Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

80% of women too unfit to be healthy?

494 replies

FlowerArranger · 01/02/2023 20:03

I listened to Women's Hour while doing my workout today. In a segment on women in sport, one contributor stated that research shows that 80% of women are too unfit to be healthy.

I Googled and found a reference to a Canadian study from 2007 and CDC research from 2013:

A new (US) government study estimates that nearly 80 percent of adult Americans do not get the recommended amounts of exercise each week, potentially setting themselves up for years of health problems.

www.cbsnews.com/news/cdc-80-percent-of-american-adults-dont-get-recommended-exercise/

I don't suppose British women do much better? If this is indeed true, it is is shocking.

I remember when my children were little and I was working full-time, there was little or no time to exercise in a formal way - though I'm sure all the running after them and running up and down stairs and housework and gardening kept me fit enough!

If this is you, you are excused......... but what about all the years before and after looking after children? Why don't women exercise enough to keep themselves healthy? Which the CDC defined as:

at least 2.5 hours of moderate-intensity aerobic exercise each week or one hour and 15 minutes of vigorous-intensity activity, or a combination of both

Personally I (in my 60s) work out most days and I feel so much better for it.

YABU - I don't see the need to exercise regularly
YANBU - regular exercise is vital

OP posts:
Kanaloa · 03/02/2023 10:24

And as for us all getting our exercise ‘tumbling round the park with the kids’ what is that supposed to look like in real life? How is that supposed to be real sustained exercise?

Kanaloa · 03/02/2023 10:23

DarkNecessities · 03/02/2023 07:51

Mostly what I’m reading here is ‘excuses’ tbh

Once again, excuses is what op asked for. She asked why women don’t exercise more. Anything other than ‘I have no arms and legs’ will be brushed aside as an ‘excuse’ because op didn’t actually want to hear why women feel they can’t exercise, she wanted to patronisingly tell us we need to do YouTube videos and minimise people’s answers by brightly insisting it only takes 10 minutes and we can just use cans of beans.

SedentaryCat · 03/02/2023 10:20

I used to exercise regularly before DCs. 3 classes a week plus gym and the occasional swim.

Worked FT and volunteered for a charity. Also doing OU degree.

Of course my time was my own.

Since DCs arrived its been difficult to keep up any regular exercise (eldest is 18 now). Time constraints, lack of childcare, work, fatigue. Oh and being fat shamed really put me off. Y'know when random men decide you're too fat to be running. (I wasn't, but it was enough to discourage me). I haven't done any real consistent exercise for the last 3 or 4 years. I walk sometimes, I've tried rejoining a gym, and restarted couch to 5k. My heart isn't in it.

I'm overweight by a considerable amount, my joints hurt, and I'm tired. Getting back in the habit is proving difficult. I like being fit and healthy but right now it seems an insurmountable problem.

Catspyjamas17 · 03/02/2023 10:18

Yep, most people vastly underestimate how many calories they consume and massively overestimate how many calories they burn with exercise. I get irritated by the 'exercise does not help you lose weight' brigade on here and I immediately question the nature of the 'exercise' these people claim they are doing

Oddly (perhaps not oddly to people in the know) I've found recently that I need to eat more to lose weight, about 1800 calories a day.

I can, and have stuck to eating far less in the past but it's not sustainable, I was losing out on iron, fibre and other important nutrients and your body thinks there is a famine so desperately tries to hold on to the weight.

Most diets put you on a default 1200-1400 calories- probably as they build in people under recording or under estimating. At 1800 I do have to be completely honest about recording everything, but I'm more likely to be as it's easier to stick to!

Very easy to go wrong with eating a little too much or a snack here and there.

DanseAvecLesLoup · 03/02/2023 10:05

tirednewmumm · 03/02/2023 08:29

This is a really common misconception bless you, we've all been there and I've learnt the same lesson a few years ago. ' Running round after kids' and walking are of course really good for you. BUT, they're not typically improving actually cardiovascular fitness enough and not much for muscle tone which we start to lose anyway as we get older. It's just not enough on its own

Yep, most people vastly underestimate how many calories they consume and massively overestimate how many calories they burn with exercise. I get irritated by the 'exercise does not help you lose weight' brigade on here and I immediately question the nature of the 'exercise' these people claim they are doing.

ofwarren · 03/02/2023 08:38

tirednewmumm · 03/02/2023 08:29

This is a really common misconception bless you, we've all been there and I've learnt the same lesson a few years ago. ' Running round after kids' and walking are of course really good for you. BUT, they're not typically improving actually cardiovascular fitness enough and not much for muscle tone which we start to lose anyway as we get older. It's just not enough on its own

So true
I used to go to the gym ages ago and could lift decent weights. Yesterday I could literally only lift the lightest ones on the machines.
I can walk and walk all day long, probably around 10 miles before I feel the burn in my calves but climbing the stairs makes me out of breath.

tirednewmumm · 03/02/2023 08:29

ofwarren · 01/02/2023 20:20

I walk a lot as my children are in a school 2 miles away and we don't drive there. I cover around 35 miles a week and thought I'd be relatively fit.
I did a aerobic recovery test where you exercise for 3 mins, rest for 30 seconds then take your pulse and my recovery rate was dreadful. The lowest it could possibly be.
I joined the gym yesterday..

This is a really common misconception bless you, we've all been there and I've learnt the same lesson a few years ago. ' Running round after kids' and walking are of course really good for you. BUT, they're not typically improving actually cardiovascular fitness enough and not much for muscle tone which we start to lose anyway as we get older. It's just not enough on its own

Bubblebubblebah · 03/02/2023 08:13

mathanxiety · 03/02/2023 00:03

A lot of the replies here center around three factors:
Time
Money
Safety in the environment

Essentially - money.

Many women don't have anyone to take the kids off their hands while they exercise.
Many women don't have a safe or congenial place to go running or walking.
Many women don't have the right footwear and can't afford it.
Many women can't afford a gym or a monthly app fee.

And many women do just fine without all of that.
It's really not that expensive to do 10 minute fast cardio workout at home to give your cardiovascular system a bit of happiness.
Actually, it's free.

Problem here is that everyone keeps talking about money and 90 min needed and this and that and that. And shower.
Do short bursts, free at home, before shower time🤷🏻

do at least 150 minutes of moderate intensity activity a week or 75 minutes of vigorous intensity activity a week
From nhs. And no walking isn't vigorous exercise.

I agree with others that se are simply excuses because most people don't want to say "well, i just don't want to". Most of us don't. Most of us also don't want a quadraple bypass before 50

QuertyGirl · 03/02/2023 08:03

For many (not all) it's cars.

They've distorted peoples perceptions of how far they can walk or cycle.

I had a discussion on here the other day where people were insisting that you have to be "super fit" to use a bike in an area with hills, as your main mode of transport.

They have no idea what their bodies are capable of due to years sitting in cars.

Skydaze · 03/02/2023 07:58

To be clear, I'm not advocating for no exercise, or against workarounds or suggestions. However I do think significant barriers to women exercising are being treated on here a bit like it's just precious little girls not wanting to break a nail. Whereas what I'm seeing is women with real issues being honest about why they struggle with it. Or why they've given up. Understanding and compassion goes a long way to addressing the problems constructively.

DarkNecessities · 03/02/2023 07:51

Mostly what I’m reading here is ‘excuses’ tbh

Taswama · 03/02/2023 07:49

Thanks for this thread. It motivated me to do some yoga before bed yesterday.

I fitted in exercise while the kids were doing activities for years - a long run home from Beavers drop off, a cycle ride during a riding lesson (we had cycled there), we briefly tried climbing but when they insisted a parent stay on site for the kids sessions even though ds was 12 we stopped. Have started again now he is 15 and allowed to be left.

But each child has never had more than 2 activities per week so me and DP also had evenings / weekend days to pursue our own interests.

I walk or cycle to work too (about 2 miles) and like pp have plenty of colleagues who drive similar or shorter distances. My fitness was at its worst in 10 years during the pandemic due to losing this incidental exercise.

Skydaze · 03/02/2023 07:44

greenacrylicpaint · 03/02/2023 06:17

to go for a walk is free.
to do own body weight strength exercises is free.
dancing like crazy sith dc at home is free.
tumble about with the kids in a park is free.

and those set a good example for kids as well.

Yep, there is lots of good free stuff we can do. However walking / running - as mathanxiety said - many women lack a safe space for this, or just do not feel safe. This is a significant barrier for exercise particularly for women.

I live in a decent, middle class suburban neighborhood - looks and feels safe. No obvious dangers. However both DH and I work in social service type positions, so we are well aware of the rapists and violent criminals who live within a 15min radius of our house. Literal convicted child rapist bailed to a house two streets over. One of our clients was beaten half to death on a local walking track in broad daylight in a random attack. More than one woman has been sexually assaulted on our town's most popular track.

So yes - I have definite pause for thought when walking the neighborhood. It doesn't stop me, mostly, but it's not great either. I try to be both aware but not think about it too much otherwise I'd never go walking.

Everydayitsgettingcloser · 03/02/2023 07:29

mathanxiety · 03/02/2023 00:03

A lot of the replies here center around three factors:
Time
Money
Safety in the environment

Essentially - money.

Many women don't have anyone to take the kids off their hands while they exercise.
Many women don't have a safe or congenial place to go running or walking.
Many women don't have the right footwear and can't afford it.
Many women can't afford a gym or a monthly app fee.

I don't think money has been a big factor actually - I would say energy in place of that.

Maybe this is just me but I do have money and lots of exercise options are free anyway, it's energy. And not just physical energy, emotional energy is lacking

BigButtons · 03/02/2023 06:44

I have just placed an order for a 10kg weighted vest. I have been dithering about it for months- would it be yet another item I don't use much? But it will be good to add to leg days when I do weights and for walking.

malificent7 · 03/02/2023 06:35

It's not just about the money though is it? By the time I've done my FT demanding job for the nhs, im too knackered to do pilates on my living room floor. Im lucky though as my job is quite physical and i do lots of steps at work.

BigButtons · 03/02/2023 06:23

greenacrylicpaint · 03/02/2023 06:17

to go for a walk is free.
to do own body weight strength exercises is free.
dancing like crazy sith dc at home is free.
tumble about with the kids in a park is free.

and those set a good example for kids as well.

Was going to say exactly the same thing. There is so much you can do that is free. You tube has amazing trainers posting stuff all the time- for free. Could be dance, weights, walking, cardio, yoga.
I don’t go to a gym. I also work out barefoot.

greenacrylicpaint · 03/02/2023 06:17

mathanxiety · 03/02/2023 00:03

A lot of the replies here center around three factors:
Time
Money
Safety in the environment

Essentially - money.

Many women don't have anyone to take the kids off their hands while they exercise.
Many women don't have a safe or congenial place to go running or walking.
Many women don't have the right footwear and can't afford it.
Many women can't afford a gym or a monthly app fee.

to go for a walk is free.
to do own body weight strength exercises is free.
dancing like crazy sith dc at home is free.
tumble about with the kids in a park is free.

and those set a good example for kids as well.

mathanxiety · 03/02/2023 00:03

A lot of the replies here center around three factors:
Time
Money
Safety in the environment

Essentially - money.

Many women don't have anyone to take the kids off their hands while they exercise.
Many women don't have a safe or congenial place to go running or walking.
Many women don't have the right footwear and can't afford it.
Many women can't afford a gym or a monthly app fee.

mathanxiety · 02/02/2023 23:54

@BigButtons - there's so much more to it than 'washing your hair'.

herbaceous · 02/02/2023 23:03

Thanks, but I did c25k and was not filled with the urge to do a park run. Can’t bear the idea. I cannot equate running in public with fun.

I used to only run in the dark so I wouldn’t be seen.

DarkNecessities · 02/02/2023 23:00

herbaceous · 02/02/2023 22:55

Nice!

I’n not saying they’re judging me, just that I feel ashamed. Not the same.

Ok. I stand by what I said though.
I can assure you that no-one else is bothered!

FlowerArranger · 02/02/2023 23:00

@herbaceous - Lucy Wyndham Reed has a 'running for beginners' programme - maybe this might help you build up the confidence to join Parkrun?

Here is the first of 4 sessions

OP posts:
herbaceous · 02/02/2023 22:55

Nice!

I’n not saying they’re judging me, just that I feel ashamed. Not the same.

DarkNecessities · 02/02/2023 22:28

DanseAvecLesLoup · 02/02/2023 16:36

The whole ethos of parkrun is inclusivity and that it is not just for 'proper runners', nobody gives a shit if you are slow or walk the whole course, just you being there participating is the main thing.

Agreed, and if you think others are judging you then it says a lot about you.