Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we’ve lost sight of what a healthy child’s weight should be?

516 replies

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 01/02/2023 21:42

Walking through town today as kids were leaving school and I was quite shocked by the size of them (primary kids). But then I noticed that so many of them were overweight that in a way it isn’t surprising that maybe their parents haven’t noticed or realised there is a problem? When I was little kids were skinny things, now it seems the norm for them to be built like shot-putters! I know a few parents with overweight children but they insist they’re ‘strong’ or ‘solid’, or ‘they run around so much they just burn it off’. When so many kids look like theirs it probably isn’t surprising they think that?

OP posts:
ShepherdMoons · 02/02/2023 09:30

It doesn't surprise me the average dress size has gone up. In the past there were all kinds of serious illnesses and less knowledge about nutrition.

Everything should be in balance, yes be healthy and eat healthy. Also exercise should be daily and prioritised. It's unhelpful to shame people about their weight though.

Elsatellsa · 02/02/2023 09:29

ShepherdMoons · 02/02/2023 09:27

@viques and your answer to this problem is????

She plays tennis, swims, gymnastics, healthy diet at home. Like I said, I can't control the amount of exercise at school but she says that they don't move much. Even PE isn't that vigorous. Yes, it's a problem but what do you do? Fat shame these children? Make them feel so bad about themselves that they feel negatively about themselves?

She's probably eating too much, it she genuinely isn't then it's important in a few years once through puberty she gets her thyroid checked.

KarenOLantern · 02/02/2023 09:29

I'm glad you've posted this because I was starting to worry my 2 year old is too skinny. We have ended up having to buy all her winter trousers from France this year to get ones that were long enough but skinny enough to stay up. Sainsbury's clothes especially seem to be made for very stocky children. I was almost considering sneaking extra butter into her meals to bulk her up a bit but the health visitor says she's fine. But it is hard to gauge what's healthy and what's not.

BrilliantUsername · 02/02/2023 09:28

I have two younger dc both are given the same meals and have the same activity level, one is very skinny and the other is a completely different shape and quite a stocky build. They've always been different and that's just what they are.

I also have an older ds who was very chubby throughout his pre-teens but grew into it and shot up to 6ft4 and is now as skinny as a rake. He never had a poor diet even when he was rounder either.
Unless they over eat, have a particularly poor diet or activity level let them be.

SillySausage81 · 02/02/2023 09:28

JaceLancs · 02/02/2023 09:14

I do think a lot of it is portion sizes
when I was growing up in the 60s and 70s there wasn’t as much junk food about and it was more expensive
DM worked FT so didn’t have huge amounts of time to home cook but I remember what would now be eaten as a one person pizza split between 4 of us with lots of salad
Birds Eye burgers pack of 4 - we got one each with a 1/4 of a tin of beans and a slice of bread
thankfully the fruit bowl was always full

A couple of years ago I bought a set of rather old plates from a charity shop, and the lady serving me commented that they were much smaller than the plates you get today. And it's true. Massive plates came into fashion a decade or two ago but the original idea was that they would look fancy but you still had the same portion size. But most people now fit the portion to the size of the plate.

(A bit like how massive wine glasses were originally supposed to be used for the usual 125ml measures, but give the wine space to "breath" (and look fancy) but a lot of people now fill them to the brim and convince themselves they've "only had two glasses of wine" when they've effectively had six.

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 02/02/2023 09:28

Im always slightly bemused when people say their overweight child does loads of exercise, eats a healthy diet and never has junk food. I know metabolism counts for a lot but never eating junk food doesn’t result in overweight children.

My Aunty is a paediatric nurse and she sees overweight children whose parents swear blind they never consume anything that isn’t super healthy and they exercise all the time every day. She says almost all these parents say this. It can’t be EVERY family who has a mysteriously overweight child

Elsatellsa · 02/02/2023 09:28

ShepherdMoons · 02/02/2023 09:25

@Realfastfoodie I agree

I also think that obsessing so much over size is not healthy. It's better to encourage a more active lifestyle and a balanced diet. So much fat shaming on Mumsnet.

It's not fat shaming to acknowledge its unhealthy to carry excess weight aka fat. Even if someone doesn't have any health problems caused by their weight, it alone in itself puts additional pressure on the body and someone's organs. I agree no one should be shamed for their appearance or made to feel less than because they are fat, but it's also disingenuous and dangerous to not be able to acknowledge or discuss the fact that its a problem.

TheOrigRights · 02/02/2023 09:28

My now nearly 14 yo went through a phase of being overweight. I was concerned. His father's side of the family are prone to weight gain and (unlike my older son who has my body type) from a baby you could see he was always going to be more sturdy.

Honestly, I had trouble getting people to understand that he was overweight and that I was concerned. Most people dismissed it as puppy fat or that he would soon shoot up, and while I know that can be the case, I am also aware that there is an obesity crisis and ignoring it was not the right thing.

We did make some food changes at home, he has shot up and become interested in nutrition and sport (always played football, but now loves the gym) and he is bang on target now.

My point is that it seems to be that any mention of concern about weight is so easily dismissed. I did need to tread carefully as the last thing I wanted to do was to make him feel bad about himself or introduce unhealthy patterns of eating. I framed it as US benefitting from making some changes to our eating habits, not for weight but for overall health.

ShepherdMoons · 02/02/2023 09:27

@viques and your answer to this problem is????

She plays tennis, swims, gymnastics, healthy diet at home. Like I said, I can't control the amount of exercise at school but she says that they don't move much. Even PE isn't that vigorous. Yes, it's a problem but what do you do? Fat shame these children? Make them feel so bad about themselves that they feel negatively about themselves?

maddening · 02/02/2023 09:27

SavoirFlair · 02/02/2023 07:52

And I think you are talking nonsense @smileladiesplease -

See this for evidence:

theatlantic.com/health/archive/2015/09/why-it-was-easier-to-be-skinny-in-the-1980s/407974

“a study published recently in the journal Obesity Research and Clinical Practice found that it’s harder for adults today to maintain the same weight as those 20 to 30 years ago did, even at the same levels of food intake and exercise”.

Look - I see it with my own eyes - so so many more overweight teens especially girls. It is a thing.

The thing that sticks out in the portion you have quoted is that it is harder to maintain weight today even at the same level of food intake and exercise as 20-30 years ago - if this is true then what is happening?! I know for me I have difficulty losing weight and gain easily due to health conditions (hashimoto and pcos) but we are fighting a losing battle if that is true.

FallonofDynasty · 02/02/2023 09:26

Its been that way for a while . You see old photos of groups of kids in the past, 60s, 70s, 80s and they look skinny.
At my DCs last Yr 6 sports day it was noticeable that a significant number of the kids looked big. Mainly girls.
In one family one parent was a dietitian, the other a PE teacher, with 2 overweight DCs - I couldn't fathom that one.

Elsatellsa · 02/02/2023 09:26

YANBU, it's a ticking time bomb really as it's one of the first generations where lots of children are overweight and obese at a very young age, we don't really know the toll it will take on their growing bodies or what affect the additional strain will have into adulthood. There are a plethora of reasons and its not as simple as children are eating too much because they want to, but by an large overly processed food is plentiful, people are not as active as once were and as it becomes taboo to talk about for fear of offending people it becomes the norm.

viques · 02/02/2023 09:25

ShepherdMoons · 02/02/2023 09:18

I get a bit sick of hearing this OP. My dd looks fatter than the average child but she exercises a lot and eats a healthy diet. She's going through puberty at the moment and I think the body holds on to weight during this process.

The school day is the only time she is sedentary with her having lots of after school and weekend sports. If anything, I think schools need to look at ways to increase physical exercise as dd complains that often they have had to sit all day due to wet breaks and just not enough room to move in their classroom.

I am sorry, but if your child looks fatter than the average child in her class then she is probably overweight. Because these days the average child you are comparing her to is also overweight.

ShepherdMoons · 02/02/2023 09:25

@Realfastfoodie I agree

I also think that obsessing so much over size is not healthy. It's better to encourage a more active lifestyle and a balanced diet. So much fat shaming on Mumsnet.

Realfastfoodie · 02/02/2023 09:23

RudsyFarmer · 02/02/2023 09:14

Unless you’ve watched your child get seriously ill and disappear before your eyes SO quickly you’ll never know how glad you are that they have a little bit of puppy fat.

I’m happy my eldest isn’t whippet thin and I’m trying (and failing) to give my small one a little covering too.

Yeah. Same.

Moveoverdarlin · 02/02/2023 09:23

Oh my goodness, we were far skinnier as a nation in the past. A relative has recently died and we’ve been looking at old pictures, there is one of about twenty women from say 1984. There isn’t one woman over a size ten, and they were all ages about 45-65. No men with beer bellies, double chins etc. As a nation we are much bigger now. Far more overweight children and adults.

XelaM · 02/02/2023 09:23

Aleaiactaest · 02/02/2023 09:16

It is a class and poverty issue. There are hardly any obese children in private schools across the country both because the schools tend to exercise them most days and because the parents are often rich & educated and can afford a healthy diet. There are far fewer obese children in grammar schools and state primaries with a very low percentage of free school meals.
Fast and processed food is easier and cheaper. Cramming a certain class of people into the same schools and same jobs leads to obesity and poor health outcomes throughout life and costs the NHS more money.

There is also such a thing as a fat/starvation gene which you can inherit if you come from a poor background. It has been observed in the Netherlands due to the 1940s famine. It is also partly why a Chinese or Indian person who carries the gene is more likely to become Type 2 diabetic even if they don’t look properly fat to us. Anyway, it is a very complex area. www.nytimes.com/2018/01/31/science/dutch-famine-genes.html

Good nutrition, exercise, good education for all is at the heart of a healthy population that is productive. There should be a huge drive to eat local and seasonal healthy foods again in appropriate quantities.

Maybe this is true because my daughter is in a private secondary and as I said above, almost none of the kids at her school are overweight. If you watch them come out of school at pick-up time, there literally will be two kids who are visibly overweight. Same goes for the private primary she went to - I don't think any of the kids were overweight. Some were tiny, but even the "biggest" kids all looked slim.

ShepherdMoons · 02/02/2023 09:23

From what I see on here there also seems very little real understanding about why children are becoming heavier, yes processed foods and a sedentary lifestyle don't help. However, schools are more focused than ever on academic attainment with little exercise. It's not their fault but really there needs to be more help, understanding for people than just saying 'they're all fat these days, in my day they were skinny'. Bit pointless and ignorant really.

Bullshot · 02/02/2023 09:20

maddiemookins16mum · 02/02/2023 08:53

I’m 58. At school in the 70s, there were very few ‘fat’ kids, in fact it was rare enough that the fat child was noticeable (and sadly, known as the fat boy/girl in Mrs Brown’s class). We ate breakfast, lunch and tea. Water from the playground fountain. A glass of squash and two cow biscuits after school (maybe, not always). Now parents can’t leave the house for a short trip somewhere (shop, school pick up, etc etc) without taking snacks. You only need to look at the supermarket shelves in the baby aisle to see the ‘snacks’. Plus, not all kids play out, we were outside playing 40/40, block tig, hopscotch, skipping ropes, hide and seek, etc etc from dawn to dusk in holidays and always after school.

I am a similar age - we had no snacks. Sweet, chocolates, crisps etc were a once a week treat.

Small breakfast at home, big school dinner, made on the premises - like a meat pie, cabbage and mash. Always a pudding and custard though.. :) No choices, everyone got the same.

Tea would have been a decent homemade stew or similar. No pudding.

To be fair, I was always hungry and ready for that next meal- which is probably how it should be. Nowadays I snack too much - not unheathy foods but my calorie intake could be less.

We had only one or two 'fat' kids in the school. Not the class, but the whole school.

My DC is now mid twenties and when he was a chid I was surprised at the small portions he chose, despite his height (tall family). But I never forced him to eat more. He is still the same - eats what he needs and then stops. ( i finish my plate..)

RedToothBrush · 02/02/2023 09:20

One of the girls in my son's year is twice the size of all the other kids. It's not a small difference. It's very very pronounced.

The mum got a letter saying that her daughter was obese. Mum kicked off on the parents chat saying it was ridiculous and she "just didn't see it herself" and her daughter couldn't possibly be overweight because she's vegetarian.

Mum is not exactly Kate Moss herself. Nor is she the smartest tool in the drawer

Her reaction was eye opening and very revealing. It definitely showed me how some people are in complete denial and even those who think they are eating a healthy diet are utterly clueless. The amount of sweets and cakes etc this child gets is 'interesting' - it's clearly an issue with diet rather than being able to blame it on rogue genetics.

I do feel for the little girl as she hasn't got a chance. She won't ever learn good habits with food because mum is in denial about her own issues. The system has tried to flag the issue but it's toothless. I genuinely think it should be a subject for greater intervention early on because of the long term cost and implications to that child and society as a whole but obviously we are ridiculously short sighted as a nation on that one, parroting stuff about lack of money when a lack of early invention is more costly long term.

viques · 02/02/2023 09:20

MrsGhandi · 02/02/2023 09:09

I know what ad you mean and we have talked about it. It's like he is put in for comedy effect.

I think you are right, it is supposed to be hilarious, which makes it worse, let’s all laugh at the fat kid , he is fair game and we aren’t allowed to laugh at any other kids with differences because that would be wrong. . There is another shot of him with a rubber ring , you can imagine the planning that went into that. “ Listen guys, how about this, we put a rubber spare tyre round his real spare tyre! Gosh, that will make them chuckle.”

Onwayoutsoon · 02/02/2023 09:20

JaceLancs · 02/02/2023 09:14

I do think a lot of it is portion sizes
when I was growing up in the 60s and 70s there wasn’t as much junk food about and it was more expensive
DM worked FT so didn’t have huge amounts of time to home cook but I remember what would now be eaten as a one person pizza split between 4 of us with lots of salad
Birds Eye burgers pack of 4 - we got one each with a 1/4 of a tin of beans and a slice of bread
thankfully the fruit bowl was always full

I thought I had imagined the one beef burger and a tin of beans between 4! that was us in the 70s!

Dammitthisisshit · 02/02/2023 09:19

Lindy2 · 02/02/2023 07:42

I try to keep mine on a healthy balanced diet as they are both prone to put on weight. The thing I've found most difficult though is other people.

They go to the park with a friend and the other mum or mums hand out sweets or biscuits, they go to a friend's house and there's sweets again or a trip to the sweet shop, clubs hand out sweets as rewards, someone's birthday at school (almost every day) more sweets. It's bloody endless.

Yes. I find this. I try to make nothing ‘forbidden fruit’ but it’s hard to control when they’re being given sweets everywhere. DD(7)s birthday she was given multiple big bags of sweets. She gets to keep a few to have when she wants and the others go in the cupboard for puddings for her - and usually shared with other DD - they are both pretty good about sharing. I don’t like being so controlling, but I don’t know any other way to stop them filling up on rubbish.

Mine are both a higher height percentile to weight and have consistently been so. I notice that in general mine get less processed food. Eg homemade flapjacks rather than a shop bought cake bar. I have noticed some of their friends that are looking heavier. In most cases they have divorced parents and at least 1 with a ‘Disney dad’ who sees their DC every other weekend but buys them whatever they want - they go back to their mums house with bags of sweets so she finds it hard to control. I wonder if this is happening more?

I also think more processed food for meals is to blame. If you’re working all day it’s easy to fall into the routine of grabbing something out the freezer for tea.

We have sweet things at home but it’s with other food - eg hot chocolate (made with milk, cocoa powder and a little sugar, not a pre-prepared super sweet one) with apple and cheese on toast for a post football snack. Or I might do fruit dipped in chocolate for pudding sometimes. But I do feel I’m constantly fighting to have a sensible proportion of ‘good’ food to ‘treats’ (I don’t call it that in front of them).

ShepherdMoons · 02/02/2023 09:18

I get a bit sick of hearing this OP. My dd looks fatter than the average child but she exercises a lot and eats a healthy diet. She's going through puberty at the moment and I think the body holds on to weight during this process.

The school day is the only time she is sedentary with her having lots of after school and weekend sports. If anything, I think schools need to look at ways to increase physical exercise as dd complains that often they have had to sit all day due to wet breaks and just not enough room to move in their classroom.

Swipe left for the next trending thread