Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

80% of women too unfit to be healthy?

494 replies

FlowerArranger · 01/02/2023 20:03

I listened to Women's Hour while doing my workout today. In a segment on women in sport, one contributor stated that research shows that 80% of women are too unfit to be healthy.

I Googled and found a reference to a Canadian study from 2007 and CDC research from 2013:

A new (US) government study estimates that nearly 80 percent of adult Americans do not get the recommended amounts of exercise each week, potentially setting themselves up for years of health problems.

www.cbsnews.com/news/cdc-80-percent-of-american-adults-dont-get-recommended-exercise/

I don't suppose British women do much better? If this is indeed true, it is is shocking.

I remember when my children were little and I was working full-time, there was little or no time to exercise in a formal way - though I'm sure all the running after them and running up and down stairs and housework and gardening kept me fit enough!

If this is you, you are excused......... but what about all the years before and after looking after children? Why don't women exercise enough to keep themselves healthy? Which the CDC defined as:

at least 2.5 hours of moderate-intensity aerobic exercise each week or one hour and 15 minutes of vigorous-intensity activity, or a combination of both

Personally I (in my 60s) work out most days and I feel so much better for it.

YABU - I don't see the need to exercise regularly
YANBU - regular exercise is vital

OP posts:
betweenarockandhardplace · 02/02/2023 06:13

My story is not unusual.

I was terrible at PE at school, so treated badly by the PE teachers. As an adult, I recognise that I have severe coordination and spatial awareness issues, and I wonder if I have developmental coordination disorder (DCD). It's too late to seek a diagnosis - free as a child on the NHS, £1k as an adult privately - but I can't shake the feeling of being let down, and judged for something that was out of my control.

I did try running as an adult and badly injured myself several times (mostly by tripping over my feet - doesn't the DCD seem even more likely?).

I feel fat and self-conscious, and due to my history of accidentally hurting myself, I wouldn't feel confident working out without an instructor. And due to feeling self-conscious and being terrible, I would need an expensive one-to-one personal trainer and private gym - I don't have that sort of money to burn.

I've also suffered from burnout and exhaustion from my job and I just don't know where I'd get the energy to even try.

I don't want to be like this, @FlowerArranger. But I don't see how I can change.

Switchwitch · 02/02/2023 06:10

I have a 6 and 3 yo. I havent had more than an hour's constant sleep for 6 years now. I work 50 hours a week. I try to exercise by walking the DC to school and back most days but honestly I take the car sometimes because I have meetings at 9am and can't be sauntering along a country lane on the way back from school.

At Xmas I asked for some fun exercise things I could do with the DC, Zumba and a game on Nintendo switch but Ivd had no time to actually use them, I've not even got them out of the box because I work all day, DC back from school/nursery means dinner and bed routines (5-8 is therefore a whirlwind of food, teeth brushing, stories, whinging, homework, me sitting in a darkened room to get Dc2 asleep etc) then I work 8-11, then I drop.

I would dearly love to be one of those mums who jogs away from the school gate clearly off on a sprint round the park for an hour but I just don't have the time right now.

PurelyOrnamental · 02/02/2023 06:02

I am knackered, I know I probably should exercise but I'm done.

vestanesta · 02/02/2023 05:56

It hurts. And I know people will say it gets better etc I have never found that so it's pretty bloody hard to motivate yourself when you know it will hurt.

I am hypermobike and have a damaged knee. Yes I've seen many a dr and physio about this. The exercise I like (running and swimming) and yoga) all make my knee worse. When combined with a 50-60 hour working week and 2 kids, it is easy to not do it and frankly it feels like yet another thing I'm failing at doing.

That said I know it's not ok and I am setting myself up for an unhealthy old age if I do nt get back into the habit. I've set myself a steps challenge for this month and I've actually joined a new local gym due to open in the next couple of week.

But when it hurts, you don't feel better after it, you can't do what you enjoy and you are stressed and verging on burnout it's very easy not to do it even though you know you should.

Goatinthegarden · 02/02/2023 05:54

I didn’t exercise enough in my 20s; I had a gym membership, but I sort of just went halfheartedly. I feel it was never instilled in me as that important. I’m now mid thirties and I average 90 mins a day - I feel so full of energy, I’m constantly bouncing about; I eat better; I sleep better; I rarely get ill. I wish I’d known how good I’d feel a decade ago.

I must caveat by saying don’t have kids, so I have space for home gym equipment to be permanently set up and ability to commute most places by bike. At the weekend, DH and I do full day hikes/bike rides, etc. I imagine that would be pretty challenging with a few kids in tow.

I would say there’s a bit issue with people not valuing exercise though. I have plenty of young colleagues (without children) who drive a very walkable distance (20mins max) to work each day and never workout.

rosewater20 · 02/02/2023 05:54

@greenspaces4peace that is really good to know and something I will keep in mind for the future. Thank you.

greenspaces4peace · 02/02/2023 05:36

@rosewater20 not that many years ago (myself included) HRT was not often offered. HRT prevents bone loss. Great for women now who can access, not so great for those of us 60+ who are 10 yrs plus past.

rosewater20 · 02/02/2023 05:25

greenspaces4peace · 02/02/2023 00:47

it's not death i fear it's infirmity. infirmity that could be preventable. being bed or chairbound for 5+ years before death is no way to live if a few minutes of exercise helps you live a longer period whilst healthy.
osteoporosis, spinal fractures when seniors cough, fractured hips that lead to pneumonia and such things.
being a retired nurse i've seen so much in my career that a bit of exercise would have prevented.
but the info is all out there.
personal choice and all.

This is exactly how I feel and I appreciate you providing this information. When we are talking about exercise it's not just to prevent earlier death, its to provide a higher quality of life. I have relatives who have been a healthy weight their whole lives (on the bottom end of BMI) who are now having bone issues from lack of working out. They were active in terms of walking daily, working in the garden, etc. but a bit of weight training would have prevented the mobility issues they are having now.

rosewater20 · 02/02/2023 05:11

mathanxiety · 02/02/2023 00:43

@rosewater20
Chasing your own tail means doing all that is necessary in your home daily during your second shift, and at your workplace on your first shift in order to get everything done that needs to get done daily so that the family functions.

Society is happy to pay to keep the status quo - regardless of whether the Healthcare system is based on private insurance or on the NHS model, everyone pays more when one part of society is unable to take steps to improve health. The lack of exercise catches up later in life and women's health problems start to cost money.

Treating adequate childcare as some sort of luxury means women are stressed, burned out, and unfit. All of thst leads to expensive healthcare later.

Thank you for explaining, that makes a lot of sense and I agree with your points.

NumberTheory · 02/02/2023 04:52

I was fit before kids. I used to run about 25 miles a week, swim a couple of miles and do weight training 3 times a week. I also walked all over the place.

Then I had kids, got injured, pulled another muscle while compensating for the first injury and ended up getting one injury after another even though I followed physio instructions. I wasn’t sleeping and I lacked energy. I kept trying, but couldn’t get back to anything like where I’d been. When my kids turned 3 my gym stopped doing a crèche so I stopped going. My DH would have been happy to look after his kids in the evening after work while I went but I was just too knackered by then. I walked everywhere, but it was damaging my shoulder pushing my kids in the buggy. I only stopped trading one injury for another when I started driving everywhere instead of walking.

So it was basically a matter of injury after injury, lack of support to exercise when it was convenient, and utter exhaustion from lack of sleep.

But now I am really unfit. I’ve lost some of the weight I had gained, but not enough as I hit menopause and even though I’m eating a lot less, I just don’t seem to burn calories at all and I still seem to pul muscles really easily.

sixfoot · 02/02/2023 03:18

The idea that exercise is not important is laughable. Maintaining strength and mobility through 40s, 50s and beyond is crucial to quality of life.

i hated PE / games, forced myself to do gym classes in my early 20s, walked into an Ashtanga yoga class at 25 and never looked back. 20 years later I’m stronger and more flexible than I’d ever have believed possible, despite two kids and a career. Yes, DH helped me find time when they were tiny; as soon as I could I started getting up before them (4ish) to practice before anyone else woke up. game changer.

If you want to you’ll find a way, if you don’t you’ll find an excuse. We all live with the consequences of our decisions so be happy with yours.

Reclaimtheoutdoors · 02/02/2023 02:27

I think exercise really important, it doesn’t have to be running through a park or working out at the gym. It could be 30 mins total of dancing daily split into 3 so ten mins each time And then making sure you’re not sitting for longer than an hour without getting up for a few minutes. The human body is not made to be sedentary so I don’t even think an hour of exercise is enough if you’re just sitting down for the rest of the day but it’s definitely better than nothing!

I have huge sympathy for those who don’t like exercise, or who feel self conscious doing it. Thankfully I actually enjoy exercising when I get going. I became really unfit starting from the first lockdown and I’m still WFH but I’ve got back into it. I wonder if this has affected other women too as many opt for WFH? Currently aiming for 30 mins of exercise 6x a week which I’m gradually building up alongside making sure I’m not eating too many calories. I Swim, follow YouTube workouts and walk on the treadmill at the gym.

I love walking outside but don’t find it that relaxing sometimes as in the local parks there’s increasingly off lead dogs running up or dodging dog poo on the pavements everywhere, but I try and do brisk walks along the high street library regularly. I used to live in East Asia and felt a lot safer & nicer walking around late at night there. I don’t live in a particularly grimy area but generally I do wish there were better cleaner & safer walking spaces in the UK. The weather doesn’t help either. I think people get more active in spring/summer weather.

greenspaces4peace · 02/02/2023 00:47

it's not death i fear it's infirmity. infirmity that could be preventable. being bed or chairbound for 5+ years before death is no way to live if a few minutes of exercise helps you live a longer period whilst healthy.
osteoporosis, spinal fractures when seniors cough, fractured hips that lead to pneumonia and such things.
being a retired nurse i've seen so much in my career that a bit of exercise would have prevented.
but the info is all out there.
personal choice and all.

mathanxiety · 02/02/2023 00:43

@rosewater20
Chasing your own tail means doing all that is necessary in your home daily during your second shift, and at your workplace on your first shift in order to get everything done that needs to get done daily so that the family functions.

Society is happy to pay to keep the status quo - regardless of whether the Healthcare system is based on private insurance or on the NHS model, everyone pays more when one part of society is unable to take steps to improve health. The lack of exercise catches up later in life and women's health problems start to cost money.

Treating adequate childcare as some sort of luxury means women are stressed, burned out, and unfit. All of thst leads to expensive healthcare later.

Isyesterdaytomorrowtoday · 02/02/2023 00:35

It can reduce your risk of some stuff - nothing to suggest how much by, or incrementally over just not smoking, not drinking too much and not being overweight. Most of it is exactly the same benefits as for weight loss.

if I’m going to waste a year (based on 20-30 mins a day) of my life doing something I hate I’d want a better sales pitch

madeyemoody · 02/02/2023 00:33

You've used study from 2007 and research from 2013...of AMERICANS and generalised that the UK must not much better? What a wild mental leap that was!

mathanxiety · 02/02/2023 00:33

@IntentionalError

When my DCs were small there wasn't internet as we know it now. I was a SAHM. Still no chance to exercise apart from walking slowly with toddler/ baby.

Babies and toddlers keep you up at night. This tires you out and makes you fixate on sleep. They demand attention during the day, and there are a gazillion things on your To Do list that take precedence over exercise. Speaking personally, being in the company of completely dependent small people with no sense of personal boundaries whatsoever made me crave the time and quiet in which to finish a thought. I craved exercise for my mind and snatched a half hour here and twenty minutes there to read.

Gyms near me are pricey and don't have childcare except sometimes as an add on you pay for as you go.

The only women I know who are able to take regular, meaningful exercise after having a baby are able to afford childcare either outside or in the home - nanny or creche. Or they have a partner who prioritises making time for the mother to exercise. This is a small minority.

I also know women whose partners will say 'Sure, I'll manage with the kids, go on out and run or go to that zumba class - have fun!' And the woman comes back to a home where the buffalo roam and the deer and the antelope play, and there isn't even time for her to take a proper shower before the mess gets cleared and the children re-bathed because their father has allowed them to eat ice cream with their hands. You ask what the fuck he was thinking and he gets all hurt. And it gets to be so much of a hassle that you just say forget it.

talknomore · 02/02/2023 00:28

I read recently that the "7 minutes is enough" has been debunked. It was tested on very fit participants who also did 20 min warm up before that 7 min HIIT.

rosewater20 · 02/02/2023 00:28

@Isyesterdaytomorrowtoday www.nhs.uk/live-well/exercise/exercise-health-benefits/

rosewater20 · 02/02/2023 00:26

Isyesterdaytomorrowtoday · 02/02/2023 00:24

OP keeps going on about the long term implications of not exercising- what are they? Point my to some research I can read

a quick google gives lots of weight loss/mental health short to medium term stuff which isn’t my question

Bloody hell. www.health.harvard.edu/mind-and-mood/exercise-can-boost-your-memory-and-thinking-skills

rosewater20 · 02/02/2023 00:24

mathanxiety · 02/02/2023 00:18

When do the years of chasing your own tail end?

You get past the years of being up all night woth them and spending all day stopping them from killing themselves climbing bookcases and move on to schlepping them to sports and clubs in the evening, organising them for school, shopping and cooking and doing laundry, while trying to hold down a job (or two, or three).

The stats, if true, are yet another indictment of our society's failure to take the needs of mothers into account. We're apparently happy to pay real money to maintain the status quo.

I am curious about what you mean. What do you mean by "the years of chasing your own tail"? And "happy to pay real money to maintain the status quo"?

Isyesterdaytomorrowtoday · 02/02/2023 00:24

OP keeps going on about the long term implications of not exercising- what are they? Point my to some research I can read

a quick google gives lots of weight loss/mental health short to medium term stuff which isn’t my question

rosewater20 · 02/02/2023 00:22

CrunchyCarrot · 01/02/2023 23:59

I've never liked exercise, being honest. At various times during my life I've tried one thing or another, but never stuck with it. Now I have a bad back and cannot do any. I think I've had a degree of hypothyroidism all my life, so have never had enough energy and tire easily.

Have you been to a doctor about your hyperthyroidism?

rosewater20 · 02/02/2023 00:20

Isyesterdaytomorrowtoday · 02/02/2023 00:06

What are the long term health implications of not exercising OP?

from what I can tell the NHS advice is focus is really in maintaining a healthy weight.

if I don’t smoke, drink in moderation, am a healthy BMI - what is the major impact?

cancer doesn’t seem to care, I know plenty of real fit people who dropped dead of strokes and heart attacks. What is it going to do for me? If the answer is increase my life expectancy from 84 to 87 I’d rather have cup of tea & read my book

Seriously? A quick Google can you tell you what benefits of exercise are.

mathanxiety · 02/02/2023 00:18

When do the years of chasing your own tail end?

You get past the years of being up all night woth them and spending all day stopping them from killing themselves climbing bookcases and move on to schlepping them to sports and clubs in the evening, organising them for school, shopping and cooking and doing laundry, while trying to hold down a job (or two, or three).

The stats, if true, are yet another indictment of our society's failure to take the needs of mothers into account. We're apparently happy to pay real money to maintain the status quo.