Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH wants a puppy Is it worth getting a puppy for his birthday

118 replies

Safarigiraffe · 01/02/2023 20:31

Hi all, we are thinking of getting a English Springer Spaniel puppy for DH birthday in June as a surprise for him however we do work full time, DS/DD work part time so any advice on if it’s worth getting DH the puppy he's always wanted or hang on a bit

OP posts:
DominoRules · 01/02/2023 21:45

Have you done plenty of research into Springers? They are amazing dogs but need a lot of your time and attention!

Mine is now 15 months and needs about 2 hours off lead exercise a day plus activities to occupy his mind. He is totally attached to me, if I move in the house he moves. He can cope with being on his own for a few hours on occasion but certainly wouldn’t manage on a daily basis.

I have done a lot of training with him, as well as sniffer dog classes. We are also starting gun dog classes and flyball soon, he needs that mental stimulation to learn something new and to ‘work’.

You have to honestly ask yourselves if you can give a dog like a springer the life they deserve. They are intelligent, focused and full of energy and you have to be prepared to challenge them and channel that in the right way.

BotterMon · 01/02/2023 21:43

Springers are extremely high energy intelligent dogs. Not for first time dog owners if that is your case.
If they aren't exercised/stimulated enough they will destroy things. They also love company.

Don't buy a working breed if you want a cuddly pet and you should never buy one as a surprise present. By all means it can be a present as long as you all choose the dog together and do you research beforehand as to what's a suitable breed. And buy from a registered breeder which usually kyboshes the birthday present idea anyway as pups aren't bred to order.

plumduck · 01/02/2023 21:43

What happens when your kids move out?
This is a bad idea

Rainbowqueeen · 01/02/2023 21:42

Someone needs to be home full time with the puppy for the first 6 weeks, focusing on care, settling and training.

What research have you done into suitable breeds for your family?
How are you planning to adapt your lives to adequately care for your dog for the rest of its life?

Im not saying don’t get a puppy but unless you have done the really basic 3 things above then don’t get a puppy. Saying “someone will be around” makes you sound like you haven’t fully considered what is involved in having a dog in the family.

Costacoffeeplease · 01/02/2023 21:40

Ridiculous idea. How are you going to train the pup when different people will be with it all the time? It needs consistency to learn

Plus a living breathing animal should NEVER be a ‘surprise’ or a present.

I can’t believe people still even consider doing this 🙄

Longdarkcloud · 01/02/2023 21:38

If despite all the advice here you decide to go ahead then make a voucher card to give him on his birthday saying his gift is that he can choose a puppy.
A part of the experience of getting a companion animal is the choosing and you should not deprive your DH of that pleasure.

PrincessHoneysuckle · 01/02/2023 21:37

Puppies are adorable wankers.
Mine is just coming out of it age 15 months.

Dontlistitonfacebook · 01/02/2023 21:36

Pets are not gifts. Neither for adults nor for children.

lollylimejuice · 01/02/2023 21:33

I had an English Springer Spaniel. I loved her very much.
As a breed, they are very active and need lots of walking, every day, twice a day at least and when they walk and run they kick up mud, water you name it. It's the way they run. So, you'll need lots of old towels and an outside hose for cleaning your new puppy down.
It's a big deal getting a dog and all the promises to walk disappear at 6.30pm on a cold, wet winter's night. Your husband, if he wants a puppy should choose his own.
Check the breed line and the pedigree and the temperament.

The animal charities are overrun with dogs purchased during lockdown and that now don't fit.

KimberleyClark · 01/02/2023 21:32

No no no. Getting any animal as a surprise gift is wrong.

FrauleinElsaMars · 01/02/2023 21:31

We got our dog a couple of years ago, he’s a miniature schnauzer cross. We both work full time, but both from home, I took a month off when we got him but I could have done with a full mat leave 😂😂 however we have absolutely no regrets on getting him, he was enriched our lives so much. Be prepared for that first year to be hard work tho.

Atethehalloweenchocs · 01/02/2023 21:30

Spaniels can be lovely dogs but a lot of work and need training, and lots of time put in. Lots of people understimate the amount of work they are.

whataboutsecondbreakfast · 01/02/2023 21:25

What happens when your children want to go out, or work full time, or move out?

This is a horrendous idea and a springer spaniel is really not the breed for you.

Lcb123 · 01/02/2023 21:23

Awful and cruel idea. Puppies are incredibly hard work. Surely
your DS and DD will move out soon if they’re working, then who will look after the dog. Sorry but sounds very short sighted

PupsAway · 01/02/2023 21:22

Depends on a lot! If your DH has been wanting one ages, you know exactly the type he would go for (and you trust he'll love it, even if you get him a breed he's not too keen on by accident), you've both researched the breed and know what it needs and that you can provide for him, you are ready for the vets bills, food costs, training, peeing and pooing everywhere and eating everything (your chairs, work books, laptops, cables, etc...) etc.. and all the family are on board with it, then yes! Do it!

We got a pup a couple of months ago and I adore him! It was such a good decision! He's part of the family and seems to be really getting used to us and his new surroundings. He needs a couple.of long off-lead walks a day. But otherwise is pretty chill! He's mastered toilet training and so far so good!

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 01/02/2023 21:21

We have a ten month old lab. I worked from home solidly for two months when we got her as she couldn't go anywhere until fully vaxed and needed a lot of attention. She goes to decent daycare with a trainer on the days I am in the office, sometimes overnights as I will do two long days back to back and she won't get the exercise or the stimulation she needs.

If you can afford help and lots of it then it might be viable but do your maths. There's a reason a lot of dogs are being abandoned right now.

Ponoka7 · 01/02/2023 21:20

I'm glad that someone else has posted about how much exercise a Springer needs. My hobby was camping, it is a popular breed for people who camp, hike etc because they are so high energy. It's a breed that you plan your life around. It's a bit of a crap present if it's to be a family dog, but like getting a hoover etc. Plan the exercise commitments, then perhaps a family gift for Easter? It's best to have the full set up before the puppy, so pads, toys etc. You need to plan the toilet training and everyone be on board with discipline and were the dog is allowed to go in the house eg not upstairs.

spidereggs · 01/02/2023 21:19

Set up fine

Everything else?

Worth it? Let's assume that's badly worded.

Puppy? Yes all fine, but no breeder worth that name will sell as a surprise

He is an adult

Hey let's research and get a family dog, around your birthday? Can be your present in name.....

Anything else, quite frankly, is insensitive as hell today, so I'm going to shout

DO NOT BUY A FAMILY DOG FROM SOMEONE WHO THINKS A SURPRISE IS GOOD

bakewellbride · 01/02/2023 21:19

A puppy should not be a 'birthday surprise' but instead a huge commitment.

Wolfiefan · 01/02/2023 21:18

Plus decent breeders often have a wait list and won’t automatically have pups available in June. Remember bitches generally have a couple of seasons a year. Plus decent breeders don’t have dozens of dogs or breed repeatedly from the same ones.

Whiskeypowers · 01/02/2023 21:17

My cocker is coming up for 11
I’ve had her since she was 14 weeks old and she is the child I had before my children in terms of responsibility, cost and of course love.

until recently she needed a LOT of exercise i’m talking two and half tonthree hours a day at least an hour off lead. Now she has three shorter walks a day as her back legs are getting a it stiff despite injections so they need fitting in around work and school runs clubs etc.

she had never really been left on her own as my life and job have meant that’s possible but she doesn’t cope at all well with being left along and never has certainly not for more than an hour to two max.
puppies are like having a newborn then a teenager very quickly and you only get out what you put in. The housetraining and chewing can be very hard going.

buying a puppy for a present is stupid and no decent breeder would ever let you do that.

the breed and your current lifestyle don’t add up but to fair no puppy would fit well into this set up.

RaiseTheStakesAndMakeTheLastWordDuckhead · 01/02/2023 21:13

DubLynn · 01/02/2023 21:11

I think it's a lovely idea and June is a great time to get a puppy because they're like little kids and get up very early in the beginning so nice to be getting up in the bright rather than depths of winter!

I have a springer spaniel (he's 4 now) and got him when he was a puppy. However I'm a preschool teacher so was off work for the first 6 weeks we had him and then only working 4 hours a day.

I get up at 6am Monday - Friday and walk him for a full hour. It's tough going in the winter. My husband works from home most of the time but when he's not here the dog is alone for 5 hours by the time i drop kids to school, go to work myself, come home etc. He gets another decent run around (about 30 minutes with a ball) when i get home from work and then any time I'm going anywhere that i can bring him, i do. So if i was calling up to my mum i bring him. Or when the kids do basketball on a Wednesday night i use that hour to walk him.. hail rain or shine. The exercise goal with a springer is 1-2 hours per day and more at the weekend. It's a huge commitment.

Long story short, getting a family dog is a wonderful idea but think about the breed and whether or not you can meet the needs.

OP - putting aside the fact you sound a bit clueless to getting a puppy, this poster is giving you a generous insight into amount of work involved.

DubLynn · 01/02/2023 21:11

I think it's a lovely idea and June is a great time to get a puppy because they're like little kids and get up very early in the beginning so nice to be getting up in the bright rather than depths of winter!

I have a springer spaniel (he's 4 now) and got him when he was a puppy. However I'm a preschool teacher so was off work for the first 6 weeks we had him and then only working 4 hours a day.

I get up at 6am Monday - Friday and walk him for a full hour. It's tough going in the winter. My husband works from home most of the time but when he's not here the dog is alone for 5 hours by the time i drop kids to school, go to work myself, come home etc. He gets another decent run around (about 30 minutes with a ball) when i get home from work and then any time I'm going anywhere that i can bring him, i do. So if i was calling up to my mum i bring him. Or when the kids do basketball on a Wednesday night i use that hour to walk him.. hail rain or shine. The exercise goal with a springer is 1-2 hours per day and more at the weekend. It's a huge commitment.

Long story short, getting a family dog is a wonderful idea but think about the breed and whether or not you can meet the needs.

AuroraForever · 01/02/2023 21:07

Can you wait until you’re retired? A puppy as a birthday surprise gift sounds lovely but the novelty of that will wear very very thin very very quickly. It’s all right thinking everyone will share responsibility but that soon wears away and it’s usually left to one person ‘to sort the dog out’. Puppies are hard work but dog ownership is a huge responsibility. Think about it rationally. Have you the experience? The finances? What about when you all want to go out? Abroad? On holiday? It’s a bad idea especially now when you’re all working and I know from experience. As sad as this sounds, when ours pass away we won’t be getting any more. This is something not to rush into.

Allytheapple · 01/02/2023 21:05

If you are experienced dog owners go for it. If not there are lots of factors to consider.

We have a family dog and everyone in the family is involved in his care. If your gang are up for the same, it is great idea.

Swipe left for the next trending thread