Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we’ve lost sight of what a healthy child’s weight should be?

516 replies

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 01/02/2023 21:42

Walking through town today as kids were leaving school and I was quite shocked by the size of them (primary kids). But then I noticed that so many of them were overweight that in a way it isn’t surprising that maybe their parents haven’t noticed or realised there is a problem? When I was little kids were skinny things, now it seems the norm for them to be built like shot-putters! I know a few parents with overweight children but they insist they’re ‘strong’ or ‘solid’, or ‘they run around so much they just burn it off’. When so many kids look like theirs it probably isn’t surprising they think that?

OP posts:
midgetastic · 02/02/2023 09:44

BMI is better than dress size for determining healthy weight. Bangs head against brick wall

Unless you are an elite athlete bmi is pretty good
You should also use the waist size metrics which adjust for ethnicity

If both say you are overweight , suck it up

Trixielo · 02/02/2023 09:43

RudsyFarmer · 02/02/2023 09:33

Congratulations for being fucking rude AND superior. What a gift you are to the world.

I don’t think it’s rude, it’s unfortunately true.

KarenOLantern · 02/02/2023 09:42

freckles20 · 02/02/2023 09:05

@Teateaandmoretea apologies. DS is still growing and has been over 6 foot since he was 13. He has been medically underweight since he was a toddler whilst showing as overweight using standard NHS BMI measures.

To me discussions about overweight or underweight children apply to DS But I appreciate that to parents of younger children a 16 year old seems like a hulking great adult.

An average adolescent boy requires 2,800 calories per day, which is 40% more than an average adult woman and 300 calories more than an average adult man (equivalent to a full extra meal per day) so I do think it is a slightly different conversation to whether a 4 year old should be eating one slice of pizza or two 😅(not that your experience of BMIs isn't relevant (and very interesting) too.)

jagody · 02/02/2023 09:41

Timaya · 02/02/2023 09:33

And yes dress sizes have gone up... but I'm a size 12-14 and yet my BMI is in the healthy range.

BMI is rubbish I was overweight according to my BMI but I wear a size 6.

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 02/02/2023 09:40

ShepherdMoons · 02/02/2023 09:37

@LeapingCat I know a lot of mothers like this. Mothers who are actually borderline anorexic or just neurotic about food. The children follow suit and some of them look extremely ill they are so thin. One of the school mums has bulimia and her dd has started to copy her. She has panic attacks eating food and tries to be sick after eating. They've involved the GP and CAMHS.

How very statistically unlikely, given how much more common it is to be overweight than ‘borderline anorexic’.

OP posts:
curiousfurious · 02/02/2023 09:38

If your child is on the 97th centimetres then 96% of children their age weigh less. It means your child is one of the heaviest. No amount of sport will make up for the fact they are fat and the fat is putting a strain on their internal organs. My dds were both shamed for being skinny but actually they are just a healthy weight at the lower end of the centiles. Fat has become normalised.

ShepherdMoons · 02/02/2023 09:37

@LeapingCat I know a lot of mothers like this. Mothers who are actually borderline anorexic or just neurotic about food. The children follow suit and some of them look extremely ill they are so thin. One of the school mums has bulimia and her dd has started to copy her. She has panic attacks eating food and tries to be sick after eating. They've involved the GP and CAMHS.

BernardsarenotalwaysSaints · 02/02/2023 09:36

I agree. It isn't always an easy fix though. I have 5 dc. 4 are a healthy weight, 1 is closer to overweight (age 5.5 wearing either age 5 wide fit or normal age 6 trousers). He's asthmatic & takes long term medication that contribute to weight gain, he eats portions appropriate to his age & has a good diet, he loves being outside. His Dr & asthma nurse aren't concerned because they can see from his siblings, DH & myself that it's not 'the norm' in our family. He's actually just had an upward growth spurt so has moved back from the overweight end, ultimately though there's not a huge amount I can do. That being said he doesn't stand out as being 'big' in his class or year group in the same way my older dc do in theirs for being 'skinny'.

midgetastic · 02/02/2023 09:36

It may not be right to shame people who are overweight

Mostly because it just sets their mindset to ignore any healthy weight messages

But being body positive isn't helping either
In fact it's even worse than shaming as it makes people think it's ok

it is wrong to pretend that it isn't a major cause of concern , a major cause for NHS to be under stress

smileladiesplease · 02/02/2023 09:36

SavourFlaire

nonsense. Perception has changed not sizes. Can assure you plenty of fat kids and adults around in the 70s as I was there. I assume you were not?

BertieBotts · 02/02/2023 09:36

She gave me a rule of thumb for whether a child is a healthy weight: on an undressed child you should be able to see their ribs frequently, hip bones occasionally, nasal bone never.

Nasal bone? As in the nose? Is that a typo?

allthethingsyousaid · 02/02/2023 09:35

My kids eat lots of snacks and decent portion sizes and they are still so skinny. They have cakes, chocolate, crisps almost everyday. But they also have lots of vegetables with their dinner and a decent breakfast which doesn't include sugary cereals. Hardly any processed meals though.
They do quite a bit of exercise though.
I don't think there's a magic answer to this, but I think it's the exercise that makes the difference. We hardly use the car and walk and cycle 99% of the time, plus they do sports clubs too. Most children we know who are driven places regularly tend to be the overweight ones.

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 02/02/2023 09:35

ShepherdMoons · 02/02/2023 09:34

@Winniethepoohandtiggertoo I can assure you right now that my dd isn't riding round an estate with a 'can of pop'

She does a range of sports, she doesn't overeat. She's tall for her age, she's going through puberty. I imagine she will shoot up in a few years.

I hope so but what’s the harm in helping her out now? What if she doesn’t shoot up? Much easier to lose a few pounds at 11 than a few stone at 20.

OP posts:
ShepherdMoons · 02/02/2023 09:34

@Winniethepoohandtiggertoo I can assure you right now that my dd isn't riding round an estate with a 'can of pop'

She does a range of sports, she doesn't overeat. She's tall for her age, she's going through puberty. I imagine she will shoot up in a few years.

LeapingCat · 02/02/2023 09:34

I think it’s a bit strange that there are so few in between kids. They’re either super skinny (all ribs as described on MN). Someone asked me if my youngest had had the overweight letter from the reception weigh in! Umm no, she just has chubby cheeks and a load of muscle from hours of gymnastics a week. She’s middle of the healthy weight range and super fit. But like the competitive thinness and healthy eating on MN, there seems to be a thing where ultra thin middle class mothers are aiming for their kids to be all cheekbones and ribs at 5.

AIBUYESYES · 02/02/2023 09:34

It's unhelpful to shame people about their weight though

No one is shaming.

Swap the word shame for 'concerned'.

It's all down the parents if the child is living at home and the parents are buying the food and putting it in front of them.

Parents need to take some responsibility.

RudsyFarmer · 02/02/2023 09:33

viques · 02/02/2023 09:25

I am sorry, but if your child looks fatter than the average child in her class then she is probably overweight. Because these days the average child you are comparing her to is also overweight.

Congratulations for being fucking rude AND superior. What a gift you are to the world.

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 02/02/2023 09:33

If it’s a choice between ‘fat shaming’ and being overweight with a life of health problems, I would choose the former to be honest. I would rather they were temporarily upset and spared the horrors of type 2 diabetes, furred up arteries, PCOS in the girls and heart attacks.

OP posts:
Timaya · 02/02/2023 09:33

And yes dress sizes have gone up... but I'm a size 12-14 and yet my BMI is in the healthy range.

Trixielo · 02/02/2023 09:32

Completely agree. I hated my children learning that certain foods were ‘bad’! It’s such an unhealthy way to think about food. Chocolate isn’t bad. Cheese isn’t bad. It’s only unhealthy if you eat too much of it.
Little kids can’t understand real nutrition choices - like processed vs unprocessed, salt content, etc. It’s the parents’ job to make choices for them. Eating healthily then becomes normal for them.
I see so many friends say their kids won’t eat this or that. No veg only pasta etc. But that’s because they offer unlimited snacks between meals! Why would they eat vegetables if they can have treat food instead? Some parents seem to think feeling hungry is a terrible thing. I think it’s fine to let a child get hungry before dinner. Then they’ll happily eat a good meal and feel satisfied. People confuse food and love. They think not feeding on demand is withholding love.

WestwardHo1 · 02/02/2023 09:32

smileladiesplease · 02/02/2023 07:48

I think you are talking nonsense op. I am nearly 60 and have grown up kids and grand kids. Been in a school playground picking up both for over 40 years. Kids seems just as mixed today in size as they ever were. As a teenager in the 80s the desired size was a size 12! I was an 8 and got teased.

As a 70s kid all sizes in my class from skinny to very fat.
My 22 year old dd has friends of all shapes and sizes.

Nothing new here. All this we were all skinnier in the past is nonsense

It's patently not nonsense. Very many children now are fatter than children used to be.

ShepherdMoons · 02/02/2023 09:32

@BrilliantUsername I totally agree, if they are following a healthy balanced diet and exercise then it's likely that it is just a phase.

My dh was fatter as a pre teen but then shot up in height so much in secondary school. He seems to think dd is the same, she's already a lot taller than everyone in her class.

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 02/02/2023 09:32

ShepherdMoons · 02/02/2023 09:27

@viques and your answer to this problem is????

She plays tennis, swims, gymnastics, healthy diet at home. Like I said, I can't control the amount of exercise at school but she says that they don't move much. Even PE isn't that vigorous. Yes, it's a problem but what do you do? Fat shame these children? Make them feel so bad about themselves that they feel negatively about themselves?

But you seem to be relying completely on exercise. It’s now understood that while exercise has some bearing on weight, the main influence on whether you are overweight or not is food - how much food, what type, snacking etc.

A lot of the overweight kids I know are out in their bikes on the estate from dawn til dusk, they’re still fat because they often ride along holding a can of pop or packets of crisps or go home at regular intervals for snacks.

OP posts:
AIBUYESYES · 02/02/2023 09:32

She plays tennis, swims, gymnastics, healthy diet at home.

@ShepherdMoons In YOUR opinion she eats a healthy diet at home.

How do you know you are on the right lines with her diet at home?
Your idea of what is healthy may not be.

You'd need to list every meal for a week and show pics of portion sizes for an opinion.

I am actually shocked at some of the threads on here about 'what have you eaten today' and see all the crap and the amount people eat.

So many people are either in denial over what is a 'portion' or they are uneducated about what is really healthy.

Timaya · 02/02/2023 09:31

My DD doesn't eat majorly healthy and isn't particularly active. She's a healthy weight though, I've checked. She takes after her father who is and always has been desperately thin/underweight genetically, seemingly regardless of diet.

Swipe left for the next trending thread