Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

80% of women too unfit to be healthy?

494 replies

FlowerArranger · 01/02/2023 20:03

I listened to Women's Hour while doing my workout today. In a segment on women in sport, one contributor stated that research shows that 80% of women are too unfit to be healthy.

I Googled and found a reference to a Canadian study from 2007 and CDC research from 2013:

A new (US) government study estimates that nearly 80 percent of adult Americans do not get the recommended amounts of exercise each week, potentially setting themselves up for years of health problems.

www.cbsnews.com/news/cdc-80-percent-of-american-adults-dont-get-recommended-exercise/

I don't suppose British women do much better? If this is indeed true, it is is shocking.

I remember when my children were little and I was working full-time, there was little or no time to exercise in a formal way - though I'm sure all the running after them and running up and down stairs and housework and gardening kept me fit enough!

If this is you, you are excused......... but what about all the years before and after looking after children? Why don't women exercise enough to keep themselves healthy? Which the CDC defined as:

at least 2.5 hours of moderate-intensity aerobic exercise each week or one hour and 15 minutes of vigorous-intensity activity, or a combination of both

Personally I (in my 60s) work out most days and I feel so much better for it.

YABU - I don't see the need to exercise regularly
YANBU - regular exercise is vital

OP posts:
FlowerArranger · 03/02/2023 17:48

I agree, @ErrolTheDragon . Some can be a bit shouty or overenthusiastic, eg Popsugar Fitness (though i like Jake Dupree...) or Rebecca Louise, who I also like - especially her older videos, with the sound turned off.

Fitness Blender is excellent but a bit dull.

Lucy Wyndham Reed is very calm and gentle. Perfect for beginners, the elderly or unfit.

Theres a reason why Heather Robertson and Sydney Cummings are very popular. They know their stuff and are able to engage with their audience.

Personally I like Caroline Girvan and Growingannanas because they are very professional and they don't talk. So I can listen to Women's Hour while I do my workout. Hence this thread, LOL.

Theres a lovely chap called Harry who does reviews of online influencers. Most of them are very technical, but every now and again he does a review of a dozen or so and ranks them:

(NB: Forget about Blogilates...)

OP posts:
TheOrigRights · 03/02/2023 17:45

Astrabees · 03/02/2023 17:43

Despite my negative attitude I did try park run a couple of years back, I could run it in just over 30 mins despite my aversion to exercise. It was full of fit young men who shout at you to move over and younger women who are very competitive. I did come first in my age group but there was no one else in my age group except me. It is not very inclusive, I was expecting lots of older people, walkers, people just starting running but no, really just for serious runners.

It depends where you go.
I've been to one in a Uni city - very competitive, full of uni sport students.
Another one more local to me is (I think) more representative has walkers, pushchairs, kids, club runners, old, young.

nca89 · 03/02/2023 17:45

Does walking fast (not quite power walking!) count as moderate exercise? I try to do this for half an hour a day, it registers as exercise on my Apple Watch.

Astrabees · 03/02/2023 17:43

Despite my negative attitude I did try park run a couple of years back, I could run it in just over 30 mins despite my aversion to exercise. It was full of fit young men who shout at you to move over and younger women who are very competitive. I did come first in my age group but there was no one else in my age group except me. It is not very inclusive, I was expecting lots of older people, walkers, people just starting running but no, really just for serious runners.

ErrolTheDragon · 03/02/2023 17:14

FlowerArranger · 03/02/2023 16:49

I agree about the positive knock-on effect of exercisin

Especially the "not eating/drinking crap on the sofa and scrolling on my tablet" thing.

I have more energy after an hour with Caroline Girvan than if I had been 'resting'.

I've tend to find YouTube instructors a bit hard to engage with, partly I think their channels can be a bit overwhelming, not always clear where best to start and how to put together a coherent program. But I do think I need a change from Jillian Michaels....
maybe a thread or two on the exercise board might be apt at this point...

FlowerArranger · 03/02/2023 16:49

I agree about the positive knock-on effect of exercisin

Especially the "not eating/drinking crap on the sofa and scrolling on my tablet" thing.

I have more energy after an hour with Caroline Girvan than if I had been 'resting'.

OP posts:
TheOrigRights · 03/02/2023 13:34

LolaSmiles · 03/02/2023 12:59

I find exercise has a bit of a halo effect
Same I think it's a keystone habit for me and has a knock on effect to other areas.

It means getting to bed at a good time, choosing to eat well so not to feel sluggish, not wanting to eat junk as much.

When I'm not exercising it's too easy to sit and scroll on my phone, eat junk, and waste time.

Indeed. When I was over-exercising (due to an eating disorder) it was a struggle to find a good balance (and to convince my health providers that the exercise was good) because knowing I was going to do a long run the next day meant I ate better the day before.

LolaSmiles · 03/02/2023 12:59

I find exercise has a bit of a halo effect
Same I think it's a keystone habit for me and has a knock on effect to other areas.

It means getting to bed at a good time, choosing to eat well so not to feel sluggish, not wanting to eat junk as much.

When I'm not exercising it's too easy to sit and scroll on my phone, eat junk, and waste time.

Everydayitsgettingcloser · 03/02/2023 12:38

I find exercise has a bit of a halo effect - I do a PT session once a week. The night before I don't want to drink alcohol because it might make me feel sluggish. The rest of the day after I do it, I feel strong and happy with myself which makes me do things like make healthy soup/salad for the week. A couple of days beforehand I do a short session on my own so that I don't hurt so much after my PT session.

Of course everyone is different - I just wanted to put it out there in case it helps anyone else. I still hate every minute of the actual session though.

My PT once said "some of my clients love their time with me as their me time indulgence", I was like "no offence but I would much rather be on the sofa with a G and T and a nice book". She laughed.

DanseAvecLesLoup · 03/02/2023 12:27

midgetastic · 03/02/2023 11:57

People who say exercise doesn't help with weight loss know that on most cases people eat to make up

You have to burn a shedload of calories ( because eating thousands extra calories is hard ) or be really strict with yourself before it becomes likely that doesn't happen

The other reason exercise rarely helps with weight loss is that people are more likely to be less active after an exercise session - if you do an hour class and then collapse on the sofa for the rest of the day with a glass of wine and bag of crisps you could end up gaining

In fairness that does not prove that exercise does not help with weight loss. Nothing wrong with flopping on the sofa after an exercise session (I do it all the time) but you also reaching for the big bag of crisps or seeing off half a bottle of wine is an issue with your self control with your eating habits. Exercising is not making you open the Doritos or wine.

Devoutspoken · 03/02/2023 12:21

part of the reason I exercise is so I can eat what I want

Devoutspoken · 03/02/2023 12:20

It's not just exercise itself, it'sakso being active in everyday life, which keeps me fit and at a good weight

herbaceous · 03/02/2023 12:19

DarkNecessities · 02/02/2023 23:00

Ok. I stand by what I said though.
I can assure you that no-one else is bothered!

Sorry to bang on about this, but I think this kind of feeling is common.

I'm not egotistical enough to think that anyone else is looking at me or cares two hoots about my existence. But the feeling of shame is deep-rooted, and illogical. I'm sure it stems from school PE when unless you were good at sport you were just a drain, and when failing to catch/hit a ball resulted in much eye-rolling from staff and team-members.

Doing anything one is physically bad at in the presence of others is just a non-starter for many of us!

stayathomer · 03/02/2023 12:15

I don’t know though- if you work in an active job you’d have answered that you did no exercise but on a busy day (retail)- I can be doing up to 15000 steps and lifting loads (but would be marked as no exercise!)

TheOrigRights · 03/02/2023 12:11

midgetastic · 03/02/2023 11:57

People who say exercise doesn't help with weight loss know that on most cases people eat to make up

You have to burn a shedload of calories ( because eating thousands extra calories is hard ) or be really strict with yourself before it becomes likely that doesn't happen

The other reason exercise rarely helps with weight loss is that people are more likely to be less active after an exercise session - if you do an hour class and then collapse on the sofa for the rest of the day with a glass of wine and bag of crisps you could end up gaining

I recognise this, but it is less common in people who aren't exercising specifically for weight loss.
There's no 'making up' frame of mind if you're going our for a bike ride or a swim. There's also less collapsing on the sofa if regular exercise is part of your normal life.
I don't mean to sound evangelical about it and of course there's an element of "yay, I can't wait for my tea and cake" after a long bike ride or a running race, but it's more that they're just going to have some cake rather than working out that they burnt 300 calories and therefore have earned the cake.

I have seen people with so many gels on a belt for a half marathon I reckon they'd put weight on even though they're running 13.1 miles.

DanseAvecLesLoup · 03/02/2023 12:09

ErrolTheDragon · 03/02/2023 11:55

Urgh... weather isn't very nice here today, DH is probably going for a swim, I'm thinking 'I really ought to do some exercise' but not sure I can face Jillian Michaels.... but I've got a nice Concept2 erg in the garage which I've not used for ages, so I suppose I should go and see how many calories a 5'1" 65kg 62 yo can burn.HmmGrin

For your stats it is 273 calories for the above 45 min UT2 session.

Concept 2 is all you need! 😀

Fizbosshoes · 03/02/2023 12:04

Sorry haven't read the full thread but I'm not sure it's as black and white as OP is saying.

And I say this as someone who does do the recommended amount of exercise. I was surprised on a day arlier this week , where I hadn't done any "official" type of exercise I had done 11,000 steps just walking to the station and using the stairs and running errands at work. But I wouldn't want that to be my main form of exercise.
I'm shit at most sports involving a ball and I hated team sports at school because I was the crap one who was last to be picked. My parents didn't prioritise sports they were more interested in academic results (for some reason they seemed to think they were mutually exclusive!) But I am decent at running and actually liked cross country at school because it was an individual sport where you wouldn't let your team mates down. I was lucky that I was a SAHM when my DC were pre school age and there was a creche at the council run gym that I could leave them.
But I will say its only since they are teens and I can leave them at home for a few hours, that I can follow training plans so much more easily.

OP "excuses" parents with very young children (thank you!!) But habits are hard to make and break. If you haven't had time to exercise when your DC are young and full on, where do you start? If youre used to not exercising it can be daunting or difficult to suddenly start, join a class etc. I know when I had periods of depression and stopped running or exercising (even just for a few months) the longer I didn't do it, the harder it was to start.

And agree, men are more likely to prioritise their exercise time. I had to change/stop/adapt my exercise routine when pregnant, post parturition, breastfeeding, for young kids etc whereas DH has had 20 years of uninterrupted "Monday at 7pm is my sports club time".

midgetastic · 03/02/2023 11:57

People who say exercise doesn't help with weight loss know that on most cases people eat to make up

You have to burn a shedload of calories ( because eating thousands extra calories is hard ) or be really strict with yourself before it becomes likely that doesn't happen

The other reason exercise rarely helps with weight loss is that people are more likely to be less active after an exercise session - if you do an hour class and then collapse on the sofa for the rest of the day with a glass of wine and bag of crisps you could end up gaining

ErrolTheDragon · 03/02/2023 11:55

Urgh... weather isn't very nice here today, DH is probably going for a swim, I'm thinking 'I really ought to do some exercise' but not sure I can face Jillian Michaels.... but I've got a nice Concept2 erg in the garage which I've not used for ages, so I suppose I should go and see how many calories a 5'1" 65kg 62 yo can burn.HmmGrin

DanseAvecLesLoup · 03/02/2023 11:41

Bubblebubblebah · 03/02/2023 11:23

You really can't compare competitive rowing with standard exercise most people do😂
10k row on water IS massive amount of exercise.

Also your calorie burns totally differ to what I am apparently burning on my rowing machine.
People are often overestimating, yes you were right.

Hence me highlighting the use of an erg machine which anyone can use and something that any gym worth its salt will have several of. There is no reason at all that use of said machine can't be part of a 'standard exercise' programme by your average person embarking on a new get fit programme. Of course what you burn during exercising will vary between individuals based on your existing weight and cardiovascular fitness but you will burn calories if exercising properly (i.e. not one of the above mentioned 'bumblers'). I am convinced the proponents of the 'exercise is not great at weight loss' mantra have no idea what an actual proper work out is which is why they are perpetually disappointed by the results.

A 65kg 5'2" 40 year old woman doing a moderate (UT2 - ie an intensity which can be held for the full duration, and should be comfortable enough so the person is able to speak throughout the erg and about 65-75% maximum heart rate) for 45 min will burn 300 calories. That is entirely possible for your average person without being part of some elite training programme. Do that three or four times a week and it will make a difference.

Bubblebubblebah · 03/02/2023 11:23

DanseAvecLesLoup · 03/02/2023 11:14

Depends on how you define 'massive'. I row competitively so spend a lot of time on the water or on an erg machine. I wear a heart rate monitor so can accurately track how many calories I am burning. Me going out for one hour (10km) in my single at moderate intensity I will burning around 600 calories, if I am giving it beans (max intensity) that will be knocking on the door of 900 calories. If I am on the erg machine at home a 40-50 min session, again depending on the intensity, UT1, UT2 etc, I will burn between 450-600 calories. I appreciate rowing is a niche sport and not everyone can jump in a boat but rowing machines are accessible to many and in my opinion offer one of the best forms off full body exercises out there and if used properly can help you burn a 'massive' amount of calories. Using an erg three or four times a week for 45mins is at least 1200+ calories being burned which is quite a lot. I am a big fan of quality over half arsed quanity. When I am using the gym near my office I see so many people just bumbling about for an hour, not really engaging properly with equipment or looking like they are elevating their heart rate for any kind of sustained period. Some of those 'bumbling' people are work colleagues and they talk a good game back in the office about 'going to the gym' which is technically true but I can't see much evidence of a work out and I have no doubt they are probably over estimating how many calories they have actually burned. These are the same people who will eat three or four chocolate digestives (85 calories each) throughout the course of the day which amounts to more then a McDonald's hamburger.

You really can't compare competitive rowing with standard exercise most people do😂
10k row on water IS massive amount of exercise.

Also your calorie burns totally differ to what I am apparently burning on my rowing machine.
People are often overestimating, yes you were right.

xogossipgirlxo · 03/02/2023 11:16

mathanxiety · 03/02/2023 00:03

A lot of the replies here center around three factors:
Time
Money
Safety in the environment

Essentially - money.

Many women don't have anyone to take the kids off their hands while they exercise.
Many women don't have a safe or congenial place to go running or walking.
Many women don't have the right footwear and can't afford it.
Many women can't afford a gym or a monthly app fee.

I never paid for gym or subscription. Also I exercise barefoot in my kitchen. Those are really poor excuses. The only valid one is looking after kids.

DanseAvecLesLoup · 03/02/2023 11:14

Bubblebubblebah · 03/02/2023 10:27

You would have to do massive amounts for it to make considerable difference to weightloss.
However, that shouldn't doscourage because exercise does help with posture, firmimg, strrenght, MH, energy levels and list goes on.
But you really don't lose wight just by picking up exercise unless you will do it on extreme level.

Anyway, the fitness in these articles is more about cardiovascular health usually rather than weight itself.

I think this thread also shows how people think exercise is for when you need to lose weight, going by how many people immediately jump to weight. Exercise is for anyone of any weight. You can be slim, non active and get heart disease issues at 50 as the active overweight person.

Depends on how you define 'massive'. I row competitively so spend a lot of time on the water or on an erg machine. I wear a heart rate monitor so can accurately track how many calories I am burning. Me going out for one hour (10km) in my single at moderate intensity I will burning around 600 calories, if I am giving it beans (max intensity) that will be knocking on the door of 900 calories. If I am on the erg machine at home a 40-50 min session, again depending on the intensity, UT1, UT2 etc, I will burn between 450-600 calories. I appreciate rowing is a niche sport and not everyone can jump in a boat but rowing machines are accessible to many and in my opinion offer one of the best forms off full body exercises out there and if used properly can help you burn a 'massive' amount of calories. Using an erg three or four times a week for 45mins is at least 1200+ calories being burned which is quite a lot. I am a big fan of quality over half arsed quanity. When I am using the gym near my office I see so many people just bumbling about for an hour, not really engaging properly with equipment or looking like they are elevating their heart rate for any kind of sustained period. Some of those 'bumbling' people are work colleagues and they talk a good game back in the office about 'going to the gym' which is technically true but I can't see much evidence of a work out and I have no doubt they are probably over estimating how many calories they have actually burned. These are the same people who will eat three or four chocolate digestives (85 calories each) throughout the course of the day which amounts to more then a McDonald's hamburger.

Bubblebubblebah · 03/02/2023 10:27

DanseAvecLesLoup · 03/02/2023 10:05

Yep, most people vastly underestimate how many calories they consume and massively overestimate how many calories they burn with exercise. I get irritated by the 'exercise does not help you lose weight' brigade on here and I immediately question the nature of the 'exercise' these people claim they are doing.

You would have to do massive amounts for it to make considerable difference to weightloss.
However, that shouldn't doscourage because exercise does help with posture, firmimg, strrenght, MH, energy levels and list goes on.
But you really don't lose wight just by picking up exercise unless you will do it on extreme level.

Anyway, the fitness in these articles is more about cardiovascular health usually rather than weight itself.

I think this thread also shows how people think exercise is for when you need to lose weight, going by how many people immediately jump to weight. Exercise is for anyone of any weight. You can be slim, non active and get heart disease issues at 50 as the active overweight person.

Plitvice · 03/02/2023 10:26

mathanxiety · 03/02/2023 00:03

A lot of the replies here center around three factors:
Time
Money
Safety in the environment

Essentially - money.

Many women don't have anyone to take the kids off their hands while they exercise.
Many women don't have a safe or congenial place to go running or walking.
Many women don't have the right footwear and can't afford it.
Many women can't afford a gym or a monthly app fee.

Those are poor excuses. As long as you have a six foot square space you can exercise for free with your kids in the same space barefoot (as I do).