Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we’ve lost sight of what a healthy child’s weight should be?

516 replies

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 01/02/2023 21:42

Walking through town today as kids were leaving school and I was quite shocked by the size of them (primary kids). But then I noticed that so many of them were overweight that in a way it isn’t surprising that maybe their parents haven’t noticed or realised there is a problem? When I was little kids were skinny things, now it seems the norm for them to be built like shot-putters! I know a few parents with overweight children but they insist they’re ‘strong’ or ‘solid’, or ‘they run around so much they just burn it off’. When so many kids look like theirs it probably isn’t surprising they think that?

OP posts:
AzureOrchid · 02/02/2023 10:25

@Nixynic I agree regarding clothing sizing.
I think clothing is made really big for kids now
I always have to use the waist button elastic thing to cinch in the waists on the DC uniforms / jeans etc.

Aleaiactaest · 02/02/2023 10:25

@Squamata - yes I agree with that. It is also possible that having a mother or even grandmother who yo-yo dieted at some point before having you could have altered your genes to the point that your body then tends to store more fat.
There are so many different elements that come into it. We know poverty is one.
It is a big cliche to talk about anorexic middle class mums with food obsessions. But to be honest, the ones I know were never anorexic as such - in fact, they maintained a healthy body weight all throughout their lives and hardly way a couple of kilos more after children than they did before children. And interestingly, the ones that come from posh families too that never really starved and were always rich are all naturally skinny. Eat a lot, exercise a lot etc and same applies to their children.
A less educated person is going to be more affected by advertising by companies trying to make money from unhealthy foods and then yo-yo dieting fads etc and purchasing magazines and buying into social media fads as well.
It is a very complex area.

People need to be able to make their own choices though and there is no appetite in this country for an even more controlling communist type nanny state that insists kids are delivered into the system age 2 and fed and exercised there. It is a free country foremost and people’s choices with regards to their own children need to be respected. The NHS and schools are already trying quite hard to tackle the issue. I don’t think government academic expectations help though because from what I have seen, there is simply not enough time to cover the curriculum with 30 children in a class and do PE more than 1 or 2 a week.
I would welcome a programme where every child exercise 30 minutes at school in assembly every morning Chinese style or at lunch on the playground dances, daily mile that kind of thing english.news.cn/20220525/3de8b101f1fe4aa882571ae1351fcd7a/c.html
If it is instilled at primary, there may be some hope at secondary schools. Nothing wrong with getting secondary school pupils to do Tik Tok dances if it is a cheap and good way to exercise. Of course if it is not instilled early, they are probably too embarrassed to do it.

Renoir56 · 02/02/2023 10:24

I was a child in the 70s. I'm in my 50s now. Pretty much all of the kids I knew were slim but none were skinny and malnourished.

The comment above about sharing a pizza as a family made me think about portions. When we first had a freezer when I was a teenager a standard frozen pizza would be dinner for my parents and 2 teenagers with a few chips and some peas. A quarter of a pizza each!

I remember always being hungry before meals. I think a lot of people nowadays have forgotten how to feel hungry because of constant snacking.
My dad was a big man but he didn't eat massive portions of food and never snacked.

A typical day when I was a kid was

Cereal for breakfast or a slice of toast
School lunch. I guess maybe a break time snack but I don't remember one.
A slice of toast or a biscuit after school if hungry
Whatever was cooked for tea - no choice. Something like mince, potatoes and peas. Small portions for adults, not much bigger than a kid's portion in a restaurant nowadays.
Tea and toast before bed if hungry.

Pudding on Sunday only.
Sweets once a week.
A standard sized bottle of fizzy lemonade a week when we were teenagers.
Takeaway fish and chips about once a year

It's a world away from the amount of food people (and I include myself in that) eat nowadays.

Stravaig · 02/02/2023 10:24

Meal times are a bit sacred in our house. The DCs are at the table, they help with some of the food prep, it’s just about creating a food culture that isn’t “fill a hunger gap quickly before moving onto the more important activity”.

@SavoirFlair This is so important. We need to re-discover or create from scratch a healthy food culture, which is also about relationships, community, sustainable living.

I think the speed of change is terrifying, as are the concerted attempts to normalise it. The film WALL-E came out in 2008. Animated eco sci-fi, just my thing - except I did think that the immobile blob humans were an utterly bizarre invention. Only 15 years later, and it seems obvious where they came from! Another decade, and a hover-lounge patent, and we'll be there.

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 02/02/2023 10:23

Wearing clothes that are for children 5 to 6 years older than her and within the healthy weight range, are you being honest with yourself here?

Surely it depends on why? I have a 4 year old who needs 6 -7 dresses because she likes them below her knees. She's 115 cm tall. You can see her ribs though and her BMI is in the healthy range. She went to preschool this morning wearing 6 -7 tights, 3 -4 denim shorts and a 2 -3 dress as a t-shirt. She is as tall as some of her 7 year old brother's female classmates so of course she needs clothes as long as theirs.

Maamekin · 02/02/2023 10:22

My three children are underweight according to the Y6 weight screening programme, or whatever it is called. They all hover around 50-75th cent for height and 9th for weight, and that’s been consistent since they were babies.

It must be pretty unusual, because each time in Y6 we’ve been sent an unhelpful leaflet about switching to skimmed milk and low fat yoghurts, sugar free jam etc, which I assume is meant to be the overweight leaflet.

I’m sure genetics plays a big part - most members of my and DH family are built very similarly - tall, long limbed, slender.

They are all slow eaters - wonder if that makes any difference. I don’t think it’s because I don’t feed them enough - they often stop eating without finishing everything on their plates. They have a reasonable diet overall, and they both enjoy vegetables, but it’s not brilliant by any means - dc1 has Nutella or peanut butter on toast for breakfast most days, I offer pudding every day etc.

So I imagine it’s not really that simple.

Catspyjamas17 · 02/02/2023 10:19

One of the problems is that food really is so much nicer than 40 years ago when I was a kid, and the only olive oil I knew about was the stuff in tiny bottles from the pharmacy, that you would have definitely not have felt like drizzling over your Mighty White toast.

And a lot of processed foods are made deliberately, or as a happy by-product, to distort your sense of fullness and satisfaction. Even the posh ones. Sometimes especially the posh ones.

I had some Cornish Cruncher biscuits last night that were from an M&S hamper we got for Christmas. Fucking evilly good. I could have ate them until I was sick.

And even foods that are high in calories but part of a balanced diet in small amounts are easy to overeat. Nuts being a case in point. Who can eat just ten cashews?

Nixynic · 02/02/2023 10:18

I bought several school dresses online from TU recently - when they arrived they were absolute tents and completely drowned my daughters, had to send them back. My daughters are very average sized. Getting school trousers is the hardest, my eldest is tall and average waisted (not even skinny) but I have to either take in the waists of her trousers or buy ones that have adjustable elastic waists. It used to be hard for people to buy clothes for overweight children, now I find it’s difficult to buy clothes for average/slim children.

Highdaysandholidays1 · 02/02/2023 10:17

I don't think the interesting thing is whether we've lost sight of how to have a healthy weight child or how to be a healthy weight ourselves, but why?

If an entire population gets fatter, and that includes the older women, men, and all the children apart from now a minority, doesn't that tell you something about the shitty hyperpalatable food and obesogenic environment in which they live. It's highly unlikely each individual person and family is somehow defective and unable to tell these things, it's more like the food we eat is less nutritious, even for those trying hard. Chickens are now full of fat and less protein. Even fruit is sprayed and often hard and weird. Meat bubbles with preservatives (I'm mostly veggie for this reason). If you go to parts of the world where they still grow and eat high quality local produce, rather than the products of the food industry complex we have in the UK, then people are slimmer (I mean if not slim through poverty) Eating high quality good food in the UK is only for very rich people now, who can afford what used to be normal meat and organic veggies. It isn't that people can't see properly what fat looks like, it's that even cooking from scratch in the UK delivers substandard food, see US for ultimately where this is all going. Domination of hyperpalatable food industry affects us all.

Twiglets1 · 02/02/2023 10:15

YANBU.
I work in a school and it's sad to me to see so many overweight children. I mean I'm a bit chubbby myself so don't want to be a hypocrite but I was skinny well into my early 30s.
My son is a bit overweight at 24. I blame it largely on his obsession with computer games which he prefers to being physically active.

LeapingCat · 02/02/2023 10:15

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 02/02/2023 09:57

forcing adult neurosis on children about weight will only hurt in the long run.

This is just such a weak argument. If ‘body shaming’ had half the effect that people claim it does, anorexia and bulimia would be much more common, as would being underweight. Under eating has never even been 5% of the issue that over eating has.

No, body shaming doesn’t cause harm by causing anorexia (though occasionally it does). It mostly causes harm by causing overweight people to seek more comfort in food and increasing their weight. People can’t change their eating patterns to healthy ones when they’re miserable because they’re being body shamed.

Dutchesss · 02/02/2023 10:12

Quantity plays such an important part in nutrition. Obviously too much healthy food will make you put on weight, the same with a big quantity of junk food. That's why people can eat unhealthy food and maintain a stable weight. Plenty of people also eat unhealthy food and put on too much weight. It doesn't mean that it's ok to be overweight just because the weight has been put on with healthy food. That's still unhealthy for you.

AzureOrchid · 02/02/2023 10:11

I get comments from DP family that my kids are too skinny , and that they need to eat more.
They are definitely not skinny , and according to NHS bmi they are perfectly normal weights for their height and age.
The issue is that all the kids on DP side of the family are overweight and they think this is the norm.
My eldest has a cousin the same age and height that is 2 stone heavier.
Noticeably chubby with belly and round face.
They think this look is healthier.
Its frustrating having to bat off the “ skinny “ comments to my kids without retorting that their kids are in fact overweight.
I obviously would never say to them as that would be incredibly rude.

My kids are a lot more active and do not eat the same amount of junk and snacks as their relatives.

I see some very overweight children at school pick up time.

Squamata · 02/02/2023 10:10

We know very well how to reduce obesity, it takes a 360 degree approach where parents, schools, health providers, local councils, national government, retailers, food outlets etc are all involved in working towards the same goal.

Eg authorities design areas so you can travel to school actively, schools give healthy food, retailers don't promote excess consumption of unhealthy food, health providers give support programmes for people who want to lose weight.

It doesn't happen because there are too many vested interests. People make good money off selling stuff that makes people fat, then selling them stuff that promises to make them thin. It's easier to point the finger at parents. They have a role to play but it's only one part of the whole.

Dinoswearunderpants · 02/02/2023 10:10

You often find the parents are also overweight. They don't say no to food so neither does their children.

ToBeOrNotToBee · 02/02/2023 10:09

Don't forget that 'back in the day', a lot of kids were skinny because they were malnourished.

That is just as bad as being overweight, if not worse, due to the stunting in growth, brain capability, heat regulation, and more.

Catspyjamas17 · 02/02/2023 10:08

I don't think people have lost sight or haven't noticed.

The parents are overweight, unsurprisingly their kids are overweight, and it can be very difficult to change lifestyle habits to lose weight and keep it off. We live in an obesogenic society, if you hadn't noticed. It's much easier to be overweight than slim. Overweight is normal, the majority of adults are overweight.

Of course personal choices come into it, but when a huge change has happened in society over 40 or so years there is usually rather a lot more to it than that.

StClare101 · 02/02/2023 10:06

It’s not an even playing field though is it?

I say that as a parent of two very skinny kids.

I know I can be lazy sometimes and feed them junk and - visibly anyway - it won’t matter as DH and I are both very slim and so are they. Genetics really does play a huge part.

This thread has made me realise that actually they probably eat a bit much.

Elsatellsa · 02/02/2023 10:06

Squamata · 02/02/2023 10:03

You sound like a barrel of laughs, OP.

Obesity is very complex and many determining factors are pre set in the womb, or in early life up to the age of 2. Your weight at 2 determines a lot about how much fat you carry when you're in your teens and beyond.

We should be throwing a lot of money at educating women pre pregnancy about nutrition and weight, providing lots of support and programmes to ensure the conception - age 2 bit is optimised. Support for exercise and diet through the rest of childhood too.

I have no time for judgey pants 'I gawp at plump children on the school run and think how much better I am than their parents' type of people. There's an obesity pandemic, it's a systemic problem.

There are certainly lots of factors at play and it definitely isn't as simple as parents feeding their children too much, but similarly there is a level of responsibility that lots of parents seem loathe to take. Sweeping it all under the carpet and head firmly in the sand isn't helpful.

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 02/02/2023 10:06

You sound like a barrel of laughs, OP.

Best you can come up with?

OP posts:
LeapingCat · 02/02/2023 10:06

Winniethepoohandtiggertoo · 02/02/2023 09:51

Are they actually underweight though? Or they just look skinnier than their peers? I’m willing to bet the former, because like I said a chubby child is now seen as a ‘normal, solid’ weight. It’s great they see party food as treats and have the odd gorge. Isn’t that the whole point of them being a ‘treat’?

I have no idea how much they weigh, obviously. I only know that one of their parents asked me if my healthy weight DD (who is nowhere near the overweight category) had got the letter about being overweight. Which does suggest their perceptions are a bit off. I’m not sure that it’s great for kids to want to stop playing because they finally have a chance of getting some sugar!

Squamata · 02/02/2023 10:05

The other thing is that a child can be a healthy weight and still be malnourished. Just because they're 50th percentile doesn't mean they have enough vitamins and minerals, they could be having small portions of oven chips every day and nothing else. Weight is not equivalent to health.

Dutchesss · 02/02/2023 10:05

What people class as a ‘normal’ plate or food or a ‘healthy’ diet has unfortunately become very subjective.
I agree, portion sizes are way off. I order a child's meal when eating out and it's usually plenty. My children wouldn't eat anywhere near as much as is usually offered.

Elsatellsa · 02/02/2023 10:04

RagingWoke · 02/02/2023 09:54

It's not a simple thing. Children, like adults, have different body types, metabolisms etc. forcing adult neurosis on children about weight will only hurt in the long run.

In my DDs year 3 class there is one dc in age 4/5 clothes, child doesn't eat much and what they do is rarely healthy but they are fairly slim. My own DD is in age 11/12 clothes, very tall- she is a head taller than all but one child in the class despite being the youngest and well proportioned, fairly muscular and not much fat, in the healthy weight bmi zone, but I imagine judgemental people looking at her thinking she was too big and it's our fault (I guess it is, it's genetics!).

Giving children the knowledge of a healthy and balanced diet and lifestyle is much more beneficial than them learning bad habits that will affect their body, their health and their appearance for the rest of their lives. This tip toeing around weight doesn't do anyone any favours.

Wearing clothes that are for children 5 to 6 years older than her and within the healthy weight range, are you being honest with yourself here?

Wanderingowl · 02/02/2023 10:04

I worry about this quite a bit because 5 years ago I had tipped into having an obese BMI and at time I thought I was 'just a bit overweight.' And when I decided to tackle my weight and change my diet, lots of my friends told me I wasn't even a bit overweight and didn't need to change anything. While I know there was an element of them being 'kind' I also presume they really didn't look at me and see an obese women. Because our perceptions are really fucked up right now.

So I worry about it for my son and do sneaky BMI checks on him. We're both mesomorphic body types, which means we're densely built, with larger frames and a lot of muscle. So neither of us will ever be skinny. He also has clearly the same tendency that I had as a child, of looking like he is getting a bit fatter before suddenly growing taller. He's currently in the 83rd centile, which is on the higher end of healthy weight but not worryingly so. However, I worry about the chart being based on centiles. Because if everyone is getting heavier on average, which we are, then is being in the 83rd centile really still healthy? Surely he'd have been well into the 90s if you compared him to the centile weights in the 70s?