. Plus, not all kids play out, we were outside playing 40/40, block tig, hopscotch, skipping ropes, hide and seek, etc etc from dawn to dusk in holidays and always after school.

Totally agree. We didn’t snack at all, never had fizzy drinks except at Christmas, walked everywhere, played outside. No takeaways except fish and chips perhaps once a year. There was perhaps one “fat” child in the class who by today’s standards wouldn’t stand out at all.

This was a normal childhood in the 1970s, not “deprived”.

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 02/02/2023 09:07

Tessasanderson · 02/02/2023 09:04

I agree with @freckles20 my kids have always had huge appetites. Their is nothing wrong with eating lots as long as it balanced out with plenty of exercise and there is plenty of healthy food in there.

My children carry hardly any fat but need the food to fuel their activities

No, I disagree. Exercise really doesn’t offset lots and lots of food anywhere near as much as people think it does. A lot of the overweight kids I know are always on the go or out on their bikes, it really doesn’t mop up after a bad diet or too much food.

OP posts:
Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 02/02/2023 09:06

Scottishskifun · 02/02/2023 09:02

DS1 is very tall and slim have to buy 5-6 trousers to fit in the leg at just turned 4 but they fall off him due to the waist measurements. I have to adjust every waistline.
BMI calculator puts him towards the overweight end but he is honestly a bean pole and the skinniest in his class. His snacks are fruit or a oatcake and he doesn't get junk food. He's off the scale height wise for his age.

Many children are getting taller and I don't think BMI calculators or the percentile charts have been adjusted in a while which doesn't help! My 16 year old DN is 6.4ft and he's also a bean pole!

I don’t understand how any child can be a ‘beanpole’ yet overweight according to BMI which factors in height? I’m not being rude I just don’t understand how that is possible. I do wonder as some of the kids I know whose parents describe them as ‘beanpoles’ are actually average or slightly above, again because we’ve lost sight of what a healthy weight looks like.

OP posts:
freckles20 · 02/02/2023 09:05

@Teateaandmoretea apologies. DS is still growing and has been over 6 foot since he was 13. He has been medically underweight since he was a toddler whilst showing as overweight using standard NHS BMI measures.

To me discussions about overweight or underweight children apply to DS But I appreciate that to parents of younger children a 16 year old seems like a hulking great adult.

Tessasanderson · 02/02/2023 09:04

Teateaandmoretea · 02/02/2023 09:00

Let’s compare apples with pears. 6 year olds with grown 16 year old men.

I agree with @freckles20 my kids have always had huge appetites. Their is nothing wrong with eating lots as long as it balanced out with plenty of exercise and there is plenty of healthy food in there.

My children carry hardly any fat but need the food to fuel their activities