Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we’ve lost sight of what a healthy child’s weight should be?

516 replies

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 01/02/2023 21:42

Walking through town today as kids were leaving school and I was quite shocked by the size of them (primary kids). But then I noticed that so many of them were overweight that in a way it isn’t surprising that maybe their parents haven’t noticed or realised there is a problem? When I was little kids were skinny things, now it seems the norm for them to be built like shot-putters! I know a few parents with overweight children but they insist they’re ‘strong’ or ‘solid’, or ‘they run around so much they just burn it off’. When so many kids look like theirs it probably isn’t surprising they think that?

OP posts:
Squamata · 02/02/2023 10:03

You sound like a barrel of laughs, OP.

Obesity is very complex and many determining factors are pre set in the womb, or in early life up to the age of 2. Your weight at 2 determines a lot about how much fat you carry when you're in your teens and beyond.

We should be throwing a lot of money at educating women pre pregnancy about nutrition and weight, providing lots of support and programmes to ensure the conception - age 2 bit is optimised. Support for exercise and diet through the rest of childhood too.

I have no time for judgey pants 'I gawp at plump children on the school run and think how much better I am than their parents' type of people. There's an obesity pandemic, it's a systemic problem.

Bumpitybumper · 02/02/2023 10:02

The focus on weight on MN is completely wrong when we should be focusing on health, nutrition and promoting good lifestyle choices that will stand out children in good stead for the rest of their lives.

My family has a tendency towards babies, toddlers and young children with a good amount of puppy fat. EBF babies shoot up the centiles and then it takes a number of years for this weight to drop off. They are by far some of the chunkiest babies and toddler around and they are noticeably different to their peers. Not one teenager or adult in the family is overweight or has any real problem maintaining a healthy weight. This is because the fundamentals of health are established early on. Eating a range of different food that give your body the nutrition it needs. A focus on moving your body for fun and being active.

On the contrary I see parents with stick thin toddlers feeding them all sorts of rubbish and promoting a sedentary life. The kids are obviously genetically programmed to stay slim although i notice as the kids get older this changes and inevitably they begin to pile on the weight.

So many posters on MN are overly focussed on weight because they have an issue with maintaining a healthy weight themselves or are fat phobic. Even in cases where slightly overweight children are clearly eating healthily and very active, parents are still chastised for not achieving dietary perfection. Orthorexia thrives here and its completely counter productive. Look at the people that live the longest with longest amount of 'healthy years' and you will see that most didn't live perfectly and weren't obsessed with their weight but we're just consistently making pretty healthy choices and were genetically lucky.

QueenUnicorn · 02/02/2023 10:02

My daughter is the only girl in her class who isn't overweight. I know with some of the smaller overweight girls that their parents think they are 'slim', because they are comparing them to the bigger girls. I don't have the heart to say anything. In the primary check they were told, but subsequently reassured by other parents that the check is silly and wrong.

Bog · 02/02/2023 10:01

Yanbu there is a huge girl at a toddler group I take my son to.
She is the largest one there and her grandmother helicopters around her with Oti do you want a snack?

Swiftswatch · 02/02/2023 10:00

Not enough people acknowledge that what they view as ‘genetics’ is actually learned behaviour. If a parent is overweight, not active and eats large portions then the child goes the same and that is there barometer of normal.
Even as an adult I’m sometimes shocked at the portion size when I eat in other people’s houses.
What people class as a ‘normal’ plate or food or a ‘healthy’ diet has unfortunately become very subjective.

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 02/02/2023 10:00

PuddlesPityParty · 02/02/2023 09:58

Have people forgotten about “puppy weight”? I was a chubby kid, by mid - end of high school I was healthy weight just from naturally growing up - but because of all the comments about my weight I ended up with an eating disorder and my relationship with food never recovered.

Puppy fat is a myth, it’s been debunked time and time again.

OP posts:
viques · 02/02/2023 09:58

allthethingsyousaid · 02/02/2023 09:35

My kids eat lots of snacks and decent portion sizes and they are still so skinny. They have cakes, chocolate, crisps almost everyday. But they also have lots of vegetables with their dinner and a decent breakfast which doesn't include sugary cereals. Hardly any processed meals though.
They do quite a bit of exercise though.
I don't think there's a magic answer to this, but I think it's the exercise that makes the difference. We hardly use the car and walk and cycle 99% of the time, plus they do sports clubs too. Most children we know who are driven places regularly tend to be the overweight ones.

So the question is why do you buy so many snacks for your children, why do they need to eat the extra salt , sugar and fat those snacks are putting into their bodies? They don’t need them nutritionally, and a human body’s natural response to energy that it isn’t using is to store it as fat around internal organs. If they are hungry before a meal that isn’t a bad thing, if they are hungry after a meal make them eat slower so the “full” hormone kicks in. Nothing wrong with treats, we all enjoy them, but if they are everyday they stop being treats and are seen as part of a days diet.

PuddlesPityParty · 02/02/2023 09:58

Have people forgotten about “puppy weight”? I was a chubby kid, by mid - end of high school I was healthy weight just from naturally growing up - but because of all the comments about my weight I ended up with an eating disorder and my relationship with food never recovered.

Clara84 · 02/02/2023 09:57

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 02/02/2023 09:28

Im always slightly bemused when people say their overweight child does loads of exercise, eats a healthy diet and never has junk food. I know metabolism counts for a lot but never eating junk food doesn’t result in overweight children.

My Aunty is a paediatric nurse and she sees overweight children whose parents swear blind they never consume anything that isn’t super healthy and they exercise all the time every day. She says almost all these parents say this. It can’t be EVERY family who has a mysteriously overweight child

Healthy food can still be high calorie - avocados being a prime example along with fruit, olive oil etc etc.

You can have an entirely healthy diet but still be obese. Calories in vs calories out. Most people just don't think about this with 'healthy' food.

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 02/02/2023 09:57

forcing adult neurosis on children about weight will only hurt in the long run.

This is just such a weak argument. If ‘body shaming’ had half the effect that people claim it does, anorexia and bulimia would be much more common, as would being underweight. Under eating has never even been 5% of the issue that over eating has.

OP posts:
Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 02/02/2023 09:55

Yes I’m amazed by how many people have more than 1 type of carbs on their plate! Pizza with garlic bread, curry with rice and naan breads, cooked breakfast with toast and waffles… to me you generally have 1 carb, 1 protein and veg.

OP posts:
TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 02/02/2023 09:54

I do think some people think they are eating normal sized portions, when actually what they eat is enormous. And this extends to their children.

I remember as a teenager going to a friend’s house for dinner. Friend was overweight, as were her brother and parents (the latter greatly so). The meal they fed me was absolutely enormous, and I had a small appetite as a child. I wouldn’t be able to eat that portion now!. I ate probably 1/6th of the meal and the mum had a massive go at me. I remember feeling sorry for my friend and her brother, it her parents were good people and probably genuinely thought it was a healthy plate of food. I think that happens a lot these days.

RagingWoke · 02/02/2023 09:54

It's not a simple thing. Children, like adults, have different body types, metabolisms etc. forcing adult neurosis on children about weight will only hurt in the long run.

In my DDs year 3 class there is one dc in age 4/5 clothes, child doesn't eat much and what they do is rarely healthy but they are fairly slim. My own DD is in age 11/12 clothes, very tall- she is a head taller than all but one child in the class despite being the youngest and well proportioned, fairly muscular and not much fat, in the healthy weight bmi zone, but I imagine judgemental people looking at her thinking she was too big and it's our fault (I guess it is, it's genetics!).

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 02/02/2023 09:52

LeapingCat · 02/02/2023 09:51

Try Boden leggings, they’re a much tighter fit.

Very expensive though

OP posts:
SpanielSocks · 02/02/2023 09:51

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 02/02/2023 09:28

Im always slightly bemused when people say their overweight child does loads of exercise, eats a healthy diet and never has junk food. I know metabolism counts for a lot but never eating junk food doesn’t result in overweight children.

My Aunty is a paediatric nurse and she sees overweight children whose parents swear blind they never consume anything that isn’t super healthy and they exercise all the time every day. She says almost all these parents say this. It can’t be EVERY family who has a mysteriously overweight child

I don’t know about this. I think it might be possible to eat only “healthy food” and still be overweight if the portion sizes are just too big on a regular basis.

My DC definitely eat some junk food, they also have sweets and chocolate a few times a week. They are really slim and so am and I and DH.

But we don’t eat big portions at all. Some of the overweight children I know come from families where the family sit down together every evening and the mum cooks, which should be a good thing. But I think a traditional “meat and veg” dinner everyday does add up. Some people also have pudding after each meal, as if it’s standard!

We are often rushing about and might have scrambled eggs with pitta bread or beans on toast, or pesto pasta - we only sit down as a family for a “proper” meal once a week. So, combined with DC having McDonalds once a week on the way back from an sports club, probably not as healthy as we could or should be.

Maybe “healthy” is mixed up with home cooked food now in peoples mind as well. Jamie Oliver talks a lot about healthy eating, but if I followed some of his recipes and portion sizes every day I think I’d be pretty big.

My friend - who has very overweight DC and is big herself - cooks from scratch often, which is seen as a healthy thing (and she describes the DC’s diet as healthy) but she might make a home cooked lasagne and then adds garlic bread and chips as well.

To me, lasagna seems such a big meal, that a bit of salad on the side is quite enough, but if having sides is what people are used to then they might not notice that they are packing in additional calories. Even a “healthy” pudding like Greek yogurt with banana is also quite high in calories.

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 02/02/2023 09:51

LeapingCat · 02/02/2023 09:48

You’re not taking into account population distribution. Particularly at primary age, children’s average weight is strongly correlated with deprivation. If your child goes to school in a v well off area there’s a decent chance there’ll be the orthorexic mums. My DD’s school is a bit more mixed. Some overweight kids but probably more of the ultra skinny parents and kids. They’re the kids that are all over the food at parties while my average weight DD doesn’t want to stop playing to eat.

Are they actually underweight though? Or they just look skinnier than their peers? I’m willing to bet the former, because like I said a chubby child is now seen as a ‘normal, solid’ weight. It’s great they see party food as treats and have the odd gorge. Isn’t that the whole point of them being a ‘treat’?

OP posts:
LeapingCat · 02/02/2023 09:51

Iguanainanigloo · 02/02/2023 09:45

I have noticed this too! And it's not just the kids getting bigger, it's the clothes, so alot of people with overweight children think they're fine, because the clothes for their age or a size up, fit them perfectly. I struggle to find leggings that fit my girls as they're "slender" (perfect weight in my opinion, but constantly called skinny, as much thinner than the majority of their peers) most leggings just hang off them, so I have to buy two sizes smaller, and then they're too short. They're definitely not underweight though, they don't have bones sticking out, both look really well proportioned, active, and full of energy. but compared to most of their peers, they do appear much smaller.

Try Boden leggings, they’re a much tighter fit.

Scottishskifun · 02/02/2023 09:50

Forgooodnesssakenow · 02/02/2023 08:59

As you can see, same weight and height, fine if 7 not if 4.

@Winniethepoohandtiggertoo this post explains it better then I can! It's age which is a factor for my DS hence beanpole but on a BMI calculator towards the heavier end!

As said its fairly rudimentary and doesn't factor in increasing height of populations for example.
A more accurate way is to use BMI as a indicator then take waist measurements and calipers for fat.

I don't disagree that children are getting bigger btw just that tou can't use BMI calculator alone!

Saschka · 02/02/2023 09:49

midgetastic · 02/02/2023 08:05

No

Dangerous attitude

Many kids are overweight

Being overweight is a huge health problem

10% of the nhs budget is for type 2 diabetes alone - caused primarily by being fat
Instead of clapping for the nhs people could diet for them

Losing weight as an adult is almost impossible
Gaining healthy eating patterns is best done as a child

You are failing your child if you overfeed them . You are giving them in alll likelihood a lifetime of health problems and an early death

So many children are overweight it's so sad

Many two year olds are a bit podgy - DS definitely still had his baby tummy and fat little legs then. I don’t think that is a particular issue, they are still toddlers with a toddler body shape.

A seven or nine year old shouldn’t still have a big stomach or fat legs though.

viques · 02/02/2023 09:49

ShepherdMoons · 02/02/2023 09:27

@viques and your answer to this problem is????

She plays tennis, swims, gymnastics, healthy diet at home. Like I said, I can't control the amount of exercise at school but she says that they don't move much. Even PE isn't that vigorous. Yes, it's a problem but what do you do? Fat shame these children? Make them feel so bad about themselves that they feel negatively about themselves?

Unless there is a medical reason for their size then you look at what factors you can control and try to see where things are slipping. Obvious ones are exercise, which you say is sufficient, portion control, processed food with added sugar and fat, too little variety in foodstuffs so low gut biom, snacking with unnecessary calories, drinking sugary or calorie rich drinks , eating too late in the evening for her body to process a meal.I don’t know the answer, she is your child, but the reason is there somewhere.

SprayedWithDettol · 02/02/2023 09:49

I will caveat this by saying that the horrific situation where some children are hungry because this government is not supporting the most vulnerable in society, is not what I'm alluding to.

My concern is that many people (adults and children) don't seem to be able to cope with slight hunger pangs. There is nothing wrong with feeing hungry. I hate people state they are starving - which annoys the fuck out of me. You might not have eaten for a few hours. It isn't a problem. You don't need a snack. (Diabetics and other suffers of metabolic disorders notwithstanding).

LeapingCat · 02/02/2023 09:48

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 02/02/2023 09:40

How very statistically unlikely, given how much more common it is to be overweight than ‘borderline anorexic’.

You’re not taking into account population distribution. Particularly at primary age, children’s average weight is strongly correlated with deprivation. If your child goes to school in a v well off area there’s a decent chance there’ll be the orthorexic mums. My DD’s school is a bit more mixed. Some overweight kids but probably more of the ultra skinny parents and kids. They’re the kids that are all over the food at parties while my average weight DD doesn’t want to stop playing to eat.

Elsatellsa · 02/02/2023 09:47

jagody · 02/02/2023 09:41

BMI is rubbish I was overweight according to my BMI but I wear a size 6.

Not a chance.

Timaya · 02/02/2023 09:46

jagody · 02/02/2023 09:41

BMI is rubbish I was overweight according to my BMI but I wear a size 6.

Either way, it was fine as was my waist size. It's not really my top half that makes me the size I am in clothes, I could wear a 10 on top, but my bum/hips/thighs necessitate larger sizes on the bottom/dresses. It is hard to find clothes that fit properly. Either they fit my thighs and hips but are too big on the waist or they would fit my waist nice and snugly but I can't get them over my thighs.

I have been underweight in the past at a size 6/8 when I had an ED

Iguanainanigloo · 02/02/2023 09:45

I have noticed this too! And it's not just the kids getting bigger, it's the clothes, so alot of people with overweight children think they're fine, because the clothes for their age or a size up, fit them perfectly. I struggle to find leggings that fit my girls as they're "slender" (perfect weight in my opinion, but constantly called skinny, as much thinner than the majority of their peers) most leggings just hang off them, so I have to buy two sizes smaller, and then they're too short. They're definitely not underweight though, they don't have bones sticking out, both look really well proportioned, active, and full of energy. but compared to most of their peers, they do appear much smaller.